Catering by Scott

here was a lot of food, too! Shout-out to William and Peggy for taking the time to chat with us. ~Pete and Nikki

nd treated us like family. We had a fruit appetizer display, salad, two choices of protein, two sides, focaccia bread, wedding cake, and cupcake table- all included together in an incredibly reasonable package. Scotty organized and attended our tastings as well! He appeared in person at our wedding reception and warmly congratulated us like we had known each other for years. Everything was unbelievably delicious, and tasted like love and home. My husband and I just ate at his cafe in Bexley in celebration of our first wedding anniversary, and Scotty recognized us right away. Just imagine having a wedding vendor take care of you like you’re his own daughter- I will never forget it. Cannot recommend him enough. ❤️ P.S. the mashed potatoes will change your life.

cott made sure that the night went seamlessly. He even created the cookie table of my dreams with hundred's of my mom's homemade cookies. Scott and his staff made my wedding completely stress free!! He listened to all my wishes for my reception and went above and beyond. 10/10 recommend Catering by Scott for your event. You will not be disappointed!!

nd we thought the same! Highly recommend using him for any event.

melets, pastries, breakfast proteins, fruits and sweets) was fresh and delicious. Scott interacted and entertained the guests as he made multiple omelets at one time! He's FAST! His team cleaned my kitchen so well, I couldn't tell they just prepared breakfast for 140 people in there. It was spotless. Many of our guests are still commenting that the brunch was the best ending to a perfect wedding weekend! Thank you, Scott!

ved so many compliments from our guests throughout the night, and even days later! My husband and I were both blown away by how delicious everything was. Scott and his team were professional, warm, and clearly passionate about what they do. They worked so hard to make the day perfect, and it truly showed. At the end of the night, they packed up all the leftovers and sent them home with us, which was such a thoughtful touch. One of the most memorable gestures was Scott telling us he’d make us something special for our anniversary which is just another example of how much he cares about the people he works with. We can't recommend them highly enough. If you're considering catering for your wedding or any special event, this is the team you want.

restrictions were very pleased with their meal accommodations, we had delicious cupcakes that our guests raved about, and we felt so well taken care of by Scotty and his team. I truly felt like my husband and I were in great hands! We also really appreciated how many options we had for food, drinks, and dessert. Thank you to Scotty and his amazing team!

eam truly go above and beyond. Scott is also super easy to work and communicate with. I cannot recommend him enough! Also you have to try his restaurant Scottys Cafe, food is amazing! The service and staff create such a welcoming and homey environment!

way through to the kindness and care they brought with them on our wedding day! I can not recommend them enough for your wedding and/or your next big event. I know I will be calling them for any event I need catered going forward! Thank you to the amazing team and to Scott for making our wedding day perfect and for being the best in the business! We appreciate you all!!!

ptional—there’s a reason he is one of the top caterers in Columbus. I honestly can’t decide what was better—the food or the service! From start to finish, Scott’s expertise in the wedding industry was evident, making the entire planning process AND wedding day seamless and stress-free. Scott goes above and beyond to ensure his couples are completely taken care of, allowing them to be fully present on their wedding day without a single worry. As someone who asks a lot of questions, I deeply appreciated the patience and support his team provided. I was initially nervous about forgetting something or not being prepared enough, but with Scott, that simply isn’t possible. He has thought of every last detail to make sure your day is not only flawless but truly a dream come true. He doesn’t just treat you as a client—you become one of his brides, and he takes immense pride in that. He has a lot of strong and thoughtful advice about how to make sure your dinner and day flow smoothly. His guidance and advice were invaluable in shaping the flow of our day. Being an out-of-state bride, I was initially concerned about communication, but Scott made sure I had everything I needed every step of the way. He prioritized answering my questions, easing any concerns, and ensuring I felt fully supported. And now, the food—absolutely incredible! Beautifully presented, perfectly executed, and unbelievably delicious. Our guests raved about every bite, from the mac and cheese bites during cocktail hour to the pasta, salads, and the showstopping Hand-Carved Maple Glazed Dry Rubbed Pork Tenderloin with Garlic Parmesan Mashed Potatoes—WOW. With family members who have serious allergies, it meant the world to us that Scott’s team took every precaution while still delivering flavorful, thoughtful dishes. Serving over 200 guests with family-style dining is no small task, yet Scott’s team handled it flawlessly and extremely fast. The service was impeccable—servers were attentive, knowledgeable, and ensured every guest was taken care of. I never once had to worry about a thing. Scott was even there on my wedding day, and when he hugged me after dinner, I teared up because I truly felt so grateful, taken care of, and prioritized. I cannot recommend him enough, thank you Scott and team!

