How to Shop for an Etsy Engagement Ring

We've got tips for navigating the online marketplace, plus 21 styles worth shopping right now.
Elle Cashin headshot
by
Elle Cashin
Elle Cashin headshot
Elle Cashin
The Knot Fashion Contributor
  • Elle writes for The Knot online with a focus on fashion, covering gown design trends and shoppable accessories.
  • Elle is a contributor to wedding publications across the country, including Brides, The New York Times Vows and Modern Luxury Weddings.
  • Prior to shifting to weddings, Elle covered lifestyle, culture and celebrity across Chicago as the editor of the Chicago Tribune’s SPLASH magazine, where she interviewed cele...
Updated Jan 24, 2024
We have included third party products to help you navigate and enjoy life’s biggest moments. Purchases made through links on this page may earn us a commission.

"Now more than ever, couples are using their wedding rings to express their individuality," says Etsy trend expert Dayna Isom Johnson—and searches for Etsy engagement rings have been on the rise. "In fact, in the last six months alone, we've seen a 76% increase in searches on Etsy for custom or personalized engagement rings." The maker's marketplace has become a beloved resource for everything from artwork to clothing, but is Etsy a good place to get an engagement ring? Having done the legwork, we say: undoubtedly. "Shoppers know they can rely on Etsy for beautiful and unique pieces, whether that's through custom-made rings, rare vintage finds, or unique designs," Isom Johnson says. "Etsy is the perfect place for shoppers to find engagement rings that best illustrate their partner's aesthetic. From the style of gemstones to engravings and one-of-a-kind designs, buyers can work directly with a seller to bring their vision to life."

The only problem? There are a lot of options to sift through. Isom Johnson suggests a starting point: Etsy's Engagement Ring Editor's Picks page. It highlights top pieces from standout sellers in a variety of categories and can help you narrow down your search. Also, consider what's trending: in the past six months, the site has seen major upticks in searches for teal sapphire engagement rings, moissanite engagement ring sets, heart engagement rings, and thick-banded engagement rings. Here, we showcase 21 stunning engagement rings to jumpstart your search. And, keep scrolling to read Isom Johnson's top tips for finding the perfect piece on Etsy.

In this article:

The Best Etsy Engagement Rings to Shop Right Now

No matter what type of engagement ring you have in mind for your partner, chances are you can find it on Etsy. The marketplace is especially a go-to for moissanite engagement rings that mimic natural diamonds in traditional settings (at a fraction of the cost) and vintage-inspired or antique pieces. Here, we highlight some of our favorite finds.

Modern Toi et Moi Engagement Ring

Modern Toi et Moi Engagement Ring
Photo: BrocktonGems

Star seller Brockton Gems' toi et moi ring took home top prize in the Wedding Style category for the 2023 Etsy Design Awards; it's one of Isom Johnson's top picks for engagement rings on Etsy. The piece can be rendered in 14-karat white, yellow, or rose gold and features a pear-shaped diamond and step-cut sapphire in your choice of hue, from pretty light green to vibrant purple. Pro tip: This style is ultra on-trend. In the last six months, Etsy saw a nearly 350% rise in searches for toi et moi engagement rings.

Vintage-Inspired Alexandrite Engagement Ring

Vintage-Inspired Alexandrite Engagement Ring
Photo: SundayIslandJewelry

The gemstone alexandrite is unique for its color-changing properties; it appears different—sometimes green, red, or purple—in varying types of light. It's a symbolic choice for brides with big, all-encompassing personalities. This alexandrite engagement ring on Etsy has a vintage inspiration and is enhanced by accent diamonds on either side.

Pink Morganite Rose Gold Engagement Ring

Pink Morganite Rose Gold Engagement Ring
Photo: DiamondsMine

This morganite engagement ring from Etsy is pretty in pink with a sophisticated twist. The 2-carat pink morganite center stone and rose gold metal are ultra-feminine touches, while the split twisted band has a modern edge.

Bezel Set Oval Engagement Ring

Bezel Set Oval Engagement Ring
Photo: CaratsClub

Simple doesn't have to mean boring. Among the more unique engagement rings on Etsy is this 3-carat oval; its yellow gold surround sets it apart. Pro tip: A diamond is better protected in a bezel setting, so this type of engagement ring is practical for those who work with their hands or remove their rings often.

