Wonderful Wedding Cakes

Best of Weddings (1x)

296 Forest Ave, Locust Valley, NY

About this vendor

Wonderful Wedding Cakes is a Custom Cake Shop specializing in couture cakes, cupcakes and favors. We use only the finest imported chocolates and natural ingredients in our "from-scratch" baking. Let us create an edible masterpiece for you. By appointment only.

Details

Cakes & Desserts

Cake Accessories

Awards and Affiliations

5

out of 5.0

26 reviews

Search reviews

10/11/2022 • Susan K R

I first encountered Kristan at WWC for my daughters baby shower back in 2017. WWC made an absolutely amazing tasting and beautiful looking cake. I continued to use WWC for many more occasions over the years for my family and was never disappointed and never concerned over price ( and many of the cakes I ordered were $300.00 +)Kristan was never the most pleasant person to deal with ( many others have said so on her website) she can be cranky, curt and dismissive ( she could be pleasant also) but I over looked all that because WWC was so good and I was very pleased with her cakes and other stuff. This year of 2022 I did my usual and had numerous orders. I ordered 3 birthday cakes, one for April and 2 in May for August birthdays, a bridal shower cake for June and wedding cake for September for over 250 people. She did the April BD Cake and it was great. Emailed me in June( a month after the original order) and told me she could not do the August BD cakes because she was booked for those dates. I emailed her my disappointment and surprise at this since she had 3 months prior notice and emailed me back a month later after my order. Silence, no response from her at all. WWC did make the bridal shower cake for June. It looked and tasted magnificent. She was an absolute crank at the delivery when I asked her about the wedding cake. I had been emailing(numerous times) and leaving voice mails (numerous times) at WWC to talk to her and go over details and questions I had regarding the wedding cake. Again, silence, no response whatsoever even after my last email and voice mail to her stating that the wedding was getting close and I have not heard from her at all and I am concerned. Kristan did not respond to me and basically almost left me without a wedding cake ( it was getting closer to the date and I was concerned I would not be able to get another baker in such a short time. I left her one more email(7/28/22), wedding 9/4/22 stating I was extending her the courtesy , more than she extended to me that I was no longer interested in her doing the wedding cake , nor will I be ordering from her ever again Once again, silence, no response, no apology, no explanation, NO NOTHING!!! Very unprofessional, very uncaring, very dismissive. Thank goodness I was able to find another baker who could handle this with such short notice . That baker is SugarSugarCustomCakes in Farmingdale/Quogue who did a great job. I have always praised WWC and recommended them to many. I have also always been courteous, friendly and respectful to Kristan so what her issue was I will never know. This is just to let all you brides and others know to beware that this could happen to you also depending on Kristan's mood.

9/02/2022 • Fiona W

Kristan was awesome. The initial tasting was delicious and she provided helpful suggestions. The pricing was very reasonable and the final product was beautiful -- and tasted better than we could have imagined. Guests were happy, we were happy, and now we wait eagerly until next year to have more. Highly recommend!

8/05/2022 • Michelle G

Wonderful Wedding cakes was great. My husband and I used them for our July 9 wedding. The cake was delicious and beautiful!

8/02/2022 • Nicole T

Wonderful Wedding Cakes was great to work with! We went in for a tasting where they provided us with multiple delicious cake and filling options to try. We chose the white velvet cake with a raspberry mousse filling and it was absolutely delicious! We spoke about the design during this meeting as well. I had asked for a simple cake with painted lace on it to match the lace on my dress. They did an absolutely wonderful job! It looked stunning and the cake was so moist and delicious! I highly recommend working with them for your wedding!

7/08/2022 • Lisa C

The cake prepared by Wonderful Wedding Cakes was all that we hoped and dreamed it would be, and even more. Not only was it spectacularly beautiful, and the flowers magnificently selected and placed, but the various layers and fillings were unique and delicious in different ways. A good friend who is a doctor put on sunglasses and told our son's wife that she was going incognito to the dessert table at de Seversky Mansion so that she could score a second piece of cake, and she shared with us at the end of the evening that the second piece was even more delicious than the first. Indeed, there was nothing left at the end of the evening because everyone took at least one piece, if not more, and Samuel and Katherine were left with their favorite, strawberry shortcake, the top layers of the wedding cake. Countless guests have shared that it was the “best of the best” of wedding cakes and asked for the name and business card of Kristan, the owner. We wouldn’t be at all surprised if their phone has been ringing off the hook with new orders. Wonderful Wedding Cakes took exceptional care with our wedding cake order, and helped to make a magical wedding day for our son Samuel and his wife Katherine. It was a real pleasure to do business with an entrepreneur who prides herself on the quality of her work and service to her customers. We are very grateful. Wonderful Wedding Cakes deserves to win the 2022 Wedding Cake of the Year Award! Brava.

