The bride wore an elegant Galia Lahav wedding dress to swap vows with Jake Bongiovi in Tuscany.
Updated Oct 02, 2024Here's Where to Shop for Beautiful Engagement Rings in NJ
Because diamonds are forever.
Ready to pop the question in New Jersey? This diverse state offers tons of great places to get down on one knee (here are some great NJ proposal ideas). But before that can happen, you need a ring! Wondering where to find engagement rings in NJ? We can help with that. Here, we've rounded up eight of our favorite stores for you to choose from as you embark on your journey to find the perfect ring for that special someone.
But first, some engagement ring shopping tips: be sure to establish a budget (here's how much to spend on an engagement ring) and determine whether your partner will be involved in the process or whether you want it to be a complete surprise. In any case, use our handy ring size chart to figure out their ring size (simply borrow a ring they own and use it to get their size if your proposal will be a surprise).
The Knot Vendor Marketplace is a great resource if you're wondering where to shop for diamond engagement rings in NJ. You'll find many of the stores listed below there, along with helpful reviews you can read as you decide which store best meets your needs.
1. J. Vincent Jewelers
Located in the upscale enclave of Colts Neck, New Jersey, J. Vincent Jewelers is a long-standing community favorite and a great source of engagement rings in New Jersey. This family-owned business specializes in custom engagement rings, allowing you to book a private, on-site consultation with one of their highly trained gemologists. Choose from a variety of materials, like 14k, 18k, two-tone and platinum settings. Whether you're looking for something brand new or you have a family heirloom you'd like to incorporate into your engagement ring, the friendly and knowledgeable staff at J. Vincent Jewelers can help you craft the ring of your partner's dreams.
FEATURED VIDEO FROM THE KNOT
Notable Review: "Would not consider buying anywhere else!! The staff was personable and polite. Refreshing to visit a jewelry store that does not pressure you into buying something you don't want and with staff that are sincere and making sure you are getting exactly what you need. J. Vincent is the way to go!"
2. A.H. Fisher Diamonds
If you'd prefer to give your money to a local business that truly cares about the community, look no further than Jersey Shore native A.H. Fisher Diamonds. This altruistic diamond store is spearheaded by father and son team Alan and Matthew Fisher and has become a staple of the Red Bank community. Here, you'll receive personalized care and attention that will make you feel like you're the only customer in the store. Staff will help you choose a ring that's just right for you and your budget, with no pressure. With engagement rings of all sizes and for any budget, and on-site services like appraisals, repairs and insurance, it's clear the staff at A.H. Fisher cares most about making you happy with your purchase.
Notable Review: "We worked with A.H. Fisher to get our wedding bands and the experience from start to finish was AMAZING! Matt worked with us through all of our custom requests and went above and beyond our expectations. Highly recommend them!"
3. Roman Jewelers
At Roman Jewelers' large showroom in Bridgewater, New Jersey, you'll find an impressive selection of build-your-own, ready-to-wear and lab-grown diamonds. In fact, the company boasts one of the largest selections of loose diamonds and engagement ring settings in the state. If you happen to be looking for vintage engagement rings in NJ, Roman is a standout, offering a great selection of vintage and antique-inspired styles in a variety of settings as well. This family-owned business has served the Bridgewater area for four generations, and when you step into their showroom, it's immediately clear that they love educating customers about diamonds.
Notable Review: "Dana at Roman Jewelers helped me design my dream custom wedding ring which turned out perfectly. She was so helpful over the phone as well as in person. She went above and beyond to ensure that I got the exact stones and look that I wanted for the ring. My family always uses Roman Jewelers for our custom jewelry needs and we highly recommend them."
4. Story and Hearts
This upscale diamond store is a private concierge jeweler located in Colts Neck, New Jersey. At Story and Hearts, you'll find a knowledgeable staff that's ready to help you craft a custom ring that's exactly what you're looking for. They pride themselves on the ability to come up with a truly unique ring through a private, one-on-one consultation in their expansive showroom. With more than 20 years of experience and coming from a family of jewelers, owner Peter takes pride in his craft, working to ensure you're completely satisfied with your purchase.
