About this vendor
Based in Brooklyn, NY, Red Table Catering prepares fresh, exciting cuisine for weddings in the New York Metropolitan Area. These Brooklyn natives are proud of their heritage. They source food locally to create inspiring, high-quality cuisine. The team’s premium wedding menus are sure to give guests an unforgettable experience.
The team at Red Table Catering works to complement the elegant and classical venues New York has to offer. Their mouth-watering dishes are designed to be easy on the eyes and tasty on the tongue. Owner Brooke Costello believes that every couple should have access to amazing fresh food, no matter the size of the party. These culinary masters can feed weddings of 50 to 1,000 guests. Brooke has built relations with lots of local business owners to make this possible. The team partners with butchers, markets, cheesemakers, and more to get the freshest food from the local scene. They rely on Brooklyn’s status as a hub of cuisine and culture to gather top-notch ingredients.
In the leadup to the big day, these creative cooks will help to design a one-of-a-kind menu. They work with couples’ tastes, budgets, and visions to come up with a truly special selection. This can include hors d’oeuvres, food stations, and desserts. The team serves cuisine from all corners of the globe. Some of their premium creations include flank steak tagliata and seared sea bass. Rich desserts are available to top it all off. Examples of past wedding treats include créme caramel and flourless chocolate cake. These experienced chefs can accommodate a range of dietary requirements, such as vegan and gluten-free. Their goal is to let every guest enjoy the wonders of fresh gourmet food. The team at Red Table Catering is well versed in the world of wedding planning. They can offer suggestions not only on the menu, but also on florists, venues, and more. In addition to catering, the business offers bar services. Guests can wash down each delicious bite with a refreshing sip of wine.
Details
Cuisine
- African
- American
- BBQ
- Cajun
- Chinese
- Eastern European
Dietary Options
- Dairy Free
- Gluten Free
- Kosher
- Nut Free
- Organic
- Sugar Free
Food & Catering
- Buffet
- Catering Clean Up
- Catering Delivery & Setup
- Chef Stations
- Family Style
- Menu Tastings
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help
you make those big decisions with ease.
5
out of 5.010 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 2
We truly cannot say enough incredible things about Red Table. From start to finish, they were exceptional and played such a huge role in making our wedding feel elegant, seamless, ...
and unforgettable.
To start, the cocktail hour was spectacular. The passed appetizers were not only delicious but somehow still piping hot as they made their way around the room! Every bite felt restaurant quality, and our guests are still raving about how amazing everything was.
For dinner, the presentation was stunning. Each entrée was plated with sophistication and real attention to detail. It genuinely felt like fine dining. We offered chicken piccata, beef tenderloin, and pesto pasta, and all three were phenomenal. The beef tenderloin was perfectly cooked and incredibly tender, the pesto pasta was fresh and vibrant, and the chicken piccata was bright, balanced, and beautifully executed. In fact, chicken piccata was not even on Red Table's original menu options, and they gladly created it for us. That level of flexibility and commitment to personalization meant so much.
The bar service was equally impressive. The open bar ran seamlessly all night, and they crafted custom signature cocktails inspired by my wife Sara and I that were such a hit with our guests. It added a fun and personal touch while still feeling elevated and refined.
The servers were truly white glove level. The staff was polished, professional, attentive, and warm. Plates were served and cleared gracefully, drinks were refreshed without ever being intrusive, and every interaction felt thoughtful and high end. The entire evening flowed flawlessly because of their team.
David and Pierce were an absolute pleasure to work with throughout the planning process. They were incredibly responsive, organized, generous with their time, and fully invested in getting every detail right. They welcomed us back for multiple tastings in their showroom in Brooklyn to make sure we felt completely confident in our menu selections, which speaks volumes about their dedication to quality and client experience.
Red Table did not just cater our wedding - they elevated it at every level. The food, presentation, bar program, and service were all exceptional. We truly could not recommend them more highly!
We used Red Table for our wedding in May 2024, and absolutely loved the experience. We did several tastings and they were by far the most impressive. We got great comments from gue...
sts on the food (especially the passed apps!). Moreover, David was great with my many requests to accommodate dietary needs, order rentals, and personalize our bar and dessert options. Pierce handled everything beautifully on the day! The waitstaff were lovely as well. We couldn’t have been happier!