9/10/2021 • Victoria K

Kristan was a pleasure to communicate with. We ordered a two-tier cake and a separate sheet cake for our wedding. Kristan and her team was able to provide a cake exactly like the pictures we sent over. Cake was delicious and delivered without issues. Would highly recommend!

5/15/2021 • Alexandra G

Kristan was a pleasure to work with. Our wedding cake was absolutely beautiful and so delicious! We chose vanilla cake with strawberry mousse and buttercream frosting adorned with flowers from our floral vendor. It was a huge hit with our guests! The strawberry mousse is the most amazingly delicious cake filling ever. Highly recommend Wonderful Wedding Cakes!

5/11/2021 • Mary F

kristan was amazing to work with. We had a almond cake with whipped cream and white chocolate filling. It was absolutely delicious! It was one of the best Long Island has to offer. If you're looking for a cake it's worth checking out!

10/12/2020 • Katie P

Kristan was super responsive and helpful and a pleasure to work with! Not only that, but my wedding cake was absolutely beautiful AND the best cake I’ve ever tasted - We went with textured buttercream, vanilla cake, and chocolate and raspberry mousse- so good!! You won’t go wrong choosing Wonderful Wedding Cakes for your special occasion!

4/23/2019 • Irene W

I first encountered Wonderful Wedding Cakes at a bridal showcase and had the opportunity to try some cake samples. Their cake was delicious and they were able to make something specific for us. We had wanted a lemon theme for our cake and they were able to make a lemon sponge cake with a lemon curd filling and lemon-infused frosting. When we met with them, they were incredibly receptive to our ideas and nothing was impossible. They had pictures of different designs and options. Our cake looked beautiful and tasted amazing!

4/23/2019 • Nicole S

We couldn’t be happier with the service and cake!

1/12/2019 • Sarah M

We used Wonderful Wedding Cakes for our wedding in October on Long Island. Kristan and her team made us a three tiered wedding cake (each tier with a different flavor combination) and a Groom's cake. The cake came out absolutely stunning! I emailed Kristan a picture of a cake I saw on Pinterest and she made it look 10x better than the photo! She also worked with Petals, our incredible florist (use them too!), to add real flowers to our cake! It is also important to mention that the cake tasted DELICIOUS! The raspberry chocolate combo and the cannoli cream are to die for. The team at Wonderful Wedding Cakes is also very responsive and helpful. They are a little pricey, but they are worth it! Use them for your next event if you want everyone talking about how delicious and beautiful the cake was!

8/08/2018 • Jessica M

Wonderful Wedding Cakes was all around awesome! Our Florist, Petals in Locust Valley, recommended that we reach out to Wonderful Wedding Cakes, and we are so happy that we did! They were also one of the suggested cake vendors at our venue, NYIT DeSeversky Mansion in Glen Head. Kristan was great to work with! We did a brief tasting with her and knew right away that the variety and quality of what WWC could offer us was exactly what we needed! Kristan was able to accommodate each one of our requests: A three layered naked cake using chocolate pound cake, with a filling of chocolate ganache, Nutella, raspberry jam, and fresh raspberries. The outside of the cake was lighted frosted with white chocolate buttercream. Kristan knows our venue well and the dessert offerings they provide, so she made a very reasonable suggestion as to how large of a cake we needed based on our anticipated number of guests and the variety of desserts that would be presented in addition to the cake. Even with so many dessert options available, our guests LOVED our cake... we only wish we'd had more than a few bites of it, and we can't wait to enjoy the top layer of it on our first anniversary! In comparison to the other bakery we considered, WWC quoted a very reasonable price, and absorbed the nominal cost of the tasting into the cost of the cake. The communication and payment process leading up to the wedding was seamless - Kristan was always very responsive. She worked with our venue and our Sales/Event Coordinator Rocio, who is awesome, to work out a timeline for delivery. She also coordinated with Diana at Petals and our Day-Of Coordinator Kelly Teglas to arrange for fresh flowers and our cake topper to be added to the cake. We used the cake stand available (for no fee) at our venue, and everything came together perfectly!! We definitely plan to use WWC for other occasion cakes in the future!

