Bartleby & Sage Catering

Working with Bartleby and Sage for our wedding was the best decision we made. We were married at the Foundry and their team made our dream come to life with both the fantastic catering and day-of-coordination services they provide. We worked with Rachael Livingston-Meko, whose expertise and kindness made the planning process easy and fun. She did an amazing job steering us through the food and rental selections, offering advice on vendors, and generally helping us bring our vision into focus. The day of was great - everything ran smoothly in large part to the highly professional and gracious Bartleby and Sage team, and we are so grateful. The food was one of the main highlights of the evening. Everyone was really impressed and happy with their meal, and the service was top-notch. We 100% recommend Bartleby and Sage. The catering is such an important part of the wedding, and it is an area you absolutely want to spend your money on. Bartleby and Sage offers amazing value. Hire them!

Bartleby & Sage catered our wedding and they did a fantastic job! The menu was so unique to us and everything was delicious. Guests raved that it was the best wedding food they had ever had, and were amazed with how many options there were to accommodate their dietary preferences. Rachael Livingston-Meko from Bartleby & Sage also was our Day of Coordinator and kept everything running smoothly and on-time. We don't know what we would have done without Rachael and her team.

We worked with Stacey at Bartleby & Sage for both catering and planning services, and it was literally the best decision of the entire wedding. Our wedding guests are still talking about the food, months later. Food & bev was one of the wedding details my husband and I were most excited about, and Bartleby & Sage let us do a lot of customization to make reflect us, from putting together the perfect tablescape for our budget, down to Stacey hunting for the perfect chocolate shells for dessert liqueur shots! I am also so impressed with not just their chefs (Hans is an artist) but the staff they brought. The bartenders, waiters, etc. were all so professional and kind, and made everything run so smoothly. Seriously, if we had to do it all again, booking Bartleby & Sage would be step one!

Working with Bartleby & Sage was a DREAM. Bartleby & Sage (Leslie, specifically) was our wedding planner, day-of coordinator, and caterer. Each step of the process was flawless. On the food, Leslie, and Hans on desserts, curated an incredible menu. Bartleby & Sage really is not catering so much as a sit down dinner equal in quality to a restaurant meal. Their options are comprehensive, but they also love ideas and individualizing options. (We discussed some appetizers more specific to our hometowns) They hold a private tasting dinner for the couple and two guests, which is fun and delicious. Multiple people at our wedding commented that it was the best food they had ever had at a wedding. (The burrata! The macarons! The mini ice cream cones! The steak! It goes on). We were so impressed by the wedding menu that we asked Bartleby & Sage to also cater our departure brunch. The brunch food was likewise excellent and the options endless. Leslie was so helpful throughout the planning process. She kept us on track, in budget, and was responsive throughout. She connected us with vendors who met all of our criteria (cost, aesthetic, quality) and also encouraged and helped us with vendors we found on our own. Bartleby & Sage also has a great online system for the seating chart and layout, which made final planning steps much less stressful. Finally, the day of coordination was perfect. My husband and I did not have to worry about any logistics and truly enjoyed our wedding weekend. It was a stress-free weekend with no behind-the-scenes snafus; we were confident throughout in Leslie's management of the details and logistics. A few months later and we're still glowing. We cannot recommend Bartleby & Sage enough!

Leslie and her entire staff are incredible. She is the exclusive caterer for our venue, the Wainwright House, and also served as the venue coordinator. She made planning the entire day an absolute breeze and was always responsive and on top of details. She is also clearly very experience and just a wonderful person to work with - I really trusted her and all the advice she gave. It was clear she wanted our day to be the best it could be. Everything from the food to setup was wonderful - my family and friends raved about the Tuscan table, the cake, and the food. One friend specifically said she always has low expectations for wedding food, but was surprised at how amazing the food was. My husband was also impressed by how attentive the staff were to make sure our glasses were never empty, and we were always informed where we should be next. Highly recommend for any event you are planning!

Our experience with our caterer, Bartleby & Sage, was nothing short of extraordinary. From the first bite to the last crumb, their culinary creations left our guests raving and our taste buds dancing. The slow-braised short ribs were an absolute highlight of the evening - tender, flavorful, and simply divine. Working with Stacey Cervellino Thorp, our dedicated contact at Bartleby & Sage, (and our day-of coordinator) was an absolute pleasure. Stacey not only demonstrated impeccable professionalism but also brought an infectious energy and enthusiasm to the planning process. She went above and beyond to ensure that every detail of our day was tailored to our preferences, encouraging creativity and offering valuable suggestions along the way. From our first meeting, working with Stacey immediately felt like working with a good friend. And let's not forget about the pièce de résistance - our wedding cake, expertly crafted by Bartleby & Sage's talented pastry chef, Hans Baang. We presented Hans with a challenge of a cake flavor combination he hadn’t made before. The result was exquisite, and it was evident that Hans poured his heart and soul into creating a masterpiece that exceeded our wildest dreams. Our compliments extend beyond the outstanding food and service for our wedding; The Bartleby & Sage team also went above and beyond to establish a genuine personal connection with us. What truly amazed us was their continued support even after the event was over. It's rare to find a vendor who not only delivers exceptional service but also genuinely cares about their clients on a personal level. In summary, Bartleby & Sage exceeded all expectations and played a significant role in making our wedding day truly unforgettable. We wholeheartedly recommend them to anyone seeking exceptional cuisine, impeccable service, and a team that genuinely cares about making your event a success.

