From classic rock to bumpin' new pop songs, here's a curated list of crowd-pleasers.
Updated Mar 06, 2025Here's the Scoop on the Etsy Wedding Registry
That's right—you can now register for all things cute, custom and handmade.
Photos, From Clockwise: Neon Decor Lovers, Hometown Engraving LLC, Crosby and Taylor, Lili DiPrima
We know it, we love it, we've ordered countless pieces of handmade home decor and personalized goodies from it. And now, soonlyweds can create an Etsy wedding registry to curate a wish list full of unique wedding gifts by artisans around the world. We love a good universal registry moment (aka a registry that gathers all of your items from different retailers in one place) and Etsy truly adds something (or really, a few things) special to the mix. Once you have your registry stalwarts all set (*cough cough* KitchenAid stand mixer), peruse Etsy for some truly bespoke items to celebrate your union—think: a hand-painted illustration of you and your love's first-date spot, a pair of personalized ring dishes for your betrothed baubles or a neon sign spelling out your newly shared last name. "On Etsy, we've seen a staggering 872-percent increase in searches for handmade gifts as modern couples leave traditional wedding gifts behind," says Etsy trend expert Dayna Isom Johnson. Translation: You'll end up with a much cooler registry with Etsy than you would otherwise. We've got the details on all things Etsy registry below, plus a curated collection of our favorite Etsy wedding gifts to get you started.
In this article:
How to Create an Etsy Registry
We know you're eager to get clicking to fill up your Etsy wedding gift registry, so we're answering all of your burning questions about the process below, from how to make an Etsy wedding registry, to how to link it to your The Knot Registry, to the ins and outs of how exactly to use it.
Can you register with Etsy?
You can (and should) register with Etsy. The marketplace is a mecca for handmade and personalized homewares and gifts that you just can't find at traditional retailers. "With Etsy, couples are not limited to generic, mass-produced items. They have the opportunity to infuse their personality and love story into every aspect of their registry," says Isom Johnson. "Plus, every gift couples register for on Etsy supports small, independent sellers from all corners of the globe."
FEATURED VIDEO FROM THE KNOT
How do you make an Etsy wedding registry?
Making an Etsy registry is super easy—simply go to their website, select "registry" and then follow the prompts to enter relevant info like your names and wedding date. That's it. To sync it with your The Knot registry, it's even easier. Etsy is one of our registry partners, which means that any gifts you add to your Etsy registry will automatically populate on your The Knot registry ASAP for you and your guests' convenience. Just be sure to create your The Knot registry beforehand and use the same email address to sign up for both wish lists.
How do you add items to your Etsy registry?
Once you've created an Etsy wedding registry, an "Add to Registry" button will appear alongside the typical "Add to Cart" button when you're logged in. Just click on that button whenever you see an item you like and it'll pop up on your registries on Etsy and The Knot. Bonus: Any personalization details you input before adding items to the registry will be carried over to your wish list.
How can guests access your Etsy registry?
Guests can easily access your Etsy wedding registry through your The Knot wedding website. If you have both a website and a registry with The Knot, your registries will automatically display on your wedding website and the wedding website link will show up like magic on your registry profile. Otherwise, you can also create a link to share your registry manually with your loved ones. Just go to your registry profile settings and select "Copy Link" under your registry URL.
My Favorite Etsy Registry Picks
Now that we've covered why Etsy is one of the best places to register, here's a list of some stunning handmade items from indie artisans to get you started. You'll find Etsy wedding registry ideas that range from glassware blown by hand to custom artwork that won't break the bank below, but that's just the beginning when it comes to what Etsy can offer.
1. Restaurant Matchbook Print From Haus Craft Designs
Photo: Haus Craft Designs
This Etsy artist creates custom artwork that mimics a shadowbox filled with matchbooks. Each print features a bevy of perfectly placed illustrations of matches from popular restaurants in cities from around the country. Choose a premade print that features the city where you and your love live and add it to your registry as is, or choose to customize any of the existing city prints, swapping out the restaurants you don't visit much with those where you two are regulars.
