Tourterelle catered our wedding in June of 2012. My wife and I were married at my parents house in Middlebury, and needlessly drove all over Vermont meeting caterers when the perfect solution was just 15 minutes away.
I'm a vegan and my wif...e has some nut allergies - not an easy bunch to cook for! Christine and her husband - co-owners, the latter the chef - didn't balk in the least at this conundrum. Whereas other caterers floundered completely with ridiculous menus or wanted to charge absurd amounts for "specialized" food, Tourterelle simply took all this in stride. Christine in particular, but really everyone at the restaurant, was very calm, helpful, communicative, and honest, which made dealing with this aspect of the wedding totally stress free.
We got some guff from family members about a vegan wedding being total nonsense. And yet several friends and relatives remarked after the reception - we did family style, so everyone could try everything - that they were glad we did a vegan wedding, because they had no idea vegan food could be so good. These are hardcore meat and potatoes and whiskey people.
Finally, Christine dealt with table rentals, table cloths, the bar, and everything else associated with catering for us – it was all done with great efficiency, and we didn't have to worry or even think about any of it.
As for cost, Tourterelle fit perfectly within our budget. The bar tab was high, but we insisted upon open bar and have a lot of big drinkers in the family, so we anticipated as much. The food, service, table rentals etc were very reasonable. However, I should add the disclaimer that my wife and I have lived in places like New York, Tokyo, London, and Los Angeles, so we're usually surprised when things aren't incredulously expensive. I can't really speak to the value of Tourterelle relative to the Vermont economy because neither of us have lived in New England since 2007 or so.
If we had to do our wedding again, we might change a detail or two here or there, but would go straight back to Tourterelle. One of the best choices we made.