Let us Cake YOU Happy on your big day!
$100 starting price
Indianapolis, Central Indiana, Carmel
Service area
Amy
OWNER
AWARD WINNER (1X)
Thanks to recommendations from couples on The Knot
Cake Me Happy is a bakery in Carmel, IN, that designs delicious wedding cakes and treats for your special day. The family-owned company is led by Amy Murnane, a talented baker and decorator with many years of experience in the industry.
Amy or a Cake Me Happy team member will meet with you face to face or speak over the phone as you discuss your wedding day dreams. They will take every single detail and instruction on board to ensure they design a cake that makes your heart skip a beat. Amy can whip up a deluxe, multi-tiered wedding cake with delicate floral patterns and delicious flavors for your guests to admire and devour.
Cake Me Happy aims to please your loved ones and offers gluten-free and customizable cake options. You can choose your own flavors and design and let Amy and her staff do the rest. Cake Me Happy is here to make you happy.
Woman-owned Business
+5 years in business
Speaks English, Espanol
Prices & packages
No pricing details yet
Reach out to get a customized quote from this vendor.
Details
Cakes & Desserts
Cake Accessories
Cake Stands
Cake Toppers
Cake Delivery & Setup
Cupcakes
Groom's Cakes
Other Desserts
Dietary Options
Dairy Free
Gluten Free
Organic
Vegan
Awards and Affiliations
Any questions?
Meet the team
Amy
Owner
Amy is an experienced baker and cake decorator with a passion for weddings. She has over 15 years experience in the service industry and 7+ years in the wedding industry. She is passionate about creating beautiful, personalized cakes that reflect the unique vision of each of her clients.
Reviews
5.0
out of 5.036 reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Review Summary
This AI-generated summary is a snapshot of this vendor's ratings and feedback.
Amy from Cake Me Happy receives rave reviews for her delicious and stunning wedding cakes. Reviewers appreciate her professionalism, flexibility, and clear communication throughout the process. Amy's attention to detail, ability to match colors to bridal dresses, and skill in incorporating florist flowers into the cake are highlighted. Customers compliment her on the taste, presentation, and timely delivery of the cakes, with many expressing eagerness to work with her again for future events. Amy's personalized service, reasonable pricing, and willingness to accommodate last-minute requests also impress the reviewers, making Cake Me Happy a highly recommended choice for wedding cakes.Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 5
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
Meghan W
5.0
11/02/2024
We absolutely loved our wedding cake!!! Not only did it taste amazing, but the presentation was spot on. Amy was always very timely, organized, and answered any questions we had. She made the process of selecting our wedding cake flavors and appearance stress free. She utilized flowers from our florist and a small clay statue of our dog to complete the look exactly how we wanted. Additionally, when setting up the cake at our reception the day of the wedding she brought and added a cake stand to help with the display. We would definitely go back to Amy & Cake Me Happy for any future cake related orders!
Kayla B
5.0
9/27/2024
Amy recently provided the cupcakes and cake for our wedding in August. It was such a great experience working with Amy. She was patient, flexible and accommodated my many requests. I especially appreciate her communication. She set clear expectations, provided tips for a seamless cake cutting, and offered suggestions for cupcake labels. Amy went above and beyond and I couldn’t be happier with the results. I highly recommend Amy and Cake me Happy if you’re looking for great customer service and delicious cupcakes for a reasonable price.
Vendor response 10/14/2024
Hi Kayla! Thank you so much for this very kind review! You were incredibly gracious and ve...
ry easy to work with and I really appreciate your review. Thank you so much :)
Any questions?
Annie T
5.0
9/15/2024
She was so professional but fun to work with! She was so informative and flexible when I had questions. Highly recommend!
