The Knot hamburger avatar
Main Menu
  • Gifts & Favors
Find a CoupleCustomer Service
Planning Tools
Checklist
Budgeter
Wedding Vision
Guest List & RSVPs
Discover Your Vision
Take The Knot's Style Quiz
Take The Knot's Style Quiz
Vendors
Reception Venues
Wedding Photographers
Catering
Bridal Salons
Wedding Planners
Wedding Cakes
Rehearsal Dinners, Bridal Showers & Parties
DJs
Videographers
Wedding Rentals
Beauty Services
Florists
Wedding Bands
Officiants & Pre-marital Counseling
Photo Booths
Bar Services
Transportation
Jewelers
Soloists & Ensembles
Dance Lessons
Decor
Invitations
Favors & Gifts
Travel Specialists
Hotel Room Blocks
See All Categories
Are you a vendor? Start here
Build Your Vendor Team
  • Reception Venues
    Reception Venues
  • Wedding Photographers
    Wedding Photographers
Wedding Website
Explore Wedding Websites
  • Start a Wedding Website
  • Browse Website Designs
Find a Couple's Website
Check Out Top Designs
  • Modern Minimalist by Vera Wang
    Modern Minimalist by Vera Wang
  • Beloved Floral - Red
    Beloved Floral - Red
  • Romantic Calligraphy
    Romantic Calligraphy
  • Elegant Glow - Blue
    Elegant Glow - Blue
Invitations & Paper
Save the Dates
Change the Dates
Invitations
  • All Invitations
  • Wedding Invitations
  • RSVP Cards
  • Enclosure Cards
  • Envelope Liners
  • Bridal Shower Invitations
  • Rehearsal Dinner Invitations
Ceremony & Reception
  • All Ceremony & Reception
  • Programs
  • Place Cards
  • Menus
  • Table Numbers
  • Stickers
  • Gift Tags
  • Guest Books
Thank Yous
Shop by Style
  • All Styles
  • Floral
  • Classic
  • Rustic
  • Destination
  • Simple
  • Modern
  • Vintage
  • Bohemian
  • Beach
Shop The Knot Invitations
  • Vera Wang x The Knot
    Vera Wang x The Knot
  • Free Samples
    Free Samples
  • Foil Collection
    Foil Collection
  • Wedding Invitations
    Wedding Invitations
Registry
Start a Registry
Add Store Registries
Cash Funds
The Knot Charity Program
Find a Couple's Registry
Collections
Brands
Kitchen
  • All Kitchen
  • Appliances
  • Cookware
  • Bakeware
  • Knives & Boards
  • Tools & Gadgets
  • Storage & Organization
  • Coffee & Tea
  • Kitchen Linens
Tabletop
  • All Tabletop
  • Dinnerware
  • Flatware
  • Serveware
  • Drinkware & Bar
  • Table Linens
Home
  • All Home
  • Décor
  • Furniture
  • Cleaning & Organization
  • Laundry
  • Outdoor
  • Electronics
Bed & Bath
  • All Bed & Bath
  • Bed
  • Bath
Lifestyle
  • All Lifestyle
  • Luggage
  • Camping
  • Electronics & Gadgets
  • Pets
  • Fitness
Experiences
  • All Experiences
  • Gift Cards
  • Experiences
Shop The Knot Registry Store
  • Wedding Registry Essentials
    Wedding Registry Essentials
  • Registry Awards
    Registry Awards
  • JoJo Fletcher & Jordan Rodgers
    JoJo Fletcher & Jordan Rodgers
  • Get 20% off after your wedding
Attire & Rings
Wedding Dresses
  • All Wedding Dresses
  • A-Line Dresses
  • Ball Gown Dresses
  • Mermaid Dresses
  • Sheath Dresses
  • Short Dresses
Suits & Tuxedos
Bridesmaid Dresses
Mother of the Bride Dresses
Flower Girl Dresses
Engagement Rings
  • All Engagement Rings
  • Princess Cut
  • Asscher Cut
  • Cushion Cut
  • Emerald Cut
  • Pear Cut
  • Radiant Cut
  • Round Cut
  • Oval Cut
Wedding Rings
Wedding Jewelry
Wedding Accessories
Get Fashion Inspiration
  • Wedding Dresses
    Wedding Dresses
  • Engagement Rings
    Engagement Rings
  • Suits & Tuxedos
    Suits & Tuxedos
  • Bridesmaid Dresses
    Bridesmaid Dresses
Ideas & Advice
Engagement
  • All Engagement
  • Engagement Rings
  • Wedding Proposals
Ceremony & Reception
  • All Ceremony & Reception
  • Real Wedding Photos
  • Budget Advice
  • Invitations & Paper
  • Themes & Decor
  • Wedding Traditions
  • Music & Songs
Parties & Events
  • All Parties & Events
  • Engagement Party
  • Bach Parties
  • Wedding Shower
  • Rehearsal Dinner
Travel
  • All Travel
  • Destination Weddings
  • Honeymoons
Fashion
  • All Fashion
  • Couples Attire
  • Rings & Accessories
  • Wedding Party Attire
  • Guest Attire
Beauty & Wellness
  • All Beauty & Wellness
  • Hair
  • Makeup & Grooming
  • Health & Wellness
Gifts
  • All Gifts
  • Registry Advice
  • Gifts for Couples
  • Favors & Gifts
  • Gift Ideas
Sponsored
Groom's Men's Wearhouse
The Ultimate Guide to Wedding Day Style.
Sponsored by Men's Wearhouse
East Islip Wedding Venues
0/0
  • Photos
  • About
  • Amenities
  • Pricing
  • Reviews
  • Contact