7/22/2018 • Kristin Z

Wow Kristan was so great to work with! Stress free, didn’t say no to our crazy design we wanted and built a fantastic cake that tasted great! Unique one of a kind and beautiful! Glad I used Wonderful Wedding Cakes on my wedding day they were professional and delivered beyond what I asked for! Thank you Kristin and Alexey

7/11/2018 • Jesse C

My husband and I got married on June 24th 2018 at Soundview Caterers. Wonderful Wedding Cakes made the PERFECT wedding cake for us! It was beautiful and tasted delicious also. They were very easy to work with and I highly recommend them for any of your cake needs.

11/22/2017 • Emma V

We used WWC for my bridal shower and she made an absolutely GORGEOUS cake. I showed her a photo of what I wanted and she literally replicated it to a tee!! We had a 2 tier cake and each tier was a different cake and filling. Everyone couldn't stop talking about how delicious and beautiful it was!! So happy we chose to work with them again for our wedding cake!!

11/14/2017 •

Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious! Kristan was absolutely wonderful to work with. She was very responsive to all of my questions. We will definitely be happy to work with her again.

8/23/2017 • Lauren S

Our wedding cake did not disappoint! Not only was it delicious, it was beautiful! Kristan was so easy to work with and was reasonably priced.

6/24/2017 • Brooke Z

Kristan is absolutely amazing! She has made cakes for me for every occasion - birthdays, baby shower, bridal shower, wedding, christening... every cake is perfect! AND as perfect as it looks, it is even that much more delicious! A cake that is so yummy and picture perfect!? yes! WOW! She is just fabulous! She should be known worldwide and be the only person allowed to make desserts! Thanks to Kristan every event I have had has been that much more special because of her!

11/05/2014 • Amber Y

I live out of state so it makes finding good vendors difficult. I didn't even meet this baker in person. We only had communication through phone and email. I sent them a picture of a very complex groom cake shaped like an airplane. It looked better than the picture. They even asked for a picture of us to replicate us on the airplane :). I would have chosen them for our wedding cake if our venue didn't have their own baker they work with. We thank you so much!! Amber & Chris Marovich

6/16/2014 • Christine W

I used Kristan for my engagement party, shower, rehearsal dinner, and wedding cakes, I was not once disappointed. She was so creative and not only were the cakes beautiful, they tasted great too! I would recommend her to everyone!

8/20/2013 • Emma M

Wonderful Wedding Cakes did an amazing job on our wedding cake! The handmade sugar flowers were beautiful and the piped design perfectly matched the embroidery on my dress. It was also the best cake I’ve ever eaten! The favors were incredible! Everyone really loved it!

5/29/2013 • Stacey S

Working with Wonderful Wedding Cakes was a pleasure! I always said, there are two things that are most important at my wedding: my dress and my cake (after I actually got engaged I realized that there was so much more, including the groom, but that's besides the point). Kristan was great to work with. She was knowledgeable and flexible. She met our request for a peanut butter mousse cake to be delivered to Montauk with no problem! The lace design on our cake was so beautiful I almost felt bad eating it but now that our wedding is over I can't wait to eat the top layer on our one year anniversary!

11/09/2012 • Joni F

We were so lucky - when booking our wedding at The Club at The Metropolitan for 9/12, we found out that our cake would be included. What we didn't know at the time was how not only beautiful it would be, but how delicious it would be! The theme for our wedding was Autumn leaves, & when meeting with Eileen, The Metropolitan's Catering Manager, to discuss our cake, we gave her several pictures of cakes we liked, & chose red velvet with cream cheese buttercream frosting. We were so happy to see our cake for the first time on the morning of our wedding - it was not only beautiful, but exactly what we envisioned - Kristin at Wonderful Wedding Cakes you are amazing!

10/24/2012 • Kayla M

We picked out our cake with Wonderful Wedding Cakes after our initial meeting, and went with a chocolate cake with chocolate ganache and raspberry mousse. It was seriously the best cake I ever tasted, and it looked absolutely perfect.