About this vendor
Verstolo Fine Jewelry brings precise workmanship, vast expertise, and deep-rooted history to every diamond that bears its name. As fourth generation diamantaires, we understand what it means to create a work of art that lasts a lifetime. All Verstolo designs are completed by hand, from stone sourcing to individual facet polishing, each Verstolo diamond receives meticulous attention to detail and the utmost care. No matter the size of the stone, bought or borrowed, Verstolo is redefining wearable luxury one carat at a time. Our Diamond Rental Program offers customers the unique opportunity to experience our most extraordinary pieces for their special occasion. Email us at info@verstolo.com to book an appointment today!
Details
Rings
- Engagement Rings
- Ring Services
- Appraisals
- Custom Designs
- Engraving
- Financing Available
Wedding Jewelry
- Bracelets
- Earrings
- Necklaces
- Rings
Awards and Affiliations
6-Time 'Best of Weddings'
2026.2025.2024.+3 more.
Best of Weddings
The Knot independently assesses vendors for this award—it’s never self-reported. We base it on firsthand experiences from real couples and guests, and they must have a 4.5-star average across 7+ reviews in the qualifying year.
Hall of Fame
Earned by winning 'Best of Weddings' four or more times.
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
5
out of 5.0145 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
My experience with Verstolo was incredibly amazing. They designed my dream engagement ring. Verstolo created our custom wedding bands and bids, their creativity for both my engag...
ement and wedding was awesome! A similar recommendation I have is "hackspeed24@gmail. com" the tech genius can assist you to gain remote access to your spouse's phone activities, if you ever suspect them of cheating on you, the'r hacking services is so on-point.
Wonderful experience renting with Verstolo for my wedding! The team worked with me to find pieces that were the perfect match for the style I was aiming for. I chose a necklace and...
earrings, and both were beautiful and brought the whole look together. The entire process was seamless!
I had a very seamless experience with Verstolo. I had a destination wedding and was able to pick up and drop off the package at a FedEx right near our venue. The piece I rented (di...
amond bracelet) was absolutely stunning and in pristine condition. It was my “something borrowed” for my welcome and after party! I’d recommend to any bride or for any event where you want a little extra sparkle.
Verstolo was one of my favorite wedding finds. I rented my wedding earrings and necklace from them and had such a wonderful experience from start to finish. It was easy to schedule...
an appointment at their Midtown NYC showroom, and Caitlin made the entire process so fun, informative, and stress-free. She helped me try on a variety of pieces, offered thoughtful advice, and ultimately helped me choose the perfect combination—the Rosie earrings and Isla necklace.
What really stood out was their customer service and flexibility. I was nervous about how the jewelry would look with my dress, so they generously allowed me to borrow the pieces for 24 hours to bring to a gown fitting at no additional cost. I also appreciated the option to split payments throughout the process and cancel up to 30 days before my wedding for peace of mind. The jewelry arrived in pristine condition, looked brand new, and felt incredibly elegant and luxurious. For any bride who wants to wear real diamonds on her wedding day without the cost of purchasing them outright, I cannot recommend Verstolo highly enough.
Amazing experience all around with verstolo!
I had an incredible experience with Verstolo for both my engagement and wedding! They worked with my now husband to design my dream engagement ring, helped us create our custom wed...
ding bands, and helped me select the perfect rental pieces—including a bracelet and two pairs of earrings—for my wedding weekend. The rental process was seamless, from pickup before the wedding to an easy return afterward. Lauren and her team were so warm, professional, and a true pleasure to work with every step of the way. I can’t recommend Verstolo enough for anyone looking to add something special and truly sparkle on their wedding day and beyond!
I worked with Caitlin to curate my wedding day jewelry and I could not be happier with what I rented! I will be returning for other events I have in the future. 10/10 - highly reco...
mmend!
I cannot recommend Verstolo enough! They are an absolute joy to work with and offer incredible rental pieces at very accessible prices. The diamonds I rented made me feel like a ce...
lebrity on my wedding day.