Our experience with our caterer, Bartleby & Sage, was nothing short of extraordinary. From the first bite to the last crumb, their culinary creations left our guests raving and our taste buds dancing. The slow-braised short ribs were an absolute highlight of the evening - tender, flavorful, and simply divine. Working with Stacey Cervellino Thorp, our dedicated contact at Bartleby & Sage, (and our day-of coordinator) was an absolute pleasure. Stacey not only demonstrated impeccable professionalism but also brought an infectious energy and enthusiasm to the planning process. She went above and beyond to ensure that every detail of our day was tailored to our preferences, encouraging creativity and offering valuable suggestions along the way. From our first meeting, working with Stacey immediately felt like working with a good friend. And let's not forget about the pièce de résistance - our wedding cake, expertly crafted by Bartleby & Sage's talented pastry chef, Hans Baang. We presented Hans with a challenge of a cake flavor combination he hadn’t made before. The result was exquisite, and it was evident that Hans poured his heart and soul into creating a masterpiece that exceeded our wildest dreams. Our compliments extend beyond the outstanding food and service for our wedding; The Bartleby & Sage team also went above and beyond to establish a genuine personal connection with us. What truly amazed us was their continued support even after the event was over. It's rare to find a vendor who not only delivers exceptional service but also genuinely cares about their clients on a personal level. In summary, Bartleby & Sage exceeded all expectations and played a significant role in making our wedding day truly unforgettable. We wholeheartedly recommend them to anyone seeking exceptional cuisine, impeccable service, and a team that genuinely cares about making your event a success.

B&S was our top choice for catering because of their menu options and professionalism! We loved working with Rachael and meeting her at our tasting and they truly delivered the day of our wedding. They accommodated dietary restrictions with no problems and everyone loved the food, especially the taco station at cocktail hour!

We are so glad we chose Bartleby & Sage to cater our wedding (and have Stacey as our day-of coordinator). They truly were the central pillar of our day and we don't think we could've planned such a great day without Stacey's guidance. The food & desserts came out so great for our ~140 person wedding (with many compliments from our guests) and the staff were very professional. We'd definitely recommend them for your wedding or any other kind of event.

For an extraordinary wedding experience, Leslie and her team at Bartleby & Sage are exemplary! The food was as special as the presentation. It was a magical experience for all - made all the more perfect by Leslie’s guidance and experienced hands. For a truly remarkable wedding experience Bartleby and Sage are a stand out . With Bartleby and Sage setting the bar, to the unbelievably talented Ariel Band to Top Class Limo to the elegance of The Wainwright House all involved exceeded expectations for this once in a lifetime event . We couldn’t be more thrilled that all worked together, with Leslie at the helm , to create a lifetime of memories and just great, dancing fun! Superb!

The highlight of our wedding and wedding planning experience BY FAR was Bartleby & Sage, led by Leslie! Leslie's team was the easiest, most welcoming, and diligently attentive team we worked with for our special day and we seriously could not have done it without them leading the way. The food was simply exquisite, multiple people have told us afterwards they have never had such delicious food at a wedding in their LIFE! And we would have to agree!!! If you want the best food for your wedding or event, executed by the finest catering team in the north-east, hire Leslie and Bartleby & Sage!!!

We worked with Bartleby & Sage for the catering for our wedding, and Stacey was also our day-of coordinator. She did such a great job on the catering, with some awesome suggestions that made our day really special. The food was delicious, everyone really enjoyed it. And Stacey went above and beyond on the day of to make everything run smoothly. I couldn't have done it with out her!

