The Muttontown Club - Pristine LI Mansion

luding some of the last minute things. We could not recommend this venue enough.

toured two venues, with The Muttontown Club being the first. The moment we met Robert, we knew we had found the perfect place. He immediately made us feel comfortable, welcomed, and, most importantly, like family. From the planning process through the very end of our after-party, Robert and his incredible team were by our side every step of the way. He truly went above and beyond to ensure our wedding was not only beautiful but also a reflection of who we are as a couple. From personalized cocktail hour stations inspired by Montauk and Mykonos to thoughtfully displayed photographs throughout the venue, every detail felt uniquely "us." I would be remiss not to mention Nicole, Samantha, and Chet, who helped make the planning process and our wedding day everything we could have imagined and more. Their attention to detail, professionalism, and genuine care made us feel supported from start to finish. One of the things that stood out most was hearing our guests rave not only about the beauty of the venue and the incredible food, but also about how warm, attentive, and genuinely invested Robert and his team were throughout the entire day. Their level of hospitality was unlike anything we had ever experienced. It was truly the best day of our lives, and we are so grateful that The Muttontown Club and its amazing team made it possible. Ben and I feel incredibly fortunate not only to have the memories of such an unforgettable day but also to have formed lifelong friendships with the people who made it all happen. If you're looking for a venue with a team that will make you feel supported, valued, and genuinely cared for throughout your entire wedding journey, look no further than The Muttontown Club. We will be forever grateful for everything they did to make our dream wedding a reality.

ng process, the entire catering and events team was exceptional. A special thank you to Robert, Samantha, and Nicole, who made the entire process feel effortless. They were always available to answer questions, guide us through decisions, and help us navigate what can be a very overwhelming planning process. Their responsiveness, professionalism, and kindness took so much stress off our plates, and we always felt like we were in the best possible hands. On our wedding day, The Muttontown Club absolutely exceeded every expectation we had. The hospitality, professionalism, attention to detail, and overall execution were flawless. My husband Tom and I were completely blown away, and so were our guests. Days later, people are still talking about how incredible the food was, how attentive the staff were, and how beautiful the entire experience felt from start to finish. A special thank you to Chet, our Maître d', and Tatem, our bridal attendant. They were truly the MVPs of the day. Chet made sure every detail was handled perfectly and kept everything running smoothly behind the scenes. Tatem was an absolute angel. She was by my side whenever I needed anything, somehow anticipating what I needed before I even realized it myself. From helping me stay calm to making sure I had everything I needed throughout the day, she played such a huge role in making our wedding feel effortless and enjoyable. The servers, bartenders, and entire catering team were phenomenal. The service was warm, attentive, and seamless all evening. AND THE DRINKS ARE STRONG!!! One thing that stood out to us was that The Muttontown Club didn't just make us feel special, they made every single guest feel special. The level of care and hospitality was evident in every interaction. As someone who always thought every bride raved about her venue because that's just what brides do, I can honestly say The Muttontown Club earned every bit of praise. Every wedding vendor faces challenges, but from our perspective, The Muttontown Club was truly flawless. They didn't just host our wedding, they helped create one of the best days of our lives. We are beyond grateful to Robert, Samantha, Nicole, Chet, Tatem, and the entire Muttontown team for making our wedding so unforgettable. We would host future events here without hesitation, and I will absolutely be one of those people encouraging every engaged couple I know to go see The Muttontown Club.

