Atlantic did a fantastic job at our wedding!
They were recommended by a number of venues we visited, and were one of the preferred caterers for our venue, the Baltimore Museum of Industry.
From the start, Atlantic calmed our nerves- even walk...ing into their old-looking office, Kristin noted that they've not updated the decor in years because they put their money right back into the food and the service- and it shows. Working with Kristin was fantastic- she answered all questions, was very responsive, and we never had second thoughts about working with them. We did not "shop around" for our caterer, but Atlantic were recommended by just about everyone we talked to, for being a very professional caterer with great food at mid-level prices- in other words, a real value for the money!
We met with Kristin several times in person, and discussed a lot via email- any changes we wanted to make were easily made. The tasting was wonderful- they did not have any problems with us including my brother, who happened to be with us, and gave us enormous amounts of delicious food- so much so that there were tons of left-overs which they happily packed up for us to take to our family for dinner that night!
The wedding went off without a hitch- even with a sudden change in location for the cocktail hour due to the weather. The staff were kind and professional, and our guests were very impressed. My dad even mentioned that when cocktail hour began, he and his brothers swarmed the shrimp cocktail, practically eating right through it, but by the time they had blinked, the shrimp was refilled! My new husband continues to rave about the beef empanadas, and was thrilled that they had the pigs-in-a-blanket that were his only requirement for cocktail hour. The food was abundant and delicious.
Dinner also went beautifully. My only requirement, being a native Marylander, was crab cakes for dinner- and they were great! People continue to rave about them, there were even notes in our guest book about how delicious the crab cakes were. We also had the stuffed chicken and ravioli, with asparagus and roasted potatoes. Our only tiny, minor, nit-picky problem was that some of the potatoes were cut larger, so didn't cook as well as the smaller potatoes. This was the only "problem" we had with our entire experience with Atlantic- they were fantastic.
I myself had a nervous stomach during our wedding, and didn't really eat much, sadly- but our wonderful day-of-coordinator (Entertain Me De- Heidi Kern) and the staff at Atlantic made us a huge plate (really, a big foil pan's worth) of food, which I was able to eat later that night and the next day.
Overall, great food, good prices (definitely worth the cost!), fantastic staff.
We would absolutely recommend Atlantic and Kristin, and if we are able to throw a big party in the future in the Baltimore area, we will have no reservations about using them again!