Irish Coffee Pub

e and beyond with their offerings to make the food experience amazing. Their value proposition is top-notch. We did three tastings with different caterers for our RGNY north fork wedding and found Stephen's food at Irish Coffee Pub to be the best which was only unexpected because their pricing & quantity that they offered was also head & shoulders above the competition. Additionally, the level of professionalism and service that they showed us during the tasting made us feel like we were not going to be just another wedding to them and that they took tremendous pride in what they did. We knew we'd be in good hands. It's truly hard to do justice with the amount of quality touches & upgrades we received from this team but I will do my best. Five, yes, five entree choices for our guests, including a vegetarian option. More passed hors d'oeuvres than we were contracted for, endless hot stations during cocktail hour, what felt like almost complete customization, premium liquors, it was really unbelievable the way they went above & beyond. Oh yes, and of course dealing with the fact that our guest list kept getting smaller & smaller inside 2 weeks of our date and accepting the lower guest count & therefore cost without complaint. The carrot cake their partner bakery set us up with was the best carrot cake we've ever had. The one time we slightly butted heads during the process was when we felt like it would be easier to ask guests to provide their entree order on their wedding RSVP and Stephen refused because he felt it would look like it was a cheap caterer and the food was prepared ahead of time. He insisted on collecting orders live after cocktail hour so it was clear to guests that their orders were being cooked for them on the spot. We agreed but were a bit concerned that this would lead to the orders coming out late but these concerns were completely unfounded as the food came out quite quickly and didn't hold up the 2nd band set at all. Just another example of the pride they put in their work. There was so much food to go around, the portions were large, the quality high, the logistics handled easily. You just would genuinely be making a huge mistake to think twice and go with another caterer. Other reviews will say this but we have to as well that years later, we are still reminded by friends how good the food at our wedding was. So many comments of it being the best food anyone has had at a wedding and we couldn't agree more. My wife and I and our friend group lived in lower Manhattan and as a point of NYC price, always wanted to have food be the highlight of our wedding since dining out was such a big part of our life in the city. We went to dozens of weddings as guests and were so glad to be able to feel like the food at our wedding really stood out. And to think we were able to get that at a reasonable price point without a pretentious attitude was all the more unbelievable. Thanks to the whole team at ICP who made our wedding so special!

ting, warm, and overall just phenomenal. They were beyond easy to work with and super communicative. To top everything off, the food was fantastic. Even weeks after my wedding people have gone out of their way to say how fantastic the food was. I can’t begin to express my gratitude towards Stephen and the whole ICP team. I will definitely be an regular at their restaurant for life.

pliments from our guests about how amazingly delicious every bite of food was- from cocktail hour down to dessert. Our guests were never left hungry (or thirsty!) and our wedding simply would not have been an perfect as it was without Stephen and ICP! Thank you endlessly!

ding planner and venue. By a stroke of luck, they had a last minute cancellation for our wedding date and were able to help us out. From day one, Stephen’s kindness and support through all the craziness put us at ease. The entire event was flawless, and the food was beyond incredible. Our guests have been raving about it ever since, saying it was the best wedding food they’ve ever had! The true test: my grandma ate all the appetizers AND her entire dinner. The team also made sure we were well-fed throughout the night, which was much appreciated. We highly highly recommend them and can’t wait to go to the restaurant for future dinners and anniversaries!

ore our upcoming wedding date on October 9th and decided to work with him immediately. He is such a warm and easygoing person... someone you need when you have your wedding fast approaching. He was very transparent and always available when I needed to talk to him. He set up a tasting for my parents, in-laws, and my husband and I about a month before our wedding to lock in what we wanted. Megan and Niall came to my in-laws backyard (our newest wedding venue) and before leaving told me that they had everything covered- open bar, passed apps, dinner, dessert, tables, etc. They made the process completely effortless. Fast forward to our wedding, Megan handled everything, I felt like a guest at my own wedding. Niall came by as well to check in. The servers, bartenders, Megan, and Niall were extraordinary. Irish Coffee Pub is my family's new favorite place... we even ordered some of the dishes from our wedding because the food was SO incredible. We cannot thank them enough. If you need catering for a wedding or ANY event... this is your place.

itchen you are eating from, and they are always perfect". The salads, appetizers and entrees were also excellent. We have had some of the same servers for twenty years, also the sign of a great restaurant. I actually worked there over thirty years ago and still consider it my favorite place to go, especially for those important occasions. I can't say enough about "The Pub". John Conley

e and respect. This team is extremely organized, detail-oriented, and genuinely kind. Our wedding at Martha Clara was complete with the help of them. Our guests could not stop raving about the delicious food and exquisite service. Multiple people have told us that it was the best wedding food they have ever tasted and I would have to agree! We thank you from the bottom of our hearts!

oose the ICP. The food was phenomenal and our guests are still talking about it!

the details such as cocktail hour layout, reception layout, select chairs/tables/linens/etc, and of course make the food selections (Lots of other caterers leave it to you to separately book everything except the food - all the way down to forks and knives). Excellent communication with us the whole time. Stephen did a fantastic job handling everything. The ICP handles more aspects of the wedding day at a vineyard (or similar venue) wedding than anyone else. All food is prepared on site and everything was very fresh, tasty, and timely. We got lots of compliments on the food. They even man stock and man the bar, which was great too. Stephen was right on site for us throughout the entire wedding day starting with setup and was probably the last one to leave that night. Given the amount of responsibility that Stephen and the ICP took on, we couldn't have asked for more. Extremely detail oriented, reliable, high quality, and professional. Highly recommend them for weddings!

job. People are still ranting about the food everything from appetizers to dinner to desert it was seamless and delicious!!!!

uestions and was always available to meet when we needed (my husband and I live in Washington, DC and often had very narrow windows of time to meet). He knew the venue inside and out, and, because of his great leadership and highly professional staff, everything went along smoothly. The food was absolutely delicious; I keep getting compliments on the food--not only that, but he made sure my husband and I had time to actually eat at our own wedding. And it was so affordable! Irish Coffee Pub not only serves amazing meals, but the cake and glassware/flatware rentals are included in the price. Plus, Stephen has an amazing Irish brogue, how could you not love that?

nd calls immediately and was super communicative. He's also really flexible and was so willing to work with us to make sure everything was just as we wanted it. The food is also AMAZING! We are still getting compliments on the hors d'oeuvres. The cocktail hour was perfectly timed, the servers were attentive and friendly, and the food was out of this world. The quantity and quality is just amazing, and they're very reasonably priced. The dinner was also excellent. We gave our guests a choice of steak, chicken, and fish, and everyone has told us that their food was delicious. All in all, I can't say enough about how wonderful Irish Coffee Pub is. The quality of the food and the wonderful experience working with Stephen can't be beat. I highly recommend them!

were able to spread out and have time with everyone before our big day!

ul throughout my 13 month planning process. Dealing with me isn't easy because I'm super detail-oriented. He'd answer my emails at midnight. The service was amazing. He knows what he's doing and he's proud of his work. You can tell. Don't let their "pub" name fool you. They're professionals. Give them a shot.

od for what was included in the per person price for a Saturday afternoon shower.

s that we were rushed out at the end and that the drinks (punch and champagne table) were put outside our room...that was weird because all the guests had to go out to get a drink. Other than that it was great