5.0
Verified reviews from real couples
Deluxe custom wedding cakes and desserts
NH, Southern ME, Northern MA
Service area
We had the pleasure of working with Three Sisters Cake Shop for one of our couples’ wedding desserts, and we couldn’t be happier with the experience! From start to finish, the team was responsive, friendly, and professional, making the entire process smooth and stress-free — exactly what you want when planning a big day.
The custom cake and cupcakes they created were not only beautiful but absolutely delicious — guests couldn’t stop raving about the flavor and presentation. Their variety of cake flavors and fillings meant there was something for everyone, and the tasting process was fun and personalized.
They also coordinated delivery and setup seamlessly, and their attention to detail really showed in the final product. We highly recommend them to any couple looking for gorgeous, tasty wedding desserts and a joyful vendor experience!
The Knot
Ajay G.
5.0
Three Sisters Cake Shop was an absolute dream to work with and exceeded every expectation we had. From start to finish, the entire process was seamless, stress-free, and incredibly well organized — exactly what you hope for when planning a wedding.
They went above and beyond by offering excellent gluten-free options for my now husband, who has celiac disease. Knowing that his needs were not only accommodated but treated with such care and attention meant so much to us and gave us complete peace of mind on our wedding day.
And the desserts — truly unforgettable. Three Sisters created the most delicious and beautifully curated array of desserts we could have ever asked for. Every single item was fresh, flavorful, and absolutely loved by our guests. We received countless compliments on how incredible everything tasted, with many people going back for seconds (and thirds).
If you are looking for a bakery that combines professionalism, thoughtfulness, and exceptional quality, Three Sisters Cake Shop is it. We couldn’t recommend them more and are so grateful they were part of our celebration.
Morgan D.
5.0
AWARD WINNER
Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot
Based in Dover, NH, Three Sisters Cake Shop offers custom wedding cakes and curated dessert bars for weddings and wedding-related celebrations. Our wedding cake flavors include Vanilla, Chocolate, Marble, Red Velvet, Coconut, Almond, Carrot, Spice, Pumpkin, Confetti, Apple Cider Donut, GF vanilla, GF Chocolate and GF marble. We also offer a variety of Buttercream frosting flavors and fillings.
We can also schedule a custom in-person tasting prior to ordering your cake. Other desserts offered for weddings and celebrations include cookies, cupcakes, cake pops, whoopie pies, cannoli, lemon squares, and more.
Woman-owned Business
Details
Cakes & Desserts
Cake Delivery & Setup
Cake Tastings
Cupcakes
Groom's Cakes
Other Desserts
Dietary Options
Gluten Free
Vegetarian
Awards and Affiliations
2026 'Best of Weddings'
Best of Weddings
The Knot independently assesses vendors for this award—it’s never self-reported. We base it on firsthand experiences from real couples and guests, and they must have a 4.5-star average across 7+ reviews in the qualifying year.
Join couples who chose award-winning vendors for their wedding
Reviews
5.0
out of 5.033 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
Three Sisters Cake Shop is praised for responsive, professional service and beautiful, delicious wedding cakes and desserts. They offer many customizable flavors and accommodate dietary needs (gluten‑free/vegan), with reliable delivery/setup and reasonable pricing. Couples highlighted the helpful tastings, attention to detail, and anniversary cake follow‑up.Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
Maddy B
Highlighted review.
5.0
9/28/2024
We loved the fantastic cupcakes and cake from Three Sisters Cake Shop for our wedding! It was fun to have several customizable options for all our guests’ many tastes. We made sure...
to order some unique seasonal flavors such as lemon blueberry and raspberry, which were delicious. They really went above and beyond like helping deliver vegan cupcakes from another bakery for our guests.
Ajay G
5.0
12/22/2025
We had the pleasure of working with Three Sisters Cake Shop for one of our couples’ wedding desserts, and we couldn’t be happier with the experience! From start to finish, the team...
was responsive, friendly, and professional, making the entire process smooth and stress-free — exactly what you want when planning a big day.
The custom cake and cupcakes they created were not only beautiful but absolutely delicious — guests couldn’t stop raving about the flavor and presentation. Their variety of cake flavors and fillings meant there was something for everyone, and the tasting process was fun and personalized.
They also coordinated delivery and setup seamlessly, and their attention to detail really showed in the final product. We highly recommend them to any couple looking for gorgeous, tasty wedding desserts and a joyful vendor experience!