They make the rental process unbelievably easy and offer shipping so you do not have to worry about picking up pieces during an already busy wedding week. Returning the jewelry after the wedding is just as seamless. They also offer a credit program where the money you spend on a rental can be applied toward a future purchase. Be sure to ask about the details when you rent with them.
I will absolutely be using Verstolo again for jewelry rentals for future events!
I felt like such a princess wearing all these exquisitely beautiful diamond jewelry on my wedding day that perfectly complimented my dress and second look (without breaking the ban...
k!). It was such an easy and seamless process to select the jewelry, pick it up and drop it off. The Rent. Own. program to apply the credit of the rentals towards a purchase is icing on top! Can't recommend it enough!
I had such a wonderful experience working with Verstolo for my wedding. I rented the Fern earrings, Isla necklace, and the Diana pearl necklace, and each piece was beautiful, timel...
ess, and the perfect complement to my wedding look.
I also brought in an heirloom ring to be sized down for the wedding so it would fit my finger properly. From the very first consultation through the final details, the entire process felt thoughtful, collaborative, and genuinely fun. The team took the time to understand what I was looking for and made everything feel personal rather than transactional.
At the end of the night, I accidentally broke one of the delicate pearl strands on the necklace, and the Verstolo team could not have been more kind, understanding, and accommodating. They handled the situation with so much grace, which really speaks to how much they care about their clients.
Verstolo added something truly special and meaningful to my wedding day, and I couldn’t recommend them more highly for their craftsmanship, service, and care. It was such a fun way to elevate my bridal look, and I’m already looking forward to using my rental credit to purchase something in the future.
I had a wonderful experience renting my wedding day jewelry from Verstolo. The necklace was stunning and it sparkled so beautifully. The whole process was incredibly easy and worth...
while. I cannot recommend Verstolo enough!
Lauren and her team really are pros at what they do. My fiancé went per recommendation of a friend to choose my engagement ring and they were extremely helpful. Since then, we have...
been back for both our wedding bands and my rentals for my wedding day! They are very attentive and were so helpful with any and all questions. I will be going back for all my diamond needs in the future :)
I loved working with Lauren and the Verstolo team for my wedding. The whole process was so easy and fun, and I was able to wear the most gorgeous pieces for my wedding day. Couldn'...
t recommend working with them more!
I highly recommend renting wedding jewelry from Verstolo! Lauren and team made the process so easy and fun. The pieces are so beautiful. The bracelet I wore and the earrings my mom...
rented completed our outfits. You won't regret your decision!
Lauren made the jewelry rental process so streamlined and enjoyable! I could not recommend Verstolo more highly to future brides looking to try some special pieces for their weddin...
g day.
I loved working with Lauren at Verstolo. My jewelry showed up in pristine condition and the necklace/earrings complimented my entire wedding look and pulled everything together jus...
t as I imagined it. Their entire rental process is absolutely seamless and I could not recommend their services enough!
Could not recommend Verstolo enough! There are so many amazing diamond rental options available to elevate any bridal look. I rented the Isla necklace for my wedding and didn’t tak...
e it off all weekend! The rental process is also super organized and easy.
Had the most amazing experience with Verstolo! They fulfilled my dreams of wearing the most gorgeous diamonds on my wedding day and really completed my look. It was a pleasure to w...
ork with Lauren and the delivery and return of the items was so easy! Definitely recommending to everyone I know!
Could not recommend Verstolo more for jewelry rental! They understood exactly what I was looking for and made the process so seamless and fun. Lauren and the team are incredible!
Working with verstolo & Lauren was nothing short of a pleasure! Initially, I had set up a meeting to discuss rental jewelry with Lauren and then my husband and I ended up getting o...
ur wedding bands from them! The entire process from time of booking to jewelry pickup was absolutely seamless. Our bands came out perfect and customizing them to be exactly what we wanted couldn’t have been easier.
When it came to the rental jewelry, I rented a pair of earrings and a tennis bracelet. Both pieces of jewelry were absolutely stunning & 100% made my entire look for wedding day. For any bride who is thinking of renting from verstolo, my recommendation would be to not hesitate as you will absolutely not regret your decision! My husband and I look forward to working with verstolo in the future! Thank you Lauren & the verstolo team again for all of your assistance! You guys are the best!!
