From classic rock to bumpin' new pop songs, here's a curated list of crowd-pleasers.
Updated Mar 06, 20257 Places to Shop for Engagement Rings in Jacksonville, FL
These long-standing jewelry shops are the best in the Jacksonville area.
Photo: Stocksy
Popping the big question is a big deal—one that comes with a joyous "yes!" and a happy future ahead. Picking out the right ring for bae can sometimes add a little pressure, but with an excellent jeweler, you'll be set. If you're shopping for engagement rings in Jacksonville, FL, we're here to help you narrow down all your choices with the best of the best. Whether you're in the market for glittering lab diamonds, moissanite, or natural diamonds, are seeking rings with precious gemstones or want to design a one-of-a-kind custom engagement ring, start your search with these top-rated engagement ring studios in Jacksonville.
1. Sanders Jewelers
Founded more than 30 years ago, Sanders Jewelers is a local jewelry store that sells engagement rings in the Jacksonville area. It's owned by husband and wife team Rick and Melinda who've united their skillset of design, business and customer service to create a shop that people keep returning to for all their jewelry needs.
Along with selling jewelry from established brands—such as Alison Kaufman, Malo Bands, Dove's Jewelry and Cherie Dori—Sanders Jewelers also creates custom engagement rings and other jewelry pieces. They also offer restoration services, cleaning and inspection, jewelry appraisals, engraving, repairs and resizing. Prices range from $590 (plus the cost of a center stone) to $9,650 (plus the cost of the center stone) and no appointment is required to visit.
FEATURED VIDEO FROM THE KNOT
Notable Review: "I have enjoyed working with Rick and his team for years now. As a first-time customer, Rick took my rough scribbles and transformed them into a beautiful, 100% unique engagement ring. After that, I have returned to the Sanders team on every jewelry gift occasion, large and small—always a unique gift. I look forward to working with them on custom projects for as long as I'm married!"
2. Crawford Jewelers
This family-owned jewelry store is one of the best places to shop for gemstone, moissanite and diamond engagement rings in Jacksonville, FL. They've been so successful in their 65 years of selling beautiful jewelry that they've opened two additional locations in Georgia. Crawford Jewelers sells exclusive collections from beloved brands and does custom work for those seeking personalized pieces. Along with engagement rings, they also sell earrings, necklaces, bracelets and watches. No appointment is necessary.
Notable Review: "Upon walking into Crawford Jewelers to search for wedding bands, the owner immediately recognized and remembered my fiancé from a few months ago buying my engagement ring. He was friendly and personable and had already picked out a few wedding bands to fit my engagement ring. He graciously cleaned my engagement ring while we looked at the bands, and by the time we had picked them out, my ring was sparkling. Once we decided, he gave us a fair price for them and ordered them immediately. This was on a Friday around lunchtime and they were available Monday morning. The service was great and we love our bands."
3. Harby Jewelers
Shopping for an engagement ring at Harby Jewelers is a treasured experience from the moment you step inside. The store, founded in 1926 and considered one of the oldest family-owned jewelry stores in the area, is located on the 25th floor and offers sweeping views of downtown Jacksonville. Owned by gemologists Hugh and Brad Harby, the store features an impeccably curated selection of engagement rings, fine jewelry, and estate pieces. Along with engagement rings in Jacksonville, Harby Jewelers also offers custom design services, jewelry repair, appraisals, resale and consignment. Prices range from $1000 to $11,000. Walk-ins are okay, but scheduling an appointment ensures quick, 1:1 service.
Notable Review: "Harby Jewelers is an excellent place for all your jewelry needs. My husband was able to design the perfect engagement ring that absolutely blew me away. We were also able to get the exact match as a wedding band so they look perfect. It's a family business and it feels that way. They genuinely care about their customers and making sure they sell the best product possible."
4. Oaks Jewelry
Whether you're set on creating a custom engagement ring in Jacksonville, FL, are seeking a vintage stunner or want to get a new ring from a reputable brand, there's no shortage of options at Oaks Jewelry. Established in 1983, this family-owned and operated store is a favorite in the area not just for its robust selection, but for its team of highly educated, GIA-certified jewelers who can help you with this important investment piece. Prices on engagement rings vary dramatically—from $250 to $40,000. Services offered include online and in-person customized design, estate evaluation and jewelry repair. No appointment is required.
Notable Review: "I came to Oaks Jewelry to design an engagement ring for my now fiancé. Kim and the team at Oaks Jewelry brought my vision to life. From the band, hidden halo, they even enabled me to decide how many prongs the ring had and guided me from the beginning to the end while keeping everything in the budget I gave them in the beginning. I still remember the day I picked the ring up, I was speechless. Couldn't recommend a jewelry store any more than Oaks; they are the best!"
5. Blue Water Jewelers
If you're looking for a top-tier engagement ring shopping experience near Jacksonville then Blue Water Jewelers is your spot. This family-owned and operated shop was founded in 2006 and offers a huge selection of fine jewelry from some of the most coveted designer lines, including Noam Carver, Sylvie, Lafonn, Midas, VanMark and more. Blue Water Jewelers also specializes in custom pieces, hand-selecting some of the most beautiful diamonds in the world directly from Antwerp. Additional services include appraisals and jewelry repair. Prices range from $900 (not including center stone) to $58,000, and you do not need an appointment to shop.
Notable Review: "Could not speak more highly of the selection or staff at Blue Water! Incredibly attentive and communicative throughout the entire engagement ring shopping process. They truly made my partner's dream ring and made an already amazing experience that much better for the both of us."
6. Beard's Diamonds
Beard's Diamonds prides itself on carrying the largest inventory of GIA-certified diamonds in Jacksonville and ensures every customer understands the basics of diamonds before making this major investment. Along with a design team that'll work with you to create a custom engagement ring, Beard's Diamonds also sells from some of the world's most coveted jewelry brands, including Sylvie, Gabriel & Co., Verragio, Tacori and Noam Carver. Walk-ins are welcome, but you can request an appointment if you'd like to ensure your shopping time and 1:1 support.
Notable Review: "THE BEST!! Wonderful staff and a huge selection of beautiful ring settings and diamonds! Do not hesitate to go here for your engagement ring, just go, you won't be disappointed. They actually listen to what it is you are looking for, they are not pushy and they answer your questions professionally. They kept us within our budget and did not try to push or oversell us, unlike other jewelry stores in the area. This was worth its weight in gold! Also, if you purchase your ring here, they will buy your diamond back at the appraised value if you ever want to upgrade your diamond, and they offer lifetime cleanings literally as often as you need. No gimmicks, just great service. A big thanks to the whole Beard's staff for such a wonderful experience!!"
7. Faith Jewelers
Founded 20 years ago, Faith Jewelers is a family-owned business in the Murray Hill neighborhood of Jacksonville. Their tight-knit team includes husband and wife Gwen and JR Strickland along with their son, John-Frazier, who handles all custom design work. It's rounded out by a jewelry sales professional and graduate gemologist from the GIA, as well as a master bench jeweler and goldsmith with over 35 years of experience. The store provides custom jewelry design, jewelry repair and jewelry appraisals. Walk-ins are welcome.
Notable Review: "John is AMAZING!!! He is knowledgeable, honest, patient and super helpful. John took the time to educate us, answered every question that we had and helped us find the most perfect engagement ring of my dreams and the wedding ring my fiancé wanted to match mine. Absolutely wonderful stress-free experience! Right rings at the right price, my goodness did he find me quite the sizable rock that sparkles. I would recommend Faith Jewelers to anyone looking. They gained a lifetime customer!"
