25 of the Nicest Jewelry Gift Ideas for Girlfriends Who Accessorize

Because a little sparkle goes a long way.

Photo: Gorjana

Updated Nov 19, 2024

So you're celebrating your girlfriend's birthday, the holidays or your anniversary. A romantic gift, like jewelry, is perfect for the occasion. Need some inspo to get started? We've rounded up the best jewelry gift ideas for your girlfriend to steer you in the right direction. Along with our top picks, we'll be sharing tips on how to find a jewelry gift that feels appropriate for a specific milestone or holiday. For example, gifting an expensive accessory for a three-month anniversary might be a little OTT, but a sweet trinket may strike the right note. Whatever the occasion, relationship stage or your girlfriend's style, we're here to help pick out something that'll dazzle her. From personalized birthday presents to sweet Valentine's Day gifts, here are the best jewelry gifts for a girlfriend who loves to accessorize.

In this article:

The Best Jewelry Gifts for Your Girlfriend
Frequently Asked Questions

The Best Jewelry Gifts for Your Girlfriend

It's time to scoop up something that shines as much as she does. We've curated a list of thoughtful jewelry presents for girlfriends below, from casual pieces to statement baubles and everything in between. Don't have time to scroll? Check out our short list of girlfriend jewelry ideas:

Birthday: Birthdate Candles Pendant, From $165
Christmas: Swarovski Tennis Bracelet, $149
Valentine's Day: Talia Sari Brick Heart Necklace, $69
Anniversary: Love Wue Heartbeat Earrings, From $30
Long-Distance: Bond Touch Long Distance Bracelets, $138 for 2

1. Birthdate Pendant

Looking for good custom jewelry ideas for your girlfriend's birthday? Try this pretty zodiac pendant inspired by her date of birth. It's personalized with her birthstone and other semi-precious gems on one side, with her birthdate, initials and star sign on the reverse. As long as you know your sweetheart's birthday (and her preference for silver or gold), you can't go wrong with this jewelry gift.

Get 15% off sitewide with this code: KNOT15.

From $165 | Birthdate Candles

2. Hoop Earrings

If your girlfriend is into jewelry, she probably already has a go-to pair of hoop earrings in her collection. Add something new to her rotation with these bold huggies. Available in sterling silver or 14K gold, these chunky baubles look great worn alone or stacked with dainty studs. They're timeless yet modern, making them a great jewelry gift for a girlfriend who loves classic styles.

From $48 | Mejuri

3. Crystal Tennis Bracelet

When it comes to choosing jewelry for your girlfriend for Christmas, our advice is simple: make it sparkly. This elegant tennis bracelet is made from two strands of dazzling crystals—perfect for all those festive parties she'll be attending. It's not just a great holiday gift though. The classic design means she can wear it year-round for birthdays, weddings and other celebrations. Bonus: The adjustable sliding ball closure means you don't have to worry about sizing.

Want to save money? Use Theknot10 code for 10% off sitewide.

$149 | Swarovski

4. Birth Flower Necklace

We get it: deciding where to buy jewelry for your girlfriend can be overwhelming. That's why Made By Mary is one of our favorite places to shop for accessories. Their birth flower pendants come in 12 different designs (one for each month of the year) and are a thoughtful gift for your girlfriend's birthday, Valentine's Day or another occasion. Pick from gold, rose gold or silver for an elegant piece she can wear daily.

From $52 | Made By Mary

5. Apple Watch Accessories

Finding nice jewelry for a girlfriend who only wears a smart watch may seem impossible, but it can be done. Upgrade her favorite accessory with Goldenerre's Apple watch straps. This gift set comes with a stainless steel band and a white patent leather strap which she can swap out for a whole new look. She'll be thrilled to receive such a thoughtful and practical jewelry gift. (Editor's tip: Check if her watch model is compatible before purchasing.)

From $154 | Goldenerre

6. Pearl Initial Necklace

Shopping for jewelry for a new girlfriend? Kendra Scott's letter necklaces strike the perfect balance between personal and playful. This gold pendant features her first initial suspended at an angle, with a tiny freshwater pearl for added elegance. She can layer it with other pieces of jewelry or wear it alone for a more understated look. Either way, she'll never want to take it off.

$65 | Kendra Scott

7. Cute Jewelry Holder

PSA: Not all jewelry gift ideas for your girlfriend have to be accessories. If she already has a substantial collection (or you just don't know what to buy), opt for some clever storage instead. This jewelry holder is shaped like a hummingbird and has little spots to hang her earrings, bracelets and rings. It's a creative jewelry-inspired gift for your girlfriend she can use to display her favorite treasures.

