We don‘t know Jay Feder Jewelers‘s story by heart. Message them to get to know more about their business.
Engagement Rings, Ring Services, Wedding Rings
Jay Feder Jewelers Reviews
Share your thoughts with other couples
Reviewed On 7/16/2020 by Brandon F
What an amazing experience working with Marc, Jacqueline, and the Jay Feder Jewelers team. I've been a customer of this family business for over 20 years. It's their service, value, and eye for design that keeps me coming back. The entire proce...
ss of creating a custom-designed engagement ring including the selection of a loose diamond was done online and through FaceTime conversations. There's no other place I would go for jewelry purchases. Thank you!
Reviewed On 7/25/2018 by Tomme S
Jay Feder Jewelers is the epitomy of what it means to go above and beyond for their customers.
Last February I met the girl of my dreams and after a few months I found myself thinking about something I had never before thought about, proposin...
g. With that thought came the realization that I would need to buy a ring. As a result I started researching rings and where the best place to buy a ring would be. I told my dad I was thinking about proposing and he said you need to go to Jay Feder. He told me that he was one of Jay’s first customers in the 1980’s. I was a bit skeptical at first, because they didn’t show up in my research and my now fiancé had her heart set on a specific style of ring. So in an effort to humor my dad I agreed to meet with Jay Feder Jewelers, believing that I would end up buying the ring for my fiancé at a more well known jeweler.
I walked in for my appointment and none of the ring options fit what my fiancé was hoping for in a ring. I figured that I would have to look elsewhere. Denise, the representative I was working with, asked for examples of rings my fiancé liked, so I whipped out my phone and started showing her pictures of rings my fiancé liked when she and I went looking for rings. What happened next truly surprised me. I figured Denise would see the examples and realize that they didn’t have what I was looking for. Instead she asked me what it was about each ring I showed her that my fiancé liked. After I told her what my fiancé liked about each of the rings I had pictures for, Denise suggested that they build a custom ring with each element from the different rings that my fiancé liked.
This was great news, but there was one problem. I was planning on proposing in less than a month at Yankee Stadium. It was at this point that Marc Feder called me from his personal cell phone. He asked me what my budget was and when I needed the ring by. After answering his questions, he said okay and charged me lower than my budget and said I’d have the ring in time to propose in New York. I was elated!! I thought we were good to go. Then Marc said wait a second, do you want diamonds around the prongs leading up to the center stone? Before I could answer he said of course you do and he told them to include that in the order for no additional charge.
Marc also asked me to text him pictures of me the proposing, which I did and he was genuinely excited for my fiancé and me. He regularly tells me to stay in contact with him personally. Marc Feder has not only carried on his father’s legacy, in my opinion he has furthered his father’s legacy! Working with Marc Feder is hands down the best experience I have ever had working with a business in my life by far and away, and I honestly don’t see that ever changing.
At Jay Feder Jewelers you are treated like family. They take a personal interest in you, and genuinely get excited for you! I could not recommend any business higher than I recommend Jay Feder Jewelers!! I encourage in the strongest possible way for everyone who reads my review to do business with Jay Feder Jewelers! I personally guarantee you will not be disappointed in the slightest, you will genuinely be blown away by the overwhelmingly positive experience you have working with Jay Feder Jewelers!
Reviewed On 7/23/2017 by Megan R
When shopping for an engagement ring, I shopped at over 10 other jewelry stores before I found Jay Feder. Avi was, by far, the best jeweler I met with. He knew diamonds and made the buying process fun and easy. He understood what the engagement...
process meant for me and my unsuspecting fiancé. He was willing to work with my budget and we looked at several stones that fit the criteria I was looking for. After I was engaged, my fiancé and I went back to Avi for our wedding bands. I also purchased jewelry for my Mom as I cannot envision shopping anywhere else.
The entire staff was professional and welcoming, I highly encourage shopping here for your loved ones.
Reviewed On 10/07/2016 by Jenn B
Love my ring! My husband was able to pick my diamond out of the vault and we had a great experience picking out our wedding bands. They are not pushy like most jewelers and we really appreciated our pressure free experience! Their collection is...
amazing and I highly recommend them!
Reviewed On 7/29/2015 by Lindsay W
Working with Emily at Jay Feder to custom design my engagement ring and our wedding bands was one of my favorite parts of the wedding planning process. My fiance and I never felt rushed or pressured and ended up with pieces that we adore. Emily...
was extremely knowledgable and patient and also a really fun person to spend time with! She worked very hard to translate our ideas into rings that are exactly what we wanted. When I went to go pick up our wedding bands, I was thrilled with them but also sad that we wouldn't be seeing Emily as much. I hope we have a reason to visit Jay Feder again soon.
Reviewed On 12/31/2014 by a member
They helped design a custom engagement ring, matching wedding band, and pendants that were gifts to my mother and sister. I had some family diamonds and they helped design pieces to use all the various sizes.
It was a great experience and we...
worked through CAD drawings and then wax models. Communication back and forth wasn't always seamless, but overall they are great and we will definitely go back!
Reviewed On 12/07/2013 by Christy W
I used Jay Feder for my wife's engagement ring and again for both of our wedding bands. Stephanie was very helpful and very easy to work with. She taught me about diamonds and helped me pick out the perfect rock for my style and price range. Va...
lue was very high relative to other jewelers I had looked at. They offer very fast turnarounds for resizing, cleaning, and special requests. I would recommend them to anybody.
Reviewed On 9/29/2013 by Lindsey H
The staff was so great with helping me find a wedding band. They have a nice selection of women's bands within a fairly decent price range. They could have had a little more selection for men's bands. Overall, great experience.
Reviewed On 7/21/2013 by Sadie S
We loved our experience purchasing our wedding bands from Avi. There was no pressure to buy and he then resized me engagement band(which I had purchased elsewhere) for free! We love the rings and really love the company and how responsive we ca...
n see they will be in the future.
Reviewed On 6/12/2013 by Katie K
I will never use another jeweler! They were so accommodating and helpful. They made my engagement ring, wedding ring, and earrings and all are stunning
Reviewed On 9/06/2012 by Angie H
A friend of mine recommended this jeweler, as she had used them for her wedding years ago. I went in there, and Natalie remembered my friend, details about her, and asked about how she was doing - I could tell she geniunely cared. Amazing ser...
vice. We're happy with my wedding band we ordered through the store - also, we waited too long to order it, so it wasn't going to arrive befor the wedding. They let me borrow another band for our wedding free of charge!