My husband and I had such a hard time deciding on a venue. We visited several of them during a trip to Hawaii, and couldn’t choose because they were all so beautiful and all had their pros and cons. We ended up settling on Turtle Bay because, f...or everything we wanted, it fit well into our budget. It also offered the conveniences that come with having a hotel wedding (e.g. not having to rent a ton of equipment and not having to hire a separate caterer) while still allowing us to have the wedding we wanted (i.e. aside from the food, they didn’t have required vendors, just preferred, and we could book whomever we wanted).
We ended up choosing the pavilion at Kuilima Point for our ceremony, and the Kuilima Point lawn for our reception (under a tent). Overall, I was definitely happy with the fact that we had our wedding at Turtle Bay, but there were some things I would have liked to have known beforehand.
For example, I knew that our guests would have to make a special effort to stay or make it to the North Shore, but for whatever reason it did not occur to me just how much the travel fees for all of our vendors would be. I totally understand vendor travel fees, and why they are necessary, but man, I really wish I had factored in the travel fees to the North Shore (which were generally more expensive than to, say, Honolulu) when trying to decide on a venue because boy did they add up.
I think someone in some of the other reviews mentioned the funky way Turtle Bay does their hotel block. We ended up not doing the block because we didn’t have a guaranteed count of how many people were planning on staying at Turtle Bay, and because of that there was the potential for us to be on the hook for a lot of money if we did go with the block. I honestly felt super bad about this though, because it would have been nice to have had to offer to our guests. It would have been nice for the room block option to have been realistically more doable.
Also, we ended up having out wedding in September to accommodate some of our family’s schedules. I was prepared for the fact that it would be windy in the North Shore, but when we checked in to Turtle Bay a few days before our wedding it was pouring. Honestly, the weather was pretty terrible until the day of our wedding. I don’t know how we lucked out, but I was seriously preparing myself for the worst. I think the rainy season starts even later in the year in Hawaii, so this was probably just bad luck on our part, but I do think that it would have (possibly?) been less likely to rain if we had planned our wedding for late spring or summer. All I am saying is definitely consider the weather on different parts of the island too before making your decision (for example, we drove to Aulani on one of the days it was pouring at the North Shore, and the weather was beautiful).
But, with that said, did we have a beautiful wedding? Yes. The sunset during our reception was so beautiful that everyone started getting up and taking pictures. I was worried about the food too because we hadn’t had an opportunity to taste it beforehand (there is a complimentary tasting included with your package, but we could not fit it into our schedule), but my worries ended up being totally uncalled for. The food was SO GOOD and everyone was raving to us about it. Food is so important so we were very pleased that it turned out this way. In the end, we were extremely happy with our wedding, so overall I would recommend Turtle Bay.