11 Stores to Shop For Engagement Rings in Connecticut

If you're looking for engagement rings in Connecticut, congrats are in order! You're ready to take the plunge and offer your loved one a sparkly ring as a symbol of your lasting love, and you're probably looking for the best place to shop. You're in luck! This beautiful New England state is close to New York City, which is a great place to shop for just about anything, but it also boasts lots of amazing jewelry stores of its own.

Once you've planned the perfect Connecticut proposal, established your budget (here are some guidelines for how much to spend on an engagement ring) and figured out your partner's ring size (here's a handy ring size chart), it's time to hit the stores (or the websites). If your proposal will be a surprise, you've probably spent time learning your loved one's tastes and preferences. If you'll be shopping together, it's always a good idea to make an appointment for a consultation once you're really serious about finding the perfect ring.

The Knot Vendor Marketplace is a great place to start when you're unsure where to shop. We've got tons of jewelry stores and customer reviews to help inform you before you ever step foot in a store. Or, browse our round-up of the best stores to shop for engagement rings in CT, whether you're close to the Big Apple in Stamford, mid-state in New Haven or up north in Hartford.

Now that you're armed with some engagement ring shopping tips, it's time to get started! Here are 11 of our favorite engagement ring stores in Connecticut. Each has high ratings, repeat customers and an impressive selection of diamonds to ensure you find exactly what you're looking for.

FEATURED VIDEO FROM THE KNOT

1. Libero Jewelers

Photo: Libero Jewelers

Libero Jewelers is a beloved staple in bustling North Haven, Connecticut. Not only does this store boast a huge selection of diamonds both onsite and online, but it also offers a host of additional services like diamond upgrades, appraisals and a lifetime craftsmanship warranty. They provide quality you can count on when it really counts. Whether you're looking for lab-created or natural diamonds, in a classic setting or a custom-made bauble, you're sure to find the perfect ring when you shop with the knowledgeable associates at Libero.

Notable Review: "My family has been using Libero Jewelers for all of our jewelry needs for years! They never disappoint. My brothers both bought their wives' engagement rings and then wedding bands from Libero. I knew that I wanted my fiancé to go there as well, not only because I could be sure of the quality, but also the experience. Everyone at Libero is phenomenal and they really take the time to build the ring of your dreams! We can't wait to go back in the next month to purchase our wedding bands! This is the one stress-free part of the wedding planning process for me in a year full of stressful moments. Do yourself a favor and put your trust in Libero Jewelers."

2. Becker's Diamonds and Fine Jewelry

Photo: Becker's Diamonds and Fine Jewelry

It's one thing to find the perfect engagement ring: it's quite another to afford it! But when you head to Becker's Diamonds and Fine Jewelry, you'll be met with several convenient financing options that can help you afford the ring of your loved one's dreams. The company, which has three convenient locations state-wide, offers an in-store 60-day interest-free layaway plan, which allows you to make payments toward your purchase. Becker's also offers financing via a credit card that you can apply for right there in the store. With an expansive selection and a helpful website, this is the place to shop for engagement rings in West Hartford, CT, that truly offers everything you need.

Notable Review: "The staff at Becker's helped my husband pick out the perfect engagement ring to fit my ideas and specifications. When we went back for wedding bands, they were able to find a band that matched my engagement ring as well. They were also able to re-string my grandmother's pearl necklace so that I could wear it on my wedding day. The customer service was excellent and I will continue to go there for my fine jewelry needs. I would recommend this business to anyone!"

3. Diamond Designs

Photo: Diamond Designs

If you or your partner is a fan of shopping locally, Diamond Designs in Orange is a great place to shop for an engagement ring in CT. This family-owned business has served the greater New Haven area since 2002, quickly becoming a beloved establishment for jewelry lovers. The company's community-focused approach means they want nothing more than to make you a customer for life, offering top-notch customer service and providing you with a diamond expert who ensures your every desire is met at this important milestone in your life. Diamond Designs is comfortable working with any budget to find the perfect ring.

