About this vendor
It starts with a complimentary tasting...
At Green Mill Catering, based in St. Paul, MN, we specialize in catering for weddings and special events. Our passionate team of culinary professionals is dedicated to not only serving delectable food but also providing seamless, thoughtful service that enhances your celebration.
We look forward to helping you and your guests come together over a delicious meal. We prepare everything fresh using high-quality ingredients, and each plate is beautifully presented. Our menu includes a variety of classic dishes along with numerous vegetarian options, and we’re happy to customize it to meet any dietary preferences or restrictions.
To ensure your event runs smoothly, we offer delivery, setup, and cleanup services. Our friendly and professional staff will be there to serve your meal, whether plated or family-style, making sure everything goes off without a hitch.
Details
Cuisine
- American
- Italian
Dietary Options
- Gluten Free
- Vegan
- Vegetarian
Food & Catering
- Buffet
- Catering Clean Up
- Catering Delivery & Setup
- Chef Stations
- Family Style
- Menu Tastings
Awards and Affiliations
Pricing
Curious to learn more?
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.8
out of 5.0312 reviews
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
Green Mill received glowing reviews for their catering services at weddings, with multiple reviewers praising the delicious food and professional staff. Guests complimented the variety of food options, including mac 'n' cheese, taco stations, late-night pizza, and buffet dinners. The attentive and accommodating team, including Katie, Sarah Carter, and Randella, impressed with seamless communication and service. Clients were especially pleased with the delicious meals such as walleye, bruschetta chicken, ravioli, and the flavorful dishes served at the events. Overall, Green Mill was highly recommended for weddings and other special occasions, with its exceptional food quality, attentive staff, and affordable pricing standing out to customers.- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
Green Mill was absolutely amazing! The food was excellent, and we received so many compliments from our guests about how delicious everything was. Their team was professional, timely, and made everything run smoothly. The bartender, in particular, was outstanding—fun, engaging, and a hit with everyone. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience and would absolutely recommend them to anyone planning an event!
Response from the Vendor on 12/10/2024
Ali, it is so great to hear about your positive experience. It has been great working with you! -Sarah
The Green Mill staff was amazing between our first meeting to have a tasting to our wedding day! The food was delicious, we had the mac ’n’ cheese station and the taco stations! Everyone was commenting that it was an amazing dinner! Then we had late night pizza, and again, it was delicious of course!
Response from the Vendor on 11/25/2024
Montana, thank you so much for your kind words! The stations can create such a fun experience for your guests! Glad you enjoyed! -Sarah
We used Green Mill for our bar services at our wedding and lunch for our wedding party day-of. Katie was great to work with and willing to work with our requests. The bar service was smooth and the lunch was perfect for our crazy day of getting ready. We would highly recommend using Green Mill for your events!
Response from the Vendor on 11/11/2024
Hannah, thank you so much for your kind words! It was great working with you!
-Sarah
Any questions?
Katie and Green Mill catering made our day incredibly special. They were highly responsive, very accommodating, and very easy to work with. The food tasted amazing. We had the walleye, bruschetta chicken and ravioli, which all of our guests loved, all for a very reasonable price. Definitely recommend.
Response from the Vendor on 10/22/2024
Nico, it was so great working with you and Tia!! Congratulations!! ~Sarah
Our venue works closely with a few catering companies, and we chose Green Mill Catering to cater and bartend for our wedding on 10/5. We were very happy with the communication from our primary contacts, Sarah Carter and Katie Melland! Our questions were always answered very quickly, especially for being in the full bustle of the wedding season.
The food was really delicious! We really loved the garlic butter that came with the bread. We also loved that they had a variety of napkin colors to suit our theme! We chose a buffet dinner, and it went very smoothly. I didn’t hear of any food running out.
As for bar services, though I never approached the bar myself during the evening, everyone seemed to enjoy their drinks, and I didn’t hear about anything running out there, either.
Our catering staff were also very kind to us and made sure that me and my new wife had everything we needed! We really liked working with them and recommend them for anybody in the Twin Cities metro who wants a good, customizable menu for their wedding day.
Response from the Vendor on 10/21/2024
Rea, It was so great working with you! Thank you for taking the time to leave your kind words!! We wish you all the best!
~Sarah
Green Mill catering delivered on every level from not only the well seasoned and flavorful food, but also the setup and presentation was amazing! The staff kept our buffet filled up, hot and looking good. From the tasting with Sarah Carter to the final planning call with Brock Millsop all the way to wedding day it all turned out to be an amazing experience working with great and reliable people. We highly recommend Green Mill for catering as we had nothing but rave reviews from our friends and family about our food choices. Now being on the other side of the wedding that took place on July 20th, 2024 at Brookview Golden Valley it is such a relief to know we made the right choice. Lastly we did the Chicken Campielle (without the wild mushroom) and the Absolute Vodka Chicken Breast with a variety of sides for dinner and a few appetizers for cocktail hour. My one piece of advice is to work together as a couple to truly make it what you both want and like vs. what you think you have to do as far as food options! Congrats and enjoy! ~ Michael and Tori Bratsch, 2024
Response from the Vendor on 08/07/2024
Micheal, we truly appreciate all of your kind words. It was great working with you and Tori on your special day 😊! We are looking forward to working with you again at the end of this month!! - Sarah
We couldn't have asked for a better catering service for our wedding day. From the very beginning Green Mill catering was always so responsive to all of my questions (and there were a lot) and so professional and organized. Our food trial was so much fun we felt like we were on a date. They kept me in the loop and were in constant communication all the way from our taste test to the end of the wedding day. On the actual day of the wedding, the staff were incredibly professional and the table settings were beautiful. THE FOOD WAS SO DELICIOUS. We got rave reviews from our wedding guests about dinner, specifically about the tortellini (although everything was amazing). I would HIGHLY recommend this catering company to anyone getting married. They will make your day seamless and sooo delicious. I was stress free about the food the whole wedding day and the catering lead that worked my event always made sure I was doing ok and continued asking me if I needed anything. Wonderful service!
