14 Barn and Rustic Wedding Venues in Water Mill, NY

The Boathouse Shelter Island is an elegant wedding venue located on Shelter Island, NY. Nestled along the West Neck Harbor, this nautical-themed setting offers a blend of rustic charm and modern chic.

For a rural wedding venue with a rustic allure, look no further than The Vineyards at Aquebogue, located in Aquebogue, NY. Situated in the heart of Long Island’s picturesque wine country, this stunnin

**Now Offering 35% Off 2026 Wedding Dates** Situated in the heart of Riverhead, NY, RGNY stands as a premier winery destination on Long Island's famed North Fork. Renowned for its award-winning wine

Jamesport, NY is home to Jedediah Hawkins Inn, a historic wedding that beautifully blends timeless elegance and rustic charm. Dating back to the mid-19th century, this Empire State gem is nestled clos

The Roundtree, Amagansett is an exquisite Hamptons wedding venue in Amagansett, NY. Combining natural beauty and modern comforts, this serene property is the perfect setting to celebrate your love sto

Set on 28 lush acres on Long Island’s North Fork, East Wind Long Island is an award-winning venue offering three distinct settings, each providing exceptional service and exquisite cuisine. Offering b

Situated in East Setauket, NY, The Old Field Club is a seafront wedding venue in Long Island’s North Shore region, established by the Melville family in 1929 and hosting private members and luxury pub

Located in Old Bethpage, NY, The Barn at Old Bethpage Village Restoration is a barn and farm venue that hosts weddings and special events. This rustic farmhouse offers a stunning backdrop for nuptial

A private 35 acre manor nestled in the Hudson Valley offering outdoor ceremony & barn reception all in one venue. We are a seasonal barn that offers weddings from May 1st - the last weekend in Octobe

In 1873, John D. Hedges married the village belle, Isabelle Homan. As a gesture and proof of his love he built his bride a then large and pretentious boarding house and promptly set his newly wedded

We are Benner's Farm. A historic, authentic, real-working homestead with a lot to offer. Scenic fields, forests, and a barn set the stage for your wedding day. After that, the creative vision is yours

From a wedding in your own backyard, to a New York City ballroom, to a Long Island mansion or country club, there is no space, location, or event we can't host.