We were absolutely thrilled with the service and quality provided by Red Table Catering at our wedding! From the initial tasting to the final plate served, everything was impeccabl...
e. The food was not only delicious but beautifully presented.
David worked closely with us to create a menu that perfectly suited our tastes and dietary needs, going above and beyond to accommodate every request. Their professionalism and attention to detail made the catering process completely stress-free. On the day of the wedding, their team was efficient and friendly, ensuring that everything ran smoothly.
If you’re looking for a caterer who will exceed your expectations and is so easy to work with, Red Table Catering is the one to choose. They truly helped make our special day unforgettable, and we couldn’t be happier with their service!
Red Table was superb from start to finish. They weren't just our catering, but a centerpiece of our wedding planning process. They accommodated a wide range of dietary restrictions...
and incorporated custom coffee roasted by a guest into the evening. The food was delicious, and we're still getting rave reviews about it from our guests. Working with Pierce and David was smooth and fun, and we recommend Red Table without hesitation.
The entire Red Table team is amazing. Professional, organized, thoughtful and completely responsive. A class act in every respect. The food was superb. The craft cocktails they ...
created were fantastic and HUGE hits. Service throughout our event was brilliant. We can't wait to have them run our next event. More than 5 stars. 6+++
Red Table Catering is fantastic! They're easy to work with and the food is delicious. Our guests keep commenting about how tasty everything was! Their staff is professional and fri...
endly and we'd hire them again in a heartbeat. Thank you again, David &co!
Dave at Red Table Catering was a fantastic key partner for our wedding at The Bordone LIC. From the tasting at their Williamsburg storefront through the day of the wedding itself, ...
he was extremely calm, flexible, and easy to work with. Not only did he and his staff provide incredible service; the food was beyond the quality we expected within our budget. We loved the many choices available and were beyond satisfied with how the food turned out at the wedding. Our guests felt the same - we received a lot of compliments. Beyond handling menu planning and food preparation, Dave was also a great help in working with Broadway Party Rentals and visited the showroom with us to help us choose our dishes, glassware, stemware, and more. (He was also really nice about it when we overhauled almost all of our selections just two weeks before the wedding!) That level of service was exactly what we needed, and we would absolutely recommend Red Table to any couple in need of a caterer for their wedding.
The team from Red Table Catering went above and beyond to make our day perfect and beautiful. Leading up to our wedding, Brooke & David were prompt and professional answering email...
s and phone calls - even from a different time zone. They worked with our budget and helped us coordinate with different vendors - all of which were spectacular! The food... it's light years away from 'typical wedding food'. It's inventive and delicious and beautifully displayed. All of the staff was so friendly and many of our guests went out of their way to tell us so. These guys know what they're doing - in the kitchen, behind the bar and beyond. Thank you for the most incredible day of our lives!!
<3 Missy & Marco
Hiring Red Table was the best decision my husband and I made for our wedding. It was PERFECTION. Our guests have been raving about the food, everything down to the starter salad!...
They really know they are stuff and are so passionate about what they do. Not only that, but they are down to earth, kind people. We knew from the second we met Brooke and David that they were "the ones" to take on the job. They really just want to make you happy and make delicious incredible food. They really felt more like family at the end of the wedding process. I really can't recommend them enough. Hire them, it is the best decision you'll make and trust me, you'll want them by your side on your big day.
I only wish Red Table had been around for my own wedding 25 years ago! We were extremely fortunate to work with Brooke and his team on a charity fundraiser for our non-profit earl...
ier this year. From start to finish, they were amazing. They put together a fabulous cocktail spread for us and somehow managed to do it within our limited budget.
His blood orange margaritas and white sangria were the perfect complement to our Cinco de Mayo-themed hors d’oeuvres, which were delicious and creative, beautifully presented, and plentiful. Their signature market table was a huge hit, with an abundant spread of dips, spreads, cheeses, market vegetables, and more.
The staff was incredibly professional but also warm and friendly - a combination that can be difficult to find. And Brooke was a complete pleasure to work with, start to finish. He was immediately responsive whenever we contacted him during the planning process, gave us great suggestions and also listened to ours, and made sure that every aspect of the event was carefully planned and went off without a hitch.
Red Table will definitely be my first (and only) call the next time I need a caterer. SIX stars.
Contact
631 Grand St., Brooklyn, NY | New York
Red Table Catering