My Tomato Pie

3085 Sheridan Drive, Amherst, NY

Call

About This Vendor

We don‘t know My Tomato Pie‘s story by heart. Message them to get to know more about their business.

Details

Cuisine

Italian

Dietary Options

Gluten Free, Vegetarian

Food & Catering

Servers

Pricing for My Tomato Pie

Curious to learn more?

My Tomato Pie Reviews

4.8 out of 5.0

4 reviews

5 Star

75%

4 Star

25%

3 Star

2 Star

1 Star

Reviewed On 11/07/2013 by Megan

We had our wedding catered by My Tomato Pie. I have nothing but wonderful things to say about the food, bar, and service. Tony S. and his staff went above and beyond for our wedding. The food was wonderful and I received many compliments about ...

how good our wedding food was. During the buffet, many people even went up for seconds! I can't thank Tony enough for all his help: from helping me choose a menu that would work well, choosing linens, helping set up/arrange tables and everything else that goes into an off-site catering event! He certainly went above and beyond! I highly recommend My Tomato Pie for their catering services!

Reviewed On 6/27/2013 by Jen A

We decided on a bridal shower here after having been to a baby shower and really enjoying the food. The place is wonderful for a shower if you get the back room but if you are unfortunate to get the 'front room' I don't think it would be as en...

joyable or rather not as private. Again the food is always delicious however a lot goes to waste and you're not allowed to take the left overs home. We weren't even allowed to take the cake that you brought in from a separate entity home with you. I had a grandparent in a nursing home that couldn't come and I would have loved to take her a slice of cake and we couldn't.

Reviewed On 5/27/2012 by Terri G

We had our rehearsal dinner at My Tomato Pie and it was perfect. We had a lot of out of town guests and we ordered the perfect buffet for former Buffaloians. Everyone LOVED the food!

Any questions?

Reviewed On 10/01/2011 by Jaime S

I went with The Buffalo Menu (pizza, wings, beef on weck, ziti, salad) and it was so delicious. The food was fantastic, the staff couldn't have been nicer, the room was beautiful, and they were great at helping me keep the shower organized and ...

moving along.

Contact Info for My Tomato Pie

3085 Sheridan Drive, Amherst, NY

(716) 838-0969

Message Vendor

Contact for Pricing

By clicking 'Request Quote', you agree that your information will be shared with the vendor and used to create an account on TheKnot.com. Please see our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for details.