Irish Coffee Pub

4.9
(15)

131 Carleton Ave, East Islip, NY

About This Vendor

The Waterford Room, with its crystal chandeliers and magnificent sweeping staircase, is nothing short of extraordinary. When you have your wedding reception, you will be treated to an event as unique and special as you are. Perfectly suited to a great time, this elegant space can seat up to 225 people comfortably. Our goal is simple: to make your wedding reception a fantastic event for you and every one of your guests.

Amenities + Details

Dressing Room
Indoor Event Space
Reception Area
Covered Outdoors Space
Handicap Accessible
Liability Insurance
On-Site Accommodations
Outdoor Event Space
Wireless Internet
Guest Capacity
Up to 200
Settings
Restaurant
Venue Service Offerings
Bar & Drinks, Cakes & Desserts, Food & Catering, Rentals & Equipment

Irish Coffee Pub Reviews

Share your thoughts with other couples
Reviewed On 12/05/2020 by Kate C
Irish Coffee Pub was nothing short of outstanding. My husband and I worked closely with Niall and we were later introduced to Megan, who was our Maitre D the night of our wedding. They were absolutely amazing. We met with Niall a few months bef...
ore our upcoming wedding date on October 9th and decided to work with him immediately. He is such a warm and easygoing person... someone you need when you have your wedding fast approaching. He was very transparent and always available when I needed to talk to him. He set up a tasting for my parents, in-laws, and my husband and I about a month before our wedding to lock in what we wanted. Megan and Niall came to my in-laws backyard (our newest wedding venue) and before leaving told me that they had everything covered- open bar, passed apps, dinner, dessert, tables, etc. They made the process completely effortless. Fast forward to our wedding, Megan handled everything, I felt like a guest at my own wedding. Niall came by as well to check in. The servers, bartenders, Megan, and Niall were extraordinary. Irish Coffee Pub is my family's new favorite place... we even ordered some of the dishes from our wedding because the food was SO incredible. We cannot thank them enough. If you need catering for a wedding or ANY event... this is your place.
Response from the Vendor on 12/05/2020
Hi Kate & Chad, Thank you so much for your kind words!! It was an absolute pleasure working for you. We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us and that you were able to relax on your special day and enjoy your family and friends....
The back yard was a beautiful setting for a great couple!! Hope to see you in the near future. All the best! Niall
Reviewed On 2/14/2020 by john c
My wife and I went to the Irish Coffee Pub recently and as usual it was terrific! Steve and Nial greeting us is always a pleasure, very nice men. The food is always excellent, I like to say "the vegetables are the first indiction what type of k...
itchen you are eating from, and they are always perfect". The salads, appetizers and entrees were also excellent. We have had some of the same servers for twenty years, also the sign of a great restaurant. I actually worked there over thirty years ago and still consider it my favorite place to go, especially for those important occasions. I can't say enough about "The Pub". John Conley
Reviewed On 7/31/2018 by Danielle Y
The Irish Coffee Pub was a dream to work with! Stephen and all of his crew provided us with the most professional and heartfelt service in the wedding industry! From our very first meeting to our wedding day, we were treated with prompt servic...
e and respect. This team is extremely organized, detail-oriented, and genuinely kind. Our wedding at Martha Clara was complete with the help of them. Our guests could not stop raving about the delicious food and exquisite service. Multiple people have told us that it was the best wedding food they have ever tasted and I would have to agree! We thank you from the bottom of our hearts!
Reviewed On 11/04/2017 by Stacey C
The Irish Coffee Pub catered our wedding at Martha Clara Vineyards and they did an outstanding job. Stephen was wonderful to work with and I was always excited to meet with him. The professionalism and hospitality made it an easy decision to ch...
oose the ICP. The food was phenomenal and our guests are still talking about it!
Reviewed On 11/15/2016 by Katie Z
Irish Coffee Pub catered our wedding in Aug 2016, which was held at a vineyard on the North Fork. Stephen at ICP was with us from the first meeting until the wedding. He met with us on several occasions leading up the wedding to plan out all of...
the details such as cocktail hour layout, reception layout, select chairs/tables/linens/etc, and of course make the food selections (Lots of other caterers leave it to you to separately book everything except the food - all the way down to forks and knives). Excellent communication with us the whole time. Stephen did a fantastic job handling everything. The ICP handles more aspects of the wedding day at a vineyard (or similar venue) wedding than anyone else. All food is prepared on site and everything was very fresh, tasty, and timely. We got lots of compliments on the food. They even man stock and man the bar, which was great too. Stephen was right on site for us throughout the entire wedding day starting with setup and was probably the last one to leave that night. Given the amount of responsibility that Stephen and the ICP took on, we couldn't have asked for more. Extremely detail oriented, reliable, high quality, and professional. Highly recommend them for weddings!