Vendor response 09/17/2024
Aww Annie thank you so much for your kind words!! It was such a pleasure working with you ...
as well! Your pictures turned out amazing and thank you so much for sharing them. I really appreciate you leaving this review. thank you so much and congratulations again!! ❤️❤️
Sally R
5.0
9/05/2024
My husband and I recently celebrated our 45th anniversary along my with my cousin and her husband having their 45th. A highlight at our dinner was a surprise cake given by my daughter. It was an elegant 3 layer ganache filled chocolate cake that stood 5 inches high. Dark chocolate frosting with gold dust and gold inlaid design wrapped around the top rim—Elegant! We enjoyed the rich flavors of chocolate found in the moist cake and the smooth creamy ganache. Amy’s cake was a delightful way to end this celebratory dinner. And I now have my own personal baker for any occasion that calls for cake! Thank you, Amy, I am grateful and proud of you.
Vendor response 09/12/2024
Sally- it was such an honor to make this cake for you.. I mean it!! And your words really ...
touched my heart. Thank you for your kind and thoughtful review! I’d be happy to make another cake for you anytime. ❤️
Jennifer D
5.0
9/01/2024
Amy was so helpful from the very start of our wedding cake ideas! She helped up pick flavors and worked with us on the color and decoration for the cake. She matched the color to the bridal dresses perfectly. To top it off, the cake was absolutely delicious!
Vendor response 09/02/2024
Thank you so much, Jennifer! It was such an honor to be a part of your and Tommy’s wedding...
. Thank you for trusting me with your cake, for your kind words and for letting me be such a big part of your special day 😔
E C
5.0
8/12/2024
We couldn’t be happier with our experience with Cake Me Happy for our wedding cake. Amy was so sweet and easy to work with, and the cake was absolutely beautiful (and tasted great too!). We were especially impressed with Amy’s skill at taking the loose flowers we had on hand from our florist, and arranging them beautifully on the cake on the fly at the venue. She was kind and professional, and her prices were also very reasonable. Thanks, Amy, for a stunning and delicious cake, and for making the process so smooth and easy for us!
Vendor response 09/17/2024
Thank you so much for your review! You were an absolute joy to work with, and your family ...
and friends were SO sweet and accommodating at the venue. It was so heartwarming to see how much everyone cared and wanted to pitch in. I'm very pleased that you enjoyed the cake so much. I'd be happy to create a cake for you again anytime! :)
Sarah T
5.0
7/16/2024
Amy was great!
Vendor response 09/02/2024
Thank you, Sarah! Really enjoyed working with you and appreciate you trusting me with your...
cake!
Hannah M
5.0
7/02/2024
Personalized cake was beautifully made and tasted amazing!
Vendor response 09/17/2024
Thank you so much! So glad you were happy with it! :)
Heather P
5.0
6/26/2024
Amy is one of the best vendors for our daughters wedding. As we live out of the country we had to depend on instinct. She was so sweet, communicated timely and the end products (cake, cupcakes and cake pops) were a hit. She didn’t miss a step even when adding two dozen additional desserts last minute. Highly recommend!
Vendor response 06/30/2024
Hi Heather! Thank you so much for your review! It was such a pleasure working with you, an...
d I'm so glad you enjoyed everything. Let me know if you ever need anything else in the future! Congratulations again on your daughter's wedding :)
Traci B
5.0
6/22/2024
Fantastic cake in taste & design! Great communication & professional throughout. All guests raved about the cake!
Vendor response 06/24/2024
Thanks, Traci! It was my pleasure... and loved seeing the look on your daughter's face.. s...
o sweet. Thanks again for your business :)
Amanda A
5.0
6/21/2024
We ordered a two-tier lemon Gluten free cake with white ganache from Cake Me Happy and were very happy with the result. They created exactly what we wanted! Amy was easy to work with, provided lots of options and suggestions if asked and was very prompt with responses. Additionally we appreciated her patience as we were not quite as prompt as she is. Very professional and easy to work with. Would recommend.
Vendor response 06/30/2024
Hi Amanda! Thanks for your review.. I really appreciate the kind feedback. You were a brea...
th of fresh air to work with and I truly enjoyed working with you and creating your cake! Thanks again and please keep me in mind if you ever need another cake :)
Katherine B
5.0
6/15/2024
Excellent service, great communication, cake was delicious and beautiful!
Ordered this sweetheart cake for the cake cutting and bridal party.
