Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot
Based out of Kansas City, Cosentino's Catering is a full-service wedding caterer. Cosentino's has skilled chefs and specialists that take care of everything right down to the cake. They work closely with couples to come up with a sensational celebratory menu. The team caters to different tastes and budgets to create one-of-a-kind wedding banquets. They also know that special occasion meals are about much more than the food. These creative professionals can help with rentals, flowers, and themed decor to help make the dinner table stand out.
This family-run business has been serving the community with delicious creations for decades. Their talented chefs are able to prepare mouth-watering fresh fare to suit different styles. From simple and delicious to decadent fine dining, there is something for everyone. They take pride in designing unforgettable displays, from buffets and food stations to elegant tablescapes. The team takes a personal approach to each couples' milestone event. Beginning with a friendly consultation, they will gather the details for a show-stopping experience.
Both buffet- and family-style service can be provided by the team's energetic staff. They will take charge of delivery and setup on the day. The newlyweds can enjoy a drink with guests as each delicious dish is carefully arranged. The creative chefs at Cosentino's Catering have a global knowledge of cooking. From Italian and American to Mexican and barbecue, they know their way around a kitchen. Some of the team's mouth-watering specialties include sushi, antipasti, and shrimp platters. Their wedding cakes are available in a variety of flavors. Couples can choose from classics like chocolate, red velvet, and lemon. Fillings include fudge chocolate mousse, raspberry cream cheese, and more. Buttercream or fondant can be used to add the finishing touches.
Let us take care of all you needs, including your rehearsal Dinner, Reception dinner and your wedding day event party trays.
No business details yet
No team details yet
Pricing details
No pricing details yet
We’re here to help! Find other vendors that suit your budget.
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
Multiple reviewers highly recommend Cosentino's Catering for weddings, praising their delicious and beautifully set up Italian meals, cupcakes, and desserts. The staff, including Ashley K, Rhyanne M, Stacey, and Alicia, are commended for their excellent communication, support, and professionalism throughout the planning process and on the wedding day. Despite some minor issues with floral deliveries, overall feedback highlights the wonderful experience with Cosentino's in terms of taste, presentation, pricing, flexibility, and customer service. Highly recommended for weddings and special events.
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 3
Top reviews
Newest first
Oldest first
Highest rated
Lowest rated
Sort by
Kelsey B
5.0
3/02/2025
The wedding cake provided by your bakery was absolutely amazing! The cake tasting was very informative and helped us make our decisions with ease. We were also impressed with how you were able to work within our budget without compromising on quality. Not only was the cake beautiful, but it was also incredibly delicious. The design was exactly what I had envisioned and I couldn't have been happier. Thank you for helping make our special day even sweeter!
Katie K
5.0
11/27/2024
We worked with Rhyanne from Cosentino's Catering for our cake and cupcakes at our wedding reception! Cosentino's is fairly priced and are able to offer a lot of options when it came to the cake and other reception desserts. Rhyanne was extremely communicative and helpful in the planning process. Our cake and cupcakes turned out beautifully and were delicious! Our cake and cupcakes were set up well by the Cosentino's staff and they were effective at working with our venue and onsite contact. Highly recommend as they made the experience easy.
Any questions?
Liz M
5.0
6/24/2024
This catering service was exactly what we wanted. We did an Italian meal and cupcakes. It was the perfect price, the attendants were so nice and on top of everything. And it all tasted so good!!!
Mary O
4.0
5/13/2024
Planning our reception and rehearsal dinner with Ashley was great. I sent a million emails and she answered each one with all of the information I was looking for.
At the wedding reception they ran out of gravy, but other than that is was perfect. We got to keep all the left overs and the staff was very kind.
Gretchen C
5.0
1/22/2024
We used Cosentino's for catering and bakery for our wedding day and our experience was wonderful on so many levels. It started with our tasting with Ashley K and Rhyann M which quickly turned to planning our menu for our special day. Their patience and guidance was greatly appreciated as they both were there to support us through the whole process, including a last minute change in venues as our original location was closed 10 days prior to our wedding day. Our experience the day of the wedding was also wonderful as the food for the charcuterie and buffet was delicious, the cake was amazing and the catering staff were professional and accommodating. We received so many compliments from our guests on how wonderful everything was, which contributed to our day being so special.
Elle S
5.0
11/07/2022
We used Cosentino's Catering for cake, dessert, and flowers. Stacey absolutely nailed our vision for cake and the dessert bar was great. I couldn't have asked for any better! Highly recommend this service! I would give the floral experience a 4/5 overall. I would definitely use this service again but there were some issues. There were delivery problems the week of the wedding with one of the main flowers. That resulted in last minute substitutions without the best communication. Ultimately, the flowers ended up looking beautiful, but the bouquets and arbor piece were smaller than expected. The centerpieces were perfect though.
Kara T
5.0
7/24/2022
We had Cosentinos cater our daughter’s wedding and they did a fantastic job. From the tasting prior thru the wedding day. Food was great. Communication was great. Pricing was great. In addition, we went with them for the wedding cake and it was perfect! All around a great experience.