The Knot
Any questions?
Morgan D
5.0
12/15/2025
Three Sisters Cake Shop was an absolute dream to work with and exceeded every expectation we had. From start to finish, the entire process was seamless, stress-free, and incredibly...
well organized — exactly what you hope for when planning a wedding.
They went above and beyond by offering excellent gluten-free options for my now husband, who has celiac disease. Knowing that his needs were not only accommodated but treated with such care and attention meant so much to us and gave us complete peace of mind on our wedding day.
And the desserts — truly unforgettable. Three Sisters created the most delicious and beautifully curated array of desserts we could have ever asked for. Every single item was fresh, flavorful, and absolutely loved by our guests. We received countless compliments on how incredible everything tasted, with many people going back for seconds (and thirds).
If you are looking for a bakery that combines professionalism, thoughtfulness, and exceptional quality, Three Sisters Cake Shop is it. We couldn’t recommend them more and are so grateful they were part of our celebration.
Haley M
5.0
11/23/2025
We chose Three Sisters Cake Shop to provide a wedding cake and dessert table for our wedding and they were absolutely incredible!!! They are incredibly friendly, flexible, and most...
importantly, make DELICIOUS desserts! Everything came out exactly as we hoped for and our guests devoured it with rave reviews. Their pricing is very also very reasonable. Thank you so much to the team and we are already so excited to get our cake on our one-year anniversary!
Sara B
5.0
9/15/2025
We were smart enough to choose Three Sisters Cake Shop to make our wedding cake and they did not disappoint! They were incredibly responsive and organized, answering every question...
we had throughout the process. The introductory appointment was so helpful, not only getting to try slices of all of their amazing flavors but it gave us the opportunity to talk about our vision for the cake. They were all so delicious, we ended up choosing a different flavor for each tier! After sending a handful of pictures, they created the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake we had ever had! They made sure to deliver the cake promptly and ensure it was staged beautifully at the venue. The cake was exactly what we had envisioned and it was one of the first times we had ever seen guests ask for seconds. We can’t wait for our 1-year anniversary cake and cannot recommend them enough!
Ashley M
5.0
9/08/2025
Three Sisters Cake Shop made the desserts for our wedding, and they were delicious as well as affordable! We got cupcakes, cake pops, and a small cutting cake. Everything was amazi...
ng and exactly as we pictured.
Jess C
5.0
7/27/2025
As a gluten-free girlie, I wasn't sure I wanted a cake at all for our wedding. We had another plan for desserts, so that wasn't an issue. But when I found that Three Sisters makes ...
"cutting cakes" AND can make them gluten free - I was sold! We chose the color/style, cake flavor, and filling flavor and it was delicious. It added a ceremonial touch to our reception and I'm so glad we did it.
Jenna C
5.0
4/28/2025
Three Sisters provided our cutting cake and cannoli dessert for our wedding! Everyone loved the cannoli, and the cake was so cute, delicious, and exactly what we wanted. I'm lookin...
g forward to visiting them again for a 1-year anniversary cake :)
Molly D
5.0
1/12/2025
We were very happy with our cake and whoopie pies from Three Sisters and are already excited about our anniversary cake! The staff provided great information during our tasting, he...
lping us figure out the best cake options for our particular wedding, and went above and beyond by offering to deliver baked goods from another bakery to accommodate our guests’ dietary needs. They were on top of every detail and the finished product was delicious!
Jessica B
5.0
1/04/2025
Our ceremony was 11/8/24 at Flag Hill. We ordered a small 2 tier wedding cake and 6 gluten free cupcakes, all were amazing! We got nothing but compliments about how good the cake/c...
upcakes were. We got a vanilla cake with coconut frosting and vanilla gluten free cupcakes. The cake was exactly how we pictured it to look. Delivery flawless/ on time, taking away some of the days stress.
Jordan V
4.0
12/15/2024
Our cupcakes were amazing and they brought our sweetheart cake vision to life. We also go cannolis which were good and the brownies were a little dry which was a bummer. But overal...
l I recommend them!
Courtney K
5.0
4/20/2024
The cake and desserts from Three Sisters were amazing! They did such a great job making my vision come to life off of just a few inspo pics! They send you cake on your 1 year anniv...
ersary so you don’t have to save a piece on wedding day which was nice as we didn’t get a very large cake. They have so many flavors and desserts to choose from and the pricing was very reasonable. Highly recommend Three Sisters!
