4.9 out of 5 stars and 72 reviews
4.9
(72)Best of Weddings (2x).W341 N 6619 Timberline Road, Oconomowoc, WI
About this vendor
Your wedding is a special day and your cake should reflect that. At A Little Slice of Heaven you get, just as the name implies, a custom designed moist and beautiful cake that will leave a lasting impression on your guests.
Details
Awards and Affiliations
Reviews
Your trust is our goal. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.9
out of 5.072 reviews
Review photos
Showing slide number 1 out of 2
- Top reviews
- Newest first
- Oldest first
- Highest rated
- Lowest rated
Sort by
Lynn did a wonderful job on our cake -- it was so pretty and absolutely delicious! Would 100% order more cakes from her in the future
We had a great experience with Lynn and Little Slice of Heaven! The wedding cake and cupcakes were delicious, it may have been the best red velvet we've ever tasted! The peanut butter cupcakes were also fantastic. We can't recommend her enough!
We ordered our wedding cake from Lynn 8 years ago and every celebration we had since then has had a Little Slice of Heaven cake! Her flavors are amazing, her buttercream is top notch, her decorations always creative, her prices are totally reasonable and on top of that she is so incredibly friendly, kind and has great service! I can tell so many 5 star stories and I've literally had someone tell me she can "put her buttercream on a brick and I'll eat it!" We love Lynn and her cakes!! ❤️ Of all my wedding vendors this is the one I always reccomend first to anyone getting married in wi!
We had 3 different types of cupcakes and all 3 were delicious! Only had a few left at the end of the night and everyone loved them!!! Highly recommend!
We chose champagne cake with raspberry filling for our wedding cake and received so many compliments from our guests that it was the best wedding cake they had ever tasted. Thank you, Lynn!
Lynn is such a talented baker! Everyone loved the cupcakes she provided for our wedding. The groom and I chose the raspberry champagne cake to cut and it was so delicious. The design on the cake looked great also.
A Little Slice of Heaven was everything we could have hoped for our wedding! Affordable prices, great service & amazing taste. We chose to do cupcakes for the wedding & Lynn did a great job at setting the dessert table. Our guests loved the champagne flavor! Thank you Lynn!
On time, tasty, good communication
Lynn was great to work with! She is very responsive and her prices are very reasonable! Our wedding cake was absolutely stunning. I had multiple guests tell me they had to have more than one piece because the cake is so good! I’ve also started using this bakery for birthday cakes too because they are so delicious. Highly recommend!
A Little Slice of Heaven was an absolute delight to work with! She creates beautiful cakes and cupcakes, and they are delicious! Our wedding guests raved about them all night!
Great! 100% recommend A Little Slice of Heaven! Lynn was so understanding and kind even through our whole experience with my husband being deployed and having to move our wedding date. We also were able to add some cupcakes last minute which I appreciated the flexibility. Our cake was delicious and gorgeous!
Lynn was so great and her cakes are delicious! She was recommended to us by our florist, so we set up tastings/consultations with her and a few other bakers as well. Unfortunately for those other bakers, it was no contest. Lynn was so sweet and so personable, and she let us try so many different flavors and combinations! Every tasting we went to after that, we just couldn't help but compare them to Lynn, and none of them came close. The other nice thing is that she has very reasonable prices! We ended up going with cupcakes for our guests and a 6-inch cutting cake for us. She has different displays available for rent (also reasonably priced), she offers a big variety of flavors of cake and frosting, and she is just so sweet. We were very happy with our choice for our wedding cake baker, and we highly recommend Lynn!
Lynn came through for us when we found out from the original baker that "they don't deliver to Oconomowoc". This was 2 weeks before my daughter's wedding. I called Lynn and she was able to make the cake.
The cake was delicious and the guests raved over the raspberry champagne flavor.
Lynn is an amazing baker. She made the cupcakes and wedding cake for my wedding. The cake was incredible and the cupcakes were too. So many people loved the lemon blueberry cupcakes. They said it actually tasted like lemons instead of the synthetic taste most lemon cakes have. The raspberry champagne was light and perfect for the wedding. It was all so delicious!
Lynn was absolutely amazing, she was very easy to work with. Everything turned out perfect, I would recommend her to anyone!!