Reviewed On 8/03/2016 by Jennifer T
We have friends that drive over an hour to pick up fresh lobster.. they told us they have never had a dinner like they had at our wedding. Stephen was a dream to work with, and its so nice to just trust someone and know they will do an amazing ...
job. People are still ranting about the food everything from appetizers to dinner to desert it was seamless and delicious!!!!
Reviewed On 7/19/2016 by Knottie1468980108
We got married at Martha Clara Vineyards on June 25, 2016 and if you ever get married there or need a caterer elsewhere: go with Irish Coffee Pub! For starters, Stephen, the caterer, is on top of EVERYTHING! He was incredibly attentive to our q...
uestions and was always available to meet when we needed (my husband and I live in Washington, DC and often had very narrow windows of time to meet). He knew the venue inside and out, and, because of his great leadership and highly professional staff, everything went along smoothly. The food was absolutely delicious; I keep getting compliments on the food--not only that, but he made sure my husband and I had time to actually eat at our own wedding. And it was so affordable! Irish Coffee Pub not only serves amazing meals, but the cake and glassware/flatware rentals are included in the price. Plus, Stephen has an amazing Irish brogue, how could you not love that?
Reviewed On 6/14/2016 by Meredith S
We used Irish Coffee Pub as our caterer for our wedding at Martha Clara Vineyards over Memorial Day weekend. It was amazing! First of all, Stephen is wonderful to work with. He is extremely detail-oriented and organized. He responds to emails a...
nd calls immediately and was super communicative. He's also really flexible and was so willing to work with us to make sure everything was just as we wanted it. The food is also AMAZING! We are still getting compliments on the hors d'oeuvres. The cocktail hour was perfectly timed, the servers were attentive and friendly, and the food was out of this world. The quantity and quality is just amazing, and they're very reasonably priced. The dinner was also excellent. We gave our guests a choice of steak, chicken, and fish, and everyone has told us that their food was delicious. All in all, I can't say enough about how wonderful Irish Coffee Pub is. The quality of the food and the wonderful experience working with Stephen can't be beat. I highly recommend them!
Reviewed On 12/27/2014 by Jenna L
My inlaws found us this place for our rehearsal dinner and it did not disappoint. The food was spectacular from the pasta to the fish to the ice cream brownie dessert everything was great. They gave us a large private room to ourselves and we...
were able to spread out and have time with everyone before our big day!
Reviewed On 9/16/2014 by Narae K
I can't tell you how amazing their food is. It's been 2 weeks since my wedding and I'm still hearing compliments about how good the food was. Let me tell you, guests only remember one thing: the food. Stephen was amazingly patient and helpf...
ul throughout my 13 month planning process. Dealing with me isn't easy because I'm super detail-oriented. He'd answer my emails at midnight. The service was amazing. He knows what he's doing and he's proud of his work. You can tell. Don't let their "pub" name fool you. They're professionals. Give them a shot.
Reviewed On 10/22/2013 by Kelly-Ann K
My mom had my bridal shower here. The room was nice, they let her bring in additional decorations for a theme and a special gluten free cake from an outside bakery. The service was great and the food was tasty. My mom also said the value was go...
od for what was included in the per person price for a Saturday afternoon shower.
Reviewed On 8/15/2012 by Jenna F
My mom and mother in law surprised me with a shower at the irish coffee pub! The food was amazing, everything was great! Everyone was very nice and the room was beautiful! Very nicely decorated and good service. The only thing we didn't like wa...
s that we were rushed out at the end and that the drinks (punch and champagne table) were put outside our room...that was weird because all the guests had to go out to get a drink. Other than that it was great
Reviewed On 12/24/2011 by Nicole B
my mom threw my bridal shower and everything was beautiful. the only thing that went wrong was they had a baby shower cake instead of a bridal shower cake, which was very embarrassing for mom and I. The fixed the situation though.
Reviewed On 12/02/2011 by Diana G
The staff was so helpful and attentive. They worked with us, and made the night perfect.
Reviewed On 9/04/2008 by Annie C
Food was GREAT. Staff was wonderful and took care of all needs.

