The Sweet Tooth Bakery

Don't bother placing an order here. Cake nightmares. Associates doesn't know what they are doing and messed up my order not once but twice after they took it back to fixed it. Manager Shawn not sure if she's the manager and if so she needs to be demoted. I sent an email and Shawn not once apologized for what her team did. And stated there won't be a refunds. She even quoted me $80 and charged me $115.95

Everyone loved our cake from Sweet Tooth! The decor we asked for was beautifully done and the cake tasted great. We had fallen in love with a certain icing flavor before landing on sweet tooth and they gave us two different tastings while they perfected the recipe (the icing was a flavor they hadn’t previously done before). They were pleasant, easy to communicate with, and on time the day of. If it says anything, we ended up with only three pieces of cake left at the end of our reception!

I don’t know how I missed the link for Sweet Tooth Bakery on this website, but somehow I did when I was doing other Wedding vendor reviews earlier on—SO glad I found the link now! My husband and I were married in April 2021 at a church in Berryville, VA and we had our Rehearsal Dinner and Wedding Reception at beautiful Historic Rosemont, also in Berryville. We worked with Joyce from Sweet Tooth Bakery in Winchester, VA for our wedding weekend cakes and sweets. Right from the start, we were blown away by Joyce and her Sweet Tooth treats. After we tasted her yummy cake samples at our Rosemont “Vendor Day” interview, we knew she was the baker for us. We had a very hard time deciding on the flavor and filling of our wedding cake because all her samples were so delicious. And the chocolate Grooms Cake—oh my goodness! My husband and I were engaged on Mardi Gras, so our Rehearsal Dinner had a Mardi Gras theme. We showed Joyce a picture of a Mardi Gras cake idea we had, and she truly brought the vision to life. She even ordered some gold colored crowns for decoration, where one sat majestically right on top of the King Cake. The perfect touch! Joyce and her colleagues also made decorative Mardi Gras-style cookies, where they were liked so much that a guest asked if they could take the leftover cookies with them after the Reception. And there were chocolate covered strawberries, too, we can’t forget those—it was like Joyce brought Sweet Tooth Bakery right to Rosemont—wow! And that’s not all—our wedding guests stayed on the lovely Rosemont grounds, and we wanted them to have some sweet treats in their rooms, so Joyce and her colleagues created individual little chocolate gift boxes for each guest, as well as the most amazing pralines, wrapped in cute little bags. If someone would have given me a bucket of those pralines I do believe I could have eaten them all! And I want to add here that I don’t believe pralines were a “standard” item at Sweet Tooth Bakery when we asked Joyce about them. But perhaps they should be because they were that good! When my husband and I got it in our heads that we wanted to have pralines as part of our Mardi Gras theme, and we asked Joyce if she could make them, she was sweet as can be. She thought for just a moment and said, “Well I don’t see why not!” And the rest is history. I still think about those pralines and start drooling! Thank you Joyce and all your Sweet Tooth colleagues for making our sweet-treat and wedding-dessert dreams come true!

This cake was so good but our recommendation goes beyond that. Our original cake plan fell through only a couple weeks before the big day so we had to come up with a new plan. Upon our last minute scramble we happened upon this company and we were so lucky that we did. First off, in relation to price there is no better deal in the area. Delicious cake at starting at $2 per slice. Everywhere else was more like double that. Then there is the business itself. The happy and helpful people that you speak to, who calm you down, and let you know immediately that you are in good hands. In two weeks, we did a tasting, chose the flavors, and communicated and decided on a final design (pinterest boards are really helpful for this). We arranged delivery and knew that we had nothing to worry about after that. And this was all finalized the Thursday before the wedding. This company takes care of it's brides. They do everything they can to keep the process stress free on their end. And believe me, I had a lot of stress going on when I turned to them. Having no cake as of the last couple weeks was a bit of a hurdle, but they told me we had plenty of time and I knew from that point that I could trust that.