Lynn was so awesome to work with! From the moment we met with her for a sampling, we knew she was the one! She had such a great selection of flavors! All of our cupcakes were gone by 8 pm! She even gave us a 6 inch cake for the two of us! Would definitely go back to her for our future bakery needs :)
Lynn is a FANTASTIC baker. I would highly recommend her to any Bride looking for an amazing deal and a great tasting wedding cake. My husband and I did a three tiered wedding cake along with 5 half sheets with different flavors for our guests. Everyone LOVED the cake. We still have people telling us how tasty and great the cake was. It was a very fun option that Lynn suggested we do to make our wedding day more unique. She is a truly amazing!
Lynn is fantastic. Her cakes are to die for! And the design was perfect, just what we had discussed. Super affordable and delicious.
Lynn did an amazing job with our wedding cake. The cake tasting was so much fun and we were able to work with her as to what we wanted for our big day. Our guests commented on such a beautiful cake she did along with how good it was. We would recommend Lynn because we had a great experience working with her!!!
Our cupcakes were absolutely fantastic for our June wedding! We got compliment after compliment on them and many of our guests were asking where we got the delicious cupcakes from! Lynn was so great to work with. She executed some beautiful designs that matched in perfectly with our overall event decor. We cannot say enough about Lynn and her wonderful cakes and highly recommend her to anyone looking for the perfect sweet treat on their big day!
Very disappointed. Was looking forward to picking cakes and has yet to return any of my phone calls. Was very helpful in helping us pick flavors to try...
We had the BEST cupcakes. So many compliments. Beyond delicious and easy to work with!
Lynn was incredible to work with from the beginning & captured what my husband & I wanted for our wedding day cake. Not only did it look absolutely beautiful but the taste was outstanding! Would recommend her to any of my closest friends/family! Very good pricing & delivery with great communication throughout... what more could you ask for? Thank you so much, Lynn!
Amazing and delicious cupcakes/cake choice!! We ordered way more than we needed and somehow barely ended up with any cupcakes! Our guests LOVED them, as well as the groom and I. Able to choose multiple flavors, delivery and set up was included. Lynn was easy to talk with, she always responded back in a timely manner, and is just so nice!
Lindsey and Greg 9/16/17
Better than 5 stars!!! At our taste test we had raspberry champagne, red velvet and carrot cake, and we fell in love with all three of them! I only wish we could have tried all the the different kinds she has, and there are sooo many!! We ended up ordering cupcakes for our wedding in the 3 flavors that we tried, and we received COUNTLESS complements! If I ever need an order of cupcakes, I know who to look to without hesitation. Lynn has our highest recommendation.
Lynn was very easy to work with and makes INCREDIBLE cake. It literally melts in your mouth. She is able to provide tiered cakes and also sheet cakes. Her price on sheet cakes were actually cheaper than what I saw at the local grocery store. I HIGHLY recommend A Little Slice of Heaven!
Lynn was amazing!!! Throughout the night, people were telling us how much they loved all 4 cupcake flavors. Lynn brought the cupcakes, set up the display, and picked up the displays the next day so we had nothing to worry about. To top it off, her prices are unbeatable! We HIGHLY recommend A Little Slice of Heaven for any event.
Lynn made our two tiered wedding cake and sheet cakes for our wedding, and they were amazing! I am not a big cake person to begin with, but I was blown away by how delicious her cakes were! She is so easy to work with too, very laid back and dependable. We did a free cake tasting at her charming home in Oconomowoc and only needed to contact her once or twice from then on to confirm details. The cake turned out exactly as we had discussed and our guests loved the multiple flavor options we had too. I would highly recommend A Little Slice of Heaven as your wedding cake vendor! Thank you, Lynn!!
BEST CAKE EVER - Lynn made a gorgeous cake that also tasted amazing. She was also extremely easy to work with and reasonably priced. Would recommend her to anyone!
Our wedding cake was amazing! Lynn does an outstanding job. During our tasting, she showed us photos of designs she had done in the past. I did not have anything specific in mind for a design, so she really helped with that process. She made a gorgeous 4-tier cake and the 5th tier was made by our florist. She communicated with the florist to make sure their timing lined up on the day of the wedding. Our guests loved the cake! When shopping around for cakes, we thought that so many places were priced outrageously. Lynn's pricing was incredible, especially for what we got in return. Highly recommended!
