Spice things up with these steamy flicks.
Updated Oct 14, 202412 Plus-Size Engagement Rings to Fall in Love With
Plus, five retailers to explore for more.
Photos, from left to right: Rêve Diamonds, Mabel & Main
Just like with every other element of plus-size bridal fashion, there are certain considerations to take into account when shopping for plus-size engagement rings. Chief among them: pricing and durability. Unfortunately, there is often an upcharge for rings above average size due to the cost of added materials. But, that's a good thing as opposed to the alternative: stretching a ring through a resizing process that sacrifices its durability.
One brand that's working to offset all this is Mabel & Main, one of the only jewelers devoted exclusively to larger sizing. "At Mabel & Main, we design our rings in size 11 for women and size 14 for men," says founder and CEO Vipul Lakhi. "We ensure the ring looks perfect on a larger finger. We can quickly craft any ring up to size 18 for women and size 20 for men." We tapped Lakhi to offer insight into what to look for in a plus-size engagement ring (spoiler: you can still have any design you want!) and dug up some top retailers and a dozen trending styles available in plus-size.
FEATURED VIDEO FROM THE KNOT
In this article:
- What is Considered a Plus-Size Engagement Ring?
- Where to Buy Plus-Size Engagement Rings
- Shop Our Favorite Plus Size Engagement Rings
What is Considered a Plus-Size Engagement Ring?
According to Lakhi, ring sizes above 9 for women and above 13 for men are considered plus size. "Finding rings in these sizes can be quite challenging," he says. "Most jewelers attempt to stretch a stock ring to a larger size, which often weakens the ring's integrity and distorts it into an oval shape." Make sure the ring you are looking at is already offered in your size or can be custom-created (rather than resized or stretched)—though note that custom creation can be costlier and take more time. Costs vary; some jewelers charge the same across the board, but many charge an additional fee for plus-size rings due to the extra cost of materials.
Where to Buy Plus-Size Engagement Rings
We can admit that it is not easy to find ready-to-order women's plus-size engagement rings (though many jewelers can custom-create them). In recent years, plus-size brides have seen improvement in offerings of wedding dresses and ancillary event attire, with more and more designers adding plus collections—yet rings can still be tough to come by. Here are our top five retailers for plus-size diamond engagement rings and more info on associated fees.
Mabel & Main
When Lakhi founded Mabel & Main in 2021, the sole mission was to service plus-size brides—and, to this day, it's the only jewelry brand devoted exclusively to larger sizing. That means there are no extra materials fees, deposits or custom costs (and since the jeweler is direct-to-consumer, no retail markup). "Keeping our rings affordable is crucial to us," Lakhi says. "We have no extra markups or custom fees for plus-size jewelry; the price is the same for sizes 8 and 18." Rings are designed in size 11 for women (most jewelers design in size 7); they can be custom-made on a short timeline up to size 18. "To ensure durability, we reinforce larger rings with extra gold," Lakhi adds. "All our rings feature a sizing bar at the bottom, allowing easy resizing up or down by about a size. If the ring doesn't fit perfectly, we offer free resizing within 60 days and will even recraft the ring at no charge for adjustments."
My Trio Rings
Mabel & Main first launched as a plus-size collection within its sister brand, My Trio Rings, before spinning out on its own—but My Trio is still a great source for plus-size products, especially if you're looking for a plus-size wedding band to match. "My Trio Rings is the world's largest jewelry store for matching rings," Lakhi explains. "At My Trio Rings, we've worked with thousands of plus-size brides and grooms to craft rings that fit perfectly and look beautiful without costing a fortune." You'll find exclusive, direct-to-customer engagement and wedding band designs available at both retailers; though if you're looking for additional plus-minded jewelry such as bracelets and necklaces, Mabel & Main is full-service.
HauteCarat
Chicago-based HauteCarat is a leader in the ever-expanding lab-grown diamond industry. The brand stands out for a number of reasons: Its online customization options are easy to use and allow customers to get exactly what they're looking for, its concierge-level service raises the bar, and its 100-day return guarantee means you can make sure your partner is just as in love with the piece as you are. But most importantly, rings are offered up to size 14 at no additional cost. "We provide the courtesy of not charging extra for sizing up to 14 for not only engagement rings but all our rings, including eternity bands," says director of client relations Kristi Kroll. "We truly believe this is a part of top-notch customer service and making our customers feel appreciated and valued."
Diamondère
Though Diamondère was founded in 2012, it is owned by two brothers whose family has been in the industry since 1890, making them seventh-generation jewelers. So, it's safe to say they know a thing or two about engagement ring design. Though the retailer's pricing does change slightly based on sizing, it offers engagement rings up to 12 without special order (larger sizes can be custom-made); most jewelers offer only up to size 9 ready to buy. One other unique bonus: The brand specializes in engagement rings not just with diamonds but with almost any gemstone you can dream up.
Etsy
A search for "plus-size engagement ring" turns up more than 1,000 results on Etsy, where there's truly something for everyone. The platform is especially ideal for those looking for moissanite (rather than diamond), which can look nearly identical to the naked eye and be much easier on the engagement ring budget. A few shops to check out? Diamond Carnival is an Indian brand that offers rings up to size 13 and 14+ at the same cost as smaller ones; star seller Cool Ring Jewelry out of California allows users to type in their own size; and Vintage Diamond US offers all rings up to size 13.
