35 of the Most Romantic Anniversary Gifts for Your Boyfriend, According to a Serial Monogamist

You love your boyfriend, but oh man is he difficult to shop for, and anniversary gifts for your boyfriend are by far the hardest. The last thing you want is for a gift that's supposed to express your love and commitment to be returned. I can relate. I just celebrated eight years with my boyfriend. (Yes, I am hoping it'll be the last year without a ring.) After all this time, I've finally cracked the code on what to get him for an anniversary. And I'm here to share my secret to success.

When it comes to the best anniversary presents for boyfriends, you can't go wrong with a "two-in-one gift." What does that self-coined term mean? Snag him something you know without a doubt he wants (it's okay to ask him directly), plus something that'll be a surprise. This way, your boyfriend's anniversary gift will be a hit no matter what. Typically, I like to choose gifts that relate to each other. For instance, an insulated travel mug so his coffee stays warm on his commute to work (very practical), paired with a monthly coffee subscription so he can sample new blends (very creative). Alternatively, you could choose a single personalized anniversary gift that combines utility and sentimentality, like a set of lowball glasses adorned with a map of the college campus where your story began. Whatever you decide, combining function with meaning will create an unforgettable anniversary gift for your boyfriend.

FEATURED VIDEO FROM THE KNOT

So whether you're looking for a one-month or a one-year anniversary gift for him (or two, three or four years and climbing), we've got a list of ideas he'll love. And they're all vetted by this editor's BF. From personalized milestone gifts to practical faves, prepare to steal his heart all over again with these unique anniversary gifts for your boyfriend.

In this article:

• What to Get Your Boyfriend for Your Anniversary
• The Best Anniversary Gifts for Your Boyfriend

What to Get Your Boyfriend for Your Anniversary

Start with what dating anniversary you're celebrating. One-month anniversary gifts for him will differ from those for a boyfriend of two years or more. We got some inspo for every milestone below.

• One month: Fresh connections can always benefit from more quality time together. That's why we love experience gifts to celebrate this milestone. For the guy who loves pushing the Scoville scale, treat him to the Uncommon Goods virtual Hot Sauce Making Class for two.
• Three months: The way to a man's heart is through his stomach. If you're looking for a good anniversary gift for your new boyfriend with a sweet tooth, check out Sugarwish. You choose the size, then he chooses the candy and it's sent right to his home. Sweet!
• Six months: After half a year of dating, you're pretty comfortable together. So, get a six-month anniversary gift for your boyfriend that reflects that, like Mack Weldon's Ace Sweatpants.
• One year: When it comes to celebrating your first full year together, it's understandable if you want a gift that's a little sentimental, and maybe a bit nostalgic. Uncommon Goods Retro Reel Viewer is just the anniversary gift that'll show off all your favorite memories together in the cutest way.
• Two years: You're officially in a long-term relationship, but it won't feel like it once you've gifted your boyfriend (and kind of yourself) The Adventure Challenge's Couple's Edition and …In Bed Edition to keep your dates fresh and fun.
• Three years and beyond: If you're in search of an anniversary gift for your boyfriend of three years or more, rest assured that your enduring love story was destined by the stars. As such, Mapiful's Star Map is a fitting gift idea. Capture the night you first met with a beautifully printed and framed poster, creating a romantic piece of wall art.

The Best Anniversary Gifts for Your Boyfriend

Our ideas for anniversary gifts for your boyfriend don't stop there! Keep scrolling for shoppable presents for your loveable guy.

1. Personalized Reel Viewer

Photo: Uncommon Goods

This anniversary present for your boyfriend will give him sweet, sweet nostalgia. When he clicks through the made-to-order reel filled with your most beloved photos together, he'll get the warm and fuzzies. It's one of the most creative and romantic gifts we've come across, hence it's the top spot on our list. Choose from five cool colorways for his reel viewer: red, blue, black, white or wood. You can give him a new reel of your most-recent memories for every anniversary. Aww!

2. Custom Star Map

Photo: Mapiful

Maybe he's into astronomy or maybe he's just a hopeless romantic. Either way, there's a reason this anniversary gift for your BF is super popular. Treasure the night you first met with a print of the sky on that special day. You can also include the location coordinates, the name of the spot, and the date. How special is that?