$32 | Uncommon Goods

8. Interlocking Fidget Ring

Here's a jewelry gift for your girlfriend that's pretty and thoughtful. This fidget ring is perfect for anyone who gets anxious or likes to keep her hands busy. It's made from three interlocking rings that she can spin to help reduce feelings of nervousness and tension. She'll be touched that you found a gift to soothe her everyday worries.

$60 | Mint & Lily

9. Gorjana Layering Necklaces

Gorjana is a good place to get your girlfriend nice accessories. Their pieces are timeless, wearable and high-quality, not to mention affordable. This necklace set feels like two gifts in one, offering her even more styling possibilities. It includes a gold- or silver-plated paper clip chain and a longer dog tag necklace that's made for layering. Of course, she can always wear them separately if she prefers.

$140 | Gorjana

10. Earrings and Cuff Set

Searching for jewelry for a girlfriend with multiple ear piercings? Stop scrolling now. This accessory set from BaubleBar is perfectly curated for earring lovers. It comes with two pairs of stud earrings, a pair of huggies and a matching cuff—all crafted from cubic zirconia stones and 18K gold-plated silver. She can wear them all at once for a chic party look or mix and match with her favorite pieces.

$104 | BaubleBar

11. Long Distance Touch Bracelets

A pair of touch bracelets is an excellent long-distance relationship gift that'll help you and your GF feel connected when you're apart. Every time you tap your bracelet her matching band will light up and vibrate, so she'll know you're thinking about her. You can even create your own special code based on certain tap rhythms to tell her you're missing her.

$138 for 2 | Uncommon Goods

12. Monogrammed Jewelry Case

If your girlfriend loves jewelry (but you're unsure about picking out a piece for her), opt for a luxe case instead. Not only is it a creative jewelry gift for a new girlfriend, but it's also a practical present she'll use a lot. This vegan leather jewelry case has multiple compartments for organizing all her earrings, bracelets and necklaces. Choose from various colors and patterns, before having her monogram printed or foil debossed on the outside.

From $69 | Mark & Graham

13. Birthstone Earrings

Anthropologie offers nice jewelry for a girlfriend who prefers colorful pieces. These birthstone earrings are a tasteful pick if she likes to switch up her style regularly. The set includes four pairs—each made from 14K gold-plated brass with semi-precious stones—on a card displaying her birth month. We love these for a new relationship gift, since they're pretty and won't break the bank.

$62 | Anthropologie

14. Studded Bangle

Kate Spade's whimsical jewelry will please any girlfriend who loves to have fun with her accessories. These studded bangles are timeless pieces she'll wear over and over again. They come in gold, silver or rose gold and are embellished with sparkly crystals for added sparkle. If you can stretch your budget, splurge on a few so she can stack them.

$58 each | Kate Spade

15. Brick Heart Necklace

How cute is this brick heart necklace? This playful piece features a gold-filled chain and a heart formed from two plastic bricks. It fastens at the front, with the heart doubling as clasp. It's the perfect piece of unique jewelry for your girlfriend for Valentine's Day, her birthday or the holidays.

$69 | Talia Sari

16. Personalized Ring Dish

Here's another jewelry-inspired gift that your girl will cherish: a personalized ring dish. This square-shaped vessel is made from ceramic and can be customized with her name and birth flower. Now, she'll have a designated spot to stash her gems when she's not wearing them. (Psst: It makes a great stocking stuffer for your girlfriend, especially if you pair it with some new jewels).

From $24 | Etsy

17. Custom Charm Bracelet

Does your girlfriend like to keep up with the latest trends? Surprise her with a lucky charm bracelet for Christmas or her birthday. These jewelry gifts are becoming increasingly popular, thanks to their endless customization options and nostalgic appeal. This handmade bracelet comes with up to five charms of your choice, which she can mix and match to suit her personality. Choose from an array of charms (like an evil eye, a four leaf clover and a horseshoe) to send all the positive vibes her way.

From $68 | Uncommon Goods

18. Jewelry Polishing Mitt

If your girlfriend wears jewelry daily, she'll appreciate something to keep her gems shiny. Baublerella's jewelry mitt is infused with a cleaning formula to polish and reduce tarnishing on precious metals, like platinum, gold, silver and brass. It's also reusable, making it a really clever jewelry gift for your girlfriend.

$20 | Baublerella

19. Heartbeat Earrings

Need a romantic dating anniversary gift for your girlfriend? Let these heartbeat earrings do the talking for you. They're made from sterling silver and come on a card that reads: "I'll always be there for you in a heartbeat." It's a simple yet meaningful jewelry present for your girlfriend that'll remind her of your unwavering support. Bonus: You can choose a personalized gift bag for a thoughtful presentation.