Bartleby and Sage catered our summer 2023 wedding at the Bordone in NYC and absolutely knocked it out of the park!! We were so thrilled with their food, staff, and professionalism every step of the way. We chose Bartleby and Sage after interviewing several caterers and sampling their menus. What struck us about B&S was their commitment to our experience. From meeting one, Stacey planned a lovely tasting menu. She had nice background music playing, a selection of chilled wine and water, a beautifully set table and a printed menu for our reference. During our tasting we met the chef Ramon and pastry chef Hans, who presented us with beautifully plated food and left us completely stuffed. Everyone was friendly, enthusiastic and passionate about making our experience special. Stacey took notes and offered great suggestions. None of the other caterers we sampled lived up to this experience. We chose to hire Stacey as our day of coordinator in addition to Bartleby and Sage’s catering. She walked us through every step of the wedding planning process, through countless emails and several meetings, making the experience enjoyable. She gave us vendor recommendations, coordinated all of our rentals, and prepared our day of timeline, among other things. On the day of our wedding, everything went off without a hitch. The food was absolutely delicious and so beautifully presented. The cake and desserts by Hans were also incredible. We had many compliments from our guests. Friends and family have told us that it was the best wedding food they’ve had. The service was prompt and professional. The servers were always looking out for us, making sure Dave and I got enough appetizers during cocktail hour and had our beverages refilled throughout dinner service. Tables were promptly cleared and there were no delays in service. B&S also happily accommodated a couple specific requests as well as last minute adjustments. Stacey’s calm confidence throughout the night was reassuring and allowed us to let go and just enjoy ourselves. When we popped into the kitchen to say hi, the team was friendly and kind. And after the last song played, most of our important personal items were packed and distributed to our bridal party for safe keeping. We had such a great experience with Bartleby and Sage and would highly recommend to everyone!

Bartleby & Sage is an amazing company led by Leslie Nilsson, who was a joy to work with. The team is way more than just a catering operation as they were immensely helpful to us throughout the entire process. We got married at the Wainwright House in Rye, New York on June 10th, 2023. We highly recommend the venue as well, it’s a beautiful place. Let’s start with the food. The food was SO delicious, and there was so much on hand with nice portion sizes. We had many friends and family telling us it was the best food they have ever had at a Wedding. We also had a few special food requests given the Bride is from Brazil and the Groom is Vegan, but they were easily incorporated into the menu. B&S made a special Risotto as one of our three main meals which had vegan cheese, and in addition to the standard baguettes for the table they made a popular bread from Brazil called Pao de Queijo (essentially cheesy bread). They also made a tasty Brazilian dessert called a Brigadeiro – the Brazilians said this one of the best they’ve ever had. Now, onto the team. The staff’s performance was flawless, and they brought great energy throughout the entire Wedding. Leslie even brought more Brazilian staff for our big day, which was extra nice. Also worth noting that Leslie and her group serve as the day-of-planner, so they coordinated everything including our early morning prep, the Ceremony, and managed all of our vendors throughout the event. It was truly executed to perfection. Pre-Wedding help was extraordinary. From day 1, Leslie basically served as a quasi-Wedding planner. She provided us with her top vendor recommendations (all groups they work with on a regular basis), which were also exceptional. She was extremely responsive by email and always willing to chat and make occasional trips to the venue with us. We actually didn’t hire a Wedding planner and did everything ourselves, but the process was made easier and more efficient with Leslie and her team. Our Wedding was a magical day, and we are so grateful to Bartleby & Sage for being a huge part of it. Thank you to everyone who made our big day so perfect!!

Bartleby & Sage was the caterer on our wedding last August 5th at the Wainwright house. They provided the best hors d’oeuvres, dinner and desserts! I could not thank them enough for their great service from food planning, food tasting, cocktail hour, and reception. Leslie, the owner was very helpful in every way, she accommodated every little thing we asked. The servers and bartenders were very professional and made great drinks for our cocktail hour. Our first course was the burrata salad, everyone loved it! The main courses was amazing as well! Our wedding cake, it was made by Chef Hans, was the star of night! They were really kind to make us a very one-of-a-kind cake, which is called Sansrival cake, tasted great and so happy that we were able to incorporate my country’s delicacy to our wedding day. I couldn’t thank them enough for this very kind gesture. We also had brunch the next day with omelet station and mimosas and the chefs and bartenders made our brunch experience top notch. The food was amazing! From pastries to omelets to bloody marys. Me, my family and guests have zero complaints about this company. They provided us amazing food and great service! Thank you Bartleby and Sage for the nice wedding experience!

Leslie was incredible from the start until the end. She was beyond amazing in making everything we had hoped and dreamt of to come true. From the planning to tasting to the venue and organization of multiple parts, to the unexpected and making everything run smoothly, we are forever grateful. The food and beverages were beyond incredible - to feed 250+ people and have everyone say how amazing and delicious everything was truly incredible. Thank you for making our dreams come true and making everything run so smoothly regardless of a mini hurricane and broken engine!! Thank you thank you thank you! Couldn't have imagined my wedding without Leslie and team

Having nothing but amazing things to say about this venue and all the staff. They made my wedding dreams come true when it decided to pour throughout my entire wedding. What meant to be an outside cocktail hour was quickly transitioned inside without any of the guests knowing that was not the initial intention. They were flawless and presented everything wonderfully. Leslie was a dream wedding planner and made sure my entire wedding party didn't have to worry about a thing. The food was exquisite and presented beautifully. Thank you for the best day of my life!