2. Personalized Casserole Dish From Hometown Engraving LLC
Photo: Hometown Engraving LLC
Once you tie the knot, chances are you'll inherit some coveted signature recipes from both sides of the family. This Pyrex dish can celebrate a special one—it's laser-engraved with the recipe of your choice in the exact handwriting it's scrawled in. Don't forget to drop a hint or two to your grandma to scoop up her secret snickerdoodle recipe beforehand.
3. Pewter Heart Measuring Spoons From Crosby and Taylor
Photo: Crosby and Taylor
How darling are these pewter measuring spoons? Each one is handmade in Oregon by a pewtersmith with decades of experience. The handles feature a stack of hearts to add a little touch of romance to your newlywed kitchen.
4. Large Elegant Wooden Tray From Sea Wood Design France
Photo: Sea Wood Design France
If you're after a natural, Scandinavian design aesthetic for your newlywed nest, this gorgeous serving board deserves a coveted spot on your registry. Handmade, the tray showcases a stunning slice of a tree's interior. The edges are painted a soft white, while the center retains the gorgeous natural pattern and hue of the red cedar wood.
5. Vintage Silver Cheese Spreader From Prose and Polish
Photo: Prose And Polish
If you and your beloved are known to get a little cheesy (both in the literal and figurative sense), this cute little spreader will give you a side of giggles with your gouda. Each knife is a silver-plated vintage utensil stamped with a punny saying that celebrates a different type of cheese. Select between cheddar, gouda or brie, or scoop up all three.
6. Amour Espresso Cup Set From La Fleur Artisane
Photo: La Fleur Artisane
This set of two handmade and hand-painted mugs will look so cute toasting together with your Sunday morning coffee. Each is painted with tiny red hearts and features a unique, slightly organic shape. They're crafted from porcelain clay and glaze sourced in Canada, Italy, Spain and the US.
7. Couples Portrait From Lili Di Prima
Photo: Lili DiPrima
According to Isom Johnson, custom couples portraits have been one of the most popular picks on Etsy registries so far. This one is a hand-done digital drawing created by a 2023 Etsy Design Award finalist and features a sweet illustration of the both of you with your last name below. You can also shop additional options that include space in the composition for kiddos and pets.
8. Personalized Wedding Jewelry Dish From The Painted Press
Photo: The Painted Press
Need a pretty place to store your wedding rings? This personalized clay dish is just the ticket. Your first initials are displayed in gold at the center, while a shimmery border adds some extra sparkle. Choose between a painted leaf detail or a floral detail, if you'd like some additional decoration.
9. Ceramic Dinnerware Set From Makaki Studio Store
Photo: Makaki Studio Store
This speckled dinnerware set is handmade and the epitome of minimalist-chic. Each comes with a bowl, a large rimmed dinner plate and a smaller side plate. We love how sleek and of-the-moment the silhouette is paired with the timeless earthy beauty of the clay.
10. Handmade Pint Glasses From Stephanie McCune Glass
Photo: Stephanie McCune Glass
There's nothing more artistic and elegant than blown glass. And these pretty 16-ounce pint glasses are custom made just for you with your two favorite colors in the mountains of North Carolina. Choose one, two, four or eight.
11. Embroidered Wildflower Tea Towel Set From Fancy Stitches 4U
Photo: Fancy Stitches 4U
Etsy is all about stunning items handmade with love and true craftsmanship—and these kitchen towels are the epitome of that ethos. Each one in this set of four towels is embroidered with a patch of wildflowers or little berries rendered in stunning detail. The towels themselves are 100-percent cotton.
12. Last Name Neon Sign From Neon Decor Lovers
Photo: Neon Decor Lovers
Looking for a funky piece of home decor that also celebrates your union? This neon sign that can feature both of your first names or your shared last name will give your living room, bedroom or entertaining space a cool ambiance that'll rival your favorite trendy bar. It's battery operated and available in eight different sizes.