Response from the Vendor on 07/12/2024
Carly, it was so great working with you and Dacotah on your wedding day!! Congratulations again!
Our guests gave us great compliments about the food. The catering company was very accommodating in many ways, making the night special for us.
Response from the Vendor on 07/12/2024
Ana, thank you so much for your kinds words!! We wish you all the best!
The whole process of booking and planning with Green Mill was painless. Their team helped make a taco bar that was not too simple but loved by all attendees. We got their pizza as a late-night snack, which was also amazing!
We went out on a whim because we didn't try anything beforehand but we got many compliments on the food. The meat was well seasoned, "not boring wedding food", and vegetarian options were delicious.
Waitstaff were professional, catering manager was lovely, the day went incredibly smooth!
Response from the Vendor on 05/31/2024
Jackie, it has been just as easy working with you two!! We wish you all the best!!
Green Mills was exceptional to work with. They were prompt in their responses and helped make our wedding day amazing! The food was excellent and had a competitive price. I would highly recommend them for wedding catering needs!
Response from the Vendor on 05/23/2024
Ryan, it was great getting to work alongside you and Abby on such a perfect day!! Thank you so much for the kind words!
Green Mill was great to work with from the planning process through our wedding day. Before the wedding, they were quick to respond to any questions we had and were very flexible working with our guests' allergies and dietary restrictions. On the wedding day, the quality of the food was amazing! We had many of our wedding guests tell us how good their food was. I would highly recommend Green Mill for any wedding!
Response from the Vendor on 04/29/2024
Collin, it was so great working with you and Ally! Congratulations again!
Used Green Mill Catering & Bar service for a corporate event and they were wonderful and attentive every step of the way. Truly cannot highly recommend them more!
Response from the Vendor on 04/10/2024
Elena, thank you so much for your kind words! We had a great time working with you and your team!
Green Mill was an absolute pleasure to work with! They were very communicative, and made sure everything was exactly as we wanted and even checked on us through the wedding time. The food was AMAZING. I don’t think we had a single guest who didn’t mention how good the food was. Thank you to the entire staff!
Response from the Vendor on 04/10/2024
Kelli, thank you so much for your kind words! It was so great working with you and Travis! Congratulations again!!
Green Mill was the perfect vendor to go with for our price point and the needs of our micro wedding. Finding a caterer that doesn't require large minimums is difficult, but Green Mill right from the start was flexible and helpful. They made the process of ordering and understanding so easy, and they answered all my questions promptly and patiently. On the day of the wedding, they waited until after our Grand Entrance to remove the tops to the buffet so our food remained hot. The Mac and cheese was a HUGE hit with the kids. I also appreciated how kind our staff was with clearing our plates and keeping the cupcakes and chocolate covered strawberries stocked for us! Definitely was the right choice for us and I would book them again in a heartbeat.
Response from the Vendor on 03/20/2024
Melina, thank you so much for the kind words!! It was so great working with you! We wish you all the best!
Green Mill Catering, Sarah and Brock, WOW, is all I can say about the food and service!! They were fantastic from the first planning phone call through the end of the night!! From the box lunch to appetizers to dinner people raved about the food!!! The service was amazing, professional and on time!!
Response from the Vendor on 03/04/2024
Thank you, RaeLynn, for the kind words! We’re thrilled to hear you enjoyed our services. We're happy to have been a part of your special day and we hope you keep us in mind for any future events!
We had street taco stations, a large assortment of appetizers, and late night pizza. Everything was absolutely delicious and our guests loved the spread! Communication was great with them throughout the entire process. Delivery was on time and their staff are so kind and professional! Highly recommend them for your wedding caterer needs!
Response from the Vendor on 01/15/2024
Cindy, it was great working with you!! We wish you all the best!
We hired Green Mill to cater our wedding (they were a preferred vendor for our venue) in October and they were incredible! The food was delicious and the staff who worked at our wedding were amazing.
Our guests kept commenting on how wonderful the food and service was. The whole evening went by so smoothly- many thanks to Green Mill catering and their incredible staff! Would highly recommend:)
Response from the Vendor on 12/21/2023
Anna, it was so great working with you! We wish you and Jon all the best!
Let’s be honest here. Catering is expensive. If you are looking for a catering service that provides great taste with a more budget friendly price, look no further than Green Mill. They were very helpful with providing and helping with figure out exactly what we needed. Went with a buffet style with a delicious chicken bruschetta option and a real nice tri tip steak.
Response from the Vendor on 12/18/2023
Keegan, thank you so much for your kind words! We hope to work with you again!
Partnering with Green Mill for our wedding was awesome! They were a preferred caterer for our venue and it was easy to see why.
They have delicious options for hors d'oeuvres, entrees AND dessert. We didn't even do a cake because their options were tasty enough.
They also had great options for multiple price ranges and worked hard with us to stay under our budget.
Their bar staff was also stellar. Even when they ran into an issue with our special order keg, they did their best to make it right.
Response from the Vendor on 12/11/2023
Corry, it was great getting to work alongside you and Kenny! It was such a beautiful day. We wish you all the best!
Green Mill recently catered our wedding, and we could not have been happier! The food was wonderful and the service was exceptional. Katie and Sarah were both very helpful and worked closely with us to create a menu that was perfectly tailored to our needs and budget. Plus, who wouldn’t want late night pizza at their wedding??