Lynn was amazing to work with throughout the entire process. We truly enjoyed our tasting appointment where we got to talk to her a lot and get to know her; this really personalized the experience for us and is what sold us on booking with her versus a bakery where you get a much less than personal experience. Not only does she make outstanding cakes and cupcakes but it is clear she also prides herself on the visual presentation of her desserts. Our setup was a dream come true for us. We received so many wonderful compliments on both the visual aspect and how great they tasted. We ordered 70 cupcakes more than we needed for our guests and very few were left at the end of the night. We are so glad we chose her and we know for certain we would not have had such a great experience or result by going anywhere else. She receives an outstanding recommendation from us and we will pass her information on to our friends.
Very inexpensive and the cake was absolutely beautiful and tasted amazing!!
The cake tasted great and it was a reasonable price. She delivered it on time. When I met her at her house to cake-test/taste she seemed frazzled and didn't remember we had an appointment (however, in her defense, we did have to change around the time a couple times). Then on the wedding day, the cake did cave in one part...it wasn't a big deal, it was covered up with flowers and no one knew...I wouldn't have even know if I wasn't told about it. I think it was due to the heat...not a mistake on Lynn's part. However, I thought she was supposed to stick around to put the flowers on the cake and she didn't..so my florist did, which again is no big deal. For the taste and price I would recommend Lynn and I would choose her again.
I would highly recommend Lynn and her cakes. First of all, she helped us along in the process a lot, because I am not a cake person and had no ‘vision’ for what my wedding cake should be. She made designs that were really pretty and ended up being just what we wanted. The hardest part was picking the flavors because they all tasted so good! She also recommended a rice kripsy cake for something fun and different, and I’m glad she did because it was definitely a hit! She is very affordable, especially for the high quality of cake you receive. We got many compliments on this cake, and one of our vendors even noted how unbelievably good it was- that is saying something, as this person obviously attends a lot of weddings! Definitely go with Lynn for your cake needs, you will not regret it. PS- one of our flavors was champagne cake- it is delicious!! Be sure to try it.
Lynn was absolutely amazing! My cake turned out gorgeous and tasted delicious! I highly recommend the lemon! :). Everyone couldn't get over how incredible the cake tasted and how beautiful it was! I would highly recommend her!!!
Lynn was awesome to work with. Personal touch and service! Loved her recipes. We got the rehearsal night cake, our wedding cake and 3 dozen cupcakes for our wedding day from Lynn. All the sweets were cleared out. Our guests raved about the cake and cupcakes, even people who generally don't eat cake were going back for more. Gorgeous, tasty and over the top quality. Thank you Lynn!!
Lynn at A little Slice of Heaven is just as sweet as her baking. We got cupcakes for our wedding and we didnt have a single one left! After the fact i have several guests reach out for her information so they could use her in the future.
Great cake--displayed beautifully! And the price was right! Can't say enough! Thank you Lynn!
We met Lynn very early on in our planning and we knew from the start she was our person for all of our dessert needs.
We had roughly 110 guests, and we ordered 120 cup cakes and a 2 tier cake. Everything was so delicious (our guests words) that 15 minutes after dinner, the entirety of the cake table (save the top tier) was decimated.
My wife and I couldn't have been more thrilled that they went over so well. We instantly decided that any anniversary or party we will have Lynn's creations will be there.
I recommend hiring Lynn, owner of A Little Slice of Heaven, 200%. When we had a cake tasting with her, we were able to try 5 or 6 of her delicious cakes and ultimately ended up going with her number one best-seller, the champagne cake with raspberry filling and buttercream frosting. It is TO DIE FOR. Our guests were raving about it after the cake was served, and we are STILL getting compliments about the delicious cake three weeks after our wedding. I was able to send her a picture I found of the design I liked, and she replicated it to a T. It was PERFECT!!!
I was unable to meet Lynn in person, but she did an amazing job on our cake. Everyone was complimenting it all night. I am very thankful for the work she did and at such a reasonable price.
