A Slice of Heaven Custom Cakes

Sarasota, Venice, Lakewood Ranch, Longboat Key, Siesta Key,


Price Range

$$ – Affordable

Wedding Categories

Cake Accessories, Cakes + Desserts


Contact Info

7357 International Place Suite 106, Sarasota, FL Sarasota, Venice, Lakewood Ranch, Longboat Key, Siesta Key, (941) 341-0038

Reviewed on 6/22/2017 Chelsea K

Our cake was arguably the best part of our wedding- we did a three tier, 'translucent' (think a naked cake with a schmear) amaretto cake with alternating layers of cannoli cream and raspberry coulis. It was beyond words!! We will be making return trips for anniversary cakes!

Reviewed on 12/02/2016 Kate Q

I highly recommend this vendor. I planned my wedding from out of state and I was nervous about the cake (since I couldn't do a tasting). The cake turned out beautiful and my families and friend agreed that it was the best cake they have ever had!

Reviewed on 9/11/2016 Katie T

I found Thomas to be very dismissive when I sent my initial email about my wedding cake. When I told him it was a small wedding, he pretty much pushed me to the Brides on a Budget section and advised that I place my order at least 5 days before my wedding. Just because our... Read More wedding is small, does not mean we want a stock cake and not a custom design (which we more than willing to pay top dollar for). He lost our business very quickly despite the great reviews. We found another baker who was excited we are getting married and offered ideas right away. She congratulated us, asked our theme, and sent dozens of photos of potential designs. That is what a bride wants when choosing a baker. Not a perfunctory email basically saying your business isn't important and they can't be bothered to suggest ideas.

Reviewed on 11/12/2015

The groom's cake we requested from Mr. Brazen exceeded our expectations. Not only was the design original and our son-in-law touched by it but the cake was delicious and tasted like it was home baked. We would highly recommend him and use them again for another event.

Looked and tasted amazing!!

Reviewed on 7/16/2015

My catering company, Sarasota Catering, recommended A Slice of Heaven to us. I worked with Thomas and Michelle on both my surprise groom's cake and tiered cupcake tower. They went above and beyond to make my vision a reality. They were quick to respond to all my questions and... Read More emails during the wedding planning process. Michelle was so patient through all my indecisiveness and had great suggestions and guidance. The groom's cake and cupcake tower both turned out incredible and I received tons of compliments on them (wish I could share pictures). Whatever ideas you have, they will do whatever it takes to deliver. I'm so happy I went with A Slice of Heaven for my wedding!


Reviewed on 11/30/2013 Bonnie B

Tom and the staff at Slice of Heaven are phenomenal!! Our wedding cake was SO GORGEOUS.. decorated to PERFECTION with fresh flowers, scroll work, beading, and our personal cake topper! And of course...it was absolutely DELICIOUS!! Designer Michele was FABULOUS to work with ~ I... Read More descibed what I envisioned ~ and WOW, the end result was way beyond anything I ever imagined ~ just beautiful!! AND she personally delivered it to our venue ~ now that's OUTSTANDING service!! The cake was a surprise for my husband, and after our Ceremony he kept asking.. "Did you see the cake?".. "Did you see the cake?!" He even mentioned it AGAIN today.. over a month after our wedding!! No kidding!! That's how much he loved it! Our friends gave us a little photo album of the pictures they took from our wedding- and guess what the first picture was? Nope, not us...it was THE CAKE!! LOL! Tom & Michele, I can't thank you enough for making all our Wedding Day dreams come true! I HIGHLY recommend A Slice of Heaven to anyone seeking THE BEST OF THE BEST in the area for your cake, cupcakes, or whatever you dream of for your special event ~ THEY ARE HEAVEN SENT!!

i hate cake and i loved this cake

Reviewed on 5/31/2013 Jackie K

the groom and i are not cake people, but i found this place through our wedding venue and they had brides on a budget cake. i chose the flavor and one of the designs they had on their website. i never talked to anyone on the phone or went in for a tasting. i just sent an... Read More email, paid the really great price they asked for, and the cake appeared on my wedding day. it was absolutely gorgeous and i was blown away by how great it tasted. i could be byass because it was my wedding, but it was the best wedding cake i have ever had. usually wedding cakes and cupcakes are dry and the frosting is hard, but this cake was so good. it was moist and so freakin good! top notch quality for such a great price!

Husband did good!

Reviewed on 11/20/2012 Amy S

I let my husband take care of the cake. I gave him a picture and he did the rest. A slice of heaven made my vision come true. I am very thankful and we had so many compliments on how good it was!


Reviewed on 10/13/2012 Lisa S

OMG!!! Amazing staff, so artistic, so YUMMY!! They made our grooms cake to look like a playstation controller and our wedding cake was georgeous!! I have found our new baker for whenever we need a cake!! You will not be disappointed!!

lego grooms cake

Reviewed on 8/20/2012 Tiffany M

I had a blue lego cake made for my hubsand as his grooms cake. he was totally surprised and LOVED it! turned out just as i pictured it. great to work with very prompt in answering any questions i had.