Response from the Vendor on 11/27/2023
Kaitlyn, It was great working with you and Aj on such a special day! We wish you all the best!
Green Mill did a fantastic job with the catering for our wedding. The staff was professional and communicative leading up to the event and the food was so tasty! Our guests were especially pleased with the mac and cheese bar! Our one complaint is they didn't tell us until we asked about it that an urn was broken so we would not be receiving the coffee we ordered. That being said, we would go with them again for catering needs as we liked the food and service otherwise.
Response from the Vendor on 11/27/2023
Zia, thank you so much for taking the time to leave a review of our experience. We wish you and Ian all the best!
The food waa delicious and the staff was great. They were very polite and professional. Made sure everyone was taken care of. I highly recommend.
Response from the Vendor on 11/16/2023
Samantha, it was great working with you and Kevin on your day 😊! We wish you all the best!
I would highly recommend Green Mill catering! We had family style service at FIVE event center. We got so many compliments (tri-tip steak and tortelloni.) Everyone was so impressed that the food was brought in (especially because the steak was still pink!) Absolutely wonderful!
Response from the Vendor on 11/10/2023
Hannah, It was so great working with you and Brett! We wish you all the best.
The food was great! We did family style dinner with braised beef and butternut squash ravioli.
Numerous guests commented about how they really liked the food and even our videographer said it was the best wedding food they've had!
Response from the Vendor on 11/10/2023
Jorian, we had such a great time working with you and Ian! Congratulations again!!
I would highly recommend Green Mill catering for anyone’s wedding! We were very impressed and everyone raved about the food at our wedding! Katie and Rory were great to work with throughout the planning process. They were very responsive and accommodating to allergies. I would recommend Green Mill for any catering needs!
Response from the Vendor on 10/25/2023
Bianca, it was a pleasure working with you on your day! We wish you all the best!!
Honestly was very skeptical of them before booking as I think Pizza and wasn’t sure how the food would be. It was amazing, we had multiple guests come up and tell us how great the food was, which isn’t common at wedding. Sarah, our contact was amazing and was great about answering all my questions and working through the menu with us.
Response from the Vendor on 10/19/2023
Maureen, It was great working with you as well! We wish you both all the best!
We worked with Susan from Green Mill in Plymouth for our reception dinner! She was incredibly responsive & helpful as we planned the wedding from a state away! Green Mill was able to accommodate a vegan meal & veggie skewer added on a bit late in the planning. The food tasted great & the staff on the day of were timely, professional, and provided good service to our guests for buffet line & water service. They boxed up the leftovers at our request (ended up having less guests attending than planned, even though we were able to set the meal counts when list was complete) & we've been enjoying them from the freezer. Our service from Green Mill on the day of went smoothly!
Response from the Vendor on 10/19/2023
Kayleigh, thank you so much for the kind words! It was great working with you!
Green Mill catered and provided bar service for our wedding and did a wonderful job! They were very responsive from the beginning and were easy to work with and helpful when planning out all the details ahead of time. The day of the wedding, everything went very smoothly- no issues whatsoever. The lead did a great job of handling things but checking in every now and then for small thoughtful things like if my husband and I wanted appetizers saved for us at the head table. All our guests loved the food and we got compliments on literally every part of the meal (we did a buffet-style dinner), but at the same time they were more affordable compared to other options we looked into. I would highly recommend them based on our experience!
Response from the Vendor on 08/29/2023
Sarah, It was so great working with you on your perfect day!! We wish you all the best!
This is quite a bit delayed because life got crazy after our wedding! Green Mill provided AMAZING service and delicious food! They made sure I had an opportunity to try each of the hors d’oeuvres, and made sure everyone was well attended. On the day of I didn’t have to worry about anything in terms of food because they had everything handled. Best day of my life!
Response from the Vendor on 07/06/2023
Jessica, it was so great working with you! We wish you all the best and thank you so much for the kind words 😊!
We had Green Mill cater our wedding. They were excellent to work with leading up to it, but execution fell through on our wedding day.
Fewer than half of the table linens were delivered prior to the ceremony which meant that most of the table setting and decorating needed to happen during cocktail hour. Our guests had to put the tablecloths on the tables by themselves.
Most of the food arrived an hour late. Nobody from the catering team told us about this until we were ready to dismiss our guests to the buffet line. We had to check in with them a couple times over the next hour as the ETA was pushed back.
But once it arrived the food was delicious! Definitely no complaints there.
A month later we received a partial refund. In retrospect we wish we had gone with a different caterer.
Response from the Vendor on 01/11/2023
Lauren, we appreciate you taking the time to leave a review of your experience. We are happy we were able to connect after the wedding to discuss the day of details. We wish you and your husband all the best!
The food was delicious and Sarah and Katie were so helpful/patient during the planning process and all the way through the event. I had many people from our company come up to me during and after the event to remark how good the food was. I would highly recommend hiring Green Mill to cater your next event!
Response from the Vendor on 12/27/2022
Vanessa, it was great working with you on your company holiday party! We hope to work with you again!
We catered Green Mill for our wedding. The whole experience was great! Setting up a tasting with the manager was super easy and the tasting itself was very helpful. Then working with the manager later to coordinate with the numbers was very easy. The food at the wedding was great! Guests said they liked their food and the portions were very generous! I LOVED the stuffed portabella mushroom!! The only complaint was that the food was a little cold when it was served, but since they were not able to cook the food onsite, that is to be expected. Even still, the food was still very enjoyable.
Response from the Vendor on 12/07/2022
Karley, thank you so much for taking the time to share your experience. It was great working with you! We wish you all the best!
Green Mill staff made it so easy to plan our daughter's wedding! From the wide variety of quality menu options for dietary restrictions to accommodations for a children's menu, the caterer went out of their way to meet our needs making it the memorable occasion we had imagined. Quality food, quality service, quality memories!