Vendor response 09/17/2024
Hi Katherine! Thank you so much for your kind words. I'm so glad you were happy with your ...
cake :)
Kimberly W
5.0
6/03/2024
Amy is an ABSOLUTE GEM! Her cake for my wedding day was the star of my show! Everyone could not stop raving about how delicious it was! She created the most beautiful cake and it was EXACTLY what I envisioned! She HAND DELIVERED tastings to our door! I have not only found my baker for all of my future cakes, I found a wonderful friend as well! You will not regret working with her...she is TOP NOTCH!!! WE LOVE YOU CAKE ME HAPPY!!! Kim and Darin
Vendor response 06/04/2024
Thank you so much, Kim! It was an absolute joy and pleasure to work with you and Darin. Y...
ou were so sweet and lovely and I hope your wedding was absolutely marvelous. So glad I could be a part of it and happy to hear you and your guests were so pleased with the cake!! Thanks again and Congrats to you both!!!
Linnea S
5.0
6/03/2024
We couldn’t have been happier with our cake! It was delicious and everything we wanted!
Vendor response 06/30/2024
Thank you so much, Linnea! Loved the beautiful flower colors you chose.. your cake was so ...
fun to create and you were a breeze to work with - thanks for being so on top of things! Congratulations again on your wedding! You looked beautiful :)
Meghan V
5.0
5/30/2024
Amy is absolutely wonderful! So professional, delivery was on time, the cake looked so beautiful and tasted amazing!! I hate frosting but I loved Amy's buttercream!!
Vendor response 06/01/2024
Thank you so much, Meghan! It was a joy to work with you. I’m so glad I got to see you and...
your hubby do the cake cutting and be a part of that moment. You were such a fun, laid back client and I appreciate your kind words. Best of luck in your marriage and beyond!!
Courtney H
5.0
5/20/2024
The cake looked absolutely amazing, and it can't be said enough how delicious it was. The vendor was also very friendly and responsive. I have no complaints
Vendor response 06/30/2024
Thank you so much, Courtney! Thanks for giving us such a fun cake to create, and for being...
one of the most laid-back, easygoing clients I've ever had. I really enjoyed working with you! Congratulations again on your marriage. By the way, your dress was breathtaking!
Anna A
5.0
5/14/2024
Amy has been absolutely amazing, communication and offers have been great and the cake turned out better than we could have imagined
Vendor response 09/17/2024
Thank you so much for your thoughtful review! I'm so happy you were pleased with how it tu...
rned out. Congratulations again!
Toni L
5.0
5/09/2024
OMG I was in tears when I saw my beautiful cake at my reception. Amy the owner and baker did an amazing job on my wedding cake. I really enjoy working with Amy. She took the time to understand exactly what I wanted. She was able to make wonderful suggestions. I could not wait to see my cake at my reception for the first time. What sold me on booking Cake Me Happy was their wonderful customer service. once I spoke to Amy and selected the flavors that I wanted to try, she was able to deliver the samples to me. I didn’t have to go to her. She was able to deliver the samples. I was very impressed by that. 5 stars!!!! The cake was delicious!!!!!!
Vendor response 09/17/2024
Hi Toni! Thank you so much for this amazing, kind review!! You were SO much fun to work wi...
th, and it was one of my favorite cakes to create thus far... I had a lot of fun with it. Thanks for everything and I'm so glad you were pleased with it. I hope you are enjoying married life!
Kayla S
5.0
5/07/2024
Cake me happy went above and beyond for my wedding cake! She made the tasting experience so much fun for me, my mom and matron of honor. I wanted a really special cake to fit my greenery theme and a nod to my Irish heritage and she spent so much time perfecting the shamrocks of my dreams! It tasted delicious and everyone was talking about it! We also just love how cute and friendly she is. You won’t be disappointed hiring Cake me happy!
Vendor response 05/09/2024
Thank you so much for your kind words, Kayla! It was such a joy working with you. It was g...
reat meeting you and your mom and matron of honor at the tasting, and working with you to design your cake was special for me as well. Thanks for being so laid back and easy to work with. Best of luck in your marriage and life!