3. Custom Roman Numeral Hoodie

Photo: UniqueCustomApparell

Does he rock merch from his favorite artist or band? He'll be just as into wearing some swag that celebrates your relationship, too. This sweatshirt is embroidered with the date of your first date in Roman numerals. Choose between a crewneck or hoodie, each available in over a dozen fabric colors, then select an embroidery thread color. We wouldn't blame you if you grabbed one for yourself to make it a cute matching couples gift!

4. Personalized Bar Tag Necklace

Photo: GLDN

Customizable with a special engraving, this sleek unisex necklace is a subtle yet stylish way to carry a piece of your relationship wherever he goes. Whether it's a special date, initials, coordinates or a personal message, this necklace is a thoughtful anniversary gift for your boyfriend that's sure to make him smile every time he wears it. Plus, its timeless design means it'll never go out of style!

5. Concert Tickets

Photo: StubHub

Whether you're strengthening old bonds or building new ones, quality time together is always a win. If you're stuck on what to get your boyfriend for your anniversary, consider experience gifts like concert tickets. Check out local shows and sports games and grab tickets on StubHub. (If you're unsure about his schedule, a gift card gives him the freedom to choose.) Just make sure he knows you're coming along for the fun!

6. Conversation Card Game for Couples

Photo: Amazon

How well do you know your partner? This card game will put your knowledge to the test. Even if there's more to learn, you'll both be winners by the end as you discover new things about each other. It comes with 150 prompts and six whiteboards with dry-erase markers so you can go head-to-head with other couples for a fun group date, too.

7. Vinyl-Inspired Song Art

Photo: Lime & Lou

Whether your song is "Can't Help Falling in Love" by Elvis Presley or "Thinking Out Loud" by Ed Sheeran, immortalize the melody with this cute anniversary gift for your boyfriend. The vinyl record illustration has the song lyrics with the significance and your names underneath. Decorate his walls with a little love.

8. The Adventure Challenge Gift Set

Photo: The Adventure Challenge

Looking for an anniversary gift idea for your boyfriend that you can enjoy together? The Adventure Challenge's Couple's Edition book is a good choice and the additional …In Bed edition is a great (and spicy) choice. The bestselling books are each filled with 50 scratch-off date ideas, both in and out of the bedroom, for spontaneous activities that'll get you learning about, laughing with and lusting after each other.

Use code THEKNOT25 for 25% off sitewide.

9. Custom Oreos

Photo: Oreo

Delicious and uniquely personalized? Add to cart! You can design your own Oreo cookies, complete with a fudge coating, sprinkles and a selfie of you and your boyfriend. Plus, you can overlay your chosen photo with a sweet message like, "Happy anniversary, sweetie."

10. Bonsai Tree Lego Set

Photo: Lego

A bonsai tree is a beautiful symbol of friendship, loyalty, love and respect—qualities that form the foundation of a strong relationship. But real bonsais can be a lot of work to care for, and the last thing you want is for a gift symbolizing your connection to wither. (Ahem, "You let our love fern die?!" That's where Lego's bonsai tree comes in! It's not only a fun and engaging activity for your boyfriend to build, but it also makes a meaningful addition to his home decor.

11. Funny Scented Candle

Photo: Crudewicks

For a charming one-year anniversary gift idea for your boyfriend, consider a scented candle that'll help set the mood. This one adds a touch of humor that acknowledges your time together with a label that reads, "Smells like you're stuck with me." It's handmade using a natural soy wax blend, cotton wick and reusable glass jar and it comes in five classic scents: Clean Cotton, Sea Salt + Orchid, White Sage + Lavender, Apple Harvest and Cinnamon Vanilla.

12. Custom Engraved Watch Box

Photo: Personalization Mall

A watch box is a perfect anniversary gift to get your boyfriend because just like his watches, your time together is something to be treasured. You can customize the glass lid of this vegan leather box with your choice of a meaningful quote, his name and your anniversary date. The five felt-lined compartments and soft yet durable removable watch cuffs, ensure that his timepieces are both well-protected and beautifully displayed.

