We had the most wonderful mid-September wedding at the Picnic House, and we are so grateful we chose to get married there! Kymberle became the point person midway through our planning process, and she was wonderful to work with; she was incred...ibly responsive to e-mails, very helpful, and super friendly when we eventually met in person. William, the house manager who was on-site the day of the wedding itself, was also completely lovely and ensured that everything ran smoothly, including gradually adjusting the overhead lights over the course of the reception to fit the mood. The Picnic House is a beautiful space before you bring anything into it — the only decor we added was flowers and some candles on the tables (no extra lights), and it looked even more gorgeous the day of the wedding than we had imagined it would. The private room downstairs is no frills, but it's a secure place to leave valuables and sit with your partner / officiant before and after the ceremony and sneak a bite to eat before joining the cocktail hour; the bathrooms were also no frills but were perfectly serviceable. We definitely got married IN Prospect Park, and we were surrounded by the people of the park — there were kids playing and laughing nearby, people picnicking, and lots of bystanders observing the ceremony. We loved that environment and thought it was really special to be in the midst of Prospect Park. All in all, the Picnic House was the perfect venue for us.
If you are considering getting married at the Picnic House, a few things to think about: Unlike other venues, Picnic House is pretty bare bones in what it provides; other than the tables and chairs, you have to bring everything else in yourself. This might be more cost effective in the end, but it does require more work and coordination than a venue that does everything for you. (Fortunately, your caterer should be responsible for reserving the rentals, and we were able to delegate a lot of that decisionmaking to the catering captain.) You should read the contract closely before signing it and probably at some point again as you start to lock down vendors. We didn't realize that the chairs the Picnic House provides could not be brought outside and that we couldn't amplify sound outside until we were well into the wedding planning process; neither wound up being a huge issue, but we hadn't accounted for them or budgeted for the extra set of chairs. The Picnic House is strict about clearing out the space at the end of the contract time, so you should have at least a day-of coordinator or a VERY supportive friend or family member who is responsible for making sure everything is out on time. Before booking you should also take a look at the list of exclusive caterers and rental company to make sure they work for your wedding vision, budget, etc. (For what it's worth, we thought it was great to work with a caterer who was familiar and comfortable with the venue and knew how to work with the space and the staff.) And, if you are hoping for an outdoor wedding, you should decide if you are comfortable having your wedding in a public space, surrounded by people; we thought it was a blast, but that might not be everyone's vibe.