We had a great experience working with Lynn at A Little Slice of Heaven. And our cake turned out beautiful and, more importantly, delicious! We had the signature champagne flavored cake with a raspberry cheesecake layer, all topped with chocolate ganache. Amazing!
I don't even know where to begin, working with Lynn was the most amazing experience! We went on cake tasting after cake tasting and once we sat down with Lynn and had a bite of her cake, the deal was sealed. She is an absolute sweetheart and her cake is the perfect "Wedding Cake." Her creativity and decorating skills made our wedding that much more perfect. She had the brilliant idea of doing center piece cakes on each table along with a 2 tier cake for us to cut!!! It saved us the cost of buying center pieces, time spent decorating because she basically set every table up, no need for the venue to charge a cake cutting fee since everyone cut their own cakes at the table, and the cost was incredibly inexpensive for 16 individual 6" cakes plus the 2 tier! I could go on and on! I never cared for cake until I had Lynn's cake. The flavor was incredible! My mom and, now, husband are what I like to call "wedding cake snobs." The cake HAD to taste like "Wedding Cake" or they were not happy. NOW I know what "Wedding Cake" tastes like and they were right. It is a very important thing:) Please use Lynn's services. She will welcome you into her home as if you've been friends for years. She is an artist, to say the least, and has a way of comforting you with her calming voice while you are in the middle of wedding craziness. I remember my final call with her a few days before the wedding and one phrase she said stuck with me, "Don't worry, I've got this. Everything is fine." I needed that. Not for a minute did I stress about the cake. Thank you, Lynn, for all you did. You helped make my wedding day a fairytale I will remember for the rest of my life!
Easy to work with and best of all, GREAT value. While every other thing came in over budget, my cake came in under budget but above expectation. My cake was BEAUTIFUL (and looked exactly how I described) and delicious, and Lynn was easy to work with. Recommended!
Lynn is a cake rockstar! She is a genuinely nice person to work with and a great baker! We loved meeting with her and tasting all the delicious flavors. She was very accommodating of the decorations we wanted and made the cake look even better than I could've imagined. And it tasted great - the most important thing! We had so many compliments! (Try the lemon cake - yum!) We tried cake at many vendors but Lynn's tasted the best (by far) and had the lowest price! A combination you can't beat! I would highly recommend hiring her for your baker - you won't regret it! She is a joy to work with!
Lynn was amazing to work with. She works out of her home and was very welcoming when we discussed what kind of cake we wanted. She was very honest and the price of the cake was more than reasonable. We went with the Oreo and did 3 tiers. She was on time coming to the venue and the decorations on the cake were perfect. Everyone commented on how amazing the cake tasted and how pretty it looked!
My husband I and planned our wedding on a very compressed schedule (6 weeks), which created a whole set of problems for vendors we engaged. As a result, we struggled to find a baker for our wedding cake. We dealt with two other vendors before finding this shop, one who made us feel like we were a huge bother and another who attempted to extort a ridiculous price for delivering in time for our wedding. When our reception hosts recommended A Little Slice of Heaven, we anticipated more of the same. Instead, what we experienced was completely unexpected and wonderful. The owner, Lynn Reimer, sympathized with our situation and was extremely accommodating. She made us feel as though she appreciated our business and was more than happy to be of service. Within a couple of days, she had us at her in-home cake tasting appointment and at a time that was convenient for us. Lynn had about 12, 8" inch filled and frosted cakes in various combinations of fillings and cake flavors which really helped us appreciate more of the options in front of us. Each sample was truly amazing and so flavorful! She offers a strawberry/champagne cake/frosting combination which was unique and absolutely delicious, and we chose this for one layer of our wedding cake. She also has an almond cake with chocolate buttercream filling that is also incredible. We chose this combination for another layer. Finally, we were able to choose an entirely different combination for our top layer, which (as another reviewer noted) was provided at no charge to us. Lynn has a very large portfolio at her in-home bakery which isn't fully represented on her website. Her talents are very diverse, and she has created some amazing desserts to meet her clients' varied requests. We were so pleased with her disposition, offerings, and pricing that we ended up ordering a table full of cupcakes to serve as a late-night treat for our wedding guests. Lynn decorated them to match the flowers on our reception tables which was an exceptional touch. Our wedding cake and cupcakes were both, beautiful and delicious, beyond words, and we received so many compliments from our guests! We will be ordering from Lynn again in the future, and our recommendation of her couldn't be more emphatic. Thank you so much, Lynn, for adding to the joy and uniqueness of our wedding celebration!!