ent we started planning to the very last moment of the wedding, everything was handled so beautifully and professionally. Rob, the Director of Catering, is truly one of a kind. Beyond being incredibly talented at what he does, he genuinely cares about the families he works with and it shows in every detail. He made us feel so comfortable, supported, and taken care of throughout the entire process. His professionalism, kindness, attention to detail, and calm presence made such a difference, especially as a mother wanting everything to be perfect for her daughter. He went above and beyond for our family, and I will never forget that. His staff is absolutely top notch and every single person made us feel celebrated the entire evening. The service, the food, the atmosphere, and the overall experience were simply incredible. As a mother, you dream of your daughter having the most beautiful wedding day possible, and they gave that to us and more. It was truly an honor to celebrate there and I will forever be grateful for the unforgettable memories they created for our family ♥️

ided to meet with Robert to see if they could hold our fairly large group. From the start, Robert seemed like he actually cared about us as a couple! He is full of energy and will customize your wedding to fit you. The Club is truly beautiful and we felt so taken care of. The food is AMAZING and the team is so professional. Often, wedding venues can feel like wedding factories. This is not that. The Muttontown Club is a special place that made us feel like family. They really valued our thoughts and opinions, and were willing to do whatever it took to give us the most amazing day. Everything ran so smoothly and perfectly. It was the most fun we have ever had. Our friends and family can’t stop talking about the night. We feel incredibly blessed!!! We cannot thank the staff enough!!!

and his entire team went above and beyond to cater to our every need. Their professionalism, attention to detail, and genuine care made the entire planning process seamless and stress-free. No request or ask was too big and while the Club hosts many weddings, we always felt like our wedding was their top priority. The food and venue are also top notch with numerous food options that are all curated for each couple. This was especially important to us as we had a number of wedding guests with severe food allergies. The team at The Muttontown Club took great care to ensure all allergies were accounted for and delicious substitutes were available (including an entirely gluten free desert table!!!). We would highly recommend any couple getting married on Long Island to consider The Muttontown Club!

Club team went above and beyond to make our day absolutely perfect. The venue itself is elegant, timeless, and so beautifully maintained, but it was the team that truly made our wedding unforgettable. They anticipated our needs before we even voiced them, handled every detail with professionalism and care, and made the entire planning process feel seamless. We never had to worry about a thing because they had already thought of it. One of the most important elements to us as we were planning was the food. Guests might forget the small details, but they always remember the food. Let's just say our guests are still raving to us about the amazing food on our wedding day. If you’re looking for a venue where the team treats your wedding like their top priority, go to the Muttontown Club! They helped create the wedding day of our dreams, and we are forever grateful. Sending the most heartfelt thank you to Rob, Nicole, Jen, DJ, and Laiba.

t interests at the center of it all. Brian & Natalia

friends and family are still raving about the gorgeous venue, incredible food, and fantastic service. The team really went above and beyond to craft our dream wedding and worked with us to bring our unique vision to life. We highly recommend the Muttontown for your special event!

ns into a beautiful tiled entry with a sweeping circular staircase. There are several rooms on the first room to include, "The Oak Room" which has a beautiful paneled ceiling. The room opens into a breathtaking atrium on one side and a patio on the back side. There is an Art Deco styled lounge, a dining area, a beautiful bar area and a large elegant ballroom. The food was exceptional! Our guests are still raving about the fantastic food at the cocktail hour, the mini margaritas and delicious diner entrees. The staff at the Muttontown Club was top notch with an incredible team. The teams professionalism, vision, experience, willingness to think outside the box, kindness and flexibility made the day an unforgettable celebration. Prior to the event the staff was receptive and informative, answered all our questions and offered suggestions to enhance the day. Emails were answered immediately and the staff was engaged in the planning. The day of the event the Director of Catering was a rock. He addressed any concerns and made special accommodations for elderly guests. He was gracious to our guests while overlooking and shepherding things along, always in the background and stepping in to take action. The day of the celebration the staff was everywhere without being obtrusive and made sure everyone had what they needed. The celebration flowed smoothly. The servers were professional, upbeat, caring and friendly. They were eager to get you anything you needed and never made you feel as if anything you asked for was a problem. Our guests are still complementing the venue, the delicious food and the wonderful hospitality of the staff. The Muttontown Club has an amazing team. The care and professionalism of each person contributed to the magical evening. They truly made this celebration a night to remember.