Response from the Vendor on 12/07/2022
Tracy, It was great working with you and your daughter!!
We used Green Mill Catering for our wedding this past weekend. We had approximately 160 guests with a buffet of roasted pork loin and spinach tortellini as our main entrees, and everyone thought the food was delicious. Our late-night partiers were incredibly impressed with the pizza that was brought out later too! We worked with Sarah and Randella, who were both incredibly helpful in planning, and their team that was onsite for our reception was amazing! I highly recommend Green Mill!
Response from the Vendor on 11/30/2022
Erin, It was so great working with you on your special day! Congratulations!
We had Green Mill Catering cater for our wedding and overall they did a great job! The tasting went great, the communication was always timely and helpful and the food at the wedding was amazing! We would highly recommend them to anyone for any type of catering.
Response from the Vendor on 11/30/2022
Erin, thank you so much for taking the time to leave a review of our services. It was great working with you!
Green Mill with the best food and service. They served a buffet at our wedding and the food tasted amazing! They also hosted our bar and everyone loved the bartenders and their drinks. We'll be recommending Green Mill Catering to everyone!
Response from the Vendor on 11/15/2022
Sydney, it was great working with you! We wish you all the best!
Food was very affordable and delicious. Special requests weren’t complete on wedding day, but guests were still pleased overall.
Response from the Vendor on 11/15/2022
Amy, thank you for taking the time to review our services! It was great working with you!
I would highly recommend Green Mill Catering & Bar Service for a wedding. We had plated meals for 85 guests and the food looked and tasted great. Our guests loved it. The entire Green Mill Team was excellent to work with throughout the entire process. The service on the night of our wedding was exceptional and the team was a pleasure to work with. Great food and great people.
Response from the Vendor on 11/13/2022
Emerald, it was a beautiful day! Congratulations and thank you for allowing us to be a part of your day!
We had a fabulous experience with Green Mill catering our daughter's wedding. At tasting...we thought we knew what we wanted, but glad they offered us several options to make the best buffet for our guests. They loved it! Sarah and Katie were super responsive to all my inquiries and I was grateful they would communicate via phone when I had SO many questions in planning our best day ever. The servers did a fantastic job keeping the tables picked up and neat throughout the evening. Late night snack was Green Mill pizza and it was devoured by our guests :) I would not hesitate to work with Green Mill again my experience with them was just great.
Response from the Vendor on 11/13/2022
Sandy, it was great working with you and your daughter on her special day!
Yum yum yum!!! We had a delicious well planned dinner buffet style! And late night pizza was a hit!😀
Response from the Vendor on 11/13/2022
Amanda, thank you so much for the kind words!! We had a great time working with you!
Overall a good experience with Green Mill. We had a positive taste testing experience, and were able to find exactly what we we're looking for. Very accommodating with dietary restrictions and organized on making sure everyone got a safe meal. There was a few bumps with the day of food, but they we're able to make it right. Would recommend!
Response from the Vendor on 11/11/2022
Jessica, we appreciate you taking the time to leave us your feedback. We had a great time working with you! Congratulations again!
It was such a relief working with Sarah and Katie with Green Mill! Anytime I ever needed to change up things or had questions they were always so welcoming and loved to help ease the wedding planning process in anyway. We did a plated dinner for about 80 guests and it went off without a hitch, and can’t forget how affordable it is compared to many! The food was hot and equally amazing tasting, the waiters and waitresses did amazing on getting everyone the right food since it was plated with different menu options for each guest. If you are thinking about Green Mill for your wedding or any event don’t think twice!
Response from the Vendor on 11/01/2022
Mariah, it was so great working with you!! Congratulations!
The food and bar service was AMAZING. We worked with Randella and Sarah - who were very helpful throughout the planning process and the day of. We did a pizza buffet (with salads and fruits as sides) and it was delicious! Absolutely loved the food - the pizza and desserts were a HUGE hit with our guests too!
Response from the Vendor on 11/02/2022
Catherine, it was so great working with you!!
Green Mill was great to work with! From the tasting/initial contract process with Sarah to going into last questions and updates with Randella, they made the process smooth. The food was delicious - we got lots of compliments on it, especially the walking tacos - and the staff was so helpful. I would highly recommend them!
Response from the Vendor on 10/25/2022
Kirsten, it was so great working with you! Congratulations!
Amazing—easy communication from start to finish. Sarah and Katie were wonderful to work with and so professional. They were able to work with our budget, and help us customize a wedding dinner that was above and beyond. We got so many compliments on the food, and enjoyed it very much so. Highly recommend hiring green mill for your next event!
Response from the Vendor on 10/21/2022
Emily, it was so great working with you!!
We did breakfast food for our wedding, in the form of a breakfast buffet. We were slightly worried that it was going to be some cheap-looking and cheap-tasting buffet, but it was DELICIOUS. All the food was cooked so well. And the entire process of trying to figure out all the logistics was made as simple as possible by Sarah Carter and her team. Wedding planning can be stressful, but Sarah and Green Mill made it smooth and easy. Thank you guys!
Response from the Vendor on 10/21/2022
Weston, thank you so much for the kind words!! It was great working with you!
Green Mill was amazing to work with for our wedding, from start to finish they were very responsive and helpful. Somehow the food tasted even better than it did during our tasting in the spring! Appetizers, entrees, desserts, and late night pizza were all fantastic. The bartender and buffet staff were friendly and communicated with us as needed. They made sure everything was well stocked and well presented to ensure everyone was happy. They even helped tear down decor at the end of the night - which was unexpected but very much appreciated. We were able to enjoy our wedding knowing the food and drink was in good hands, we highly recommend them!
