From classic rock to bumpin' new pop songs, here's a curated list of crowd-pleasers.
Updated Mar 06, 2025Here's Where to Shop for Engagement Rings in Columbus, Ohio
Find the perfect sparkle for your love story.
by Raven Briana McMillan
Updated Dec 03, 2024
Shopping for the perfect engagement ring isn't just about making a purchase—it's the beginning of your forever love story, and in Columbus, you'll find some of the best jewelers to help you write it. We're breaking down the top spots to shop for engagement rings in Columbus, Ohio, detailing what makes each one special—including product offerings and shopping experience. From a classic diamond to a vintage gem or customized masterpiece, this city has it all.
Whether you prefer a walk-in browse or a private appointment, this list will steer you toward a sparkling start to your happily ever after. For even more options, head to The Knot Marketplace to continue searching for a just-right ring for your Ohio proposal.
1. Worthington Jewelers
Worthington Jewelers, located in the Columbus metro area, is renowned for its commitment to creating memorable experiences for couples shopping for engagement rings. With more than 1,300 designs on display—many crafted in the US—its collection includes styles ranging from classic solitaires to intricate vintage-inspired designs, all made with high-quality materials. And if that's not enough to choose from, this family-owned boutique specializes in custom-designed rings, offering clients the chance to craft a one-of-a-kind piece. Worthington has been honored with The Knot Best of award 11 times and their non-commissioned jewelry consultants are here to guide you every step of the way, helping you find the perfect rings to celebrate your love story.
Notable Review: "We had the best experience with Worthington Jewelers! While shopping in the store for my engagement ring, we had trouble finding something perfect for me. They helped us design a custom ring based on an existing design to make the ring of my dreams!" – Lexi C.
2. Alexanders Jewelers
Nestled in the Short North Arts District, Alexanders Jewelers has been a trusted name in luxury engagement rings in Columbus for over 14 years. Founded by Alexander Khvalsky, this locally owned boutique has earned a reputation as the area's best alternative to chain stores, offering a modern aesthetic and a wide selection of designer rings. With expertise in both contemporary and vintage styles, Alexanders Jewelers ensures every customer finds a ring that perfectly reflects their vision.
FEATURED VIDEO FROM THE KNOT
Notable Review: "I am in love with my engagement ring that my fiancé picked out (with the help of Alexanders Jewelers bridal experts). I also had the best experience picking out our wedding bands. Everyone was so nice and helpful. I highly recommend them!" – Sabrina M.
3. The Diamond Cellar
With a reputation spanning more than 70 years, The Diamond Cellar is a trusted name for engagement rings in Columbus, OH. As part of one of the United States' largest independent jewelry companies, with five stores across Columbus, Nashville and Tulsa, this high-end jeweler offers an extensive collection of designer rings from brands like Scott Kay, A. Jaffe, Christopher Design and Precision Set. They also excel in custom designs, working closely with clients to create rings that reflect their unique love stories. Appointments are encouraged, especially for those interested in customization or seeking diamond consultations.
Notable Review: "After going to a few other places this was by far the best! Randy at the Easton location was very helpful! I loved that the rings were ready to try on with sample diamonds in them. " – Debbie D.
4. Argo & Lehne Jewelers
A third-generation operation, Argo & Lehne Jewelers has been a Columbus institution since 1924, offering timeless designs and impeccable craftsmanship. Known for their personalized service, they specialize in both contemporary engagement rings and heirloom-quality custom designs. Their expertise extends to heirloom restoration and repurposing jewelry, helping clients breathe new life into cherished pieces. Argo & Lehne also offers a unique Something Borrowed program, lending jewelry to to-be-weds for their wedding day. Their collection features a range of styles, from vintage-inspired to modern minimalist designs. Walk-ins are welcome, but scheduling an appointment ensures a more intimate shopping experience with their knowledgeable staff.
Notable Review: "I'm so in love with my ring! They did such a fabulous job. I've had an endless amount of compliments on how unique and stunning it is and I cannot think Argo & Lehne enough." – Jennifer D.
5. Meyers Jewelers
Located in Grove City, Ohio, Meyers Jewelers has been a family-run business since 1966, offering a legacy of exceptional craftsmanship and personalized service. Specializing in high-end brands and custom designs, this boutique is dedicated to helping you find a timeless symbol of your sacred union. Their experienced team—collectively boasting more than 200 years in the industry—takes the time to understand your unique aesthetic and preferences, ensuring a highly personalized shopping experience. Each ring is sold without a center stone, allowing you to select the perfect jewel that truly speaks to you.
Notable Review: "My now husband and I looked at engagement rings at multiple other large and small jewelry stores in our area before going to Meyers Jewelers. None of the other stores had the customer service, ring or price per value that we wanted. When we went to Meyers Jewelers, they greeted us with smiles and made us feel at home." – Erica S.
6. Jeff Johnson & Co.
Jeff Johnson & Co. is more than a jewelry store—it's a hub for artistry and craftsmanship. Their team is made of artisans who bring years of experience to every piece they create, specializing in custom engagement rings in Columbus. The jeweler's dedication extends to their store hours; they are closed on Sundays and Mondays to be with family, reflecting their commitment to relationships, both personal and professional.
Notable Review: "I had the most amazing experience designing a ring at J.J. & Co. I wasn't sure exactly what I wanted but had some ideas. We sat down and their experts walked me through my ideas and helped me and guided me towards a design. And it came out BEAUTIFUL—better than I could have imagined!" - Carolyn C.
7. Pugh's Diamond Jewelers
Pugh's Diamond Jewelers, established in 1949, has been a cornerstone of Zanesville, Ohio's jewelry scene, for over seven decades. Known as "Where Southeastern Ohio Gets Engaged," their 2,000-square-foot space showcases the largest selection of engagement rings in the region, including the exclusive Pure 73 Diamond—a branded, high-quality stone exclusive to select jewelers. To celebrate your love, Pugh's offers a $50 gift certificate to commemorate your anniversary in style.
Notable Review: "Pugh's is the kind of place in which you can feel comfortable, with friendly, service-oriented people that treat you like family—the people that you trust with the things that matter." – Danielle A.
8. Leo Alfred Jewelers
Located in Dublin, Leo Alfred Jewelers is a family-owned business with a rich history of crafting exquisite engagement rings near Columbus, Ohio. Committed to making every customer "feel at home," they are known for their personalized service and range of timeless to cutting-edge jewelry designs. Offering designer collections as well as custom-designed pieces, their rings include everything from classic solitaires to intricately detailed settings, all featuring top-quality diamonds and gemstones. At their full-service shop, skilled custom goldsmiths, certified gemologists and appraisers handle everything from resizing a ring to designing a true work of art.
Notable Review: "I am so happy we chose to purchase our rings from Leo Alfred Jewelers. The whole team here is professional and has a vast knowledge of diamonds, current trends, etc. They are more than happy to clean your rings for engagement pictures, wedding day, etc. We worked with Julie throughout the process and she was SO kind, friendly and helpful." – Jenna T.