Use the code KNOT15PM for 15% off your entire order.

13. Personalized Leather Apple Watch Band

Photo: DavidPoleLeather

If your boyfriend only wears one watch—an Apple Watch—why not elevate it for your anniversary? This full-grain leather strap can be customized with a hidden message on the inside, along with dates, initials or a symbol that's meaningful to you both on the outside. Now he'll quite literally be wearing his heart on his sleeve.

14. Personalized Whiskey Decanter

Photo: Swanky Badger

If your boyfriend appreciates the finer things in life, get him this customized whiskey decanter for his anniversary gift. The front is etched with his name and your anniversary year as the "reserve year," while the back can feature a custom message. It's guaranteed to elevate his home bar instantly.

Use the code the THEKNOT10 for 10% off.

15. College Cityscape Rocks Glasses

Photo: Uncommon Goods

This is an ideal anniversary gift for your boyfriend if you're college sweethearts. Each rocks glass in the set of two features illustrations of iconic buildings and landmarks that represent the campus, presented in the school's colors. As he enjoys the last sip of his Old Fashioned, the university's logo becomes visible at the bottom. These glasses add a nostalgic and personalized touch to your celebration.

16. Food Delivery Die

Photo: Amazon

Instead of the usual dinner dilemma, roll this die to let fate decide your culinary adventure. Each face suggests one popular take-out dish like burgers, sushi or pizza so there's no aimless scrolling or arguing over what to eat. It's a silly and affordable dating anniversary gift for him that'll definitely come in handy.

17. Leather Smart Wallet

Photo: Ekster

Boyfriends can't get enough of this clever, good-looking wallet. Why? Because it's slim, it ejects cards with the click of a button and it has room for an optional tracker card so he'll never lose his wallet again. Choose from nine stylish leather colors, including classic brown and steel blue, for your partner.

18. Bluetooth Item Locators

Photo: Amazon

What about when he loses his keys or phone? Don't worry, there are trackers for that too. Tile makes slim Bluetooth trackers to hook onto his keys, stick on the back of his phone or slide into his already-beloved wallet so he never loses them. He can even put one on his TV remote if he has a habit of losing it between the couch cushions.

19. Lego Heart Key Chain

Photo: HeartsForFriendship

If you're searching for a small anniversary gift for your boyfriend, especially as part of a two-in-one gift, this key chain is a cute option and a perfect matching couples gift. The Lego heart splits in two for each of you to carry—as if you don't already hold a piece of each other's hearts everywhere you go. Just choose his favorite color and you're all set.

20. Hot Sauce-Making Class

Photo: Uncommon Goods

For a memorable new relationship gift or a fun activity for your anniversary, consider squeezing yourselves onto one Zoom screen and participating in a hot sauce-making class together. Before the class, he'll be sent a kit of assorted ground and whole spices, distilled white vinegar, a funnel and six jars with labels to help him become a sauce craftsman. Once you've whipped up concoctions together, you could cook an anniversary meal to taste-test them.

21. Custom Funko Pop Couple

Photo: Funko

Does your boyfriend collect Funko Pops? Instead of adding to his fandom assembly, gift him two major collector's items: yourselves! You can customize your own Pops to create mini versions of you both, complete with a pet.

22. Scratch-Off Movie Poster

Photo: Uncommon Goods

Shopping for a movie buff? Here's a fun gift: an interactive poster that has 100 movie suggestions to help him watch all the classics (with you snuggled alongside him, OFC). After he watches each one, he can scratch off the square to reveal colorful film art.

23. Home Movie Projector

Photo: Amazon

Whether he's passionate about film or loves gaming with his best friends at all hours of the day, an at-home theater projector is a foolproof anniversary gift for your boyfriend. This projector and screen set has 1080p HD resolution, built-in speakers and accurate color, and is compatible with multiple systems, including cable, streaming and gaming boxes. First, he'll have a romantic movie night in with you, then he'll have all his friends over for Mario Kart on the big screen.

