I purchased the Seleste dress in Consuelo online in September 2016 for my January 14, 2017 wedding. The quality of the dress was beautiful, and for $488 was a way better deal than anything else I could have found in that price range. I am 5'9...", 130lbs, 34A bust, and a size 2 fit perfectly.
With the dress, I wore 4" heels and I added a bridal sash. Under the dress I wore a backless bra and cotton contour control shorts. The dress length was perfect, no hemming or alternations required. The dress would have been fine with lower heels too if you didn't mind a bit of a train. The dress was heavy enough that it would have been fine without the bra or control shorts, but I figured since it was my wedding day I might as well shape my curves to look their best. My only complaint was that the sleeves slipped a little bit, but considering I had the dress on for 12 hours it was not so annoying as to be distracting.
Payment was easy and shipping was fast. I did not use the return policy, but part of why I purchased the dress was because of how easy Reformation would have made the return for me (free shipping, 14-day policy, no restocking fee). This was my first Reformation purchase, and I will definitely be a returning customer!