for several years, so we already knew the level of service would be exceptional. It was important to us that not only would we have the best possible experience, but that our family and friends would be just as impressed. Muttontown delivered on every front. I love this venue so much that I even hosted my bridal shower here, and as you can probably guess, it was just as amazing. From start to finish, Jennifer, Samantha, and the entire staff were incredibly accommodating, thoughtful, and easy to work with. They took the time to listen to our ideas, offered helpful suggestions, and worked with us to bring our vision to life in the most beautiful way. Our guests are still talking about how stunning the venue was and how delicious the food was. Every detail, from the cocktail hour to the dessert display, was flawless. I can say with complete confidence that I had the wedding I always dreamed of at Muttontown Country Club, and I highly recommend it to anyone considering hosting a special event. You will be in excellent hands.

ality — and with 215 guests and a few nontraditional ideas, that was no small feat. Our cocktail hour spread throughout the oak room, the sun room and the terrace was like something out of a movie. People RAVED about the food. I dreamed of having long tables and a family-style dinner, something intimate and warm despite the large guest count. Not only did they make it happen — they made it stunning. Every detail felt intentional, and the room was exactly what I imagined. We also wanted to separate dinner from dancing to create a real “nightclub” feel for the second half of the night. That could have easily been complicated or clunky, but the transitions were smooth, the energy never dipped, and the flow of the night was perfect. And I have to give a special shoutout to Robert, who somehow managed to say “yes” to everything. His attitude was always, “Let’s figure it out,” and he delivered every single time. I genuinely felt like we were in the best hands. If you’re looking for a venue that’s not only gorgeous, but also flexible, thoughtful, and willing to take on big ideas with grace — I can’t recommend The Muttontown Club enough. Our guests haven’t stopped raving, and we’ll never forget how it all came together.

he food was endless and phenomenal! I could not recommend this venue enough, it allowed me to have the wedding I always dreamed of- thank you!!

o work with them - and for good reason! They kept incredible notes of every single conversation and email correspondence, no detail was missed and they put us at ease that everything was taken care of. The food is unbelievable, our guests raved about every cocktail station, appetizer, entree and desert. We couldn’t have imagined getting married anywhere else! A HUGE thank you to Jennifer, Lana, Tara and Rachel for executing our day flawlessly!

But while working with Jen, the event manager, we couldn’t feel more comfortable and excited for our big day!! From the minute we met Jen, she was professional, accommodating and truly went over and above for my husband and I. Jen, along with all the other staff members at the Muttontown Club quickly became family to us during our experience. After changing our original venue and wanting to keep our date, Jen and her team had less then 4 months when we booked with them. Being a COVID bride I was obviously nervous and hesitant to book another venue, but my feelings quickly changed. We could not be happier with every detail of our wedding day thanks to the incredible team at the Muttontown Club. In addition to their impeccable customer service, the food was outstanding. Not only were our guests raving about cocktail hour, dinner and dessert. They once again went over and above to accommodate my Vegan diet and also include our new puppy Hank as the signature drink!! When you walk into the venue, the grounds and stunning mansion speak for themselves. But it was really the staff that made our night perfect. From the cheerful servers & bartenders to my bridal attendant. Every single employee did right by us. They also were great about always wearing masks.. which covered their mouth AND NOSE!! My husband and I really cannot thank them enough for giving us a magical wedding day. We will continue to highly recommend this venue and can’t wait to visit for all of our future anniversaries!! ❤️❤️❤️

ways prompt to respond with my many questions and the team at the club always made us feel welcome when we came for meetings/visits. They completely exceeded our expectation the day of the wedding - the staff was on top of everything and the way they set up the club looked incredible. I've gotten nothing but rave reviews from our guests not just about the day itself (which is also thanks to the club team) but specifically about how perfect the venue was. I highly recommend this as a wedding venue to future couples!!!