The team was so helpful! I loved my wedding jewelry, and it was easily shipped.
My mom and I both rented earrings and a bracelet each for my wedding through Verstolo. The jewelry was absolutely stunning and made my wedding dress and afterparty look complete! L...
auren was fantastic to work with and the process was very easy! SO happy we did this!!
My (now) husband got my engagement ring from Verstolo. I LOVE my ring and still admire it as much as I did the day I first got it. It is exactly what I requested, and more! Michael...
(owner) helped my husband go the extra mile by providing guidance about other details, such as ring setting height, which I'm pretty sure my husband would've had no clue about. Now, my wedding band (we got our bands at Verstolo, too!) sits flush against my emerald cut beauty!
I also rented earrings from Verstolo for the big day and got compliments all night from family and friends about how perfect they were! Lauren was so helpful in deciding which pair to go with, and made the whole pick up/drop off process for our slightly complicated destination wedding situation a breeze.
Everyone at Verstolo is knowledgeable, welcoming, and professional. We won't go anywhere else for our jewelry, and neither should you!
I can't thank Verstolo enough for lending me the most stunning earrings for my special day. I received countless compliments—these pieces truly completed my bridal look and brought...
my vision to life. The entire process was so seamless and stress-free, thanks to their incredibly kind and professional team. I couldn’t recommend Verstolo more
Loved working with the Verstolo team to find my wedding jewelry - super helpful, gave great suggestions, and made the entire rental process seamless!
I rented the Mia earrings & Mila tennis bracelet from Verstolo for my wedding & could not have been happier! It was an absolute dream to be able to wear such beautiful jewelry on ...
my special day. The rental process was great - it was very easy to make an appointment, and Lauren patiently sat with me as I tried on a number of earrings - and then tried the same ones on again until i was certain I had picked the right jewelry. The price was incredibly reasonable and with that, I look forward to the opportunity to rent jewelry from Verstolo again!
Lauren and the rest of the Verstolo team are amazing!!! I found them about 4 years ago when someone I follow rented their wedding day jewelry from them and knew then (wasn’t even e...
ngaged at the time) that I would use them for my wedding day! The day after I selected my dress and veil I made an appointment to book my rentals from Verstolo. I rented the beautiful Savannah pearl and diamond drop earrings and the Mila marquee tennis bracelet. I would pick them both again in a heartbeat! They were the perfect touch to my sleek, modern yet classic wedding look and then looked great with my second party outfit! I got more compliments on my earrings than any piece of jewelry I have ever owned and proudly shared Verstolo with all who asked! The process was clear and easy and I would rent again and again from them! Might just book a rental as a bridesmaid for some weddings this year!
Had such a great experience with Verstolo! Lauren helped curate the perfect pieces to match the vibe of our wedding and my dress style. My earrings and bracelet were PERFECT and I ...
got so many compliments on them. My mom even rented jewelry for the big day too. Can’t recommend Verstolo enough!
I had an absolutely delightful experience renting earrings for my wedding day from Verstolo! Caitlin was incredibly kind, knowledgeable, and a joy to work with. I truly appreciated...
her taking the time to personally consult with me at the NYC office, allowing me to try on several pairs and find the perfect fit. Caitlin's genuine care for my experience was evident, and she even recommended the Millie earrings, which turned out to be the ideal choice—both beautiful and more affordable than other options I had considered.
The entire process, from pickup to return, was seamless. As an added bonus, they even cleaned my other wedding jewelry for free! The earrings were comfortable and secure throughout the entire day, and I received countless compliments on them.
A huge thank you to Caitlin and the entire Verstolo team for helping bring my dream wedding look to life! I will absolutely return for future diamond rentals and purchases.
I rented my wedding jewelry here and I was SO happy with Verstolo. Lauren was amazing, so great through the whole process. 10/10 customer service - you don't see that kind of custo...
mer service anymore. They were amazing. My earrings were just beautiful and I got so many compliments. HIGHLY recommend Verstolo!!!
For our September 2024 wedding we rented a diamond tennis necklace and diamond earrings from Verstolo. From start to finish we were guided with styles that matched our wedding vibe...
and my dress. We also designed our engagement ring and wedding bands with them as well, and they reengraved our heirloom gold cufflinks. 10/10!!
