I honestly chose You + Me for the price. Out of every caterer in the area that I found, they were by far the cheapest and that was what I needed at the time of booking.
However, we were completely blown away by the service, the food, and the c...ommunication by Lindsay and team.
The service was amazing, with Lindsay going above and beyond in serving us and making sure that everyone had a great experience. Plus, they put together a beautiful spread for the appetizers and buffet tables which I had zero expectation of.
The food was also perfect. We ordered trays of lasagna to keep it simple on our end, and not only was it incredibly delicious (and tasted 100% homemade), but the portions were big and filling. On top of that, we had a healthy mix of vegetarian lasagna which was just as good as the meat, and even one vegan lasagna (which I fully expected to be a random plate of tofu stuff and not lasagna like what everyone else was eating) which again was just as good as the meat. Plus the rolls and the cinnamon butter were to die for. We all went back for more of those.
Finally, the team was on top of their stuff and was very communicative. Before the event, Lindsay was a perfect resource, constantly answering my questions and making countless adjustments to the proposal before securing the booking. I hadn’t even paid a deposit and she was giving me incredibly personal service. The team showed up early to set up and Lindsay was sure to send me a text to let me know when they would be arriving beforehand so we could make sure we had someone to meet her at the door. They assembled our tables perfectly (with real china and metal silverware I might add, which goes back to price — super affordable!), and timely, and every water glass was filled in time for the reception. Plus, throughout the night not one glass of water was empty until they left. The team cleared the tables with ease and left on time without a headache.
We had a great wedding day, and that is in large part thanks to our vendors. If I could do it all again I would do it exactly the same!