About this vendor
Our CupCakery is a wedding cake company in Dublin, OH, that can help elevate your long-awaited dinner party. We specialize in wedding and all-occasion cakes, cupcakes, desserts, and more. Our one-of-a-kind dessert displays, cupcake towers, and delicious cakes make any celebration sparkle! We are a small family-owned business in the heart of Historic Dublin, Ohio, and we put our hearts and name on everything we send out the door. We aim to deliver excellent customer service with beautiful and delicious desserts for every client, every time! Contact us today to set up a time to taste and discuss your vision for your wedding celebration.
What You'll Love About Our CupCakery
Before the big day, you can opt for a cake tasting with the team at Our CupCakery. This way, you and your partner-to-be will get to choose the perfect dessert for guests to enjoy on your special day.
Details
Business Attributes
- Veteran-owned Business
- Woman-owned Business
Cakes & Desserts
- Cake Accessories
- Cake Delivery & Setup
- Cake Tastings
- Groom's Cakes
Dietary Options
- Dairy Free
- Gluten Free
- Sugar Free
- Vegan
- Vegetarian
Awards and Affiliations
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.9
out of 5.0149 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 9
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
We ordered cupcakes and a small wedding cake from Our Cupcakery for our wedding. Laura and the entire team did such a fantastic job of working with us to select flavors and deliver the desserts the day of the wedding. The cupcakes and cake themselves were amazing! We got so many compliments from our guests about how good they were. We can’t recommend Our Cupcakery enough!
If there’s one thing guests always talk about after a wedding, it’s the food—especially the dessert! And let us tell you, Our CupCakery delivered perfection. If you’re in Central Ohio and want the best-tasting cakes and cupcakes, look no further.
From the very start, Laura made the process incredibly easy. She took the time to go over every detail of our wedding cake, ensuring it was exactly what we envisioned. Their cake batter? Moist, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. Their frosting? Perfectly balanced—not overly sugary. Instead, they created a stunning cake that was both beautiful and delicious. Their cheesecake rounds were a huge hit as well!
One thing we especially loved was their attention to presentation. They even provided elegant cake and dessert stands, making our treats look like something straight out of a fairy tale ballroom. And if you want fresh flowers on your cake, no problem—they’ll coordinate with your florist to make sure everything comes together flawlessly. And it truly did. Our wedding cake the day of the wedding looked exactly the way we had imagined and more. Just was absolutely breathtaking!
But here’s the best part—our wedding desserts were so good that we actually went back after our wedding just to get more! That’s how irresistible their cakes and cupcakes are. Our favorite being the lemon cake with raspberry buttercream icing.
If you want to ensure your guests leave with full hearts and happy bellies, Our CupCakery is the place to go. We couldn’t recommend them enough!
Our vanilla flavored wedding cake with almond buttercream frosting was so beautiful and delicious! Guests were raving about it. Highly recommend OurCupcakery for your event :)
We cannot recommend going with Our CupCakery enough. We had a small wedding (35-40 guests) and had multiple members with dietary restrictions (we had gluten-free, lactose intolerant, and vegan guests, including the bride!), so we were definitely worried about making sure we had desserts for everyone to be happy. We also LOVE sugar and it is important to us that the desserts actually taste good. Guests were RAVING about the cake and desserts we got from Our CupCakery. They were timely, professional, easy to work with, and very affordable considering the high quality you get. They will make any design you want and really listen to what you want and what your vision is for your wedding. We got a 2-tier cake, mini, regular, and king size cupcakes, macarons, brownies, and rice krispy treats for our dessert buffet. Everything was gluten-free except the king cupcakes (our request), and all of the regular cupcakes were vegan. We should have ordered more--our vegan guests who normally skip dessert devoured them all and asked if we had more!! We could not have been happier. Highly recommend.
Our Cupcakery was an absolute joy to work with. I knew from the second we had our cake tasting that we were in good hands. We had no idea what we were doing when it came to designing our wedding cake, but Laura was so helpful and so prepared. She had examples to show us and really worked with us to create something beautiful. The cakes are also delicious! Our cake was a huge hit with our guests. We didn't even have any left to take home. I can't recommend Our Cupcakery enough!
Laura and her team are amazing! We ordered a 2-tier wedding cake and cupcakes for our wedding. The scheduling for the taste test was super easy. We just emailed her what days worked best for us to meet and what flavors we'd like to try. She gave us so many suggestions and let us run with it. She discussed every detail, from what the cake and cupcakes would be set up on to the frosting we wanted to the toppers being used. She was even able to accommodate for people who needed sugar free cupcakes for us! She kept in great contact with us and made sure we had everything the way we wanted. She even threw in an anniversary cake for free! The cake was so tasty and well made. Everyone loved the cake and cupcakes! And the prices were very reasonable for a wedding. Would highly recommend OurCupcakery!