xperience so seamless and enjoyable. Scott himself is an absolute gem—friendly, professional, and incredibly attentive to every detail. He made sure everything ran smoothly and that we felt completely taken care of. The staff was equally amazing—sweet, kind, and exceptionally helpful. They went above and beyond to ensure that our guests had a fantastic experience, always with a smile on their faces. The level of care and dedication they showed on our special day truly stood out, and we felt so comfortable knowing that everything was in such great hands. Not only did they provide outstanding service, but the food was also absolutely delicious! Our guests are still talking about how incredible everything tasted. If you’re looking for a catering service that will not only deliver incredible food but also offer exceptional service, Catering by Scott is the way to go. We are so grateful for everything they did to make our wedding day unforgettable!

ere looking at you got way more food options with each station. He was so kind and made sure that when I had family members that had food allergies that he made separate dishes for them so that they could enjoy the food just like everyone else. He was also super amazing with accommodating for my brother who is unable to eat solid food it must be chopped up for him to eat it and Scotty made that happen for him so that he could have food. The deserts were amazing we had the cupcakes, cookies, and chocolate covered strawberries and everyone loved all of the deserts. I would 100% recommend Scotty and his crew at cater your wedding. They are so caring for what you would like and have great tips for how to do things.

s. The food was not only delicious—especially the lamb chop lollipops, which were a total crowd favorite—but it was also clear how deeply Scotty cares about both his clients and his employees. His personal touch and genuine concern for every aspect of our event made the entire experience feel warm, welcoming, and perfectly executed. If you’re looking for a caterer who will go above and beyond to make your event unforgettable, Scotty’s Café is the way to go. I’m a client for life!

all the desserts were unbelievable. Every food station was a theme. Fantastic affair.

dding and everyone raved about the food. Scott and his team prepared our cocktail hors d'oeuvres, buffet dinner, and after-dinner snacks. The cocktail hors d'oeuvres included an absolutely gorgeous cheese and vegetable spread which was absolutely perfect and a statement piece. Then, Scott's team masterfully managed our buffet table in which they quickly served our guests by carving the meat and personally served each of our guests with a smile and tremendous professionalism. Finally, the after-dinner snacks included a stunning display of fresh fruit and chocolate-dipped strawberries, customized cupcakes on an impressive tower, soft pretzels with customizable dips, and flavorful popcorn... all huge hits with us and our guests! Scott personally sat down with us numerous times and listened to what we wanted and enjoyed and worked hard to customize a menu and experience just for us... all the way down to custom-tailored snickerdoodle cupcakes because that was my favorite cookie... truly no detail left untouched. After the dinner, Scott and his team were remarkable in their fast clean-up and generous packing of all of the leftovers. Second, the service provided by Scott and his team were such a blessing. Scott and his team are prompt and quick at replying and will work hard to personalize your day down to the very last detail. Scott's personality is charming and he can light up any room... such a pleasure to work with. We did not have a wedding coordinator, and Scott even personally volunteered his time to help run our rehearsal and even stood in the back of the venue to help time the processional during the ceremony. That is the kind of guy he is... and the team he employs reflects his incredible heart and character. We would recommend Catering by Scott without reservation.

here were some things that Scotty brought up that I didn't think about or my wedding planner didn't mention so I was thankful for that. It took us a while to decide on food because again Scotty was pushing for food he liked and what was popular instead of what we wanted. (side note: IF you like mashed potatoes, he claims they are a must). We ended up doing an herb-roasted chicken and pork tenderloin. We thought the pork tenderloin was delicious but the chicken was dry. Scotty did guarantee that we would be able to try the appetizers from cocktail hour even though we had to take pictures during that time, however, they were cold once we got to our table. The most disappointing part of the night was that all along Scotty had guaranteed that he would send us boxes of food and desserts packed up for us to eat later that night. We did a sparkler send-off for our exit and left immediately after (which was all in the timeline) but quickly realized we were never given the food. Later that night, my mom was given the food right before they left the venue. Overall I think Scotty does a lot for the price he offers! He just may not execute everything he wishes to.

tering

d that their meals were the best they've had at weddings or events. And when Scottie offers you "Our Amazing Cupcake Display", know that you're getting the best cupcakes you can imagine.

ntive and friendly! I would highly recommend!

stepped up and handled EVERYTHING. Not only is his food absolutely delicious, but he truly cares about the bride and groom and wants their day to be perfect! My husband and I recently celebrated our 25th anniversary and we asked Scott to cater our party. We went back to the ballroom where we originally got married and renewed our vows. Scott remembered exactly what we served our guests on our wedding day and recreated every last detail. I cannot tell you how many people kept telling us how fantastic the food was...everything from the main meal to the chocolate covered strawberries. If you want to have the best food in town and have it prepared and served by people who really care about you and your reception, then you really should choose Catering by Scott. You and your guests will LOVE it!

