From classic rock to bumpin' new pop songs, here's a curated list of crowd-pleasers.
Updated Mar 06, 20258 Jewelers Who Sell Gorgeous Engagement Rings in Orlando
Shop sparkly engagement rings from local jewelers.
Finding a picture-perfect, sparkly engagement ring for your special someone is a monumental step in any love story. Not just any ring will do, though. To ensure a high-quality investment you've got to enlist help from a reputable, well-reviewed jeweler. If you're shopping for engagement rings in Orlando, we're here to make that process way easier for you.
Whether you're looking for a timeless classic solitaire, a vintage-inspired setting, an estate piece with some history or a modern twist on a traditional sparkler, these Orlando jewelry stores have options for every taste and budget. In this guide, we're showcasing the best jewelers selling engagement rings in Orlando, FL, so you can nab the ring and start working on your big proposal.
1. Nika+Cito Jewelry
If you're looking for a completely one-of-a-kind custom engagement ring in Orlando then Nika+Cito should be high on your shopping list. Founded and owned by Stacey Marie, a goldsmith and jewelry designer, the shop specializes in bespoke wedding jewelry including engagement rings and bands. The team draws much of its inspiration from art nouveau and contemporary design and uses premium diamonds, gemstones and metals to create their personalized pieces. You'll need to schedule a virtual or in-person consultation to begin the process.
Notable Review: "Stacey at Nika + Cito made my dream engagement ring a reality. Working with her was amazing, she was patient and attentive, and after a few meetings, we were able to come up with my perfect design. She has great communication and creative ideas. I highly recommend her."
2. Delores Jewelers
Founded nearly 50 years ago in 1977, Delores Jewelers is a long-standing jewelry store where you can find a range of high-end to affordable engagement rings in Orlando. The store offers a wide selection of both designer and custom wedding jewelry across its three Orlando locations: Florida Mall, Fashion Square Mall and Waterford Towers. The staff is knowledgeable, friendly and professional, guiding you through the sometimes intimidating process of engagement ring shopping. You do not need an appointment to visit.
FEATURED VIDEO FROM THE KNOT
Notable Review: "My fiancé and I purchased my engagement ring at the store in Florida Mall. Dimitri, who helped us, was excellent because he was patient, informative, honest and showed us a wonderful selection of diamonds. He beautifully mounted the diamond on the ring that I now proudly wear. We will be going back to his store for our wedding bands."
3. Goldsmith Jewelry Shoppe
Goldsmith Jewelry Shoppe boasts one of the largest selections of engagement rings in Orlando and the greater Central Florida region. The shop—opened 25 years ago—has on-site GIA graduate gemologists at the ready to help educate buyers about diamonds and gemstones. It also prides itself on helping shoppers find an engagement ring that fits their budget, which means it's a great place whether you're seeking an extravagant piece or a more affordable option. Along with custom rings, Goldsmith Jewelry Shoppe sells Gabriel & Co. engagement rings and bands which range from modern to classic designs. Walk-ins are welcome.
Notable Review: "My fiancé custom designed my engagement ring and we only have wonderful things to say about Goldsmith. They have been extremely helpful in the experiences we have had, and with buying through them you get cleaning and inspections every six months included! Everyone we have worked with has been awesome!"
4. Monarch Jewelry
Family-owned for three generations, Monarch Jewelry is a local favorite that offers a variety of diamond engagement rings, custom designs and colorful gemstone options for your Orlando proposal. Serving the greater Orlando area, its team of GIA graduate gemologists is ripe with expertise in jewelry design and diamond and gemstone selection. They have an impressive inventory of loose stones for custom designs and to set engagement ring centers; they also have pre-designed engagement rings ranging from $600 to $18,500. This is also a great place to shop for vintage engagement rings in Orlando thanks to their rotating estate collection. No appointment is necessary to visit.
Notable Review: "I can't say enough great things about this place! They custom-made my engagement ring and wedding band. They have an amazing selection of diamonds to choose from to make every piece exactly what you dreamed of. The selection of men's bands is also wonderful. Diane is fabulous, personable and extremely knowledgeable."