Our CupCakery was perfect for our wedding! Their cupcakes were delicious and beautiful and they were so easy to work with!
We used Our CupCakery for our wedding cake and were so pleased with the quality of the cake, price, and service. The had a lot of choices and we loved the at home tasting we were able to do. On the day, we received many compliments from our guests on how good the cake was! I would highly recommend them for your wedding or event!
Laura and her team were so amazing!! When the cake shop I had originally scheduled for my wedding closed its doors (2 months before our big day), I reached out to Our Cupcakery. They were able to accommodate us quickly, and the cake tasted better than the previous shop! They responded so quickly with all of my inquiries and took so much of my stress away! The cake was delivered in perfect condition and was absolutely breathtaking. They truly helped make our big day a success!
Side note: The strawberry cake is TO DIE FOR!!!
I had the pleasure of working with Laura at Our Cupcakery for our wedding cake and tasting. Our Cupcakery did a fantastic job!! The cake not only looked beautiful and exactly how I imagined it, but it is the best wedding cake I've ever had. Their cupcakes, icing, cake is incredible. We also ordered Buckeyes from them for our wedding welcome bags. We picked unique fun flavors for our wedding cake and half the cake was one flavor and half the other. Thank you SO MUCH Our Cupcakery! I would recommend them to anyone.
I got my cake from OurCupkery and it was the best experience. I really wanted a funfetti cake, but I also really wanted an almond cake so they generously agreed to make me an almond funfetti cake. It was even more beautiful in person that I imagined it would be, and it was delicious. I highly recommend Our CupCakery.
The cake turned out better than I could imagine! The whole process was easy and the communication was great. The cake also tasted amazing as well.
The selection of flavors at our cupcakery speak for themselves! We picked their signature vanilla flavor and received so many compliments from our guest. We had booked our cupcakery pretty last minute after our original bakery had suddenly closed their doors. We worked with Laura, who was so understanding to our situation and honestly came to our rescue! She quickly setup a cake tasting for us and got us booked for our big day. Laura was very responsive and answered all our questions in a timely manner. She was great to work with!
Loved the desserts we had at our wedding!! We had a small cake and 3 flavors of cupcakes. The strawberry cake was soooo good. Laura was so helpful throughout the whole process and very knowledgeable. We had a lot of fun with the tasting and loved that we could mix and match different flavors of cake/frostings. Everything was delivered and set up beautifully for us, and return of stands after the wedding was very easy. Highly recommend!
Our wedding cake was amazing! Our Cupcakery was very accommodating when our plans changed with our cupcake order.
First off – absolutely delicious! We were absolutely won over when we had a taste test at the first meeting. We got to try out different flavors and fillings and talk through design, cake sizes, etc. right away. For our guests with dairy and citrus allergies, they baked allergen-free cupcakes that our friends absolutely loved. (Note – they cannot guarantee nut-free products.) They were also very accommodating for our customized request for the cake. For one of our cake flavors (lemon), they added a custom filling (fresh huckleberry) that we were willing to pay extra to outsource. (Extremely tasty combo, by the way.)
The mountain design they created was a perfect fit. They even provided a wooden cake stand that went with the theme. The staff was always professional and courteous. Each time we went to the store, they recognized us, even months apart. They were just as excited about our cake as we were. If you need a baker that will deliver both the cake and results for your wedding, look no further. (Also go if you are just looking for good-quality deserts!)
Our cupcakery did an amazing job on our wedding cake. It tastes absolutely delicious and looked amazing. Laura was so easy and wonderful to work with. I can’t say enough good things about them! Everyone complimented our cake and they were even able to accommodate our gluten free friends, who said their GF cupcakes tasted amazing. They have so many delicious options.
We were so happy with Our CupCakery. We had a wedding of 100 guests and ordered 3 sets of 40 cupcakes and several dozen cookies and brownies. The display was perfect, the desserts were delicious (we'd highly recommend the double chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting, just perfect) and our guests raved about everything. Book them today!
We had a smaller wedding reception luncheon for approximately 70 people. Our wedding planner recommended Our Cupcakery to us and they did a fantastic job on our dessert table! We were able to try some samples and they guided us through the amount of desserts we would want based on our group size. The mini cupcakes, cheesecakes and cake pops were a hit and were so good! They have an amazing selection of flavors and they even delivered and set up a beautiful table. My only regret is not ordering more-( we had no leftovers for my husband and I). We would definitely recommend them!