The entire team at Bartleby & Sage was absolutely amazing to work with. My husband and I had a non traditional floating style reception and they completely took our vision and ran with it. Since we live out of state, we were never able to make it to NY for a tasting but I'm so happy we went with our gut and took the chance! Our guests could not stop talking about not only how delicious the food was but also how creative everything was presented (like the edible mac and cheese spoons - I could seriously have them every day). The wait staff was extremely professional, accomodating and kind. Overall, it was such a lovely experience working with B&S - we'd recommend to everyone!

My husband and I hired Bartleby & Sage for our wedding and man were we blown away! Stacey coordinated everything for us and I mean everything. From helping us with the menu, tastings, rentals, and coordinating with all our vendors to make sure everything went according to plan. She was an absolute pleasure to work with. She helped us stay within our budget and organize our day from beginning to end. The food Bartleby & Sage catered was out of this world. Some of our menu options were seafood paella, vegetable lasagna, and braised beef short ribs and the most delicious passed appetizers like ahi tuna tartare, edamame dumplings, empanadas, and others. The service was incredible. We couldn't be happier with our decision to hire Bartleby & Sage and Stacey. We had so many of our guest come up to us saying it had been one of the best weddings with the best food they've ever been too! Forever grateful. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

There are absolutely no words to describe how incredible Bartleby and Sage made our wedding! The food was simply above and beyond and our guests raved about the fantastic service and food! From the goat cheese and beet macarons to the crab cakes to the salmon and dessert station, the food was simply the best wedding food I’ve ever had. They were so accommodating with our guests who had allergies and dietary restrictions, and they truly did not miss a single thing. We hired Rachael Livingston-Meko to be our day of coordinator and this was our single best decision of planning our entire wedding! She was so professional, kind, supportive, and guided us every step of the planning journey- from menus to helping with with rentals to seating charts and rain plans (which we didn’t need but were so happy to have just in case), she was the glue that held everything together! She was so helpful and communicative- always ready to hop on a call or take over emailing our vendors! On our wedding day, we were running a bit behind schedule and she just was so flexible and proactive while adjusting things seamlessly. Rachael just made sure we were present and enjoying everything from start to finish! She made sure we ate, drank, and had the time of our lives, even making sure we had a little space to just soak everything up after our ceremony (and change my shoes)! Do not plan your wedding day without her! ❤️

My wife and I recently had the pleasure of working with Bartleby & Sage for our wedding on April 28, 2023, and we were blown away by the experience. The food was absolutely incredible! Our guests couldn't stop raving about how delicious everything tasted, and we agreed - every dish was perfectly cooked, hot, and bursting with flavor. But it wasn't just the food that made our experience so special - Leslie was also a joy to work with. She was professional, attentive, and easy to communicate with throughout the entire planning process. We appreciated how she took the time to understand our vision and preferences, and went above and beyond to ensure that everything was just right. Overall, we cannot recommend Bartleby & Sage enough. If you're looking for top-notch food and exceptional service, look no further. Thank you so much for making our wedding day even more special!

When we say we are still dreaming about the food we had on our wedding day, neither of us are exaggerating! Bartleby & Sage was hands down the best decision we made when planning our wedding. From the very start, it was an absolute breeze working with the entire team, including the absolute rock-star human that is Rachael, who we also worked with through Bartleby & Sage as our day-of-coordinator (though she provided SO much more than that!). Every part of working with this team was fun and enjoyable, two words that aren’t often heard when planning a wedding! When it came time to make day-of decisions, Rachael was supportive and encouraging every step of the way. Her level-headedness and calm demeanor kept everything breezy, but still so exciting. We are truly so lucky to have had her as a part of our day - couldn’t have done it without your magic, Rachael! As for the food? Our friends and family are still messaging us saying that the food was literally the best they have ever had at a wedding. Many are saying it’s the best food they’ve ever had in their entire lives! The tasting was incredible and the food on the actual day was somehow even better?! Portions were plentiful and everything came out hot from the kitchen. The staff were amazing and kind the entire night, treating everyone like family. Bartleby & Sage, you truly were a dream to work with and we are so so grateful for all you amazing work. Thank you eternally, we wish we could get married all over again with you!

We had Bartleby & Sage cater our wedding in NYC. Every part of the process was fantastic. Stacey, our event planner, was wonderful to work with, and she accommodated every detailed request that we had including specific cocktail cherries, ice, and outfits for the staff. Roman's food was delicious and was plated spectacularly. The cake baked by Hans was also a fantastic hit, and we received several compliments. Can't recommend enough. Bravo and thank you!

