About this vendor
Vintage Gentlemen is a Saint Augustine, FL-based jeweler with a unique selection of wedding bands. We have provided over 100,000 wedding bands to customers all across the US. Our rings are made from unique materials such as whiskey barrels, deer antlers, black zirconium, tantalum, titanium, tungsten, and more.
Are you unsure of your ring size? No worries. You can reserve your ring, and we can send a free ring sizer to help. We also offer a free resizing if you don’t get that perfect fit the first time.
We have over 4,000 five-star reviews from satisfied couples who have trusted us since 2015.
Details
Rings
- Engagement Rings
- Ring Services
- Custom Designs
- Financing Available
- Ring Sizing
Wedding Jewelry
- Rings
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
2.3
out of 5.04 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 5
If I could leave zero stars I would. I ordered my husband’s wedding band many months before our wedding on July 20 of 2025. In August 2025 his ring came apart and two pieces. I ema...
iled with the picture of the messed up ring and also sent a picture in message on their Instagram because I was not getting a response. It took me three attempts until I finally got an answer from a person named John. I bought my husband the Atlas ring. I wanted to get another one of those because we liked it so much. They said that they didn’t have another one of those that was a size 9 in stock, but they would get more and 6 to 8 weeks and they would let me know. I waited around patiently and I didn’t receive any messages or emails from them so I had to ask myself and they told me all these excuses of why they didn’t have the ring and so I kept waiting around a little longer. I have been emailing them for August of last year and I just now got a new ring mind you one that I did not want at all. Over the course of emails they said that they would let me choose a ring that was $400 and under for free. I picked a couple rings but one that I got a snarky remark from saying well it did say that on site the nine was out of stock. And remind you, I’m not getting messages from Liz and Charles and Brandon and whoever the hell I’m talking to. I found another size 9 ring, but that was pre-order instead, and I got another snarky remark from that. So I was like I’m not playing these games. You can give me a list of all the size 9 rings that you have available. They sent me three none of which looked like Atlas ring whatsoever so I just decided they need to make it right and sent me a new ring. It did ship really fast but the ring is hideous and I’m just done dealing with these people. These rings are obviously cheaply made. They don’t make them in house. If you look it up, they have like this tiny little warehouse in Florida. I feel like this company is a scam and you might as well spend your money elsewhere. Especially with better customer service.
We just got married, but when we were looking for a mens jewelry company that would match my brides rosegold ring and band it was slim pickens. This ring company had more than a fe...
w options, allowed a free exchange to get the right size, and with my ring it came with a silicone ring included. Bride and I are happy as of now.
I would avoid them. I purchased the "Outdoorsman" ring two years ago and all was well until a few weeks ago when it came apart (this is one that is metal with wood inside). The woo...
d came detached from the metal. I took this of when showering and sometimes when even washing my hands. I treated it well. And it broke.
Vintage Gentleman was no help and did not stand by their workmanship. Though they are currently offering a "Lifetime Guarantee" that you can 'buy' for free, that was not an option when I bought this ring (you had to pay for a warrantee, which seemed silly for a ring. Joke's on me, I guess.)
They offered to let me pay for a repair or pay for a warranty, despite it now being free. I passed on the opportunity to spend more money on something that should not come apart after two years. Considering it is advertised as "This ring was designed by us with the outdoorsman and adventurer in mind," one would think it would be a bit more rugged.
Avoid. Them. At. All. Costs.
Beautiful ring, horrible customer service.
Contact
Saint Augustine, FL
Vintage Gentlemen