I worked with Verstolo for my August 2024 wedding and the process was totally seamless - a friend has recommended them after her own wedding and so I ended up renting earrings and ...
a bracelet for my wedding weekend. I had gone to the showroom in person a few months in advance to see options, and even ended up swapping out to different earrings a few weeks later, and they were so easy to work with. My mom handled the return process and she said it was a breeze. 10/10 worth working with Verstolo if you are contemplating renting diamonds for your wedding!
100/10 recommend!!! The Verstolo team was so great to work with — super knowledgeable, always quick responses, and truly there to help you. They were flexible when I changed my min...
d on earrings a few times :) and always did their best to accommodate however possible! Not to mention the jewelry is absolutely STUNNING. No photo is able to capture how radiant the jewelry is in person. I felt so beautiful on my wedding day wearing such amazing pieces - felt like such a princess! - and when else would you wear other than one of the biggest days of your life on your wedding day! I would use Verstolo again 10 times over, can’t recommend enough!
Working with Lauren and Caitlin from Verstolo was such an incredible experience. They take the time to sit with you and go over every piece of jewelry you’re interested in with nev...
er feeling rushed in your appointment and on your wedding day, wearing their gorgeous jewelry, you feel so truly special. Verstolo has so many options to choose from, way more than I expected and they have something for everyone - from simple pieces to over the top stand out statements - they have so much to choose from. Their team is wonderful, prices are very reasonable for what you’re renting, and their jewelry selection is out of this world. I rented for myself, my mom and my mother in law and we all felt so special all night. Highly recommend working with Verstolo for your upcoming wedding or event.
I rented the Zoey earrings for my June 2024 wedding and I simply could not have loved them more!!!! The whole process with Verstolo was absolutely seamless from start to finish - f...
rom trying on so many different styles in their showroom, to great communication leading up to the wedding, to the earrings arriving in perfect condition and on time. They were the total star of the show and my wedding look would not have been complete without them. Thank you so much Verstolo - I will be back!!!
I rented earrings and a diamond necklace for my daughter's wedding and they were absolutely stunning. My daughter also rented earrings and a tennis bracelet that were exquisite. T...
he rental process is so easy and Lauren was wonderful to work with. I highly recommend Verstolo.
Exceptional from start to finish. I didn't have much time before my wedding and Verstolo saved me. I cannot gush about it enough. The pieces are exceptional ,but whats even better ...
is the team. They really do want to help you have the best day. Shipping is easy and they make it as stress free as possible. I will use Verstolo again and highly recommend for any brides or events!
Exquisite Elegance and Unparalleled Service - A Perfect Experience with Verstolo Diamonds:
When planning my wedding, I wanted every detail to be perfect, and finding the right je...
welry was a crucial part of that vision. After extensive research, I decided to rent earrings from Verstolo Diamond Rentals, and I am thrilled with the decision.
From the moment I visited their website, I was impressed by the vast selection of stunning diamond earrings. The user-friendly interface made it easy to browse through various designs, and the high-quality images provided a clear view of each piece's intricate details.
What truly set Verstolo apart was their exceptional customer service. Thank you Caitlin and Lauren!!! I had a few questions regarding the rental process and the specific earrings I was interested in. The customer service team was incredibly responsive, knowledgeable, and courteous. They provided detailed answers and even offered styling advice to ensure the earrings complemented my wedding dress perfectly.
The rental process was seamless and hassle-free. The earrings arrived promptly, beautifully packaged in a luxurious box that added to the overall experience. When I opened the box, I was absolutely captivated by the brilliance and craftsmanship of the earrings. They were even more stunning in person than I had imagined.
On my wedding day, the earrings added the perfect touch of elegance and sophistication to my ensemble. I received countless compliments from guests, and I felt like a true princess. The quality of the diamonds was exceptional, and the earrings were comfortable to wear throughout the entire day and night.
Returning the earrings was just as easy as the rental process. Verstolo provided clear instructions and a prepaid return label, making it convenient and stress-free.