We hired Bartleby & Sage as our caterer for our wedding and it was the best decision ever!! The food was so delicious, everyone could not stop raving about it! We also hired Rachael as our day of coordinator and she was simply amazing. She was super responsive and easy to work with. The day of the wedding wasn't stressful at all, thanks to her! We also appreciated that Rachael and the team were so open to helping us customize what food we wanted to be served at the wedding. They created the most amazing raw bar/seafood station- let's just say no one was hungry at all! I would highly recommend them for your next event!

Everyone was completely blown away by our wedding food from Bartleby & Sage, it was beyond outstanding! Everything tasted delicious and the presentation of the food was beautiful, our salad looked like a piece of art! Several of our guests reached out after the event just to let us know how much they enjoyed the food. We would highly, highly recommend!

Hiring Bartleby & Sage as our caterer was by far and away one of the best decisions we made for our wedding! From the very start, Rachael was extremely responsive and flexible in working with us. Hiring Rachael for an add-on planning service is a must as well - it doesn't get better than her! From guiding us through the tasting process, rentals, and more, we couldn't have imagined going through this day with anyone else. Rachael really made all of our dreams come true and more! As an added bonus, if you want your guests to come away saying "this is the best food I've ever had at a wedding", then look no further and book Bartleby & Sage! We had countless amount of guests tell us that during and after the wedding. A++++++

Rachael and the Bartleby and Sage team were absolutely phenomenal to work with. We had such a positive experience and have been receiving tons of compliments on the food! Thanks again!

Finding a good caterer can be quite difficult. Bartleby & Sage were helpful and their main point of contact Stacey was very through, but at the end of the day the question remains, was the day of service and food any good? Absolutely! They killed it on the day of and everything went off without a hitch. Delicious and beautiful.

We met Leslie through our wedding planners, Nomade Weddings and we are so grateful that we did! Leslie and her team provided the cocktail hour hors d'oeurves and staffed our wedding from start to finish since we decided to go with food trucks to serve the dinner. From the tasting, we knew we had made the right decision. Leslie was so accommodating to my husband's allergies (gluten and dairy) and spun up the most delicious bite-sized food. On the day of the wedding, the staff made sure that everything ran smoothly and that the tables were always cleared. Our guests would not stop raving about the arancini balls and lobster rolls! We are so appreciative of Leslie and her team, they made our wedding delicious!

We really cannot recommend Bartleby & Sage enough! My wife and I consider ourselves foodies, as do a lot of our family members. This is why it was very important for us to pick the best! We did a few tastings with other caterers, and no one compared. They made us feel welcomed from the minute we sat down. Our guests are still talking about the food and how delicious everything was. Especially the steak, which we heard multiple times that you did not even need a knife. We also hired Stacey as our day of coordinator, which does not do what she did justice. She was with us every step of the way. Our best decision was hiring Stacey and Barleby & Sage for our wedding. Do not look any further, because they are the best!!!!

Bartleby & Sage was a great pick for our wedding catering! From our first tasting to our wedding day, we were so impressed by their food. Many of our guests also commented on how delicious the food was (which doesn't often happen at a wedding, especially with 165 guests). The food is also beautifully presented. The team was very accommodating of our needs and requests. The bride and members of her family have celiac disease and they were able to create so many delicious gluten free options! Overall, Stacey and the entire team were wonderful to work with and played an important part in our beautiful wedding day.

I cannot recommend Bartleby & Sage enough! We had our wedding at Wainwright House in May and everything was beyond perfect thanks to their team. Leslie really goes above and beyond - from our initial meeting 17 months out I knew that we would be in good hands. Aside from helping us pick out tableware and linens, she also helped source vendors for other parts of our wedding such as lighting. Our wedding tasting was amazing and we had no doubt that the food (and wedding cake!) at our wedding would be amazing. Fast forward to our wedding - everything was PERFECT. I cannot tell you how many people told us the food at our wedding was the best they have ever had. Our custom cocktails were delicious, appetizers were to die for, and dinner was not only amazing but timed perfectly & hot. Our blueberry lemon wedding cake was delicious & beautiful. Hire B&S - you will not be disappointed!

We got married a couple of weeks ago and are still hearing about how fun, inventive and delicious the Bartleby & Sage food was at our wedding. We had a cocktail style event and their assortment of passed plates was exciting for our guests and certainly served as a form of entertainment. Guests are still raving about the s'mores and edible spoons! We also worked with Stacey as our day of coordinator. This is possibly one of the best decisions we made throughout our process. Stacey was not only calming and a steady rock for us through any challenging moments, but she is also hilarious and kind, always there to help in a graceful manner. She made the day of feel truly effortless for us and our families and we are so grateful for that peace of mind! We feel so fortunate to have worked with this team.