ice. Scott's wealth of experience paid off in many ways from tips on working with hotels and other vendors since we're from out of town to being able to provide bartenders and guidance on alcohol selection since our choice of the Gahanna Sanctuary meant we had to cover more of the planning than we might have had to at other venues. William and his day-of crew were fantastic to work with. Prompt & courteous - I had the opportunity to converse with several of them before and after the event and they're all top shelf folks who truly lover what they do. This is my only daughter so I don't know that I'll ever be in the market for a large event caterer again but if I am Scott's my go-to.

nd get his family more involved. Not only was working with Scott wonderful, but the food was absolutely incredible. Everyone raved about how good it was, and we were one hundred percent satisfied with our experience all around. I highly recommend Catering by Scott!!

d his wife are the most wonderful people you will ever meet. They really care about every event they do and it shows in their attention to detail and all the extras they add to the presentation. The quality of their food is by far the best I have ever had in any event I have ever been to anywhere in the world! As an event promoter myself, I have very high expectations of my vendors and Scotty never fails in any circumstance! People should now Scotty also donates his time and services to many nonprofit charities and when he shows up it is with many smalls and hugs and kisses! He is truly one of a kind!

loved the family style that we chose to do. Thank you Scott & Team <3

treated us like family and I couldn’t have asked for a better catering experience. 100% recommend!!!

f everything from setting up the napkins at each place setting, flipping my venue from ceremony to reception, clearing plates from tables, refilling waters to cleaning the reception when it was over. The staff wouldn’t even let me lift a box at the end of the day, they carried everything for me out to our cars. They were all so kind and thoughtful, I couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Scott has so much experience in the wedding world, I didn’t need a day of coordinator because he did it all for me. He made sure the flower girls went down the aisle on time, he made sure guests went to the right place for cocktail hour and served up the best food ever, followed by a beautiful and delicious dessert bar, coffee and chocolate covered strawberries. It’s all very impressive what they do and the price honestly can’t be beat! I cannot thank Scott and his team enough for all that they did for us leading up to the wedding and on the day of our wedding!

he food was as well!

or my daughters wedding. We choose the family style food service and food was wonderful and served each table with many servings. Our guests complemented the service and food all night long. The staff wonderful and made the night extra special. I know that Catering by Scott will always be the go to catering company for any family event in the future. Scott is a wonderful person and did everything he could to make my daughters wedding night very special. Thank you Scott!!!

elicious the food was and how attentive the staff was to them. Scott helped us plan our whole day so that it could be exactly what we wanted and exceeded our expectations! He worked great together with The Peak at Edison where we held our ceremony and reception to make everything completely seamless. If you need a caterer for your wedding or special event, who will make everything amazing for you this is the one you need to use!

kes sure you and your guests are taken care of. We would recommend him 10 out of 10 times!

process and offered ideas beyond catering. His experience makes a big difference. He treated my daughter and me as if we were his own. Scott even offered recommendations for us to spend less money! The staff he hired for our 260 pp event were top notch and the food displays- dessert and cocktail hour was very impressive. Our high expectations were easily met. I now consider Scott not just a vendor but a friend. As a result of our experience, my daughters best friends wedding will be catered by Scott. Professional and dependable. Thank you Scott!!

or service and ensuring that all events he is a part of are perfect!

e experience so much more enjoyable. Scott’s years of experience shows in the planning process and decision making. He was great with giving my husband and I recommendations of what he has seen be the most successful at the weddings he has catered and what would help our day run smoothly. The food was amazing and every single person at our wedding told us how tasty it was. The staff was on time and had everything in order for the event to run smoothly. Scott really made my husband and I feel special with his personalizations for us. The dessert spread he did for us was spectacular and the late night food spread was a huge hit! If you’re looking for a caterer that has your best interest in mind, then you should definitely choose Catering by Scott!

t advice. He even helped during our rehearsal which was so kind and we really appreciated. Everyone was talking about how great the food was. Everything was delicious and perfect. He set up a dessert and cookie table at the reception that was beautiful! The presentation and quality of the food is 5 stars! I highly recommend his company.

late that was enough to make your eyes roll back. The servers were very personable, and left our kitchen and dining hall in immaculate condition.

hat made that possible. Furthermore, tips he offered on beverage selection kept our budget within reason. Thank you Scott!

from appetizers to desserts. They paid attention to every detail so I could relax and enjoy the day. You guys are awesome!!