Contact Info for Irish Coffee Pub

131 Carleton Ave, East Islip, NY(631) 277-0007
Call

Wedding Vendors in East Islip

East Islip Bridal Salons
East Islip Beauty Salons
East Islip Caterers
East Islip DJs
East Islip Florists
East Islip Reception Venues
East Islip Videographers
East Islip Wedding Bands
East Islip Wedding Photographers
East Islip Wedding Planners
  1. Wedding Vendors
    /
  2. Wedding Venues
    /
  3. New York Wedding Venues
    /
  4. East Islip Wedding Venues
    /
Irish Coffee Pub
made withlove
Planning & Inspiration
Wedding WebsitesRegistryMarketplaceWedding InvitationsWedding Planning AppWedding BudgetWedding ChecklistWedding Guest ListWedding Ideas & EtiquetteEngagementParties & EventsWedding DressesGiftsReal Wedding PhotosThe Knot NewsCommunity
The Company
The Knot WorldwideAbout UsThe Knot EditorialCareersInternationalPressNational AdvertisingOur Sponsors
Sister Sites
The BumpThe GuestThe BashHow They Asked
Get Our Wedding Planner App On Your Mobile Device
Are you a vendor?
Sign up on The Knot to reach more couples and book more weddings!
Start Here
Privacy PolicyTerms of UseAccessibilityDo Not Sell My InfoCA PrivacyCustomer Service
©1997-2022 XO Group Inc.