Bartleby & Sage were a pleasure to work with and made our wedding very special. The food and service was excellent, they were clear in their pricing, flexible and delivered more than what they promised. Our wedding co-ordinator Stacey Thorp was absolutely magnificent and we couldn’t recommend her highly enough. She was a superstar. The New York wedding scene can be hard to navigate and a bit of a lottery. We feel lucky to have found them.

Professional, no nonsense, and a total delight to work with from start to finish! I would recommend Stacey and Leslie from B&S to any friend in a heartbeat. Thank you for making our wedding weekend a total and complete delight!

Rachael and the team at Bartleby and Sage made our wedding absolutely unforgettable. Every detail was considered, the service was top-notch, and the food was to die for. Our guests were raving about everything, and the day-of coordination ensured that everything went off without a hitch.

Bartleby & Sage were truly integral to our wedding! From tastings to rental to day of to navigating COVID craziness, everything was so yummy, clearly communicated, and perfectly executed. Would recommend them to anyone in the NY area!

Bartleby & Sage was amazing throughout our entire process - from the tasting to the menu selection to the main event, everything was smooth and the team was so lovely. Of course the food was delicious and service impeccable. But really it was the feeling my husband and I both had - that our wedding was not just another job to anyone from Bartleby & Sage. It really felt they were invested in making our day perfect, which they did. We also hired Rachael Livingston-Meko through Bartleby & Sage as our day-of coordinator, and it was the best money we invested. She was helpful, organized, calm. But even more than that I felt she was genuinely happy to be there, and happy for us as a couple. I would highly recommend hiring her in this capacity. Our day would not have been half as good if not for Rachael.

I can’t even put into words how AMAZING Bartleby & Sage is to work with!! I was a covid bride so obviously went through lots of stress. Everyone was so amazing to work with, always problem solving & keeping us calm. They brought every vision I had to life and it was more beautiful than I could’ve ever imagined. Our coordinator Rachael is the BEST and ran everything so smoothly. And my guests kept saying it was best food they’ve ever had! It was perfect!

At the outset, my wife and I were both naive about wedding planning, so of course, we thought the caterer just handled the food at the reception. What we soon came to realize as we started our search, is that the caterer handles much, much more than just simply the food. That being said, THE BEST decision we made during our wedding planning was hiring Bartelby and Sage to cater our wedding. Leslie’s knowledge and experience with putting together premium wedding packages, being intimately acquainted with the different venues in New York, particularly cultural institutions (we got married at the Museum of the City of New York), was extremely attractive to us, and thankfully showed up in the flawless execution of our event. She is also very easy to work with and extremely dependable as she leads with her professionalism. She also provides a fully interactive service for rental selection/coordination, which we greatly appreciated. She personally walked us through the rental showroom, offered her advice, and answered questions on the pieces we were choosing for our vision. She also helped us solidify our layout in the venue’s space so our day would run seamlessly, and be the best fit in our unique venue space. ...and finally, the food! The food was OUTSTANDING! We were blown away from the first tasting when Leslie captured our vision for a New Orleans and Caribbean-infused menu. Our guests loved it and are still raving about it. The chef’s are top notch, and our cake was so beautiful we didn’t even want to cut it. We were extremely pleased after doing so though, because that too was extremely delicious. To Leslie, Chef Ramon, and Han Solo, the creator of our glorious cake, THANK YOU for all that you did to make our day wonderfully memorable! You all were so delightful, friendly, and we are SO glad we had you on our team. We’re convinced the experience wouldn’t have been as wonderful without you. Again, BEST decision we made in this process outside of marrying each other! : )

Absolutely blown away by the food at our wedding! My husband and I are definitely foodies and our caterer was probably one of the most important vendors for us. Working with Rachael and her team was so seamless and all of the food at our wedding was wonderful. The team went so far as to incorporate Korean food into our menu since me and my family are Korean! Highly recommend!

Bartley and Sage is literally the DREAM wedding caterer. Their food is incredible and creative. Everyone at my wedding said it was the best wedding food they ever had. The unbelievable food is just the beginning of what incredible service they provide. I was married at the Wainwright house and worked directly with Leslie. Leslie is as kind and honest as she is organized and detail oriented. She is calm and confident, making me feel great the entire process. She was super helpful in guiding me with decisions around the wedding. She made the process as stress free (and FUN) as possible. Our tasting was a complete blast! We were BLOWN away by the quality and creativity of the food compared to the other tasting we had been to. Our wedding was pescatarian, something Leslie ran with and created an amazing menu around. I wish Leslie had a restaurant that I could go to now that my wedding is over! Leslie did not nickel and dime me, the way I felt with other caterers had which was SUCH a breath of fresh air. I think their pricing is INCREDIBLY fair for the quality and service they provide. The day of my wedding it was raining on and off all day. Leslie was incredibly flexible and optimistic which was awesome. In addition to the rave compliments about the food, I got a ton of compliments about the catering staff. This was something I never expected but nevertheless I still got a zillion compliments about the professionalism and excellence of the catering staff. I do not believe a better wedding caterer exists and would 100% recommend them. I hope my sisters use them for their weddings!!