cky enough to have perfect weather and were able to use the outdoor area overlooking the golf course during cocktail hour and the after party. The fire pits were a fun touch! We received so many compliments on the food - everything from the cocktail hour (sushi bar was delicious) to the food at the after party. Jen was such a pleasure to work with and was so patient with my never ending laundry list of questions. She made sure everything was executed with ease and I was confident that I had nothing to worry about on our wedding day due to her attention to detail. ALL of the staff at the Club were so genuine and professional and were part of the reason that our wedding day was so special. We loved spending time at the Club and will miss it! They always made us feel so welcomed and were beyond accommodating. Thank you Muttontown Club for everything you did to make our day a fairy tale - we are so thankful!

or making it all happen! I recommended the club to my friend for her daughter's wedding.

over with a new manager, Jennifer Harmon. One of the most important aspects of our wedding was that we wanted to have fun and not have to stress on our special day, and Jen did just that! It was a smooth transition and I honestly believe everything happens for a reason now. Jen had exceeded our expectations, Her and her team have been nothing short of stellar this entire experience. She walked us through every step of the planning process and did everything to ensure this was the wedding of our dreams. Words cannot express how stunning this venue is. The grounds are breathtakingly beautiful and perfectly maintained. We were brought to tears when we had our photo viewing, every single shot was perfect in the most beautiful venue you could ever imagine. The staff pays attention to every single detail and go above and beyond for everyone. We cannot thank Jen and the staff at The Muttontown Club enough for our PERFECT day!

. Jen, the event manager, was so accommodating and professional. The venue is immaculate and traditionally beautiful. The wedding went off without a hitch. I wish I could give it 10 stars ..

y, we booked our outdoor Indian wedding for 250 people. I wrote to Mary one day, Jennifer replied to my question. At this moment, Jennifer never introduced herself as the new manager, nor she did not express Mary was longer there or asked for us to have a meet and great. I wrote back asking her if she was on Mary's team and she did not respond, instead she proceeded to tell me how many years she's been working there. I had to call the receptionist to learn Mary a few months ago. I took it upon myself to set up a meet and greet with Jennifer and start fresh! WHERE IT WENT DOWNHILL: Initially meeting with Jennifer she was not nice at all, very snarky and didn't make you feel comfortable as a bride. She seemed bothered I was asking questions, and not a people person at all. In fact she ran more of the back of house prior. I asked about our decor, Jennifer told me it depends on what time our caterer is coming in. WHAT!?! We had no caterer, everything was being done through Muttontown. I SHOWED her my contract, it stated 3 course meal and no outside food brought in my customer. Jennifer had NO CLUE, she didn’t bother to read our contract prior. I repeated that catering was to be done by the venue and all she insisted she’d have to talk to management. We left stressed & confused, do we have to find a new venue 6 months before our wedding? I followed up several times, as you can imagine this couldn’t go on for weeks. She responded with a new proposed menu saying these were our choices for our price. I was insulted with the choice options like bread pudding for dessert and literally only one type of pasta for a station with one sauce!! Because our contract only stated 3 course meal, and we didn't decide on our choices, or did it specify all the items, they tried to be sneaky since nothing was outlined and basically say yes you can have 3 meals but your hordouves are going to be cut from 12 to 6, you are only getting two stations etc. The menu was cut down to about 2 pages from about 20 page choice I got management involved , who said apparently Mary gave us the wrong pricing – but how is that our fault!?!?!? Management agreed the choices Jennifer gave us were not for a wedding and and proposed we would either have to walk away, raise our price or lower our food options. We raised our budget to add more food items but asked for a food tasting. At the food tasting, choices were so limited. Jennifer decided to give us the same sauces for the meals, we couldn’t really have a true tasting. Her attitude towards me was so blatant, my fiancé told me it was apparent. I was trying my best to be nice, for us to salvage our wedding. What took us to the edge was the dessert, they offered us a cupcake with icing on top. I would be so embarrassed to serve the so little food and terrible options to my guests. My fiancé didn’t want me to be stressed on our wedding day , he could sense Jennifer would not be easy to work with. I'd advise anyone to walk away from this place. They act like they are doing YOU a favor by having your wedding. It was the most stressful issue we had to deal with and they were not nice or apologetic. In the end we had to change our wedding venue to avoid any stress and handing over our money to people who did not appreciate us!