Lynn was relaxed and easy to work with. Did not try to "oversell". Delicious.
Lynn made us the greatest cake ever! She was super easy to deal with, got back to emails quickly, and took our vision to create the best cake. All of the guests at our wedding LOVED our cake and kept talking about it. Lynn's pricing was extremely reasonable and I would HIGHLY recommend her to anyone!
Lynn did a great job throughout the entire process. We had a little bit of a different cake and she did a great job pulling it all together. She was easy to reach, responsive to our questions, and had a great value. Most importantly the cake was amazing!!
We would highly reccomend A Little Slice of Heaven to anyone looking a wedding cake!!
My husband and I chose A Little Slice of Heaven to make our wedding cake for our wedding on 8/9/13. The cake was delicious, beautiful, AND affordable! It can't get much better than that. Thank you, Lynn, for being so easy to work with and making a wonderful cake! We received so many compliments!
-Emilee and Todd Nellis
The cake is just as the name suggests, a slice of heaven. I received more compliments on my cake during my wedding on 8/24/13 than I can count. Lynn Riemer is the owner and is just a joy to work with. She is very flexible and has a very creative eye for design, even though my cake was simple she made it elegant with her fresh flowers idea. I can't stay quiet about this cake and I wanted to share it with any bride looking for a fantastic tasting and looking cake for their own wedding....you can't go wrong with her!!
My husband and I got a recommendation from a recently married family member to try out this home-run bakery and we are so grateful we did! We opted for wedding cupcakes and Lynn did a wonderful job. She helped me pick out three different flavors for my cupcakes (red velvet, margarita, and white w/strawberry filling) and coordinated the frosting colors to match my purple/silver theme. The cutting cake was included in with the cupcake order, and she didn't scrimp there either--it was 2 big layers of red velvet deliciousness! I only got to taste the red velvet and the white/strawberry filling flavors, but the cupcakes were melt-in-your-mouth good, I regret not hoarding more on my plate! All my guests loved them. Great product for the price!
Lynn, the owner, runs her business out of her home. She was a little confused on the original tasting we had scheduled, but I suppose that comes with the territory of a home business. She was willing to work off of inspiration pictures we gave her and was even able to fit in doing rehearsal dinner cakes last minute. She also went with the flow when I changed our wedding cake design a week before the wedding. Lynn is reasonably priced for someone with a low budget. Also, the cake itself was moist and tasted reallllly good. My mom says it's her new favorite cake and we can't wait until our one year to have our topper!
Taste was absolutely amazing. Bought it because of that. The design not exactly what i wanted, but still taste was superb.
The cake Lynn made for the 100 guests at my wedding was perfect. It was beautiful, of course, but the best part was it was delicious. I didn't get to try the cake before the wedding (my parents had the rough job of cake tasting), but it was seriously one of the best cakes I have ever eaten. Lynn was great to work with- she even brought the cake to the reception- and was very reasonably priced! Yum.
everyone loved the cake! We did centerpiece cakes and she she set all 21 up for us on their cake stands. they were beautiful and we got so many compliments
We were able to have a wedding cake for 150 guests, red velvet in flavor with cream cheese filling and homemade buttercream frosting, for a very reasonable price. Lynn runs her business out of her beautiful home. She welcomed my fiance, stepdaughter, and I into her home. We tried a wide variety of flavors of cake. Lynn is very talented, friendly, and easy to work with. She felt almost like family. All the flavors of cake were delicious and moist. Her homemade buttercream frosting is delicious, not too sweet. She was very knowledgable about the different designs and frosting choices (colors included). Our cake turned out gorgeous. She delivered the cake to our venue and put the topper and fresh flowers on the cake. All of our guests commented on how delicious and pretty our cake was. We will most definitely use Lynn for any future cakes we may need for celebrations.
Lynn is independent and works out of her home. 1/2 the cost of other area big name bakeries and 100% better. We picked the champaign flavor. She designed our cake from a photo we gave her. It was absolutely stunning! And our guests raved about the taste and many said it was the best wedding cake they ever had!