From $30 | Etsy

20. Tiny Tarot Necklace

Sometimes, the key to choosing jewelry gifts for your girlfriend lies in her interests. If she's obsessed with fortune telling, she'll be charmed by this tiny tarot necklace. It's made from antiqued bronze and holds 22 miniature tarot cards that she actually can use. It even comes with a quick pocket guide to help her interpret each sign. Just don't be surprised if she wants to read your fortune when you give it to her.

$55 | Uncommon Goods

21. Engraved Jewelry Box

If romantic gestures are part of your love language, this engraved jewelry box will give her all the feels. The mirrored box is lined with soft velvet on the inside, while the outside can be inscribed with a touching message. Choose from five romantic verses or write a love letter of your own to really melt her heart. Girlfriend jewelry ideas don't get much sweeter than this.

Use the KNOT15PM code to get 15% off your order.

From $40 | Personalization Mall

22. Morse Code Bracelet

One of the best things about being in love is the unspoken bond you share with your partner. If you and your GF have a secret language, this Morse code bracelet is a unique way to celebrate that. Available in gold, rose gold or silver, it spells out your chosen message using beads to represent a dot or dash. Whether you go with a simple "I love you," or something only the two of you will understand, she'll treasure this piece for years to come.

From $41 | Etsy

23. Subtle Studs

If your S.O. prefer fuss-free fashion (or is a daily napper), these subtle studs will be a game changer. They're designed for wearers who want to be stylish without worrying about their ear candy. They feature push pin flat backs, allowing your girl to snooze, wear headphones or exercise without being stabbed by her earrings. You'll get top marks for this thoughtful jewelry gift for your girlfriend.

$75 | Maison Miru

24. Monthly Jewelry Subscription

Why stop at just one jewelry present for your girlfriend? Thanks to Cratejoy, your girl can receive new baubles every month. Their Favorite of the Month subscription includes unique handmade accessories from all over the world. Each delivery contains fair trade products made by artisans who are trying to create sustainable livelihoods. Simply choose the subscription duration for a meaningful (and creative) jewelry gift idea for your girlfriend.

From $13 | Cratejoy

25. Music-Inspired Necklace

Take inspiration from your girlfriend's favorite song (or a tune you both love) with this music-themed accessory. Available in gold, rose gold or silver, this bar necklace can be etched with sheet music from a stanza of your chosen melody. It's an especially fitting jewelry gift for a girlfriend who's into music or plays an instrument.

$99 | Canvas Vows

Frequently Asked Questions

After browsing our favorite jewelry ideas for your girlfriend, it's totally normal if you still have questions. Keep reading for our advice on how to buy jewelry for your girlfriend, how much to spend and how to choose the right piece for any occasion.

Is jewelry a good gift for your girlfriend?

Jewelry is (usually) a good gift for your girlfriend, unless she doesn't wear accessories at all. Assuming she does, pay attention to her sense of style, her favorite brands and her lifestyle. Splashing out on fancy jewelry doesn't make sense if she can't wear it (like if she has a metal allergy or works in a sterile environment). Once the practicalities are taken care of, you can get creative. What occasion are you shopping for? Perhaps, you want to surprise her with cute matching couples jewelry on your anniversary. Or maybe you're looking for birthday jewelry she can wear every day. Considering the reason behind your purchase will help you decide what jewelry to get for your girlfriend.

How do you choose the right jewelry for your girlfriend?

Even if your relationship is in the early stages, you probably already have a sense of your girlfriend's personal style. Let this be your guide when choosing a piece of jewelry for her present. Does she like simple, understated accessories? Or is she all about layering multiple pieces that make a statement? Maybe she prefers silver to gold. Being observant pays off and will ultimately let her know you've made an effort. If she doesn't wear watches or rings (or you don't know her ring size), it's probably best to skip these altogether.

How much should you spend on jewelry for your girlfriend?

While there's no minimum or maximum amount to spend on your girlfriend's jewelry gift, there are several factors to consider. First, note what you're able to afford and how much feels appropriate for the milestone or stage of your relationship. For example, a couple that's been dating for a few months may want to stick to something under $100, while a more long-term relationship may warrant more (though not necessarily). Similarly, if you're shopping for a big milestone (like a 25th or 30th birthday gift for your girlfriend), you may want to splurge on something sentimental. Remember, the amount you spend on a jewelry gift for your girlfriend doesn't determine how much she'll love it—it's the thought that counts after all.