Caitlin B
5.0
12/19/2023
We had the most amazing mini cupcakes and cake! So many compliments! As a non cake lover - I even loved the cake!
We did not have a chance to do a tasting ( our fault) but we wer...
e not disappointed say of. Our guests who had cake still tell us how wonderful it was!
They were so easy to work with and accommodated our very late booking with ease. Then helped coordinate our venue delivery and drop off at the last minute for us.
Meredith Y
5.0
5/05/2023
Three Sisters was overall so amazing. We order a small cake, cupcakes, whoopie pies, and cookies for our dessert table at our wedding. Everything was delicious and beautifully pre...
sented. We got so many compliments on the dessert and pretty much everything was gone by the end of the night. Three Sisters was very easy to work with, quickly responded to emails, and answered all of our questions so kindly. We made some changes last minute and they were accommodating and flexible. Definitely recommend!!
Courtney H
5.0
10/25/2022
Best wedding cake(s) ever!!! Three Sisters Cake Shop was so helpful and a pleasure to work with. We weren't sure what we were interested in, what size cake we would need, or how we...
wanted to decorate it going in to our tasting and had everything decided by the time we left. We ended up doing a small cake for just us and two sheet cakes, all three cakes were different flavors. My only regret is not eating more cake at my wedding and that we don't live closer to the shop! I highly recommend them for your special day!
Taylor H
5.0
7/31/2022
AMAZING CAKE AND CUPCAKES!!! We hired Three Sisters for our wedding a few weekends ago and loved their work :) Holly was really responsive and easy to work with.
Anna M
5.0
6/20/2022
Our cake was delicious! We got a vanilla cake with vanilla frosting and a raspberry filling for our wedding cake. It was delivered on time and all of our guests commented on how be...
autiful it was decorated.
Wendy F
5.0
4/04/2022
Our cake was beautiful and delicious . Our guests truly enjoyed it. They were very professional and accommodating. I would recommend to anyone looking for a wedding cake.
Cody H
5.0
12/20/2021
I am so happy we chose them to do our cake and cupcakes! Everyone said they were the most delicious desserts they have ever tasted and we had a ton of gluten free people at our wed...
ding so being able to have that option was awesome!
We had a fun complimentary cake tasting and there are so many different options to choose from for flavors. They are also very reasonably priced which we appreciated.
I seriously couldn’t be happier - our little cake we ordered for just us didn’t even make it 3 days it was so good!
Thank you so much!!!
Joy M
5.0
9/30/2021
Three Sisters did a cutting cake, cupcakes & pumpkin whoopie pies for our wedding. All were delicious & looked great too! The pumpkin whoopie pies were a big hit!! They were eas...
y to work with & delivered everything on time.
Karen M
5.0
9/25/2021
Holly and her team were wonderful throughout this entire process! We started our search for a baker relatively late in the wedding timeline, and they were able to accommodate our r...
elatively last-minute request with aplomb. They answered all of our questions promptly and professionally, and even provided us a to-go tasting when we ended up being in their area at the last minute. The inspiration pictures and other thoughts we sent them were perfectly followed, and the end result was amazing. We ended up going with a small cutting cake for us and three flavors of cupcakes for our guests, and received MANY complements about the cupcakes. They were also able to deliver (for a reasonable fee) up to Maine! Three Sisters is a wonderful choice for a customized, professional wedding baker experience that will live up to your every expectation!
Ashley O
5.0
7/08/2021
We loved working with Three Sisters! They were responsive throughout the planning process and allowed us the flexibility to decide on our cake and cupcakes after our final guest co...
unt was confirmed. Not only was our cake beautiful, but it was delicious! They have a wide variety of flavors and we so enjoyed working with them during our tasting. If you are getting married in Southern NH I would highly recommend working with them!
Jessica S
5.0
6/17/2019
Three Sisters provided the cake for our wedding at The Red Barn at Outlook Farm. We took a simplistic approach with a quick phone call, filling out an order form with our wants (ca...
ke, filling, frosting & tiers) and letting Three Sisters handle the rest, including delivery. The process was simple and stress free, with Three Sisters being very responsive to our needs. Three Sisters also coordinated directly with our florist to place fresh flowers on the cake at the venue. The cake arrived on time, was beautiful and delicious. A lot of our guests had seconds!
