If you're still thinking about getting your wedding cake from the Newburgh Flour Shop, don't hesitate, just do it!! My husband and I decided to get married during covid and only gave ourselves a month to execute everything. Nicolette helped me ...through the process and she made it extremely easy, especially given the circumstances. We didn't want a huge cake, and she had options for intimate weddings which was really helpful because I didn't want to buy a huge cake and have a ton left over since we didn't have many people at the actual wedding.
Our cake was two white tiers with gold metallic hand brushed ombre sitting on a wooden base (it was very minimalist and earthy). There were supposed to be baby's breath on it, but because of covid, the shop wasn't able to outsource the flowers like they normally do, so the baker went as far as to mark the exact spots where we could put the baby's breath on the cake ourselves! It was super thoughtful of them, instead of just telling us that they couldn't put flowers on the cake, period. The prices were also SO reasonable.
Our cake flavor was carrot with a vanilla cream cheese, and it was DELICIOUS!! I don't even normally eat cake and I was digging into it all night. We also got a dozen each of the three flavors of macarons for people who didn't want to eat cake, and they were a hit!! Hands down the best macarons I have ever had. I plan to go back just for those. Also, since we couldn't have a honeymoon at this point in time, we decided to do a small spa getaway, and the next morning the Inn gave us banana bread from.. you guessed it - the Newburgh Flour Shop! It was like it was meant to be, haha! It was equally as delicious as everything else we had tried.
My family loved the cake so much, my parents came back only a week later to order my mother's 60th birthday cake. When my parents went back, they told me Nicolette mentioned that she was thinking of my husband and I the whole evening because it started raining the night of our wedding. It was so thoughtful to know that she actually cared about our day on a personal level and not just because we were purchasing something from them.
I know I've gushed about this place enough , but I have not stopped recommending them to my friends and family and now I can share it here too! Seriously, you won't be disappointed!!