SugarBakers

orful without being overpowering. The icings were smooth and silky and not too sweet. The guests LOVED it as well! Highly recommend. Only negative we experienced in the planning process was in regards to communication. It was difficult to reach anyone at the shop most of the time or have calls returned. That being said, the cake arrived on time, as discussed and was delicious.

ensure we were happy with our selections. Our 3 tier, 3 flavor cake was delicious. Our guests LOVED it and couldn’t stop talking about how they sampled all 3 flavors. We also loved the fact that we didn’t have to save a tier because we will get our anniversary cake next May. Thank you Khrissy and SugarBakers for helping us bring the tropical/coastal feel to our wedding with the beautiful cake you created for us.

in love. They added a small detail of a realistic sculpture of our dog that everyone loved. We did have a little trouble when we went to cut it since we didn’t realize there was a smaller base in the center but it made it funnier during the cake cutting. I would definitely recommend and look into using them again for another occasion.

come back to and realized it was half of the page :D. Thank you so much!

exactly what we wanted and the cakes themselves were heavenly. all of our guests raved about the cake. Couldn't have been more happier and so glad we chose them.

d Cake's Peanut Butter Fudge Cups Cake. I work in the wedding industry, and never considered another baker for my wedding cake. They were so easy to work with and exceeded my expectations! You will not regret getting your cake from them!!

on’t really have to keep your top layer because they will send you a freshly prepared cake (your choice of flavor) on your first wedding anniversary, for FREE. Thank you Sugar Bakers.

u!

d we get another one in a year!

detailed questions about what we specifically liked in the design. We had a hard time selecting flavors because they were all delicious, and our cake looked and tasted exactly the way we had hoped. They were also easy to work with and accommodated changes we made to our order. The only note is that they seem to recommend way more cake than you may actually need – we ended up with more slices than expected and took the entire top layer home that night. Consider scaling down on the amount of cake you order, especially if you’re planning to have other desserts as well.

d to confirm everything with me prior to the wedding. Cake was delivered on time and in one piece! They also have the option to order additional sheet cakes, which we did. On your one-year wedding anniversary they will back you a new small cake as well as part of your package!

.

wedding. We’ve frozen the leftover cake, thawed some a month later and it’s still just as delicious as our wedding day.

cluded in my package from the Admiral Fell Inn!

our tasting, explaining the various flavors and frosting combinations, showing us photos of previous cakes, and carefully detailing all our design specifications. There wasn't any pressure to commit to buying our cake at the consultation, and Amy even sent a lovely handwritten note as a follow up. On our wedding day we were blown away by how beautiful our cake turned out (all white with a quilted pattern and pastillage flowers around the middle tier), and we were thrilled to be able to serve the delicious cake to all our guests.

tness, high quality of the cake. The cake was so beautiful that we didn’t need a topper, flowers, or any other adornments and we ended up not using any! Unfortunately I (the bride) was very ill on wedding day and didn’t get to eat much cake. But even going on 2 weeks thereafter I am loving the leftovers! The cake is still quality and tastes great!

ttsburgh, so my family demands a cookie table. I also worked as a wedding server, so I have seen the amount of wedding cake that gets thrown out at the end of the night. So my brilliant idea was to have a dessert table, and sugar bakers does not offer dessert displays. Except they did. I cannot express the gratitude and joy having them work to make my ridiculous vision a reality even though it wasn’t a service they offered. Krissy was absolutely amazing and made sure that we had everything we wanted. We had a plethora of cake, cupcakes, bars, cookies, cannoli, tarts, you name it. And in the end it was everything I could have dreamed up and we received SO MANY compliments on it. We will definitely be getting a lot of future desserts from Sugar Bakers! *I want to PS this that since they do not do dessert bars we had to coordinate and collect all our own serve ware and display items, which was a pain. Definitely worth it, but a pain, so it is not for the casual bride or I would recommend a wedding planner who can set it up for you.*

buttercream frosting, designed with horizontal texturing and piped beaded borders on each tier), and we ordered a variety of mini desserts (7 types; enough for about 2 minis per guest). Everything was delicious! We attended two tastings - one for the cake and the second for the desserts, as we decided to do mini desserts later on. We loved tasting the flavor options for the cake, and they were very accommodating to food allergies. We also felt they offered a large selection of desserts, which was helpful for us in choosing a variety of things that guests would enjoy. Our consultant was Khrissy, and she worked with us primarily throughout our planning process. We had contact with a few other staff members when we emailed with questions, and everyone was kind, helpful, and professional. We even completely changed our cake design from the initial design, and that was a smooth process. The cake arrived at the expected delivery time and it looked exactly the way we discussed. It was helpful for us to initially look at their portfolio of designs and then talk with Khrissy about things we liked/disliked. The cake photographed well too :-)

awberries and mousse cups which were equally delicious and beautiful!