Kelsey H
5.0
1/26/2019
Can't say enough about Three Sisters Cake Shop. I was very particular in the decoration and they went above and beyond to make sure it was going to look exactly how I wanted it. ...
They even made a mock display cake to show me. All of our guests raved about how good the cake tasted. Highly recommend these amazing ladies!
Kelsey F
5.0
11/10/2018
My husband and I just got married a couple of weekends ago at Rivermill at Dover Landing and we were OBSESSED with our gorgeous & delicious cake from Three Sisters Cake Shop! They ...
were super collaborative and helpful throughout the process. We cake tasted at quite a few places during the wedding fair at our venue and theirs tasted the best hands down. It was an easy decision and one we'd make again! Definitely recommend!
Jaclyn A
5.0
10/26/2018
We got so many compliments on the mini cupcakes we had at the wedding, they were all amazing!!
I also worked with them to create a surprise cake for my husband, which was revealed...
during the reception. It was exactly what I had pictured, and they were so amazing at helping me figure out how to make that a reality. It all tasted amazing, we had a lot of happy guests!!
Response from Three Sisters Cake Shop on 10/26/2018
Thank you so much Jaclyn! We had fun designing the cake for you husband! We are so happy t...
o hear it all went great! Congratulations!
Ashley A
5.0
10/15/2018
We used Three Sisters for our wedding cake in September. From the get go, they were easy to deal with, fast in setting up appointments, and our tasting was so much fun. They gave...
great recommendations for a variety of cakes for our big day, and also helped us plan out the look and feel we were going for with our cake. One of my top 5 pictures from our big day was a picture of our cake table. Everything came together so nicely, and the cake was the most delicious dessert I have ever had! We received many compliments on the cake from our guests too! I would highly recommend Three Sisters for anyone looking for a beautiful creation for your big day!
Holly D
5.0
9/22/2018
We used Three Sisters Cake Shop for to make a small cake for us and cupcakes for our guests. They were amazing!
We were able to set up a consultation to try the flavors very quic...
kly, and the options they gave us were delicious.
They were extremely easy to work with, and were very quick to respond if I contacted them with information or questions. The day of the wedding they were prompt in dropping everything off and set up what they needed to.
Our only disappointment: We had NO cupcakes left over because our guests loved them so much. Everyone raved about how good they were. We're looking forward to having another slice of our wedding cake, but we might not be able to hold off until our first anniversary.
I would definitely recommend them!
Anna L
5.0
9/05/2018
We ordered chocolate chip cookies from here for our wedding favors at the end of August. The shop was incredible to work with. They went above and beyond by individually wrapping t...
he cookies and having them ready for pick up earlier in the morning. Not only were they absolutely delicious, they also held up well in the two days leading up to the wedding in an air-conditioned room at the venue. I highly recommend this bakery!
Delani B
5.0
5/23/2018
Our wedding cake was absolutely scrumptious! It was a pleasure working with Sara. She was helpful throughout the entire process from tasting to the day of. We absolutely recommend ...
Three Sisters Cake Shop!
Courtney W
5.0
10/11/2016
Three Sisters Cake Shop did a Phenomenal job with the cupcakes and small cutting cake for my wedding this past weekend on 10/9/16. The whole process was amazing. The cupcakes were ...
to die for, everyone was raving about them and asking where they came from. The choclate cupcake with salted caramel frosting was a huge hit! Even my husband, who does not eat dessert or even like sweets, said that our small cutting cake was amazing! I would highly reccomend these ladies for any sort of event and will definitely be using them again in the future!
Anonymous
5.0
12/21/2015
Three sisters made my wedding cake back in 2009 and I have been going to them ever since for all my cookie and cake needs! For my wedding cake, I brought in pictures of what I want...
ed, the theme, colors etc and Katie (the owner) created exactly what I was looking for! I find the prices to be reasonable and the quality/flavor is great!
Stephanie L
5.0
7/05/2015
three sisters is great! The cake was delicious and very reasonably priced. I will most certainly recommend in the future!
Service area & Contact info
NH, Southern ME, Northern MA
Typically included in the starting cost
Want to book a visit?
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
Wedding vendors in Dover
Three Sisters Cake Shop
Why use The Knot to message vendors?
Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure. Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place. Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go. For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.