Amazing gluten free dessert spread! It was a piece of art that offered a little something for everyone- and was so delicious we had no leftovers! Our personal cake was the perfect size and we kept half as an anniversary cake. Their setup was completed with attention to detail and perfect communication and planning. A pleasure to work with!
They brought our vision to life everything was so fresh and just what we wanted.
Found Our CupCakery one day strolling through Historic Dublin. The moment you walk into the bakery you feel welcomed and ready for an amazing treat. We decided to have a tasting and consultation, and immediately booked for our wedding on 10.14.2022. Laura and her team are wonderful! They have so many amazing options, and they all taste so good! The delivery of the cake was perfect and she went above and beyond to help place the little decor and flowers on the cake. Thank you!
our wedding cake was perfect, they recreated the wedding cake from an inspiration photo I found on pintrest perfectly
Laura and the team were amazing from the start. The tasting went well and had so many options. It was nice to mix and natch flavors at the tasting to come up with great combinations. They were able to help us execute the vision for our cupcakes and wedding cake. We were beyond happy with our experience!
Our CupCakery was awesome to work with for our wedding cake. They were so nice and very flexible with our order, not to mention the cake was THE BEST! The flavor and texture were amazing and the design was elegant - exactly what we wanted! Highly, highly recommended!!
Have you ever been to a wedding where the cake looks amazing but tastes like cardboard? Or one where the flavor was on point but the execution was mediocre at best? WELL with Our Cupcakery, you don’t have to worry because the cakes taste INCREDIBLE and their decorating skills are superb. Our wedding cake and grooms cake looked incredible and our guests RAVED about the flavor. We had a bit leftover that we took home to share on Sunday brunch and it was DEMOLISHED before noon. On top of the flavor and vision being spot on, Our Cupcakery is incredible to work with. They have a great tasting process and are so easy to work with. You cannot go wrong!!
I would absolutely recommend Our Cupcakery! We did a 2 tier wedding cake and it turned out beautiful, along with a variety of the bite-sized desserts. Everything tasted SO good!! Also the staff were super friendly and helpful!
Our cake and cupcakes were beautiful and all the guests raved
We worked with Laura to make the plan for our wedding cake, and we couldn’t have been happier with how everything turned out! I needed a gluten-free cake, so we had one tier made gluten-free for me and the other gluten-free guests while the other tier and kitchen cakes were standard cakes. Our decorative cake was beautiful and exactly what we had imagined, and it was delicious too! We heard rave reviews from everyone about both the chocolate and strawberry cakes! We can’t wait for our anniversary cake!
Very nice display and tasting! I got a two tiered cake and cupcakes for my 10-10-21 wedding, the cake was Amazing! Flavor everything I could have wished for! I had no leftovers which is sad for me but wonderful as the cake spoke for itself! Thank you so very much!
We used Our CupCakery for our wedding on 12/4/21 and could not be happier with our decision. They were so easy to work with and made the whole process so simple. But above all else, their cakes were delicious and a week later we are still getting compliments from our guests on how good the cakes were. Thank you so much for everything and we highly recommend using them for your wedding too!
OurCupcakery provided AMAZING cupcakes for our wedding. We— along with our loved ones— were astonished at the presentation and flavor. So happy OurCupcakery was with us on our big day!
Everything was delicious!! They are a pleasure to work with. Our cake and 4 flavors of cupcakes were amazing and beautiful. Cannot recommend them enough!
I highly recommend the Cupcakery. I did extensive research (tastings!), received many quotes and decided on them based on their great flavor. I could not have asked for better people to work with planning a covid wedding. I am thankful for their flexibility and support. The cake and cupcakes the day of tasted SO GOOD! The lighted display was worth every penny. I am beyond happy with my choice!!! Thank you thank you thank you!!! Cant wait for my anniversary cake!
Our CupCakery is amazing! They did the desserts for our wedding and we couldn't be happier. We did a glass tier dessert display with a small cake for us on top. We received so many compliments from our guests. The process was so easy with them which is great when planning a wedding. I highly recommend them!
Our CupCakery made both our wedding cake, as well as the cake for my bridal shower, and OH MY GOODNESS. Best. Cakes. Ever. Not only were both cakes beautiful works of art, but they were absolutely delicious! Our cake tasting with Laura was so much fun and we can't wait to pick up cupcakes and cake from their Dublin location again soon. They're our new go-to bakery!
Not only was our cake and cupcakes absolutely delicious, but our cake and cupcakes were exactly what we had envisioned. I had a dusty blue and greenery wedding with succulents and they made the frosting in a succulent design on top! They were adorable and our guests loved them, as did we. The cupcake tower was beautiful and really was a focal point in our reception area. Thank you all so much, you really helped add an extra *zing* to our wedding and we LOVED it all!!!
