13 "Will You Marry Me?" Puzzles for Your Puzzle-Loving Partner

Pop the question with one of these fun proposal puzzles.

Photos: Zazzle

Updated Dec 19, 2023

Puzzles are a tech-free pastime that require full presence and brain power. Essentially, they're the perfect bonding activity–which is why proposal "Will you marry me?" puzzles are a unique and personal way to start your love story's future.

Whether you regularly do puzzles with your partner or not, puzzles are a creative way to pop the question. Get creative and ask for your partner's hand in marriage with a "Will you marry me?" puzzle instead.

Marriage proposal puzzles will add an extra element of surprise (and challenge) to the big question–especially if your partner loves to do puzzles on the reg. If you've been mulling over how to propose to your partner, buying a "Will you marry me?" puzzle is a memorable way to do it. To help you find the perfect one for your proposal, we did the research.

In this story:

Where To Buy "Will You Marry Me?" Puzzles
13 "Will You Marry Me?" Puzzles To Shop Now

Where To Buy "Will You Marry Me?" Puzzles

Shopping online makes it easy to search for "Will you marry me?" proposal puzzles. However, some retailers have more options than others. Here are five of the best places to buy proposal puzzles.

Zazzle

Creativity is the focus of Zazzle's puzzles. With endless personalization options and your own artistic freedom, you can also find affordable prices. Proposal puzzles range from $12-$45.

Zazzle

Etsy

Unique proposal puzzles are bountiful on Etsy. Frequently made by small businesses and independent artists, you can personalize your puzzle perfectly while supporting the 'little' guy.

Etsy

Amazon

Amazon makes shopping easy, and the same goes for purchasing a proposal puzzle through them. While their selection is on the smaller side, their pricing is upfront and shipping is easy.

Amazon

Shutterfly

Highlight your photos as a couple using Shutterfly. Known for its incredible photo printing, you can personalize a high-quality proposal puzzle featuring your favorite photos with your partner.

Shutterfly

Redbubble

Redbubble features the work of more than 700,000 independent artists worldwide. Looking for something super-specific for your proposal? The site has endless designers to create your perfect puzzle.

Redbubble

13 "Will You Marry Me?" Puzzles To Shop Now

Shopping for the perfect proposal puzzle? From personalized options to pre-made proposal puzzles, here are a few of our favorite "Will you marry me?" puzzles to shop for right now.

Personalized Photo Puzzle

Personalized Photo 'will you marry me?' Puzzle

Why not propose to your partner with a puzzle featuring your favorite photo together? Once you choose your photo, you must pick your text size, placement, font, and color.

$16 | Zazzle

One-Piece Heart Proposal Puzzle

Engrave your sweetheart's name on this handmade one-piece heart-shaped puzzle. Once it's opened, your personalized proposal is revealed. Bonus: you can hang the puzzle on the wall for a memorable decoration.

$29 | Amazon

Heart Collage Portraits Proposal Puzzle

Gather all of your favorite pictures with your partner for this collage of photos that come together in a heart.

$27 | Shutterfly

Neon Sign Proposal

Funky and modern, neon signs make a statement. Personalize your proposal on this 1,014-piece jigsaw puzzle that will make your partner swoon.

From $45 | Etsy

Mountain Scape Puzzle With Hidden Proposal

This proposal puzzle features a majestic mountain scape with one important detail: it has a sign post that asks the proposal. It's perfect for nature lovers.

$60 | Zazzle

Spanish Proposal Puzzle

Propose in Spanish with this "Quieres casarte conmigo?" proposal puzzle. Whether it's the language you speak together, your partner grew up speaking, or you're learning it together, it's a sweet touch to any proposal.

$15 | Amazon

Starry Night Proposal Puzzle

Pop the question with this gorgeous 'under the stars' puzzle design that features a man down on one knee in front of his female partner, holding a box with a red heart in front of her. With the moon as a backlight, it's a sweet evening love scene.

$18 | Zazzle

Wood-Tile Proposal Puzzle

The Scrabble-esque wooden pieces of this jigsaw puzzle will put your partner to the test. With "Will you marry me?" in white letters, there are filler black letters that will try to throw your partner off as they piece it together.

$31 | Redbubble

Neutral Boho Heart Proposal Puzzle

This boho-inspired puzzle comes in a heart shape that you can personalize with your photo and proposal message. The neutral colors and boho border create a serene setting for your big moment.

$40 | Shutterfly

Red and Black "Will You Marry Me?" Puzzle

Red is the color of romance. This red and black "Will you marry me?" puzzle will make a love-filled statement. With an additional backstand, you can proudly put it on display afterward.

$12 | Amazon

Anime-Inspired Proposal Puzzle

The Japanese word for "cute" is kawaii, and this anime-inspired puzzle is just that. This kawaii proposal puzzle features a sweet illustration with two adorable anime-inspired characters.

$30 | Zazzle

Chocolate Proposal Puzzle

This sweet proposal puts chocolate front and center. With the phrase, "I love you more than chocolate" right above the proposal, chocoholics will fall in love with this unique proposal puzzle.

$18 | Etsy