Notable Review: "I cannot recommend Dee and Diamond Designs highly enough. I know I'll be back there soon for wedding bands. If you're like me and you spent a ton of time talking to friends hoping for a magical connection who could tell you how to find the right diamond or you think you'll find the perfect stone online, do yourself a favor and stop into Diamond Designs. You'll get an actual education and not an online sales pitch, and beyond that, you'll find some of the best customer care I've ever seen, plus an actual partner in one of the biggest decisions you'll ever make. It's worth it for your time, and based on my experience, it's worth it for your wallet."

4. Rumanoff's Fine Jewelry and Design

This popular jewelry store in Hamden offers an expansive selection of glittering diamonds from top designers like Tacori and Baume & Mercier. Their helpful website allows you to easily build and view an engagement ring online, with a variety of stones and settings. With a lifetime craftsmanship guarantee, Rumanoff's ensures you feel confident in your purchase. Friendly and knowledgeable staff go out of their way to assist you in finding the perfect ring, and if they don't have what you're looking for, Rumanoff's can help you craft a custom ring.

Notable Review: "Rumanoff's Fine Jewelry and Design truly made my wedding jewelry dreams come true! Not only did we purchase our beautiful wedding bands from them, but they also worked with my husband to surprise me with the engagement ring of my dreams. The craftsmanship and attention to detail were impeccable. What truly set Rumanoff's apart was their compassionate and personal touch. They created custom jewelry for my wedding day using my late father's old jewelry, which allowed me to carry a piece of him with me as I walked down the aisle. This made my special day even more memorable."

5. Manfredi

Photo: Manfredi

If you're looking to really splash out on an extravagant engagement ring for your loved one, you belong at Manfredi. A well-known source for the most fantastic engagement rings in Greenwich, CT, Manfredi sources only the finest diamonds. Expert on-site staff will work with you during a private consultation to find exactly what you're looking for to make your proposal perfect, with a luxury ring that will exceed your partner's expectations. For fine diamonds from upscale brands like Tacori, Furrer Jacot and Benchmark, Manfredi is the place to shop.

Notable Review: "I love walking into Manfredi! Everyone is always so nice and attentive and eager to help. My husband bought my engagement ring from there which was gorgeous! We loved the experience so much that we went on to buy both our wedding bands, a watch and earrings. They are the best. We never think to go anywhere else when looking for jewelry. Do yourselves a favor and GO!"

6. NAGI Jewelers

Photo: NAGI Jewelers

For a stunning selection of both affordable and high-end engagement rings and a robust customization option for creating your very own special bauble, consider NAGI Jewelers. This family-owned jewelry store operates out of Greenwich and Stamford in southern Connecticut. Here, each staff member receives continuing diamond education and certification to ensure they're able to inform you and help you with each step of the diamond-buying process. The company prides itself on its expansive, 5,400-square-foot showroom chock full of some of the highest quality diamonds out there.

Notable Review: "My husband bought my engagement ring at NAGI and I absolutely love it! He gave me a custom blue sapphire and diamond ring. It's everything I wanted and more! We came back together and bought our wedding bands here too. NAGI is wonderful to work with and so helpful! We had so much fun trying on rings! We'll absolutely be back."

7. Lux Bond & Green

Photo: Lux Bond & Green

If you reside in Connecticut or Massachusetts, chances are good that you've heard of Lux Bond & Green. The stores, with locations in both states, have become a bit of a household name in New England. That's likely thanks to their expansive selection of rings, diamonds and settings, all to ensure you have no trouble finding exactly what you're looking for when it comes to an engagement ring for your loved one. If you're starting on a limited budget, you'll love the store's generous trade-up feature, which allows you to gradually build up to a larger ring over time.