We had a fantastic experience with Our CupCakery! We immediately fell in love with their bourbon chocolate cake and especially their cream cheese frosting. Laura helped us every step of the way as we started out seeking a wedding cake but ultimately switched to cupcakes because they were JUST THAT GOOD.
Our CupCakery was totally flexible when we needed to reschedule our wedding from 2020 to 2021 because of COVID and we are so grateful for that!
We already can't wait for our anniversary cupcakes -- but we'll probably be back in to pick some up sooner than that. Their location in historic downtown Dublin is adorable!
We booked Our CupCakery for our wedding on 7/10/21. We cannot tell you how many compliments we received on our wedding cake!! The flavor and attention to detail was above and beyond. Laura goes out of her way to make your cake amazing and DELICIOUS! The cake was basically gone by the end of the night and I was worried my husband and I wa
weren't going to get any- a special box was made up for us with some slices we could take with us! So thoughtful. Highly, highly recommend!!!
We used Our CupCakery for our June wedding and I could not be happier! My husband really loves pizza so in addition to our actual wedding cake, we asked Our CupCakery to make pizza cake for the groom's cake and they knocked it out of the park! Laura was awesome to work with, and the team made the entire process seamless. And the cake tasted absolutely amazing!!
This was the first decision I made when planning our wedding was choosing Our CupCakery. I have loved their cupcakes for years and they do not disappoint!! Laura is super easy to work with and she and her team create masterpieces. I was really hoping there would be leftovers after the wedding, but the guests loved them so much they were all gone by the end of the night! :) Highly recommend Our CupCakery!!
I ordered gluten free cupcakes for my wedding and they did not disappoint! Laura was great to work with and everything turned out exactly how I wanted. Not only did they look great, but my dad said they tasted delicious! They also offered reasonable delivery to the venue which was very helpful!
There is a reason they have such a great reputation. Our wedding cake looked fabulous but more importantly was delicious! They were flexible when we had to postpone twice due to COVID and their pricing is competitive. They delivered and set up the cake on time and I cannot wait to order future cakes.
Laura was amazing to work with! She was quick to respond to email and took the time to meet with us not only at the tasting but during final planning moments to make sure everything was as we wanted. Not only was working with her such an easy process, but the cake! Beyond words delicious! Everyone loved it and eating leftovers a week after the wedding, it is still moist and delicious! I will definitely continue to give Laura and Our Cupcakery my business, even if it's just stopping in for a cupcake!
We ordered cupcakes for our wedding and a sweetheart cake to cut, and everything was INCREDIBLE. They arranged everything beautifully on our dessert table, the cake was made exactly how we wanted it, and our guests have not stopped talking about how amazing the cupcakes were. Laura was super friendly and easy to stay in contact with throughout the planning process. I highly recommend the chocolate chip cookie dough cupcake, but anything you get from here will be delicious!
We hired OurCupCakery for our wedding cake in April and oh my gosh..... their cake is so AMAZING. One of the best cakes I've ever had. The buttercream is delicious! Not to mention, the presentation of our cake at our wedding looked so classy and elegant. Very impressed. Thank you guys again for your amazing work! :)
These guys are AMAZING, I can’t say enough good things about them! We had so many compliments on our dessert display and variety and of course how tasty everything was. Any questions I had were answered quickly, they definitely went above and beyond. As a Covid bride we had a lot of stress planning weddings this year and I can say Our CupCakery was so helpful and made everything a breeze despite never meeting in person. They will be my go-to bakery from now on! Thank you all so much for making our big day perfect with your delicious treats!
I cannot say enough amazing things about Laura and her team! We originally ordered our wedding cake and cupcakes, and last minute added a grooms cake. She accommodated our needs to the highest standard! So many guests commented on how amazing both cakes were! We will forever use Our CupCakery in the future. Thank you!!
Our Cupcakery is, simply, amazing. They catered our wedding on October 5th, 2019 and everything from communication, delivery, presentation, and of course the product was PHENOMENAL. We just picked up our anniversary cake and it looks and tastes just as amazing as I remember it being on our wedding day. I highly recommend Our Cupcakery to anyone who is looking for a cake caterer for a wedding, birthday, graduation, etc. I will definitely be coming back here for all of my future cake, cupcake, and sweet treat needs!
Our CupCakery was so easy to work with especially through Covid. They were very responsive with changes needing made with guest count and change of locations. And by the end of the night, we had zero treats left!
Contact
54 S. High Street, Dublin, OH | Central Ohio and outlying areas
Our CupCakery
Our CupCakery's photos