Overall, my experience with Verstolo Diamond Rentals was nothing short of extraordinary. They exceeded my expectations in every aspect, from the exquisite jewelry selection to their top-notch customer service. I wholeheartedly recommend Verstolo to anyone looking to add a touch of luxury to their special occasions. Thank you, Verstolo, for making my wedding day even more magical!
Lauren and the Verstolo team were so helpful when i came in to pick out some jewelry to rent for my wedding. I ended up going with the Charlize earrings, and I received SO MANY com...
pliments about how beautiful they were and how perfect they went with my dress, something that Lauren made sure to keep in mind when making recommendations at our consultation. Even my mother, who had never heard of jewelry rentals and was skeptical about the process, told me she was so glad I had done it because the earrings were just so gorgeous.
I had a wonderful experience renting the Olivia earrings and purchasing our wedding bands from Verstolo for our April 2024 wedding! Lauren was extremely helpful and knowledgeable w...
hen assisting in picking out earrings to rent and spent the necessary time with us helping guide our wedding band choices. We are so happy with the earrings that we rented and love our beautifully crafted wedding bands. Thank you, Verstolo, for an awesome experience and for making our wedding day so special!
My interaction with Verstolo was seamless, the delivery, the return, the jewelry, everything was awesome. I am glad I chose them to add that special sparkle to my day
BEST EXPERIENCE. I felt like a million dollars thanks to Verstolo - I loved working with the whole team from the consultation to the receiving the package. The whole process was se...
amless.
I rented Isla, Sophie and Marielle.
Lauren is the absolute best! She helped me match the perfect earrings to my wedding dress and she was extremely kind and patient through the process. The delivery and return was ex...
tremely simple and Verstolo's team send everything pre-packaged to make it all very easy! I would definitely recommend working with Lauren to find the perfect pieces for your wedding weekend or a special occasion!
Renting with Verstolo is one of the best decisions I made for my wedding! Lauren was a delight to work with and so patient while we tried on a million styles and debated what to re...
nt. I absolutely LOVED the earrings (Ilana) and bracelet (Isabella) I wore on my wedding day - they made me feel so special. And my mom rented the most gorgeous bracelet (Aurelia) that I honestly wanted to steal and wear for myself. Most importantly, my jewelry survived a long night of very crazy dancing without any worry that it might fall off or feel too heavy, which was a big concern.
Verstolo's jewelry is so well made, so beautiful, and was really the perfect finishing touch to my wedding look. I can't recommend them enough for brides and I can't wait to buy rental gift certificates for all of the future brides in my life!!
I can’t say enough positive about Lauren and Verstolo. The jewelry was gorgeous and made my day that much more special, and the whole process was so seamless and pleasant! Lauren ...
was a dream to work with!!
Cannot recommend Verstolo enough! What a genius concept. I went to Verstolo with my mom a few months before my wedding, and it was probably my favorite wedding appointment ever!
...
Lauren is SO beyond sweet, helpful, and informative. Not to mention the amazing and beautiful styles they have in inventory. It is a grown-up Disneyland. My mom and I rented earrings for the weekend, and they truly completed the looks.
The process is so seamless- I would recommend to anyone for a major event!
Verstolo is the absolutely best! Lauren was so helpful in picking out styles. I rented for Friday and Saturday night of my wedding weekend and was so happy that I did!
My friend got me a gift card to jump start my experience with Verstolo which was great! It was worth every penny - I loved working with their responsive team and the jewels were so...
gorgeous. I received so many compliments on my wedding day. Highly recommend working with Verstolo for all of your special occasions.
I can't recommend working with Lauren and Verstolo enough! The process of booking, receiving, and shipping my earrings was seamless! My Monique earrings beautifully completed my Ho...
llywood glam look. I will be renting and hopefully buying from Verstolo! Thank you!
I can't recommend working with Verstolo enough! I felt so special all weekend long and got so many compliments on my jewels! Lauren was lovely to work with, making it a seamless ex...
perience from helping me select my pieces, to shipping them to me, to sending them back. I would absolutely rent from them again!!
Contact
590 5th Ave, New York, NY
Verstolo Diamond Rentals