'Dancing With the Stars' Pro Witney Carson Is Engaged to Her High School Sweetheart!

And just wait until you hear her proposal story.
by Maggie Seaver
Witney Carson and Carson Mcallister are engaged

We're so excited for Witney Carson! The Dancing with the Stars professional dancer and Season 19 champ got engaged on October 2 to her high school sweetheart, Carson Mcallister. The couple met in their hometown of American Fork, Utah, and they've been together (read: making everyone jealous!) for four years.

Witney told People, "My high school sweetheart popped the question last night in the most perfect, beautiful way. He was waiting for me on the beach surrounded by candles. Danced with me while the sun went down and then knelt down on one knee and asked me to marry him! Of course I said yes." If that isn't the most romantic proposal, then we don't even know what is.

Carson posted an Instragram photo on Saturday from their special evening with the caption, "my love of four years @carson.mcallister proposed last night & I feel like the luckiest, happiest woman in the world. it was perfect, he's perfect #engaged."

But it wasn't until Sunday evening that we got a glimpse of her breathtaking ring. A second black-and-white Insta shot, also taken by photographer McKenna Fulmer, shows the lovebirds wrapped in each other's arms, which is totally sweet—but we honestly couldn't peel our eyes off Carson's left hand!

Still reminiscing...😍💍 & huge s/o to my talented sneaky photog @kfulllms 👊🏻 #engaged

A post shared by Witney Carson McAllister (@witneycarson) on

According to People, the rock is a 2-carat Rocky Mountain oval-cut diamond with a diamond halo and rose gold band.

Cheers to Witney and Carson!

Up Next
Aly Michalka's wedding day
5 Insanely Gorgeous Photos From Aly Michalka's Wedding You Haven't Seen Yet
If you were looking for the most romantic wedding inspiration ever, take a gander at former Disney star Aly Michalka's flawless wedding photos (and her lilac wedding dress!).
by Ivy Jacobson2 min read