Magic Foods Catering is the same company that owns the canoe and O so if you're familiar with those, then you know the quality of their food is fantastic.
To be honest, the food wasn't a huge focus of mine. I usually don't think any wedding... food is great, so i decided not to dedicate a ton of time to this. I was also most focused on the band. However, anyone in my parents' generation considers food to be the most important part... so it's important to find a good caterer :).
We decided to do stations and Scott and Andy recommended having the food available for 2.5 hours. This way, people could eat, dance, drink, repeat. Kind of at their own pace. It's all a bit of a blur, but I know people loved the food and they're really good at what they do logistically as well. They were a little difficult to get in touch with throughout the planning process, but on the day of the wedding, they executed perfectly and I didn't have to answer a single question or tend to any details.
I remember getting a minute to have a cup of the clam chowder- UNREAL. They know what they're doing and execute like professionals.
We actually saw them the very next weekend as they catered the rehearsal dinner and goodbye brunch for our friends. It was great to see them and Andy gave us both a big hug. These are the kind of people you want to give your business to.