FOR YOU
Defining the Different Types of Diamonds
Welcome to Diamonds 101—class is in session.
A Guide to the Most Popular Gemstone Colors
From fiery red rubies to icy blue sapphires, we're covering the entire ROYGBIV spectrum.
When You Should Take Your Engagement Ring Off
Hate to break it to you, but you really shouldn't be sleeping with it.
Notable Review: "Working with Peter was a fantastic experience. He navigated me through the entire process, from picking the right diamond to delivery and insurance. He was very responsive and delivered exactly what I was looking for, and managed to do so on a very quick timeline. I am very glad I worked with Peter and would recommend him to anyone in the market for an engagement ring."
5. Spivak Jewelers
It's comforting to work with a jeweler who starts with your budget in mind. And that's exactly what Spivak Jewelers aims to do with each customer who walks through the door. They're a long-time purveyor of diamond engagement rings in Cherry Hill, NJ. With a cozy, home-like atmosphere for their private consultations, Spivak works hard to "build you the most ring for your money," a clever approach that means you'll come away with a stunning engagement ring regardless of how big or small your budget might be. All of the work is completed on-site, which aids in the on-time delivery of your ring and ensures it's exactly what you're looking for.
Notable Review: "Great communication with an in-depth understanding of finding out what moves each client and how to meet their needs within a budget. Very personable and cordial."
6. Hoboken Gold and Diamonds
With more than 40 years of experience, this family-owned store sells engagement rings in New Jersey in the Hoboken area. At Hoboken Gold and Diamonds, you'll be greeted by friendly staff and introduced to their expansive selection of both lab-created and natural diamonds. What's more, their diamond experts will work with you to create a customized ring with either type of diamond or a different gemstone altogether. It's all based on your desires and what you think your partner will love. Prefer to start your search online? No worries! Hoboken Gold and Diamonds offers an easy online customization form that allows you to select all aspects of your ring, and even attach images of ideas.
Notable Review: "We have loved working with Reynold for my engagement ring and our wedding bands! Reynold has been so patient and kind, not pushy, explains everything, has fair pricing and creates gorgeous jewelry. He custom-made my whole stack and it is exactly what I wanted. We will for sure be back and recommend Hoboken Gold and Diamonds to our friends!"
7. Helzberg Diamonds
Helzberg Diamonds is a nationwide brand with several locations across the state of New Jersey. This well-known store offers a variety of ways to shop: schedule a private, on-site consultation to educate yourself on the ring-buying process or design the ring of your loved one's dream. Or, browse the impressive selection of rings in-store or even online. The Helzberg website offers a helpful build-you-own-ring tool that can inspire you as you search for the perfect ring. With more than 100 years in the diamond industry, Helzberg offers high-quality diamonds and customer service you can count on.
Notable Review: "We decided to refurbish a ring that has been in my family since the late 1800s, and custom-create a band to match. Not only was the ring stunning but the vintage engagement ring looks brand new! My husband and I couldn't be more happy. I highly recommend them!"
8. Romancing the Stones
This popular metro-area jewelry store boasts thousands of satisfied customers. That's likely thanks to their one-on-one customer service and a huge selection of settings and loose diamonds (more than 50,000 according to their website!) you can browse in their showroom. Romancing the Stones offers a unique, unconditional 30-day refund policy to help you feel secure in your purchase, and offers a host of in-store services, too, like appraisals, cleaning and engraving.
Notable Review: "We went to John for our wedding rings on the recommendation of a few of my mom's friends—he did an amazing job! He was so patient and helpful as we tried on different rings and asked questions, and the finished product was so beautiful. We recently got married and are loving our wedding bands, which are so special to us. Thank you, John!"