Amazing Cake

Reviewed on 7/29/2012 Christina F

I went to A Slice of Heaven about 2 1/2 weeks before my wedding but that didn't really matter. They told me they would get it done. I showed them pictures of different styles that I liked and they told me how expensive each would be. I didn't have time for a cake tasting so I... Read More chose from the pamphlet they provided me and Boy! you can't go wrong with any of those flavors! They made me a beautiful 3 tier cake with no tier the same. They also made me 50 delicious cupcakes - chocolate with strawberry filling and vanilla with Georgia peach filling. The cakes/cupcakes were INCREDIBLE! We were initially worried that we had ordered too much but all the different flavors were clearly a hit because we turned around and almost everything was gone. A Slice of Heaven crew knows how to get the job done with style and taste! They are definitely the best and I will definitely be coming to them for all occasions! They even cater!

So tasty!

Reviewed on 7/05/2012 Kristine D

We had so many compliments on how good our cake was. The specialty fillings and cake were great to make a unique cake that everyone can enjoy.

Perfection in Cake

Reviewed on 6/20/2012 Julie C

I found A Slice of Heaven through my venue and their name says it all! OMG their cakes are unbelievable. We used their "Brides on a Budget" line and their was certainly nothing "budget" about our cake. Their name says it all!!! If they're not your first and only stop for... Read More cake, your tastebuds are dead!

Their name says it all!

Reviewed on 6/13/2012 Holly S

Best wedding cake and cupcakes I have had in my entire life! Have the key lime flavor! It's to die for! The cake was gorgeous and unique. Just what I wanted. Very respectable place and will definitely recommend again and again!!


Reviewed on 6/05/2012 Kelly M

Great price, many compliments. Brides on a budget was perfect for our destination wedding.

Best Place for Wedding Cake in Sarasota

Reviewed on 3/26/2012 Brooke T

This place is better than all of the other cake places in quality of design and cake, plus the people that own it are a lot friendlier than the other main competition in Sarasota. During the tasting they went above and beyond to let me sample any creation I could think of, they... Read More spent as much time as I needed with me making sure my cake was perfect, and when it came to the wedding day they were great with communication, showed up on time, and delivered a DELICIOUS and BEAUTIFUL Cake. I would recommend that EVERYONE go there for their wedding cake!


Reviewed on 2/12/2012 xxxxx x

A Slice of Heaven worked with us to create a beautiful and delicious wedding cake! They figured out how to attach our home made cake topper, placed the flowers beautifully, and delivered it to the venue right on time. On the business side - It was a bit strange that the cake... Read More tasting was only a few blobs of filling and a tiny bit of chocolate and vanilla cake, so you really couldn't tell what the final product would be like unless you bought a slice or a cupcake, if available. And when I called a few weeks before the event to pay the balance as directed in our initial meeting, I was rudely told that it should have been done weeks ago. So, they need to keep that policy consistent and not be rude to a customer that is calling to give them money per the contract! Otherwise though, the cake looked and tasted great! We chose one layer of vanilla with raspberry filling, and another of key lime with key lime filling. Guests loved it too!

Delicious Cake!

Reviewed on 12/16/2011 Jessica K

Not only was the cake visually appealing... It was so yummy! I was impressed as were my guests!

Delectable Cake!

Reviewed on 12/16/2011 Eric O

This was not just any wedding cake. It was moist and flavorful! It was everything the bride wanted it to be and more. Very impressive for being a "budget" cake.


Reviewed on 11/29/2011 sativa s

Ok, I will start with the bad I guess. The cake really did not look much like the picture I sent them. It did look like other cakes I saw on their website, which is fine. I just wish they would have told me they couldn't do what I wanted and I would have picked another cake.... Read More I was planning my Florida wedding from Texas and never actually met with them in person,but a little more communication would've been nice. HOWEVER...the cake was still pretty, of course and was absolutely DELICIOUS! And that is way more important than if it looked exactly the way I wanted. I was even told by guests that it was the best cake they have ever had at a wedding.


Reviewed on 11/29/2011 Carrie A

Good cake!!! Thomas was wonderful to work with in picking out flavors and fillings. He helped us with designing the cake and listened to all our ideas. We had done three cake tastings before this one and after tasting thier cake we signed up on the spot. Our priorty was good... Read More cake and we found it!

Awesome cake

Reviewed on 11/21/2011 michael o

Our cake was so nice. It was beautiful and delicious. It fit perfectly with our beach theme, and we got a ton of compliments on how good it tasted! We had marble with chocolate mousse filling and fondant icing.

Awesome Cakes!

Reviewed on 11/17/2011 Jessica K

My cake was marble with chocolate mousse filling. It was so tasty, we got a ton of compliments on how great it was. I really would recommend this baker, and will use them again in the future for other events! :)


Reviewed on 10/11/2011 Jordan G

Our cake was three layers: key lime with key lime filling, coconut with pina colada filling, and lemon with raspberry filling. It was DELICIOUS! Everyone raved about it--even asking if they could take some home. We did a cake tasting with Thomas and he was a total delight to... Read More work with--nice, knowledgeable, and funny. I brought in a picture of what I wanted our cake to look like and they totally delivered! We plan on visiting them again for our anniversary = )


Reviewed on 9/28/2011 Rebecca F

I had one of the most beautiful cakes I have ever seen. I also had a very unusual groom cake request. They made it perfect. It was moist and tasty.