Lea W
5.0
6/27/2022
Cosentinos was absolutely amazing! The food was delicious and they had it all set up ready to go with no issues. After we got our plate they came up and asked if we needed anything else and to let them know if we do which I appreciated so much! They also delivered our alcohol and ice which was also extremely helpful and we got to return anything that wasn’t drank. Highly recommend!! Communication was also fantastic!
Travis D
5.0
5/21/2022
We used Cosentino's for our wedding for catering, desserts and floral. We had such a great experience with them, we cannot thank them enough for their work!
Alicia in catering was great with us from start to finish. She was very responsive and helped with more than just planning the food. She worked with us on the layout and assisting planning from day 1. On the day off, her staff was extremely attentive and helped our coordinator set our entire reception. Their food was great and the staff was on top of it when it came to beverages and clearing plates as people left.
Stacey in desserts absolutely killed it. Every dessert was great and our dessert table looked incredible. She was very helpful for us from day 1 and we had a great experience with her. There were hardly any desserts left by the end of the night!
Caroline in floral was also awesome. She nailed our vision with the flowers and utilized feathers, pearls and other items we gave her perfectly. We got a lot of compliments on the floral and couldn't have asked her to do any better on the design.
Melody H
5.0
4/01/2022
Cosentino's was WONDERFUL! The best customer service, reasonable pricing, they were super flexible, AND the food was delicious. I'd recommend them to anyone!
response04/04/2022
Thank you very much for your kind review! I am very glad you enjoyed our food and service!...
Thank you for choosing Cosentino's Catering!
Sydney P
5.0
6/03/2021
My cake was absolutely perfect! It was just what I wanted! Stacey is the best!
Lindsey D
5.0
9/18/2019
We had a great experience with Cosentino's for our catering, cake and floral. It was perfect to have all of those services from the same place, as they could communicate with each other so everything and everyone was on the same page. We received many compliments on how fantastic the food was, and the service during our reception was top-notch, as well!
Everyone made us feel special and like everything was personalized to us and our event, which it was! Would recommend!
Riley L
5.0
8/12/2019
We decided to do a taco bar through Cosentino's. The food was reasonably priced and amazing! We had so many compliments on the food, even from a videographer who said it was the best wedding food they had ever had. The staff was amazing as well! They were super helpful and kept everything on the buffet stocked all night. They were great at making sure the groom and I got what we needed and offered to get us seconds. Highly recommend!
Kimberlee K
5.0
1/27/2019
We used Cosentino's for our catering, bakery, and floral. I would definitely recommend them as a one-stop-shop. The food was great, and the service of the team was top notch. Our floral arrangements were just what I wanted, and Denise even helped my mom arrange some floral that we brought in ourselves. Lastly, we had a donut wall as our main dessert, and I'm still getting compliments about how good the donuts were! Great experience with the team at a great price.
Abigail H
1.0
10/24/2018
Working with Cosentino’s was a disaster from start to finish. During just a short 6 month planning period we were shuffled between 3 different people, none of which communicated well with each other or with us. They served us the wrong food at our tasting. They took over a month to get a final quote back to us. The quote was a battle to keep updated. They overcharged us for service. THEY RAN OUT OF FOOD AT DINNER, and blamed it on people taking too much food (we had 20 fewer people show up than anticipated…..), and they took over an hour to clear dirty plates from the tables at the reception. The only reason we tolerated the early mistakes with this company is because they provided an excellent service for my sister’s wedding two years ago.
The servers who were at our event were professional and they appeared to work hard, including helping my family load cars with dishes and décor at the end of the night. Additionally, the presentation of the food was lovely, and the small amount of food we did have there was delicious.
In the end we should have stuck with our guts that Cosentino’s was not the right option to cater our wedding. They severely disappointed and literally left our guests hungry for more, not in a good way.
Jane K
4.0
8/21/2018
Bonnie and her team helped provide amazing service from start to finish. We had several compliments of the food and display that her catering team put together. She is a one-stop-shop who helped our whole day run smoothly. The cake was wonderful!
Jessica-Marie H
5.0
1/30/2018
Bonnie and her team were absolutely amazing for our special day. We had originally not wanted to have a Day of Coordinator, but after we met with Bonnie for the catering we knew we needed her to make sure our day went off without a hitch. Bonnie listened to both my husband and I and made sure we had everything we needed. Her staff did a fantastic job as well. I would recommend Bonnie and her team to anyone who is looking for hardworking attentive people.
Amy B
5.0
11/28/2017
Bonnie and her team were so so great to work with! Everything went exactly as Bonnie promised and we feel like we got great service. Little touches we never would have thought about were handled. The buffet table looked great and we got so many compliments on the food. Our guests are still raving about how great the cake tasted and I couldn't be happier with how the flowers turned out. The catering staff kept the venue picked up and clean. I can't say enough how happy we were with the entire team.
Amanda B
5.0
11/01/2017
I can't rave enough about Cosentino's. Bonnie was so helpful, she knew exactly what we needed even when we didn't. It made everything go so smoothly. The food was great, Cake/Cupcakes were wonderful, and staff was TREMENDOUS!