We had two flavors - chocolate & champagne and were able to taste multiple flavors. Lynn did an excellent job and was just what we wanted. Our guest had nothing but good things to say about the taste and presentation of the cake!
Lynn really knows how to make a delicious, quality, beautiful cake. She was a delight to work with and gave us a nice sampling of different cakes to try at the tasting, and delivered the cake with plenty of time to spare. She holds her cakes to a high quality standard and uses quality and tasty ingredients (prefers to use butter cream frosting over fondant because fondant keeps a plastic taste from how it is stored). We were able to add a couple layers of filling (we chose raspberry and Bavarian cream) into the middle of each tier for only $10 per tier extra. Her cakes are high quality and very reasonably priced if you don't want to break the bank ($2.25 per slice for a 2012 wedding). We got tons of compliments from our guest on the great tasting cake, and many guests went up for a second slice later.
My husband and I received many compliments on both the deliciousness and beauty of our wedding cake. We chose to serve white cake with lemon filling and champagne cake with raspberry filling (to die for! And the raspberry filling doesn't have seeds- was a deal-breaker for me). Every time I see a picture of our cake I am blown away by the detail and perfection of the decorations. I definitely recommend Lynn.
I could not be happier with Lynn. She makes amazing cakes! Everyone I spoke with loved the cake. Cake and frosting are made from scratch and she buys the ingredients for your cake the week of the wedding.
yummmmmmy cake! and beautiful designs
Our cake was great and beautiful. We had a lot of different flavors and were very satisfied and our guests loved it too!!!
We had A Little Slice of Heaven make a small, 2-tiered cake for our wedding with about 60 slices ($100). I gave my cake baker a picture of the design I liked (printed from the Internet) and she replicated it for my wedding day. The butter cream frosting was outstanding and the red velvet cake was very moist. The main dessert we served was red velvet, cake batter ice cream cupcakes from Cold Stone Creamery (in Delafield, WI) which were a huge hit amonst the guests! They only cost $1.75 per cupcake and it was $10 for delivery.
We tried SO many cakes last year. Lynn Riemer was supposed to be the middle stop on the great Midwestern cake tour, but we went no further. For the tasting, it was me, my (then) fiance, and my MIL. As we each took a bite of the margarita cake, we locked eyes and just knew. It was true love in cake form.
We ended up getting two flavors, chocolate and the ridiculously happy-making margarita. On the wedding day, the cake was moist and delicious, and many of our guests asked for a second slice. It was just that good. We plan to buy something from her every year on our anniversary.
Our wedding cake not only tasted great but it looked perfect. It was exactly what we had asked for and it came at an extremely reasonable price compared to other bakers/bakeries in the area. I would highly recommend ordering your wedding cake from them!
Wow...what a cake. It was so delicious that everyone wanted to take some cake home. It was a yellow cake with cheescake in the center of it. As our guest said to me "It was To Die For". My daughter doesn't like cake but couldn't help with this cake.
Lynn was easy to work with and helped out with a new design and we loved it will order from her and pass her name around, because it was a HUGE hit at the Shower!!! Loved it. Barb
Lynn from A Little Slice of Heaven made us our Rice Krispie Treat Wedding Cake. It was so awesome!!! It looked just like a traditional wedding cake. There were 5 tiers and the bottom half of each tier was dipped in chocolate and had yellow pock-a-dots on it. Everyone LOVED it! Truly one of a kind.
All the guests raved (and still do!) about the delicious cake! Lynn was very helpful, and the price can't be beat!
This venue knows how to make cakes. She has the best cake during her cake tasting and during the event. It seemed so fresh and moist on our wedding day. I had many guests compliment the taste of the cake. The cake was also beautifully done, but the only thing that I can say I was disappointed about was that one of the layers had a crooked ribbon that made it look a little lopsided. I would 100% choose this same venue for my cakes and I will be buying birthday cakes from her in the future for special occassions. She does a phenomonal job - I would highly recommend the champaign cake flavor and her chocolate cheesecake filling!!! Mmmmm....
Contact
W341 N 6619 Timberline Road, Oconomowoc, WI
A Little Slice Of Heaven
A Little Slice Of Heaven's photos