Aquamarine Engagement Ring

Aquamarine Engagement Ring from JewelryMansion on Etsy
Photo: JewelryMansion

They say diamonds are forever, but colored gemstone engagement rings are prevalent on Etsy and make unique statements. This one—selected as an "Etsy's Pick" for quality—features an emerald-cut aquamarine solitaire in a raised prong setting. Smaller moissanite stones line the band and encircle a hidden halo below the center setting.

Black Tungsten Engagement Band

Black Tungsten Engagement Band
Photo: MorfJewelryNewYork

Men's engagement rings are also on Etsy, both more traditional bands and blingier engagement styles. For the former, we love this black tungsten style with a rose gold accent strip. The piece is handmade and typically ships within a day—perfect for a romantic, spur-of-the-moment proposal.

Oval Mosaic Engagement Ring

Oval Mosaic Engagement Ring
Photo: EvaraByVPG

If a traditional solitaire isn't for you, consider a mosaic-style engagement ring. This Etsy engagement ring features a multitude of lab-grown diamonds surrounding a larger center stone in a mosaic pattern, creating a pretty art deco oval. It's available in white, yellow and rose gold; opt for the latter to lean into the vintage vibe.

Emerald Engagement Ring

Emerald engagement ring from BravermanOren on Etsy
Photo: BravermanOren

Emerald engagement rings on Etsy are a unique choice, ideal for brides looking for something out-of-the-box. This one is chic and sophisticated with a pretty emerald-cut stone in any weight the buyer prefers, from a half carat all the way up to four carats. It's the best of both worlds: While emeralds are a softer stone that's more prone to damage than diamonds, the encircling bezel is a protective setting that will keep it safe.

Marquise-Cut Cluster Engagement Ring

Marquise-Cut Cluster Engagement Ring
Photo: honngaijewelry

Hong Kong-based jeweler HN Jewelry is behind one of our favorite engagement rings from Etsy, this split-shank cluster design. The center marquise-cut diamond (0.3 carats) is surrounded by six round and six smaller marquise-cut stones forming two rows in a unique—and blingy—formation. The jeweler also offers custom services, and there's no extra charge for personalized laser engraving.

Moissanite Engagement Ring With Cluster Accent

Moissanite Engagement Ring With Cluster Accent
Photo: Lavense

Moissanite engagement rings on Etsy are a dime a dozen; the online community marketplace is one of our favorite spots to shop the lab-created stone. This piece is a great example: It looks and feels like a traditional diamond ring but costs a fraction of the price. Customers have lots of options to make it fit their budget: A 2-carat moissanite stone set in 18-karat yellow gold is $580; the price can go up or down from there.

Art Deco Engagement Ring

Art Deco Engagement Ring from ElixirJewelryStore on Etsy
Photo: ElixirJewelryStore

Art deco engagement rings on Etsy run the gamut, but this one takes the cake for being quite literally one of the biggest bangs for your buck. The central emerald-cut stone is surrounded by round and baguette stones in an art deco-inspired starburst that takes up a lot of vertical space between the knuckles. We love the piece in classic yellow gold.

Black Diamond Engagement Ring

Black Diamond Engagement Ring
Photo: TilyaJewelry

For the bold bride looking for something different, black diamond engagement rings on Etsy stand out as a top choice. This one has a cool hexagonal cut and gets a gold star for sustainability: It's made with recycled metal and vintage gemstones.

Vintage Filigree Moissanite Engagement Ring

Vintage Filigree Moissanite Engagement Ring
Photo: BravermanOren

In this vintage engagement ring, the metal tells the story: The wide square-shaped band is hand-engraved with an antique filigree pattern—a basket-set round moissanite stone is simply the cherry on top. (By the way, if it's antique engagement rings on Etsy you're shopping for, star seller Braverman Jewelry for tons of vintage and antique-inspired pieces.)

Lab-Grown Oval Diamond Engagement Ring

Lab-Grown Oval Diamond Engagement Ring
Photo: GlamAndGemsNY

Etsy is known for its selection of vintage, heirloom, and unique custom rings, but don't rule it out for modern (and big!) bling. This lab-grown solitaire rings in at a stellar 3.75 carats (with additional wattage on the pavé band) and aligns closely with the type of styles one might shop at more traditional jewelers.