Marissa H
5.0
4/28/2024
I loved working with this cake company! She was very nice and the cake tasted so good. She also personally delivered the cake herself! Will be ordering again.
Vendor response 04/29/2024
Thanks for your kind words! So happy to hear you were pleased with the service and with yo...
ur cake! Would love to bake for you again in the future. 😊
Hada T
5.0
3/22/2024
Very helpful and kind with us since the start. The cakes were beautiful and delicious. The guests really enjoyed the cakes. Definitely buying from here again!
Vendor response 06/30/2024
Thank you, Hada! I loved making your Quincenera cakes! Thank you so much for your business...
and your kind words. Please let me know if you ever need another cake :)
Kim C
5.0
3/21/2024
I had a variety of flavored cupcakes from Cake Me Happy and every single one was delicious, moist and beautiful.
Vendor response 06/30/2024
Thank you so much for your positive feedback, Kim!!
Cindy F
5.0
3/17/2024
Delicious cake
Vendor response 03/18/2024
Thank you, Cindy!
Karen V
5.0
3/17/2024
Amy created a beautifully decorated and very delicious carrot for us. She was a joy to work with, eager and enthusiastic to make our vision come to life, as well as being timely and professional. I highly recommend Amy!!
Vendor response 09/17/2024
Thanks for your kind review, Karen! :)
Krista D
5.0
3/16/2024
So thankful to have found “Cake Me Happy” and Amy! After a co-worker was diagnosed with a rare cancer, we pitched in to try to help in anyway we could to help make her day special. I found Cake Me Happy on the Knot and she very generously offered to make a cake for our beloved coworker at no charge! Amy was lovely to work with and the cake was beautiful! I hear from some of the wedding goers that it was delicious and her raspberry filling was out of this world! Will definitely contact Cake Me Happy again💜
Vendor response 09/17/2024
I was more than happy to be a part of something so special. Thank you so much for your swe...
et review! Happy to help.
Richard D
5.0
2/24/2024
We can’t say enough about Amy, our experience with her & Cake Me Happy. With so many things to worry about while preparing for a wedding, this was never one of them. Excellent design, down to the T of what we requested and the cake was just out of this world. Talk about a premiere service for a “friends & family” price. We recommend her all day every day.
Vendor response 02/25/2024
Thank you so much! Your cake was particularly fun to design 😊 and you two were such a joy...
to work with. Thanks for trusting us with your cake on your big day!
Colleen B
5.0
2/21/2024
I had a wonderful experience with Cake Me Happy! I can’t say enough good things about them. We had continuous communication that ensured we were happy with the cake presentation and flavors. Delivery was easy too. I would highly recommend them! Thankful to have someone who is local, that we can count on for all occasions!
Vendor response 02/22/2024
Thank you so much for your kind words and your business! It was a pleasure working with yo...
u and seeing your daughter so happy with the cake 😊
Mandy H
5.0
2/17/2024
Amy made a cake for our family Thanksgiving dinner, and not only was it incredibly moist with excellent flavor, she decorated it with beautiful fall colors and desgins. Amy was very professional, listened to my wants, and was punctual with our agreed upon deadline. I can only imagine what her skills could create with a wedding cake! 10/10 - would recommend.
Vendor response 06/30/2024
Blast from the past! You have been one of my first, best and most loyal customers, Mandy a...
nd I am so grateful for your support!! thanks for helping me believe in myself and for supporting my dream! Thanks for the positive feedback and for posting this review. love ya :)
Kristine L
5.0
2/16/2024
I was privileged to try Amy’s cake at an event this past fall, and it was a lovely Carrot cake, with cream cheese frosting. I absolutely adored it and had to let her know it was the best cake I have ever had. I am not saying this lightly, if you saw my figure you’d be able to tell I’m quite a cake conessouir. But what I especially appreciated was the fact it had the perfect amount of sweetness, not too much, and it was very moist and had the best texture. It was addicting, but I somehow controlled my urge to eat the whole thing. To me, flavor is king, and if you are going to have a memorable wedding you want the cake to not only look good but taste amazing and be memorable! And Amy will deliver no doubt!!
