We don‘t know Mueller's Bakery‘s story by heart. Message them to get to know more about their business.
Mueller's Bakery Reviews
Share your thoughts with other couples
Reviewed On 6/27/2018 by Devon H
I did a cake tasting a few months back at Mueller's and we got our wedding cake from them. They also did pastries & cookies for our wedding. (We stop in every once in awhile for cupcakes, crumb cake, etc). And I also got a carrot cake from them...
for my husband's groom cake at rehearsal dinner. Everything I've ever had from them is absolutely delicious. Our guests loved the cakes too!
Reviewed On 10/19/2017 by Kendall H
Our cake was so delicious! Katie was very helpful through the planning process. We decided to have left over cake bagged up so guests could take it on their way out and they loved it so much they ate it twice in one night! It was perfect and be...
Reviewed On 7/20/2017 by Jennifer R
Our wedding cake was included in our venue package and when we found out that Mueller's was the bakery, we were thrilled! Their cakes are amazing and they definitely did not disappoint with our wedding cake. We were able to choose 4 different f...
lavors of cake, which our guests loved having the option and being able to try the different flavors. Everyone at the bakery is so helpful and quick to respond to any questions and requests you may have. We look forward to going back into the store for more treats from Mueller's!
Reviewed On 7/10/2016 by Terri E
Our wedding cake was included with our reception package. When we found out Mueller's Bakery would be providing our cake, we were so happy to hear after reading all the great reviews and learning it is a loved establishment in the area. We took...
a drive there to sample their goodie and we were very pleased. Everyone is so friendly including Katie who met with us for our cake testing which was awesome. They have so many choices and everything is delicious. They were able to capture exactly what we wanted for our cake which had a beach theme. On our wedding day, the cake was so beautiful and each layer was delicious. We received so many compliments. Although, our wedding is over, we will continue to stop by Mueller's Bakery for treats in the future. It is a wonderful establishment.
Reviewed On 10/05/2015 by Kira T
Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious. The staff at this bakery was so sweet and helpful. Thank you so much!!!
Reviewed On 7/27/2015 by Brianna S
Katie really helped us decide on a perfect cake! I showed her pictures of two different cakes that I liked and we combined ideas from each one! I had 5 tiers and a different type of cake every other layer. It tasted great and looked great!
Reviewed On 7/02/2015 by rebecca L
Mueller's Bakery created the perfect cake for our wedding. It was beach themed with seashells and our colors blue and yellow. When we came to pick out the cake we were amazed by the beautiful art that they are able to create out of cake. We ...
were able to customize everything and even brought our own cake topper. We created three different layers with different cake and filling and guests were raving about it. Thank you Mueller's!
Reviewed On 11/25/2014 by Mallory T
My venue has a relationship with Mueller's, so we made an appointment for a tasting and went to the bakery a few months before the wedding.
The tasting was incredible- the cakes were so delicious and our baker provided us many options.
showed her a few pictures on Pinterest of an idea I had for a cake and left it at that. The day of my wedding, my mouth dropped when I saw my cake. It was absolutely gorgeous!!! I am so happy with how it came out, especially because it's in so many pictures.
I didn't get a chance to taste it, but my guests said it was delicious. Can't wait for the one year anniversary to try the top tier!
Reviewed On 10/29/2014 by Noelle S
Katie, the manager & wedding cake coordinator, really understood the design we wanted for our cake. I absolutely loved our cake and it tasted amazing too! We got Mueller’s information through our reception hall and I am so glad! They really mad...
e our cake better than we could have ever imagined. We are now going to go to there for any of our bakery needs when we are down the shore. It was so awesome to not have to worry about any of the details because Katie impressed us from our first meeting. We can't wait to eat our top tier on our first anniversary!
Reviewed On 8/06/2014 by Emily H
Not only was our cake delicious, but it was gorgeous too! Our venue included a cake from Mueller's in the cost, but we had heard amazing things about the bakery prior to selecting our cake. We had a cake tasting months before. We were able to s...
elect the frosting, cake, and design while we were there. We chose one from their website, but could have brought a picture and they would have made it. All of our guests said the cake was delicious! We agree!
Reviewed On 11/12/2012 by Corey Anne I
They made our cake look and taste amazing!! Super moist, delicious flavoring, and it really did look like a sandcastle!
Reviewed On 11/09/2012 by Coreen S
Delish and great to work with!! Our venue, the Sunset Ballroom at Jack Baker’s, uses Mueller’s for the wedding cake and Viennese table. We enjoyed working with Mueller’s to ‘create’ our wedding cake vision. The tasting was delicious! They had a...
wide variety of samples of cake flavors, fillings and icings. If we wanted something that was different, they were happy to give us a taste if we wanted. My fiancé and I came with pictures and examples of what we wanted in terms of the design, and the staff worked with us to make it happen! We picked a design that may have been a little difficult, and what we appreciated is that Mueller’s checked with a few different cake decorators to make sure our vision would work. The cake was excellent, as was the pastries, cookies, etc. on our Viennese table. Nothing but rave reviews!
Reviewed On 7/08/2012 by Maura B
Everyone loved the taste and appearance of our nautical-themed cake. Worked with cake shop purely through email, even to set up cake samples to pick up and bring home. Everything was excellent!
Reviewed On 12/01/2011 by Jaclyn P
Mueller's Bakery made our wedding cake, and it was delicious! I ususally don't like wedding cake, but this one was so good! I gave them a picture of a cake that I liked, and they copied it exactly!
Reviewed On 11/22/2011 by Mollie C
I brought in a picture from a magazine of a cake that I loved and they told me it would be no problem to make that exact cake. I hadn't expected it to be that easy! They took a sample of a bridesmaid dress to match the color for the icing. T...
he cake turned out absolutely beautiful and exactly as we discussed. It was delicious too! Mueller's Bakery was a pleasure to work with.
Reviewed On 9/28/2010 by Brooke R
Awesome! I had a specific cake theme I wanted, couldn't locate it in their gallery, I located a photo and they replicated it. It was beautiful, AND delicious! Ask for Marie :)