Moonstone Engagement Ring

Moonstone Engagement Ring
Photo: Aquamarise

Moonstone is rife with symbolism and considered a uniquely feminine gem; it represents happiness, new beginnings, hope, and good fortune. Need we say more? One cool moonstone engagement ring on Etsy isn't just a ring but a set; the center moonstone is surrounded by miniature diamond accents and set in a nature-inspired rose gold band. An accompanying wedding band mimics the leaf pattern. (Note that the band is gold-plated sterling silver—hence the affordable price tag—so expect some fading over time.)

Men's Diamond Engagement Ring

Men's Diamond Engagement Ring
Photo: CustomEngravingUS

Who says diamonds are just for the ladies? We love a diamond-accented band as a men's engagement ring, like this one from a New Jersey Jeweler. Personalize the piece with custom engraving for the perfect proposal.

Moissanite Engagement Ring With a Hidden Halo

Moissanite Engagement Ring With a Hidden Halo
Photo: CupOfTea925

The most unique element of this Etsy engagement ring is hidden at first glance: a halo of pavé stones rests below the center oval moissanite. It's a pretty secret to be kept between you and your partner—and the price is right. This moissanite and rhodium ring also comes with a coordinating pavé band for a pretty bridal set.

Antique-Inspired Milgrain Moissanite Engagement Ring

Antique-Inspired Milgrain Moissanite Engagement Ring
Photo: OliviaMooreJewelry

The Edwardian era is having a moment in fashion—and by the looks of this antique-inspired Etsy moissanite engagement ring, we're here for it. The circle setting enhances the round center stone, and the milgrain design gives off vintage vibes. Bonus: This low-profile setting is a practical choice for everyday wear.

Opal Starburst Engagement Ring

Opal Starburst Engagement Ring
Photo: SundayIslandJewelry

Opal is most commonly found in necklaces, cocktail rings, and other occasion jewelry, but there are a handful of opal engagement rings on Etsy. This one features a natural Australian opal surrounded by a starburst of diamonds in a vintage array. Engagement rings like this can be tough to pair with bands; luckily, Swedish jeweler Sunday Island makes and recommends perfectly coordinating styles.

Moissanite Bridal Ring Set

Moissanite Bridal Ring Set
Photo: BravermanOren

Vintage inspiration gets a modern twist in this moissanite bridal set. A prong-set oval is surrounded by round and pear-shaped stones; the matching band features pear-shaped diamonds ascending in size to a point that tops the engagement ring's oval like a glimmering crown. (But, if you have a different band in mind, these pieces can also be sold individually.)

Cornflower Blue Sapphire Engagement Ring

Cornflower Blue Sapphire Engagement Ring
Photo: TilyaJewelry

Sapphire engagement rings on Etsy run the gamut in color, from deep royal blue to pretty blush pink. This light cornflower hue, however, is the perfect bridal blue; fourteen small round diamonds dot the rose gold band.

Tips for Buying an Etsy Engagement Ring

Though Etsy works hard to vet its sellers and keep everything above board, it still pays to do your due diligence—just as you would if shopping for an engagement ring at a more traditional jeweler. Here, Etsy trend expert Dayna Isom Johnson offers some tips to ensure you find "the one."

Do your research and ask questions.

"Start by exploring the styles and designs available on Etsy to refine your preferences," Isom Johnson suggests. "Don't hesitate to message sellers directly and ask questions about customization, materials, and sizes to find a ring your partner will love. [The seller] can answer any questions you may have about gemstones, sourcing, or the creation process."

Look for the "Star Seller" badge.

These shops are known for their glowing reviews, reliable shipping, and prompt response time.

Read reviews.

"Check out the seller's reviews and sale history to get a sense of the quality of craftsmanship and customer satisfaction before making your decision. Your engagement ring purchase should be one that you feel confident about."

Make it unique.

Finally, Isom Johnson recommends making use of the unique creativity Etsy sellers embody. "Take advantage of the opportunity to personalize rings to reflect your story, whether it's through engraved messages, specific gemstones, or bespoke designs," she says. "This ensures your ring is not just beautiful but deeply meaningful and one-of-a-kind."

Up Next
  • Gothic couple
    22 Gorgeous Gothic Engagement Rings