Notable Review: "Look no further if you need an expert gemologist! I would give 10 stars if I could! My fiancé and I came in looking to get some information about my engagement ring, which had a flaw, and we weren't sure where to turn. Mark at Lux Bond & Green sat down with us in his office and spent hours educating us and exploring our options. Together we were able to recreate our DREAM engagement and wedding band rings. So much detail and engineering went into the process and from start to finish Mark made the whole process not only fun but put us at ease while we waited. We can and will only recommend Lux Bond & Green in Glastonbury to all our family and friends!"

8. Sterling Jewelers

Photo: Sterling Jewelers

Vintage engagement rings are a popular choice for couples today, thanks to their unique, customized look. If you're looking for a beautiful antique or vintage engagement ring in Connecticut, be sure to stop in to Sterling Jewelers in Wethersfield. Sterling offers a variety of vintage engagement rings and bands, and their jewelry experts can work with you to find a band that matches the unique engagement ring you've chosen for your loved one. Can't find what you need? Work with one of Sterling's expert jewelers to create a custom design that's one of a kind, even if you're looking to redesign an existing piece of jewelry or use an heirloom stone or setting in an engagement ring.

Notable Review: "My family has worked with Sterling Jewelers for years. They did a wonderful job creating my engagement ring using a family diamond. I worked closely with Jennifer to find a wedding band that would complement my engagement ring—she was so helpful! I love the combination and they fit perfectly. Thank you so much to everyone at Sterling for making this experience so smooth for us."

9. Baribault Jewelers

Photo: Baribault Jewelers

At their flagship location in Glastonbury, Connecticut, Baribault Jewelers has become one of the Constitution State's favorite jewelry stores. Here, you'll find a seemingly endless assortment of both natural diamonds and lab-created baubles as well in every cut, color, clarity and price. Or, the store's certified gemologists and master goldsmiths will work with you on your very own custom engagement ring in Connecticut. The in-store experience at Baribault is a standout, with champagne provided for your private consultation.

Notable Review: ​​"My husband went here when he was searching for an engagement ring and was so happy with the service he received. They all have so much knowledge on diamonds and jewelry, it is very reassuring. He was able to create his own design for the ring that I wanted and they brought his vision to life in the most beautiful way! After he proposed, we went back and had the ring sized a couple of times and they were so patient with us! When we went back to look at wedding bands, they were great too! They had a ring designed that matched my engagement ring, and they were actually able to engrave our rings as well. We couldn't be happier with Baribault."

10. Henry C. Reid Jewelers

Photo: Henry C. Reid Jewelers

This upscale jewelry store is a go-to for those looking for engagement rings in Fairfield, CT. Since 1910, this family-owned business has prided itself on providing top-quality diamonds and jewelry with customer service that's second to none. Henry C. Reid is conveniently located on Heritage Square in downtown Fairfield. Shop their selection of engagement rings and wedding bands, or work with their expert gemologists to create a bespoke piece that's just right for your loved one.

Notable Review: "Our experience was just great! The store is beautiful and Greg is super knowledgeable and made us feel comfortable through the whole thing. We designed and purchased a custom engagement ring and it turned out to be the ring of my dreams!! We highly recommend HCR for anyone who wants a personal and quality experience."

11. Christie's Fine Jewelry

Photo: Christie's Fine Jewelry

Located in Manchester, Connecticut, Christie's is both a household name in New England and its own brand, thanks to their extensive custom work. With a full staff of qualified gemologists to hand-select your stones, it's certain you'll come away satisfied when you shop for an engagement ring at Christie's. And when it's time to return for your wedding bands, the friendly staff will work with you to create exactly what each of you is looking for in a band, and ensure it works perfectly with the engagement ring you purchased.

Notable Review: "I want to extend my sincere appreciation to Jim, Kyla and the entire staff at Christie's. My daughter had her engagement ring designed by Kyla and it was beyond any expectation that she had. My son also purchased his fiancé's engagement ring at Christie's. It was stunning. The whole process was one of ease and fun for everyone involved. When it came to picking out the wedding bands, the staff was attentive to what they wanted and everyone walked away extremely satisfied with their rings. I can't say enough about Jim and his staff! So whatever your jewelry needs may be, I highly recommend Christie's!"