Shop Our Favorite Plus Size Engagement Rings
The good news? As long as rings are sized properly, there are no design limitations when it comes to plus-size engagement rings. "It's a common misconception when considering plus-size engagement rings that the bigger the ring size, the bigger the stone should be," Lakhi says. "At Mabel & Main, we offer both solitaire gemstones and cluster settings. Having one large diamond can get expensive, so to help keep the price low, we can set multiple small diamonds to create a cluster setting." The ring band width can be thin or thick, and the stone can be raised or bezel set, natural or lab-grown—it's all up to personal style. Here are a dozen on-trend and classic plus-size engagement rings we love.
Mabel & Main Enjoy Curves Bridal Set
Photo: Mabel & Main
Mabel & Main's Enjoy Curves collection—which includes a plus-size engagement ring and bands in varying gold colors and carat sizes—was designed in collaboration with body-positive influencer Joy Moreland. The engagement ring features five emerald-cut lab-grown diamonds. "Versatility was important to Joy, so we created a bridal ring set with an engagement ring that could also be worn as a fashion ring on any finger," Lakhi says.
HauteCarat Toi Et Moi Pink and White Diamond Ring
Photo: HauteCarat
HauteCarat puts a pretty twist on the trending toi et moi style with this ring, featuring a pear-shaped pink diamond and a radiant-cut white one, both lab-grown. Each diamond is at least one carat, but the ring can be customized to feature any size stones, up to 6 carats each, for a whole lot of bling.
Rêve Diamonds Angelina Jolie Diamond Engagement Ring
Photo: Rêve Diamonds
Inspired by the $250,000 engagement ring Brad Pitt gave Angelina Jolie, this stunning piece is handmade in New York City to fit the exact dimensions of your chosen diamonds. The design features a center emerald-cut stone and reverse-tapered baguettes on either side; customers can choose the center stone's carat weight from 0.3 up to 10. As for sizing, the ring is available for order up to size 10.75, but since each ring is custom-made, the jeweler can accommodate larger ring sizes. Book an appointment to discuss options and pricing.
Mabel & Main Shot Diva Collection Carter Engagement Ring
Photo: Mabel & Main
Another cool collab from Mabel & Main, this piece was inspired by Olympic gold medal shot putter Michelle Carter. "The ring features a 1-carat radiant lab-grown diamond set on a dainty band," Lakhi explains. "It's the perfect ring for someone with a larger finger who wants a unique yet elegant look."
Etsy Hidden Halo Solitaire Moissanite Engagement Ring
Photo: Pandrid Design
It's a common misconception that wider band widths are necessary on engagement rings for plus-size fingers. "It completely depends on the choice of the buyer," Lakhi says. "Just because someone has a larger finger doesn't mean they can't have a dainty engagement ring." This Etsy pick has a band width of 1.3mm and is available in up to size 12—plus, the price is right, with a solitaire stone and hidden halo rendered in moissanite rather than diamond.
Wove Cypress Ring
Photo: Wove
Online jeweler Wove offers both pre-designed and completely bespoke engagement rings; its ready-to-shop collection is available in sizes up to women's 13. We especially love the unique Cypress, which features dual trapezoid-shaped diamonds on either side of the center emerald-cut stone. Thanks to its custom engagement ring process, the brand can make rings in sizes larger than 13 as well and works on a quicker timeline than many other custom jewelers.
Mabel & Main Floryn Engagement Ring
Photo: Mabel & Main
"This three-stone diamond ring represents the past, present and future of the couple's journey together," Lakhi says. It's a great pick for practicality, too. "Plus-size rings can be in any setting type, but a prong or claw setting is the most common, safe and popular for everyone who wants to buy jewelry." As with all the brand's rings, it is available up to size 18 for no additional charge.
HauteCarat Heart-Cut Hidden Halo Diamond Ring
Photo: HauteCarat
What could possibly declare your love more than a heart-shaped diamond? This one boasts a sweet center stone—in your choice of carat size from 1 to 6—and a hidden halo of accent stones beneath. We love it in white gold to let the diamond really shine.
Diamondère Eugene Ring
Photo: Diamondère
For something unique and vintage-inspired, Diamondère's Eugene ring has a cool curved band and plenty of bling. The sides of the band wrap around the center stone to further showcase it, but in this case, it barely needs it: The black diamond is attention-grabbing all on its own. Diamondère is known for its selection of colored precious, semi-precious and lab-created gemstones, and any can be swapped in here; the piece is also available with a classic diamond.
Michellia Alessandra Art Deco Oval-Cut Engagement Ring
Photo: Michellia
This art-deco-inspired engagement ring is fit for a queen and features marquise and round diamond accents surrounding the oval center stone in a starburst pattern. Sizing above 9 comes at an additional charge—extended sizing costs range from $50-$280—but is readily available for order. And, there are other places to save on this stunning piece: It's available with moissanite, lab diamonds or natural diamonds.
Wove Cove Ring
Photo: Wove
If lots of bling is the goal, opt for a halo setting, in which a circle of smaller surrounding diamonds makes the center stone appear larger. (Here, diamonds also trail halfway down the band, adding even more sparkle.) As with most pieces at Wove, this is readily available in up to 13 and larger for custom orders.
Moissanite Co. Wide Band Moissanite Solitaire Setting
Photo: Moissanite Co.
Wider cigar bands are trending for engagement rings, and this style gives the look a fun twist, quite literally. Its solitaire stone—available as moissanite or a lab-grown diamond—can be custom-selected from less than 1 carat to more than 5, and shoppers type in their exact ring size before placing the order.