ment then enough. Worthy every penny. Not only was the service great and the cake beautiful it tastes simply amazing!! Thank you!

ng day. I highly recommend the Amaretto Raspberry Cake.

eryone was a fan. On the year anniversary they will also make you a six inch round cake as a gift for free.

he actual cakes themselves (we got both our wedding and rehearsal dinner cakes from them) were delicious! No complaints at all. Although our venue was ridiculously close to Sugar Bakers, we were told they deliver as far as Ocean City, MD, so that will be very helpful if your wedding is a little further away. Overall Sugar Bakers was a great vendor-the decoration of both our rehearsal dinner and wedding cakes were gorgeous and exactly what we wanted!

ere we were able to taste a variety of flavors and design our cake to reflect us as a couple. They were easy and wonderful to work with. Added bonus: you get a fresh anniversary cake on them so you don't have to eat freezer burnt cake a year later!

o hard to choose the cake flavors between all the choices! Guests raved about how good the cake was, and I had some tell me the next day they wish they could've tasted both flavors (we did cannoli cake and smith island cake). What's great is they even give you a fresh "top of your cake" on your one year anniversary, so you do not need to worry about keeping yours fresh in the freezer (we ate ours the next night!). Not to mention the cake was absolutely stunning! The detail and attention that they gave to the cake was very evident. Sugar Bakers is the way to go for your wedding cake (or cake of ANY occasion)!

d were even able to include my stepson who is 12. We were the last tasting for the day, but were not rushed to get thru it. The customer service was excellent and so helpful! I loved that we were able to choose different flavors for each layer of our cake! My favorite part of SugarBakers is that they will make us a fresh cake for our Anniversary! There was no need to save the top layer!!! Overall, an outstanding experience and I would highly recommend SugarBakers to anyone looking for a cake.

the flavors they are known for - amaretto raspberry and red velvet fudge with German butter cream frosting. I have never tasted a better wedding cake and heard the same reviews from my guests! Red velvet cakes from other bakeries can't even compare to their red velvet fudge. They also offer a complimentary cake for your 1 year anniversary so that you don't have to freeze the top layer of your cake and instead can enjoy it fresh! I went simple with my cake design, but they have some really cool designs on display in their bakery and online. I would definitely recommend them not just for wedding cakes, but any cakes or sweets!

to choose from. Couldn’t be more pleased with how beautiful and delicious the cake was. I can’t wait for our anniversary cake next year and if I ever have another special occasion to order cake for it will definitely be from Sugar Bakers!!!!

t turned out absolutely AMAZING! They were also so attentive and called me to make sure the cake would be exactly to my liking. Besides that, it tasted unbelievable. I still have dreams about eating it!

ers, and adorned the bottom of the cake with gold candy pearls. It was lovely and DELICIOUS! We saved it to finish after our honeymoon, and several people asked to have a piece!

few people that it was the best wedding cake they'd ever had. The buttercream frostings they make are so fresh and deceptively light, not like a lot of the frosting you'd find at many other bakeries. The cakes are fluffy and fresh and are a pure delight. We also found that for the quality of cake, we werent going to find a better value in this area. They will work with you on getting the right frosting/cake combination and were such a pleasure to work with. I'm so thrilled they were our wedding bakery!

r vision. We couldn't have been happier with everything they did.

process to buy this cake was so fun and easy too. They even suggested we try the mini tart desserts and the fruit ones went in less than 10 minutes! Everything was delicious!

t the person who we were working with, but another employee intervened into our conversation to try to persuade me to not get what I wanted. In addition, I was told that the bottom layer can only be a tall cake because of the design. However, I informed Sugar Bakers employee that I did not want a tall bottom layer and it could be made regular (which I emailed pictures after my appointment to prove this to be true). I believe they wanted me to do the tall layer to pay more. On top of that, I was quoted $12 a slice and asked to put a 50% deposit down, which I did. Well the employee came back and stated that she missed priced me after swiping my bank card, that the price of the cake would be $17 per slice and not the $12 a slice. So once questioned about what changed from the time she left the table until swiping my card. The employee stated that the decorator was not in to quote me a price. I then asked how was I quoted a price initially if the decorator would need to see. Sugar Bakers immediately refunded me my deposit of over $500 and informed me they will show the decorator my picture and then get back to me. Well we are almost 3 weeks away from my initial appointment and I have yet to hear from Sugar Bakers to follow-up with me regarding a price. I did call asking to speak with the employee who I worked with and was told was not in and they will give her my message. I am upset because I love their cakes, but this is really a bad experience for a bride to be.

t also beautifully decorated with sugared seasonable berries. They captured our vision perfectly! Highly recommend SugarBakers!!

ke was delicious, and we are looking forward to our first anniversary cake! :)

t and helped with the size, decorations and flavors -cannoli cream and Amaretto Raspberry. SugarBakers was the right choice!

