We don‘t know Amy's Custom Cakery‘s story by heart. Message them to get to know more about their business.
Cakes & Desserts
Amy's Custom Cakery Reviews
Share your thoughts with other couples
Reviewed On 11/08/2021 by J W
I ordered a wedding cake from Amy. She stated she could not deliver it but I could pick it up. At pick up she carried out a 3 tier wedding cake with no box and sat it in my cars trunk. No box, nothing to protect it from dirt or the environment...
. She wiggled the base and said it will be fine, this is how i deliver them and staring at it wont get it to where it needs to be. 5 miles down the road it collapsed from the bottom. My wedding cake ruined. We called Amy's and then returned to the store. She was rude, showed no care or concern and lacked empathy. She did state we were lucky that she even answered our called. She took two of the tiers and attempted to fix them and then placed them back together where again she sent it out just like the first time. The cake separated and looked like garbage. The bottom tier was destroyed and she gave us cupcakes to substitute it. She offered to money back, no apologies nothing. These tiers should have been boxed separately and send out for us to assemble. I am out 425 bucks, my wedding cake ruined and I am more upset at Amy's behavior and lack of customer service.
Reviewed On 12/12/2019 by Heather Y
Amy did cupcakes for our wedding along with a small cake to cut. It was all amazing. My husband and I LOVE banana, and we were able to have that flavor for us and the others as well as amazing other flavors for everyone. I cannot recommend her ...
Amy creates our wedding cake on October 6th and took our idea and it came alive. Our guests couldn’t get enough of the cake and raced all night about it! Highly recommended supporting this small business! We will definitely be back!
Reviewed On 5/21/2018 by Tyler T
The cake was beautiful and delicious! Our guests couldn’t get enough of it!
Reviewed On 3/25/2018 by Ciara S
The best cake ever! We tried many different bakers when planning our wedding but stopped as soon as we tried Amy’s. It was so delicious and the cake was absolutely beautiful!
Reviewed On 1/20/2018 by Sarah T
Cakes were delicious but was not the idea I really wanted. Looked very nice for birthday cakes but wedding was just not up to par, appearance wise.
Reviewed On 8/07/2017 by Lindy H
Amy was absolutely amazing! She had plenty of options for us during our tasting and even recommended a custom cupcake that matched our wedding theme- s'mores! The taste and variety of her cupcakes for the price is unbeatable. She even delivered...
and set them up at our venue on our wedding day, taking care of everything. I highly recommend her!
Reviewed On 6/13/2016 by Ray G
Amy was fantastic. She worked with us to make our dessert table aesthetically pleasing and very tasty. We had full cupcakes, chocolate chip cookies, peanut butter cookies, peanut butter drizzled brownies and sprinkled brownies. She worked with...
our color scheme and last minute additions. She was spot on with amount dessert to order.
Reviewed On 1/14/2016 by Diana Z
Our wedding cake was beautiful and looked just like the picture we gave Amy. It tasted amazing too! I would highly recommend Amy!
Reviewed On 10/18/2015 by Jessica H
My husband and I use Amy's Custom Cakery for our wedding cake. Amy did an absolutely fantastic job with our cake. When we went in initially for our tasting, she had so many different flavors of cakes and fillings ready for us to try. She even g...
ave me a fresh out of the oven red velvet cupcake when I asked if she had that flavor to try! She listed to what we envisioned with our cake and made notes. I had a picture of a cake that I really liked that I had shown her and asked if she could make something similar to that. She also reassured us that she was the one who did all of the wedding cakes to ensure that they were perfect, as well as reviewed the time of when she would be there to make sure it got there in time. With our guest list we were between having 3 and 4 layers - after we got our final count I called Amy and let her know our final count and she made sure that we would have enough cake for everyone. When we saw our cake at our reception I was so happy with how it had come out. It was exactly how I had envisioned it to be! We went with all marble cake and then alternated the filling flavor with raspberry and then chocolate mousse. Both flavors were amazing! All of our guests raved about how good it was, and how pretty it was! Our florist had left some flowers that we wanted on the cake and Amy arranged it perfectly. For an amazing cake (both looks and taste) at an affordable cost, I would definitely go with Amy's Custom Cakery!
Reviewed On 10/12/2015 by Megan H
I had over 200 people at my wedding and Amy made a beautiful 5 tier wedding cake for my wedding. I chose chocolate and peanut butter, white with raspberry, and lastly she helped create a flavor I found on the internet, apple spice cake with sa...
lted Carmel filing and brown sugar icing. It was amazing. I went in not really knowing exactly what look I wanted but showed her my there and the cake that she made was absolutely perfect. This girl is THE BEST!!
Reviewed On 10/07/2015 by Samantha H
Amy's cake was included in our package with the Altland House. We simply met with her, told her what we wanted and it was delivered day of. It was beautiful, just like I had wanted and it was delicious!
Reviewed On 7/07/2015 by Alison F
Amy was great to work with the entire process! Even being willing to contract with our caterer in a venue she is not normally contracted to do! She also made a very unique cake for us! Everyone loved the design and the cake was out of this worl...
d AMAZING... as always! We continue to frequent her shop for goodies! I would and do recommend Amy to ALL my friends for their wedding cakes, birthday cakes, anniversary cakes, etc. She will definitely be my cake maker for life!
Reviewed On 9/13/2014 by Amanda H
Amy, the owner, is very sweet to work with. I have known her for a while, and she is always so nice. She helps you decide what is best for your wedding (cupcakes vs. a normal cake, extra dessert items etc), and offers an enormous selection. We ...
had our first tasting with her and set down a deposit. And after a long while, I decided I wanted to try something different and we had a second tasting with her.
She is definitely willing to work with you. I wanted to try a neapolitan cake for the bottom tier of my wedding cake and we were able to work through that very easily! She is also up for trying any outer design for your cake.
I would recommend her to anyone.
Reviewed On 7/23/2014 by Erin L
We loved working with Amy. It felt good to support her local business and she does exceptional work. Our cake and cupcakes turned out great!
Reviewed On 6/25/2013 by sarah n
Amy was great to work with. She listened to our requests and did just what we asked. Her cake was outstanding. Not too sweet, beautiful, and had fresh fruit. Everyone loved it. Small business that was way more personable and desirable to deal w...
ith than a big place.
Reviewed On 7/19/2012 by Brittany L
My cake was ugly! It did not look at all like it was supposed to. It was the wrong shape, the wrong size, and all the wrong colors. My groom's cake was also not the way it was supposed to look. And the owner was not good with communication at a...