Response from the Vendor on 10/17/2022
Jade, it was so great working with you!! Thank you so much for the kind words. We wish you all the best!
From start to finish, Green Mill was a joy to work with. I couldn’t count how many people complemented the food and staff throughout the night. Buffet was the way to go! Multiple people went back for seconds and the mac and cheese was incredibly tasty. Don’t even get us started on the cupcakes too. All of our guests were loving them!
Response from the Vendor on 10/13/2022
Ted, we had so much fun coordinating your big day with you! We wish you all the best!
We got a lot of compliments on the food at our wedding! Green Mill catering answered all my questions in a very timely manner and was very easy to work with. The food was delicious!
Response from the Vendor on 10/13/2022
Emily, thanks so much for taking the time to leave your kind words!
Green Mill was very easy to work with and very responsive, both in speed of communication and for adjustments to bar and food menu.
The food items were delicious, special shout outs to the pineapple chicken and Mac and cheese.
We would absolutely use green Mill for catering again.
Response from the Vendor on 10/13/2022
Abby, we are so happy to hear that you enjoyed your experience! We loved working with you and wish you and your husband all the best!
Green Mill was great to work with. Their staff was quick to reply and thorough in the planning process. We had apps, buffet style meal and late night pizza. We got a lot of compliments on the food. Definitely would recommend.
Response from the Vendor on 09/26/2022
Carrie, thank you so much for taking the time to leave these kind words!! We wish you all the best! - Sarah
Our experience with Green Mill was 10/10! We offered passed appetizers and did a buffet style dinner, and the price was so reasonable! There were so many options to choose from, it was actually hard to pick! The staff was so helpful and responsive leading up to our event, making sure everything would run smoothly and it did. THE FOOD WAS SO GOOD! We received so many compliments on everything that we offered. We would use them again if we ever have another event we need catered. thank you Green Mill!
Response from the Vendor on 09/26/2022
Emma, working with you was 10/10! We are so happy that you enjoyed the experience with our services!! - Sarah
Green Mill Catering & Bar Service was so easy to work with. We did a lunch buffet and the food was delicious! The day-of staff did an amazing job with set-up, dismissing tables, managing the bar, etc. I would highly recommend Green Mill to anybody and everybody for any event!
Response from the Vendor on 09/26/2022
Cassie, we had a great time working with you!! Wishing you all the best! -Sarah
From our first emails, the coordination seemed to run very smoothly. I always received responses within a reasonable time. The day of the event, we were very impressed with everything. The servers were very responsive and hospitable. We did passed appetizers during cocktail hour, and those appetizers were pushed well. All of the food was delicious. We also got our desserts through Green Mill, and those were very good.
Response from the Vendor on 09/23/2022
Kyra, we are so glad to hear you had a great experience! We loved working with you and wish you all the best!
Sarah and Katie were so helpful throughout the whole process! Planning a wedding is stressful and they tried to take as much stress as they could. We chose the taco bar with chicken and beef and the food was amazing! Our guests loved it! We received many comments about how wonderful the food was!
Response from the Vendor on 09/23/2022
Michaela, your wedding was beautiful! It was great to be able to be a part of your big day!
The planning of all the details, food, drinks, etc for my wedding was amazing. Sarah Carter and Katie Melland was so helpful and the food tasted great the day of! I am giving 3 stars because one of the bartenders (bald, older man) made a rude remark to one of my guests. It made my guests so uncomfortable! He just seemed to have been annoyed the whole night and it just set the mood in a bad way. We did not appreciate his attitude nor his offensive remark.
Response from the Vendor on 08/31/2022
Nou Lia- We are so happy that the details, food & drinks for your wedding were amazing. We have reached out to you via email and would appreciate some further information about your event so we can take action on our end. We never want guests t...
o feel uncomfortable at events- thank you for bringing this to our attention and we hope to connect with you soon.
Overall, the food and service was good. We chose the unlimited passed apps (caprese skewers, spinach artichoke phyllo bites, and apple brie phyllo bites) - they were all delicious and just like the tasting! We chose the chicken taco buffet for dinner and added on chips and corn tortillas for additional options for our guests. The chicken was a lot more dry than the tasting and the corn tortillas were never set out - after following up with the catering manager about this she said: "When we provide a few of specific, we typically have that in the back and then the guests will tell a catering member for them to get the tortillas from the kitchen." It was not communicated to us that they were going to keep them in the back and only provide a "few", so our guests with gluten allergies had to go without. We were under the impression that they would have plenty of both flour and corn for each guest to choose what they prefer. For dessert, we requested the chef make churro shooters with chocolate which was a fun dessert to go with the theme. We also had late night pizzas which were a hit! I was disappointed to see the staff grabbing pieces of pizza though... I understand that there was plenty ordered but felt it was unprofessional for staff to grab pieces of pizza as they walked past...
I think overall it was a good experience, certain things definitely could have made it better, but I think our guests enjoyed each course which is all I can ask for.
Response from the Vendor on 08/31/2022
Jessica, it was great working with you. We are grateful we were able to chat through your concerns on the phone last week. We wish you and your husband all the best!
I would not recommend Green Mill. They catered my wedding on August 5th.. For food, the meal was mediocre. The beef kabob that we had tasted nothing like what we had at the tasting. It was so dry and under seasoned. Sure, I can forgive the dryness with complication related to the keeping the food warm but not an excuse for improperly seasoning. For service, the catering manager and the crew were pleasant people to work with and is the only reason I’m not giving them a one star. However, they absolutely under-delivered. We paid for a buffet and half of the guests were not made aware that they could return for seconds. Also, after the wedding, my sister who was there to help me with setup, told me the catering crew were setting the water glasses on the floor while filling them up and placing them in the table for guests. This is absolutely never acceptable in line of food services. They also left earlier than discussed. I did reach out to the manager and received no response. I’m sure it doesn’t matter to them because they already have my money. I’m simply disappointed.