e to stop in to buy a slice of smith island!

use they were all so delicious! Highly recommended!

not sure if this was the result of working with them via the caterer, but the process was not very guided. I provided my vision and was sent back three photos of existing cakes. From those, I basically designed my own cake by stitching together photos in Photoshop and hoping it would look good as an actual cake. I didn't feel very confident in this because I am not a cake designer! Throughout the process, Sugar Bakers was very responsive, usually responding the same day. They knew I was feeling confused, and they were willing to change the cake design a few times to make it work for what I wanted. I was a little disappointed though because when I saw my cake on my wedding day, the gold sparkle we'd settled on was actually different and it was the option that I didn't want. The best part though was the cake tasted amazing. I think most wedding cakes actually don't taste that good, but this cake was honestly delicious! I know Sugar Bakers makes delicious and well-designed cakes, and I think the process may have been much smoother if I could have worked with them more directly.

anyway, and they were able to include 2 different fillings that we liked. The cake came out absolutely beautiful and tasted amazing. It was a naked cake (very little frosting) but was not dry at all. The company was so easy to work with. They dropped the cake off to our venue early enough that our florist was able to add flowers. We got so many compliments on the look and taste of the cake. I would use them time and time again!

I forgot to tell them it was ok to serve it), and the 3rd is only leftover because it was the last flavor cut and put out. And I am NOT complaining about any leftover cake from this great place!

and it looked and tasted fantastic. The staff was very polite and helpful any time I had to contact them, and the price was super reasonable. Our guests were very impressed with the cake and all had very positive things to say about it!

ecorated. The cake itself was fantastic—a few of our guests commented that it was the best wedding cake they’d ever had and wanted to bring home leftovers for themselves. In particular, we loved their French buttercream, which was perfectly sweet and flavorful but not overly sugary. The only downside is that the delivery fee was almost the cost of the cake itself, but that’s mostly because SugarBakers was located about 2 hours—each way—from our venue. Given the quality of the cake and the fact that they were still willing to work with us despite the distance, we didn’t especially mind the cost. And as a bonus? SugarBakers will also provide a freshly baked one-tier cake for your first wedding anniversary, which we are so excited to receive next year.

with a very rude woman on the phone when I was double-checking the status of my order a week before the wedding. She was able to confirm the order, but she did so in a way that was abrupt and unprofessional. Other than that, I had a lovely experience with this vendor.

e tasting is how Sugar Bakers reels you in…damn, if each flavor wasn’t better than the last! Our salesperson brought out a beautiful plate of eleven flavors and additional dollops of the three types of frosting. Of the flavors, four stood out to me as especially delicious: Peach Melba (the best!), Chocolate Mousse Toffee, Amaretto Raspberry, and Red Velvet. I also thought the Lemon Mousse and Strawberry Breeze were quite good. My partner also liked the Toasted Coconut Cream and Cannoli d’Ville flavors; I found them a bit too subtle. For our 100-person wedding, we chose a simple cake of three round tiers, with the bottom tier Peach Melba and the upper tiers Red Velvet, all with French buttercream (rich and silky, and much less sweet than American buttercream, which they also offer if that’s your preference). (We loved those two flavors and their retro-ness fit well with our theme to boot.) Because ANY frosting decoration immediately escalates the price a lot, our salesperson recommended we get it plainly frosted, and then provide ribbon they would put around the base of each layer at no extra charge, and that we provide a cake topper. We did this and it was cute, if a bit plain. Their website offers so many beautiful designs, including incredible stuff with fondant, but of course, fondant doesn’t taste great (guests can peel it away from the buttercream underneath on their serving, if desired) and takes the price from maybe $6/serving to $11-13/serving. It’s too bad because I was enamored of the Pickle Barrel cake on their site and so wanted it for my country fair themed wedding. But ours was cute with the ribbon, flag bunting topper from Etsy, and a few paper pinwheels added by our decorator (to echo the flag bunting in tent and vases of pinwheels as centerpieces). The cake was delicious and we got many compliments on it. We had some to take home and enjoyed it on our own and with friends for several days after. SugarBakers was easy to work with from tasting through delivery, including a few emails and phone calls. I highly recommend them!

- they even printed out a picture of what I wanted (from Pinterest) right there while we were at our appointment, and then made notes on it to personalize it. I was impressed by the entire experience.

emely professional and experienced, would absolutely recommend!

r of cannoli filling with yellow and chocolate cake and a top tier of dulce de leche. I even got to taste different butter creams for the outside. SugarBakers coordinated with the restaurant where I had my reception and we had a problem-free delivery and setup. I did not have to handle anything about it. Guests loved the cake and it looked beautiful. Highly recommended.

f the Smith Island Cake with German Buttercream. The cake was absolutely gorgeous and the guests raved about the cake. A huge hit all around!