Vendor response 09/17/2024
This is such an amazing compliment and thank you so much! I'd be happy to make you a cake ...
again anytime!! Hope you're doing well! :)
Anne W
5.0
2/11/2024
I just ordered my Valentine Sweet treats for a dinner party I was hosting from incredible business woman & friend Amy Duke Murnane of Cake Me Happy .. could not have been happier with her over the top customer service & even more over the top .. her cupcakes. Delicious!! I highly recommend Amy for all your wedding sweet treats!
Christy D
5.0
2/10/2024
I had an amazing experience with Cake Me Happy. My cake was everything I dreamt about. I wanted the outside to have a marble look and Amy was so helpful and did a wonderful job! The other places I tried wanted 3x as much money and their cakes were dry! I have booked her since for other events and from now on will only use her! Also her carrot cake is to die for!
Deborah S
5.0
2/10/2024
Amy does an amazing job! Her product is delish and beautiful! She is very responsive , listens to your wants and always delivers on time . She is delight to work with !!
Vendor response 09/17/2024
Hi Debbie! Thank you so much for your thoughtful review and for being such a loyal client!...
Kelsey K
5.0
2/10/2024
Amy was wonderful to work with. Her cakes are beautiful and taste amazing! Definitely recommend.
Vendor response 02/11/2024
Thank you so much, Kelsey! It was a pleasure working with you and I’m so glad you were ple...
ased with your experience 😊
Claire B
5.0
2/10/2024
Having Cake Me Happy create our wedding cake was a dream! I am pretty particular, and I wanted very specific decoration/details. Amy was so flexible and accommodating. She even drew up a detailed diagram for us, so we could have a clear idea of how it would look. She was punctual, professional and communicative. Each tier was a different flavor, and every flavor was fantastic. We definitely recommend Cake Me Happy!
Vendor response 02/10/2024
Hi Claire! Thank you so much for your review. I loved working alongside you and designing...
your cake - you had such great ideas! I'm so glad to hear you were happy with your experience. Congratulations again on your big day and thank you!
Allison H
5.0
2/10/2024
I’m so glad we chose Cake Me Happy for our wedding. Amy was so helpful and patient with us as we decided on design. The whole process was so smooth and professional. The cake was absolutely gorgeous and our guests LOVED the taste of the cake. She delivered and set everything up right on time. We couldn’t have been happier with our experience. Highly recommend!
Vendor response 02/10/2024
Thank you so much for your kind words, Allison! It was a pleasure working with you and I'm...
so pleased to hear how happy you were with the experience. Congratulations again on your wedding and let us know if you have any needs in the future!
Sarah Z
5.0
2/09/2024
I have a gluten allergy. If you know then you know. It’s really hard to find cakes that I can eat that actually taste good and are not dry. I give Cake me Happy a 10 out of 10. You cannot tell the difference between the regular cake and gluten free.
Vendor response 02/10/2024
Thank you, Sarah! We work hard to accommodate the needs of those who have dietary restrict...
ions. It's so great to hear you were happy with the quality and taste! Thanks again for your review!
Service area
303 Congressional Blvd, 2nd Floor, Carmel, IN
Open map
Indianapolis, Central Indiana, Carmel
Service area
Contact
Curious to learn more?
Start the convo
*=Required
Use this secure form to reach out and share your wedding vision.
Amy
OWNER
- Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
- Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
- Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
- For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.
By clicking 'Request Quote', you agree to The Knot creating an account for you, if you don't have one, and to our Terms of Use. See our Privacy Policy to learn what data we collect and how we use it.
Wedding vendors in Carmel
Cake Me Happy's photos
Why use The Knot to message vendors?
- Messaging our verified vendors on The Knot is free, safe and secure.
- Conveniently track vendor messages and planning details all in one place.
- Our mobile apps make it easy to stay in touch with vendors while you're on‑the‑go.
- For personalized pricing and package details, sending the vendor a message is the fastest way to get info.