Green Mill catered our wedding- heavy appetizer buffet at a venue that did not have a catering manager (Theodore Wirth Chalet.) They were GREAT.... helping with some set-up logistics and always being prompt and courteous in our communication with them. At the event, several of our guests commented on how attentive, kind, and really personable the servers were. The food was great (I'm told... I was too busy dancing!) I enthusiastically recommend Green Mill.
Response from the Vendor on 08/31/2022
Anne, it was so great working with you on such a special day!! We are so happy to hear you had a great time!
We are pleasantly surprised with our service from Green Mill, especially because they were partnered with our venue (Green Acres Event Center). The two seemed to go hand in hand, and that made communication a breeze and took a lot of stress off our plates. We enjoyed the taste testing experience, and loved the options that Green Mill provided. We didn't want our wedding to be just another standard wedding menu... the plated meal of a few fancy looking items that no one gets full on. We gave our vision to the Green Mill staff members, and they helped make it happen. We chose a buffet style of a handful of stations: Mac N Cheese, Sliders, Mashed Potatoes, Tacos. It may not seem like the food paired up perfectly, but it appeased all types of eaters at our wedding! The unlimited butler passed appetizers were also the rave of happy hour, best some of our guests have ever had! I seriously cannot count all the guests that told us this was the best wedding food they have ever had. One guest: "That is seriously the best wedding food I've ever had, I will be thinking about that meal for many years. All of my favorite comfort foods!" All wedding food is expensive it seems, but this food was incredibly worth it.
The beverage services were also five out of five stars. The staff were accommodating in what we wanted to provide. We had to get creative, but we were able to offer our guests one complimentary "signature drink" with an accompanying drink ticket. We figured out the system we would have, and it was such a hit! This, along with the other beverages we hosted, gave our guests plenty of options to enjoy without paying out of pocket. The bartenders were also very quick and friendly. The line looked long sometimes, but I was in and out in no time once I hopped in. They were also willing to make a drink for us that we requested and they hadn't made before.
We have heard so many bad things about catering services going into our wedding from friends and family that were recently married. We went into Green Mill with low expectations based on that, but they went above and beyond to make our special day PERFECT. I am so incredibly pleased with everything Green Mill provided us.
Response from the Vendor on 08/31/2022
Brendan, we loved working with you and had fun with the custom drinks 😊! Congratulations to you two!
We were very pleased with everything about Green Mill's catering, from the detailed pre-planning walk-through, to the spotless cleanup. Catering staff were very easy to work with, the food was beautifully presented and delicious. Our guests complimented the food and we couldn't be more satisfied. Staff were flexible and accommodating when we needed to relocate a serving station. Highly recommend!!!
Response from the Vendor on 08/31/2022
Jennifer, thank you so much for the kind words! We loved working with you and wish you both all the best!
Wonderful service and the food was amazing! We aren’t planning any other events but if we do we will definitely be booking with them again! Highly recommend!
Response from the Vendor on 08/31/2022
Chrissy, thank you so much for letting us be a part of your special day! Congratulations!!
We went with Green Mill for catering at our wedding and I couldn’t be happier that we did. Everyone that we worked with during the planning process (especially Randella) was so quick and responsive, and made sure all of our questions were answered before the big day. I also loved the amount of options we had and the variety that allowed us to meet guests’ dietary needs as well.
We went with a plated meal and every single person we talked to raved about the food they had, even when we talk to guests now after the wedding, they still talk about the food and how good it was.
The servers that were there on the day of our wedding were so quick to get everyone their meals, and they were all very kind. I also appreciated being able to pick up all of our linens the week of the wedding so that we had them the morning of to start decorating!
10/10 recommend going with Green Mill for your catering needs, you won’t regret it!
Response from the Vendor on 07/22/2022
Mary, it was so great working with you!! Thank you so much for the kind words! We wish you both the best!
Affordable, reliable and professional
Response from the Vendor on 07/22/2022
Jamie, we are so happy to have worked with you!! Thank you for letting us be a part of your big day!
Green Mill provided catering & bar service for my wedding. We served butler passed appetizers & had a family-style dinner. Our dinner was served super quickly, and everything was fresh & hot. We customized our bar package to suit our group best, which was another huge plus for us. Our guests really enjoyed the family-style service and told us it was the best wedding food they’ve ever had, which was so great to hear! Green Mill was very easy to work with & very flexible. We would highly recommend Green Mill.
Response from the Vendor on 07/22/2022
Melissa, we are so happy to have worked with you!!
Green Mill was absolutely outstanding for our wedding! They were very reasonably priced, and had so many different meal and appetizer options. We received so many compliments from people on our food, which was great to hear! There were also extremely accommodating for the various food restrictions our guests had, and responded to our questions throughout the entire process in an extremely timely manner. Highly recommend Green Mill!
Response from the Vendor on 06/30/2022
Dani, it was so great working with you on such a special day!!! Thank you so much for the kind words! We wish you all the best!
Dinner was served right on time and tasted great. The wait staff were very friendly & attentive. Thank you Green Mill!
Response from the Vendor on 05/23/2022
Sophia, we are so happy to hear you enjoyed everything!!
We used Green Mills plated service for our wedding. They also did our cake and late night pizzas. The food was amazing, everyone thought so! The staff were so nice and willing to help with anything needed. We also thought they were quite affordable exorcism with the quality of food and service.
Response from the Vendor on 04/07/2022
Elisabeth, we had so much fun catering your wedding at Day Block!! We wish you all the best!!