We are so happy we chose Bartleby and Sage to cater our wedding. First off, the food was delicious. Among the hors d'oeuvres, some of the favorites were the deconstructed elote, lobster croquette, oyster, lamb burger, and duck taquito. We chose kale salad for the first course and the main entree was a choice between slow-roasted porchetta, pan-seared duck breast, or wild mushroom ravioli (veg). All of our guests were raving about how good everything tasted. They also made our wedding cake which was absolutely beautiful and delicious. Hats off to the chef Hans and the rest of the kitchen staff. We had an indoor bar and outdoor bar, fully open for the entire duration of the reception. We took recommendations for the specialty cocktails and they were all great. The service was excellent. We had around 120 guests and the wait staff did not seem to have any issues. The bartenders also did a great job pouring drinks and keeping the lines at the bars moving. Lastly, we were so happy to work with Leslie during the planning process. We originally wanted to have a cocktail style wedding but due to the pandemic and NYC's regulations, we needed to change our wedding date and change to seated dinner. During a real stressful time, Leslie helped make everything easy for us. Overall, I don't think we have a single negative remark or criticism about Bartleby and Sage.

Leslie and the team at Bartleby & Sage are truly the best in the industry! The team executed my entire wedding day to perfection down to every last detail. Leslie was responsive to every question I had and has all the best vendors at her fingertips. The catering team is also extremely talented and executed everything I requested to delicious perfection (and I am a serious foodie!). Leslie is truly a professional. I remember I would frequently see her on NBC in the morning showcasing the latest wedding trends and knew I hired the absolute BEST for my wedding day. Leslie put me at ease with all planning to-dos and is meticulously organized. I can't thank Leslie and the team enough for all they did to give me the perfect wedding day. I could not have imagined a more perfect day and owe a lot to the hard work and dedication of this team. Thank you Bartleby and Sage - you are truly amazing, creative, talented, organized and professional in all you do!!!

Leslie and her team were amazing! Leslie was very responsive to my many questions and was so supportive throughout the entire process. The food was absolutely delicious and the service was amazing. Guests couldn't stop raving! My husband and I even got our own plates of hors d'oeuvres and cocktails brought to us while we took pictures during cocktail hour! They were attentive to every detail and made everything go smoothly. I would recommend without reservation!

Rachel Livingston-Meko and the team at Bartleby & Sage were outstanding from day one. When we went to do the tasting Rachel was so excited to dream up a perfect menu with us and got the vibe we were going for straight away. When I couldn't make my mind up about chairs and we changed the table layouts a million times she was patient and understand, and as a day-of coordinator she was the perfect balance of communicative and chilled out, nothing seemed like it was a big deal and the flow of the day went really well. When I chickened out of doing the first dance and she smoothly went on to the next thing without batting an eyelid. Bartleby & Sage make the best food we tried, and we tried a few. The menu they put together had everyone talking, my mother still won't shut up about it! They picked up all our bits and pieces the day before to take to the venue in the morning and made sure we had everything when we were clearing out of the venue that night, Rachel even made sure there was some pie in our hotel suite as I was so busy trying to talk to anyone I didn't get to have desert. It's the little touches like that which make me so excited to recommend Bartleby & Sage, the dedication and care are balanced with a kind human connection and the mac and cheese is out of this world.

Bartleby & Sage is just AMAZING. All the pre-wedding planning was seamless. Rachael is sweet, responsive, and truly cares about her clients. I felt like we were friends at the end of our planning process. She helped us navigate the planning process even more than catering. The day of went perfectly. Everyone could not stop talking about our short rib and polenta entree. The catering staff was sweet and attentive as well. My husband and I cannot recommend Bartleby & Sage enough!

Bartleby & Sage was a true god-send. If you are struggling to decide between a few different vendors, just stop the madness and choose Bartleby. The food was incredible and everyone couldn't stop raving about it. Molly from Bartleby also served as our day of coordinator. She helped us soooooo much during the planning process, was always available for input, and executed the wedding flawlessly. We could not have done it without her help and the amazing work of the head chef and pastry chef (HUGE SHOUT OUT!) and all other staff there! HIGHLY RECOMMEND BARTLEBY AND MOLLY BALLARD! We will absolutely be using theirs and her services again.

