When we booked with the Holiday Inn, I was super excited. The rootftop was great, the package seemed too go to be true, and it had so many things included. I know this venue has all fantastic reviews but my experience was not so perfect.
To s...tart, my wedding coordinator changed three times in less than a year. I know turnover is normal, but nothing carried over from person to person. We would have things done and completed, then two months later have to start all over because what was promised would no longer work. We booked during a promotional period to get more extras and the back and that was constantly questioned, we had to re-do our menu a few times because what was possible kept changing, so frustrating. That said, each girl was very kind, very professional, and we like them as people.
The day of my wedding was not a good day. Once I arrived to the hotel around 3, I called my coordinator and asked her to stop by because I needed to speak with her. She said no problem, she would be there in 15 minutes. Never saw her. By 4:30, I was sick of waiting and was already a half hour late to my first look. So I sent my mom running around the building to find her. She had no luck and had to leave it at the front desk. We found out the next week that she was with the bride for the next nights with their rehearsal (which apparently took from 3pm to almost 8pm??). I called her numerous times and never got an answer, it VERY stressful to not know what is going on. It also makes me feel really crappy as a person that she couldn’t spare 15 minutes to speak with me but can easily give the other bride two nights in a row.
Next, when we were heading over to our ceremony at Midtown Park, there was no 18 passenger shuttle that we were promised. Apparently, it had been in the shop for over a week and no one cared to tell us (even after confirming it would be there on Tuesday for our Friday wedding). So, we had to call cabs and see if our wedding guests could shuttle us around – horribly embarrassing.
Finally on the roof and ready to relax, I’m immediately met (literally, as soon as I got off the elevator) and told that we have too many guests and we lied about our headcount. It turns out our family was being antisocial and wouldn’t intermingle so instead of 10 heads a table, they were stopping at 6 or 7. The first hour of my reception, my husband had to deal with their staff and do a headcount. During this ordeal, a conversation was held within earshot of my guests about how to proceed with the extra charges which caused a few people to ask me if I needed to extra help to afford my wedding. UNACCEPTABLE. There is no way to come back from that embarrassment. At this point, my coordinator finally shows back up with little to no solution, just “we’ll look at the numbers and see what you owe.” (For the record, we actually had two no-shows so we were under count.)
Throughout the night, we also had numerous wedding crashers. People in jeans and t shirts were coming off the elevators, getting food, wandering around, and leaving. The staff has no regard for this and with the threat of charging extra for those people, I was completely livid.
On the plus side, the food was delicious, the drinks were INCREDIBLY strong, and the space was gorgeous. That said, unless they have worked out the kinks of employee transition and have better policies put in place to handle stray folks wondering up, I would NOT recommend this venue, too much disappointment!