Seriously amazing! From the first email/phone call to the day after. The managers, wait staff and bar tenders were awesome! Fun & friendly! We did a taco bar for our wedding - I had 23 messages between my mom, husband and myself about the amazing food and where it was from! If you are considering Green Mill as a catering option.. don’t even hesitate!
Response from the Vendor on 02/24/2022
Morgan, thank you so much for the kind words!! We loved working with you and we wish you two all the best!!
The food was exceptional- we served everything family style and chose the chicken mushroom pasta, the soy glazed tri-tips, cheddar mashed potatoes and the vegetable medley. Everyone said it was the best wedding meal they’d ever had! We’re only giving 4 stars because service could have been better. I’m not sure they were short staffed because of Covid or the holiday but it was very slow and took too long to get through the diner service.
One other thing we loved was the variety of bar packages- felt very custom to what we wanted.
Response from the Vendor on 01/14/2022
Amanda, thanks so much for taking the time to leave a review. It was great working with you and we wish you both the best!
Working with Green Mill was great! It is so affordable and delicious! Everyone raved about the food and were shocked about how much food they got as many times you do not get enough to eat at weddings. We also used them for desserts, and they helped us get exactly what we wanted from the design of our cake to having a variety of dessert options. Great to work with.
Response from the Vendor on 12/29/2021
Jessica, it was a pleasure working with you!! We wish you all the best!!
Green Mill Catering did not disappoint. Guests raved over the hor d'oeuvres and dinner menu at our wedding. For hor d'oeuvres we selected the plum BBQ meatballs and the spinach artichoke dip (both were a big hit with guests). For dinner we selected the lemon veggie penne and the vodka chicken which were delicious. Green Mill also provided a variety of options for those with dietary restrictions, which made our decision to choose Green Mill Catering easy.
Sarah and Katie were a wonderful team to work with throughout the planning process. The food and bartending staff on our wedding day also did an excellent job and were super friendly. The entire Green Mill staff were professional and provided excellent service. We highly recommend!
Response from the Vendor on 11/29/2021
Hi Allie! We had so much fun planning your special day with you! We wish you both the best!!
The food was delicious and there was a large variety for what we were looking for. Their coordination before the day and the day of was fantastic and everything was taken care of. Highly recommend
Response from the Vendor on 11/10/2021
Thank you for taking the time to review us Corie!! We are so happy to hear you enjoyed everything! -The Green Mill Catering Team
We had such a wonderful experience working with Green Mill for our wedding. They accommodated dietary restrictions (gluten-free, dairy-free) and had so many options for us to choose from. Very generous portions, excellent late night pizza. We had guests approaching us throughout the night saying how amazing the food was. Great service from the wait staff as well. We couldn't have asked for a better catering service! Thank you!!
Response from the Vendor on 11/09/2021
Thank you for taking the time to review us Rebekah!! We are so happy to hear you enjoyed everything! -The Green Mill Catering Team
We had Green Mill cater our wedding and we were so happy with our decision! They were fantastic to work with and offer such a variety of options that can be customized to suit your vision. They took the time to review all allergies/dietary restrictions of our guests to suggest how best to deal with each one. They also provided the linens for the tables which was great to not have to deal with a separate vendor for linens. Great to work with, highly recommend!
Response from the Vendor on 11/09/2021
Thank you, Doug, for the kind words! We’re thrilled to hear you enjoyed our services during your wedding. We’re happy to have been a part of your special day and we hope you keep us in mind for any future events! -The Green Mill Catering Team
We had a hard time finding an affordable caterer that was accommodating to dietary restrictions and Green Mill did not disappoint. The food was all delicious and we had great feedback from our guests! The only reason for 4/5 was some of the staff was a bit disorganized during dinner service, but we gave that feedback to our project supervisor and they were responsive and hopefully that will be resolved for future events. Overall we were happy we went with Green Mill.
Response from the Vendor on 09/24/2021
Thank you, Christopher, for the kind words! We’re thrilled to hear you enjoyed our services. We're happy to have been a part of your special day and we hope you keep us in mind for any future events!
Great food! We had so many people come up to us and tell us how much they loved the food! I would have them cater again in a heartbeat!
Response from the Vendor on 09/22/2021
Thank you, Megan, for the kind words! We’re thrilled to hear you enjoyed our services. We're happy to have been a part of your special day and we hope you keep us in mind for any future events!
Food was delicious and guests loved it. Lots of good options. Only problem was we initially had a hard time reaching someone to start the process and getting them to return our calls. After that it was all smooth.
Response from the Vendor on 11/09/2021
Heather, we are so happy that you enjoyed your special day!! Congratulations and we wish you all the best! -The Green Mill Catering Team
First of all the food was fantastic - we got many unsolicited compliments from our guests. They had a number of vegan options to include on the buffet that were enjoyed by all guests including a vegan pasta and portabella mushroom. We only had a handful of vegans - but this was an easy way to accommodate them and still get raves from the full guest list. Highly recommend. They made a special plate just for the bride who has a number of food sensitivities. The service was wonderful from start to finish. When we were over our estimated wine early in the night they were quickly able to accommodate - we never ran out of a thing. We have some true wine lovers and they all were very pleased with the quality of the wines (we had Pinot Noir, Sauvignon Blanc, and Champagne). Above all else the service and staff were awesome. Everything went according to plan, they were all helpful and kind - a joy to work with. And of course late night pizza and wings are always a hit! In my opinion, prices were incredibly reasonable. Highly recommend!