Alyssa H
5.0
10/31/2017
I hired Cosentino's catering pretty last minute (about a week before our wedding) and they were extremely understanding and flexible. They never once made me feel like a burden and was extremely reasonable in pricing. They served us our plates before all the craziness of the reception officially started and they even made us take home meals!
Caleb C
2.0
7/06/2017
Hard to get ahold of and poor communication. We decided to go with another caterer.
Hannah L
5.0
6/26/2017
We used Bonnie and her team in Lees Summit off of 150 hwy. We originally met with Bonnie the Director of Catering and Denise the Director of Floral. From the moment we met them we knew that they were the ones. It didn't hurt that Bonnie had worked at our event space for 7 years prior to working for Cosentino's. Bonnie truly takes service to the next level. She was always easy to get ahold of and went above and behind to include every little thing that you want to make your day special. She even overheard us at the first consultation talking about skim milk for eating the cake. Sure enough she made sure there was skim milk at the reception. Her staff was professional, friendly and did a great job. Truly went above and beyond and would recommend her and her staff to anyone.
Kelly S
5.0
5/25/2017
The food was perfect, and the service was top notch. Bonnie, the catering director, was nothing short of wonderful. She did everything she could to ensure our day was perfect, even down to hand-arranging chocolates on our cake table so that they looked good for cake cutting photos. I felt very supported and heart with the Cosentino's staff.
Tom R
4.0
3/26/2017
I had a great experience with Cosentino's! I ordered dinner, cake, and flowers through them and everything turned out really nicely. I LOVED our cake - WAY better than what I would have expected from a supermarket bakery (we had the chocolate mousse filling - highly recommend). Bonnie was super competent and helpful. When I told her I hadn't arranged rental tables/chairs/linens yet, she took care of it for me. She also arranged setup and cleanup and communicated directly with my event space coordinator on the day of, so I didn't have to worry about a thing!
One other thing I really appreciated about Cosentino's was that they walked my groom and I through our buffet first and made our plates for us. They checked on us a couple of times during our meal to make sure we had enough to eat. They also packed a second meal for us to take with us after our reception, and although I completely forgot to grab it on our way out, I really appreciated their willingness to make sure that we had everything we needed.
I had an extremely short 4-week planning period for our wedding. I called Cosentino's with 2 weeks left to get everything pulled together, and they really delivered for me and made things easy!
Side note - my flowers and centerpieces were beautiful. They made everything look wonderful and I couldn't have been happier with them.
Sheryl S
2.0
11/16/2016
I went through cosentinos for the catering, my bouquet, and cake for my wedding. Communication fell through between our meetings and the people that were there the final day. My lead contact called me a few weeks before the wedding and went back over everything. Nothing from that phone call was discussed with my main contact the day of the wedding. Things were missing from the catering menu. There were things incorrect with the menu from what I had asked for such as getting breaded chicken instead of grilled, and not having barbecue sauce for the pork loin. My floral bouquet looked cheap and small. I was extremely disappointed in it. I paid $60 for a small clutch bouquet of one dozen carnations and a handful of spray roses. On the upside, the cakes were perfect, beautiful, and they tasted amazing. The staff the night of the wedding also did a great job assisting and setting up.
Kimberly H
5.0
10/25/2016
Stop your search now! Bonnie Routon at Cosentinos Price Chopper was all you need in a caterer! I know some people may worry that going with a large scale company may be too cookie cutter- Not with Bonnie!!
When my (now) husband and I met with her and Jennifer (chef), they totally individualized our meal and the presentation of our meal. We did good stations rather than family style or buffet and it was amazing and beautiful! Bonnie went out of her way to decorate the tables to match our theme. We got so many compliments on the presentation and taste of the food!
Bonnie's communication was amazing and she was so enthusiastic about OUR wedding.
I would recommend her and urge you to meet with her!
Marie R
4.0
7/07/2016
We wanted a very affordable caterer for our wedding and I think Cosentino's did a very great job providing that PLUS all the great customer service. I could tell that they really wanted to support us and cared about our wedding. Jonathan was wonderful!!! So was Bonnie and Claudia in floral. The only drawback was their cakes. We ended up going with a lady who specializes only in cakes because Cosentino's was pretty awful for a wedding. When the "filling" is like the jelly doughnut filling? Nope. :P Heheh, but aside from that, the food was wonderful. I heard several compliments from our guests.
Stephanie H
5.0
6/26/2016
Wonderful to work with! Ryan made it as smooth as it could possibly be and didn't push us into anything. We did have a little hiccup afterwards, but all was resolved immediately. All of our guests raved about the food. They took care of everything: food, dessert and beverages! Cheaper than what we figured since it included everything. My sister used them at her wedding and we would without a doubt use Cosentinos again!
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.
By clicking 'Request Quote', you agree to The Knot creating an account for you, if you don't have one, and to our Terms of Use. See our Privacy Policy to learn what data we collect and how we use it.