Bartleby and Sage was the best decision we made aside from getting married. Leslie and the team and top of the line with everything they do and really worked with us. Everyone RAVED about the food, from cocktail hour to dinner and said it was the best wedding food they'd ever had-and I agree. Leslie and team-we cannot thank you enough!! You gave our wedding so much flavor!

Bartleby & Sage were an absolute find! It's not easy to find a good caterer but once we walked into Molly and Leslie's Brooklyn office we knew we were on the right path. They welcomed us warmly and took their time to work through all of our dietary restrictions and presented the most delicious and tasteful menu. We had region specific hors d'oeuvres to give a nod to our international family, the most delicious salad with wild greens and two absolutely amazing entrees that many of our guests said was the best wedding food they have ever had. They were punctual and very flexible with all of our needs. We never once felt stressed and they handled all the details so well. We felt very well taken care of. THANK YOU!!! Highly Recommended!!!

A genuine 5 Star Rating! When I think about the best thing about working with Leslie and the Bartleby and Sage team its almost impossible to rank order of what they did best. Needless to say having amazing tasting, quality food and drink at the wedding is high on the list, but additionally almost totally stress-free planning that is totally flexible (you want a bourbon cart, a craft beer bar and a carvel ice-cream cake...no problem) is up there too. Also what's the point of planning being easy and food bring great if the team working at our wedding on the night were not so great - the servers were fun, polite and so helpful and the kitchen team made sure everything ran so smoothly. Its too hard to say one thing that makes Bartley & Sage so great so take my word for it, it would be hard to find a catering team that makes planning the wedding as fun and easy, lets you enjoy the wedding and not worry about anything and generates literally hundreds of comments from guests about the amazing food, huge and plentiful drink selection and awesome staff.

I loved working with Bartleby and Sage for my September wedding. I had very specific items in mind when it came to cocktail hour and passed hors d'oeuvres and they completely nailed it and went above and beyond to bring my requests to life. They were patient, fun, kind and flexible throughout the process despite me changing my mind several times on dishes. They had great suggestions and advice not only for food but for rentals and had a great showroom with tons of beautiful decor and furniture to rent for our big day. I can't thank them enough!

We couldn't have been happier with our choice to work with Bartleby & Sage. They worked with us to create a custom menu that highlighted where my bride and I grew up. The food was amazing, and the service was professional and precise. I have to particularly praise Molly. Her help was invaluable for taking of all facets of the catering and while caring for our budget and goals. Bartleby and Sage has a wonderful cooking staff, but their staff really sets them apart.

Bartleby & Sage’s presentation, culinary talent and staff professionalism on our wedding day were stellar. But equally important to my husband Sam and I was the creative process Molly conducted with us in the months leading up to it. Neither of us came in with “dream day” ideas, so it was a major benefit to have Molly’s expert insights on everything AND her encouragement for us to discover and do things that fit our values. There were some things we were doing “differently” with the wedding (including using a space that had never been used for events before), and Molly’s artist-oriented approach was fabulous: new structures and weird limitations were just reasons to get more creative. It worked. Throughout the planning process, we could also sense her respect for her chefs and wait staff, which was important to us. Ultimately, food-wise, our appetizers were a fusion of Asian cuisines and came out spectacularly. The main dinner and desserts was a completely different cuisine. We got compliments on it all. Our goodbye gifts for guests were edible. Molly also helped us plan a physical setup for the space that truly emphasized that our wedding was a feast – a community gathering over a shared meal. We’d recommend the staff and chefs at Bartleby & Sage to anyone thinking about a catered wedding. We felt we had an ally during this period of time that we knew could be filled with anxiety. Guest count: ~240 people. (I've also left this review on WeddingWire.)

Stellar, magical, beyond efficient from Moment 1! Leslie and the Bartleby & Sage (Dream) Team were not only accommodating but knew how to talk - and LISTEN -to us and all of our suppliers. Moving beyond that, the art/taste/design/planning behind each and every culinary creation speaks for itself - you feel the heart and soul that go into every recipe, every idea. Their experience also helped iron out and polish every last question or detail we needed to feel ready and comfortable for our big day. My husband (!!) and I worked with Leslie, Ramon, Hans and Rachael. Each really took the time to listen to what we were looking for in order to come up with the best solution/dish/recommendation/schedule. They proceeded to get things done behind the scenes without a hitch. TRUE professionals! Our favorites were (savory) Fish Tacos and the lamb chops were the overall crowd favorite + (sweet) the mini lemon meringue pots along with our wedding cake (fresh summer berries in a whipped mascarpone cream on a light sponge cake) MMM to the MAX!