Response from the Vendor on 11/09/2021
Kathryn, you were so great to work with!! We wish you all the best! -The Green Mill Catering Team
Our experience with Green Mill Catering & Bar services was such an easy going process. From day one, we were walked through our options and the process of tastings and payments; we never had to worry about what came next. Any request we had, they delivered - including a vegan late night pizza for me and handling food with care for our guests with food allergies. Our dinner was rushed a little due to the setting sun but the servers kept up and everyone was served promptly. I even had compliments from guests saying it was the best braised beef they ever had. Katie was amazing and answered all my questions promptly, and I had a lot. There was nothing they weren't willing to work with us on for food or bar services. Our guests all had a great time and we received so many compliments on the bar services, late night pizzas, dinner and more.
Response from the Vendor on 11/09/2021
Samantha, we wish you all the best!! We are so happy to hear you enjoyed everything! -The Green Mill Catering Team
I absolutely LOVED working with Green Mill Catering for our wedding!
We started with a complimentary tasting organized by Sarah - she was speedy, clear, and friendly in her communication and helped to answer my never-ending list of questions. We were able to take home all of our tasting leftovers and had meals for days!
In the end, we chose meal options of maple dijon chicken, baked salmon in dill sauce, and spinach tortelloni, opted for passed appetizers of caprese skewers, mini walleye cakes, and Swedish meatballs, and went with pizzas for a late night snack. The food was absolutely delicious, and Green Mill was able to accommodate all of our guests with dietary restrictions.
We also hired Green Mill for our bar service and chose to host beer & wine for our guests and have a cash bar. I loved that we were able to use one vendor for both catering and bar - it simplified planning so much! In addition, Green Mill offered a complimentary rental package with linens, flatware, glassware, and tableware and our day-of coordinators were able to set everything up beautifully. Servers and bar staff were very helpful and professional throughout the evening.
I would HIGHLY recommend using Green Mill for your wedding catering & bar needs - their pricing, quality, and customer service were top notch!
Response from the Vendor on 11/09/2021
Thank you so much Natalie!! We loved working with you and wish you and your hubby all the best! -The Green Mill Catering Team
The person we worked with to organize all the food was very flexible and helped us customize our order so everything would be both affordable and just the way we imagined. When we had to change so many of our wedding plans due to Covid, she did a great job making sure things would still be perfect!
Response from the Vendor on 11/09/2021
Dean & Danielle, We’re thrilled to hear you enjoyed our services during your wedding. We’re happy to have been a part of your special day and we hope you keep us in mind for any future events! -The Green Mill Catering Team
My husband and I are so thankful that we chose Green Mill to cater our wedding! We mainly worked with Jade, but Patty also helped us the week before and day of the wedding. To be honest before getting married, I had no idea that Green Mill catered weddings or had such delicious non-pizza items! During our food tasting, Jade was very helpful in helping us decide on our menu.
During the pandemic Jade answered all of my questions and reassured me that they were taking extra safety precautions so that my guests and I all felt safe. We had to flip our timeline 9 days before the wedding due to the current restrictions, and Patty was flexible and helpful at fine-tuning it so that we were the most prepared. I also had 8 people drop out last minute due to Covid, and I felt confident that I could trust Patty & Green Mill to serve everyone, even though my seating chart was not accurate.
I had multiple guests during and after the wedding who asked me who catered, and what the chicken was called so that they could eat it again! Also, the late night pizzas were such a hit!! We couldn’t be happier that we chose Green Mill to cater our wedding. Worth every penny!!
Green mill was amazing to work with at the start... very nice and helpful during covid changes. Once we got to the wedding day things took a tiny turn and I wasn’t very happy with everything. The bartender came off rude to many of our guests.. she broke part of the wall she was on so we had to pay for them to fix it at the venue. They packed up the food very fast as well. when guest went to get seconds they said it was being packed up And the green mill staff was eating the pizza over our pizza and had no masks on. The bartender kept leaving her spot. I saw them smoking on the steps to come into our venu through the large window.
Green mill emailed to see how everything went and I heard nothing back after. Very disappointed in them. But the food was fantastic.
Tasting was easy to set up and food was amazing! I had heard from so many brides that they didn’t eat dinner at their wedding and I made it a point to eat because I knew the food was going to be delicious! Katie was amazing to work with and great with communication-which was so important especially during COVID. All bartenders and staff were great to work with as well! Our only issue was that something was originally missing from the buffet, but when my husband and I went up first to make our plates we noticed it and they immediately put it out (thank goodness because we got a lot of compliments on it!!). We would definitely recommend Green Mill!
Green Mill was by far one of our favorite vendors to work with. Katie who we worked with closely was quick to respond and accommodate in the weeks before the wedding. The food was outstanding and the service was amazing as well. I joked to my matron of honor that I felt like royalty the way they ensured everything was perfect. The customer service on top of quality of food made these guys the perfect choice for catering. My husband and I booked within 2 weeks after our tasting so we received 12 free bottles of wine and 12 free late night pizzas. Also, unlike many caterers, Green Mill does not charge extra for linens, salt/pepper shakers, glassware, etc. I highly recommend using this company for your catering needs!
Green Mill catered our wedding dinner on October 3rd and they were absolutely phenomenal! Their customer service is above and beyond- one of the best vendors I've worked with! They always responded in a timely manner, the tasting was amazing, they showed up on time and their presentation was beautiful! All the servers were professional and took every COVID precaution. We got compliments from all our guests that it was the best wedding food they've ever had- and I have to agree! They far exceeded our expectations. My husband and I couldn't be happier. We would highly recommend Green Mill!
If you haven’t chosen your food yet - PLEASE go sit down with Green Mill for a tasting! They are absolutely INCREDIBLE to work with & their catering menu is phenomenal!
We cannot say enough good things about our experience with Green Mill catering at our wedding. We looked at several vendors and Green Mill had everything we were looking for:
1. Awesome Food
2. Super friendly staff
3. Extremely responsive to emai