24. Customized Portable Speaker

Photo: JBL

Crank up the fun wherever you go. This lightweight, waterproof Bluetooth speaker can play his favorite songs for up to 12 hours. Plus, it can stand vertically or horizontally to fit any space. Our favorite part: You can design it yourself. Pick the colors and add a photo or text for a super-unique anniversary gift.

25. Indoor Fire Pit

Photo: Amazon

This tabletop fire pit (suitable for indoor or outdoor use) is perfect for creating a romantic atmosphere. And I would know. I purchased it as a gift for my boyfriend. It was the finishing touch to an intimate dinner I cooked for us complete with s'mores for dessert. Feel free to steal this anniversary date idea!

26. Experience for Two

Photo: DisobeyArt | Shutterstock

Tinggly's Fun Together Box lets him choose from over 1,000 activities in more than 100 countries for a memorable date. Think: surf lessons or a bike tour. You can be a tourist in your hometown or save it for your next vacation. The voucher never expires. You'll get major brownie points for this creative boyfriend anniversary present.

27. Cashmere Quarter Zip

Photo: Quince

It's date night, but he's got nothing to wear... until now! This ultra-soft quarter zip is made from luxurious cashmere, offering a sleek, polished look in neutral hues that he'll look great in every time. Plus, it's easy to convince him to dress up when the option feels as comfy as his favorite sweatshirt.

28. Designer Beaded Bracelet

Photo: David Yurman

Trending: men's bracelets! Get your guy an accessory with a simple and classy bracelet. This one is made with sterling silver and black onyx beads. Since onyx is said to be a protector of harmonious relationships, this stylish boyfriend anniversary gift is extra meaningful.

29. Wireless Charging Valet Tray

Photo: Courant

Remember, you can't go wrong with a practical and personalized anniversary gift for your boyfriend. This handy valet tray, finished with high-quality Italian leather, can charge his phone and store his other essentials, including his keys, watch or earphones. But the monogram detail (available in silver or gold foil) is what really sets it apart from the rest.

30. The New York Times Front Page Reprint

Photo: New York Times Store

Shopping for a history buff? He'll love discovering what the front page of The New York Times looked like on the day you met, had your first date or shared your first kiss. They'll reprint those iconic headlines as a custom poster, available either unframed or with a sleek black border.

31. GQ Subscription Box

Photo: GQ Box

Here's the perfect anniversary gift for the boyfriend who's always stealing your luxe toiletries. Every three months, GQ editors select their favorite apparel, grooming and lifestyle essentials to pack and ship straight to his door. Plus, he'll get exclusive offers and discounts in addition to discovering fun new products. If you can't think of something to get your boyfriend for your anniversary, GQ will do it for you!

32. Super-Soft Sweatpants

Photo: Mack Weldon

Loungewear makes a good six-months (and upwards) anniversary gift for your boyfriend because it reiterates how comfortable you feel with him. These stylish sweatpants have a contemporary, tailored fit and are made from an ultra-soft French terry cloth. They come in regular and tall sizing and seven colorways. He'll be hoping for more date-night-ins to wear them nonstop.

33. Everyday Backpack

Photo: Lululemon

Perfect for those in the sleepover phase of their relationship, surprise your boyfriend with a versatile gift designed to seamlessly accompany him from school or work to the gym and then back to your place. Featuring three zippered compartments, including a padded laptop sleeve for a 15-inch laptop and a water bottle pocket, this seemingly simple backpack offers efficient organization for all his essentials. It's not just ideal for weekends spent with you. The trolley-compatible sleeve makes it convenient for travel as well.

34. Lovebox Spinning Heart Messenger

Photo: Uncommon Goods

He's got mail! Let him know when you're thinking about him with a digital message way cuter than a text. This gadget displays love notes you send through an easy-to-use app. Whenever a new note arrives, the heart on the box spins. No wonder it's one of our favorite long-distance relationship gifts.

35. Candy Delivery

Photo: Sugarwish

Sugarwish is a unique anniversary gift for your boyfriend to say you're sweet on him. Simply choose the size of candy box to send, then he'll get to pick from over 70 flavors to munch on. Make sure to say, "Happy anniversary" in the eCard you'll send over text or email to complete the gift.