5. Maitland Jewelers
Maitland Jewelers is a newer shop in the Orlando area that opened in 2012, but it's owned and operated by Elin Blinderman Shenk who worked with her family for 25 years at Jewelers Of Maitland. This local shop is a great option for those seeking custom-designed engagement rings and wedding bands, as well as people who want to purchase a predesigned piece. Designers offered include A&D Gems, Cherie Dori, Frederic Sage, True Romance and Allison Kaufman, among others. Prices range from $800 to $25,500 and walk-ins are welcome.
Notable Review: "I used Maitland Jewelers for my engagement ring, wedding band and for a gift for our 5-year-old daughter for the wedding day. At every step of the way, I must say what I wanted was very particular and difficult. I had my mom's engagement ring and I wanted to use the diamond, but not the band so they reset the ring. However, I wanted a wedding band that would fit with the engagement ring to look like just one ring, which was difficult as the diamond was a marquise cut. Elin was so patient with me and helped me through the whole process. She was also very honest about the jeweler's confidence in giving me exactly what I wanted. I am so happy with the results of everything and would highly recommend!"
6. Park Jewelers
Located just outside of Orlando in Lake Mary, Park Jewelers is a family-run business founded by Tony Tsirigotis—who has 30 years in the business—and his wife Sylvie and son Demetre. It's dedicated to delivering exceptional service to those seeking fine jewelry. The shop sells a thoughtfully curated selection of items with featured designers including Fana, Nasbro, Parvis Designs and Peter Storm. Along with engagement rings, the shop sells a selection of bands, watches and other jewelry, and provides custom designs, appraisals, jewelry repair, resizing and maintenance.
Notable Review: "My now-husband and I bought my engagement ring and our wedding bands from Park Jewelers. We went in and told them what we wanted to spend, and Tony helped us select a beautiful setting and diamond UNDER our budget. When I expressed concern about the prongs of my engagement ring getting caught on yarn when I knit, they were happy to change my prongs to a bezel at no cost to me. My husband and I both found beautiful wedding bands, and Tony was happy to let us make payments at a pace and price that was comfortable for us. And every time we went in to make a payment, they recognized us immediately and always offered to clean my engagement ring for free. Tony even thanked me in person after noticing that I'd submitted a review on Facebook! I'll recommend Park Jewelers over and over, working with them was a pleasure!"
7. Thompson Jewelers
Photo: Thompson Jewelers
Thompson Jewelers was founded in 1948, making it one of Central Florida's longest-standing family-owned jewelry stores. With locations in both Orlando and Kissimmee, they offer a wide selection of engagement rings, estate pieces and fine jewelry, as well as custom designs and pre-designed lab-grown diamond engagement rings.
The cost of engagement rings in this Orlando jewelry store ranges from $750 (not including the center stone) to $9,200 (not including the center stone). The lab-grown diamond rings are less expensive, with prices topping out at $6,000 including the center stone. No appointment is necessary.
Notable Review: "My fiancé and I went ring shopping last summer and we loved how helpful Bob was. I wanted a very unique ring and after doing my research, I knew I wanted to get it from a local jeweler as opposed to a chain shop. I found a photo of the ring I wanted online and left it at that. My fiancé took that image to Bob and together they designed this ring. My fiancé tells me Bob found him an amazing deal on a super high-quality diamond after he initially could not afford it. I'm so glad he did because my fiancé bought the ring and proposed to me in November 2022! This ring is absolutely incredible and I've gotten so many compliments on it. I'm so happy we were able to support a family business that clearly knows what they're doing and cares about providing stellar service."
8. Victoria Jewelers
Photo: Victoria Jewelers
Victoria Jewelers opened in 1987 and, for the last 25 years, has been run by jeweler Frank Walter. He's joined by on-staff designer Dustin Brake, who has 10 years of experience in the field, and third-generation jeweler Briant Hunt, who is a GIA-certified gemologist. Victoria Jewelers earned its reputation as the place to go in Orlando for redesigning and restoring special jewelry pieces. They also offer new predesigned pieces, custom jewelry design, full-service repairs and appraisals; their Orlando location features a full-service repair shop, where expert craftsmanship and quality materials ensure each piece endures and sparkles. No appointment is required to visit.
Notable Review: "We worked with Brian Hunt to purchase a new wedding ring and band for my wife. The store itself is incredibly impressive and the staff is welcoming. Brian is a true expert and a pleasure to work with. We viewed and selected the perfect bands over two trips to Victoria Jewelers. A true 5-star experience and product."
